Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sprirituality does not have to include spirits. This really isn't a difficult concept to grasp.



My truth changes compared to yours, At 23C an Innuit would be hot and a desert dweller cold. One is hot - his truth, one cold her truth.



You might need to show me where I said that it did. Did you actually read the earlier posts? I'm guessing not; we were discussing whether alcoholism could be a spiritual based problem (in part). Many psychologists believe it does which supports some of the arguments that AA and others here have been making.

Then what does it include?
 
Did you find that the mention of God and the use of prayer at closing was a common factor in the majority of these meetings?

Sure. Sort of like good sex and prior to/during football games.

Are high school football games considered religious activity?

If my mate calls me God, oh God... does that make me Divine?
 
Then what does it include?

Are there really psychologists who believe there are "spiritually based problems"? What does that even mean? How is that defined?

We know by now that there is absolutely zero acceptable evidence of a spirit, a soul, or a god. Psychologists, as scientists, should know better than positing mythical bases to problems. (I thought they did, but I might have to research this. I know there is a certain amount of old woo in psychology, but this is ridiculous.)
 
That's more of a secular, "outside meetings" definition of alcoholic. In meetings alcoholism is all about negative feelings, anger, resentment, selfishness and self-centeredness, as described in Chapter 5 on the fourth step.
I have no idea where you attended meetings, but those weren't topics in the closed discussion meetings I've been in and that were the reason I no longer have a problem with alcohol.

Perhaps you people never got beyond open Beginner and Speakers meetings. I usually found those unhelpful and at times jargon laden.

And yes, of course there have always been many who quit without AA, but AA members dismiss their abstinence as either they weren't "real" alcoholics or they're on a "dry drunk" because they're not working the spiritual program of AA. I recall several articles talking about how President George W. Bush was a "dry drunk" and had those negative feelings and characteristics of an alcoholic.
Luckily I never met one of those members you seem to hang out with.

I never heard "jails, institutions, death or stopping drinking without AA" said in all the meetings I attended or by any AA member.
Why would you have expected to? For me, Rehab was the place where "jails, institutions, or death as the end of untreated alcoholism" was a keynote.

I've alos seen a lot of misrepresentations in this thread, but I suspect we wouldn't agree on which statements are misrepresentations.
Yes, we wouldn't agree which statements are misrepresentations.
 
According to what little information we have, it doesn't work for the vast majority of people. Too bad only one circuit court in the US ruled that alternatives to AA had to be pushed. So, are the courts *really* interested in 'effective'?
I'd say, no. That's not their problem to solve.



Is your religion claiming to be secular?
Does that statement actually mean something to someone?

And you're minimizing the God-talk in AA if you think all that people's shorts are bunching over is "one little PRAYER."
You're minimizing the ability of an alcoholic to find reasons to be offended and a good excuse to go have a few drinks.




The book['s authors] had no frikkin' clue about what a 'real' alcoholic is or not.
A problem apparently shared by most who aren't alcoholics.



I believe it is used as such, and I stand by my opinion. In fact, it isn't really known yet how addiction ties in with other mental illnesses. It is thought that the alcoholic uses alcohol as a self-medicating routine to alleviate the symptoms of the mental illness. In these cases, alcohol in and of itself isn't really the issue at all.
A trite and rather useless set of statements for most drinking alcoholics.

But many alcoholics who might fit this criteria won't ever learn this because they're attending meetings which views alcoholism as a spiritual illness which requires a spiritual solution, i.e., God as you understand Him.
Evidence?

When AA doesn't even view the central issue as a medical one, then how will the untrained masses who attend AA even be on the lookout for it?
Maybe someone should demonstrate the problem exists before too many people worry about it.


What does the seeking of this God have anything to do with alcoholism?
As many who've been in the program awhile will explain to you GOD = Good Orderly Direction; what an alcoholic lifestyle lacks.

Apparently googling for "christian aa" returns many groups which are hard-core religious with a little booze thrown in. Why keep the farce going that AA itself is not religious then? If the AA World Intergroup truly thought AA as an organization was "spiritual and not religious" then why did those groups in Canada get de-listed? They didn't remove the spirituality, just the God. Oops.

Seventy five years ago, I could see it. Now, not so much.
Without Good Orderly Direction (GOD) there is no "program"; just a bunch of drunks.
 
And you're minimizing the God-talk in AA if you think all that people's shorts are bunching over is "one little PRAYER."
I wish I had as much as a penny for every time God was mentioned in the AA meetings I went to. I could have gotten my dollar back in many or even most meetings.

And the "God talk" is not the only thing wrong with AA, not by far.
 
Sprirituality does not have to include spirits. This really isn't a difficult concept to grasp.

But in the case of AA, at least in the basic texts, spirituality has a lot to do with a spirit. The texts talk specifically about a monotheistic deity who is not only indispensable in one's achieving sobriety but also in one's attaining a better moral character. Do you agree?
 
The book['s authors] had no frikkin' clue about what a 'real' alcoholic is or not.

On this note, I'm gonna have to duck out of this thread.

I just can't agree with you on that one whatsoever. I'm not even going to argue with you anymore because we are on two different planets here.

But it was good talking to you folks. It's been fun. You can dm/pm me if you would like.

Have a good day.
 
Then what does it include?

I have posted a response to this question a number of times (at least three) and have included links also, I do not intend to do so again.

In short, spirituality can include simply having a purpose or meaning in life, inner peace or the foundations for happiness. In Maslow terms it might even include the process of self actualisation, in whatever form that takes for the individual.

"Religious" and "spiritual" are different things.
That said, religion needs spirituality, spirituality does not need religion.

It appears to me that the very narrow definitions that some here hold dictates that the two words are the same. If they were the same, in an instance I would agree that AA is religious; but they are not and as such AA is by this definition spriritual.
 
In short, spirituality can include simply having a purpose or meaning in life, inner peace or the foundations for happiness. In Maslow terms it might even include the process of self actualisation, in whatever form that takes for the individual..

Self-actualization is the polar opposite of the AA program. Whatever you are advocating ( and it is so so ambiguous and contradictory it's really hard to tell), it is not AA.

AA does not give empowerment to the individual (read: steps 2, 3 and 11). AAs very definition of alcoholism is it is "self-will run riot." Like when AlBell wrote this last week:

Alcoholism == self-will run riot.

Which is a direct contradiction what he wrote yesterday:

Finding it within oneself.

This is why one can discuss these things rationally with someone who has been brainwashed into the AA program. Arguments are just thrown together ad hoc. It's one giant contradiction.
 
Self-actualization is the polar opposite of the AA program.

Wrong to start with.
But the point was that self actualisation (or the other items I nominated) could easily be spirituality or an aspect of it, which is what we were discussing.

AA does not give empowerment to the individual (read: steps 2, 3 and 11).

Self actualisation is exactly what AA empowers and directs one to achieve.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have posted a response to this question a number of times (at least three) and have included links also, I do not intend to do so again.

In short, spirituality can include simply having a purpose or meaning in life, inner peace or the foundations for happiness. In Maslow terms it might even include the process of self actualisation, in whatever form that takes for the individual.

So what would a person who lacks spirituality be like? They'd have no purpose, inner peace or foundations for happiness. That sounds like a definition of a depressed person.

Is spirituality really just being used to describe "normal"? Are there non-spiritual people who live normal happy lives, or is, that by definition, impossible?
 
Wrong to start with.
But the point was that self actualisation (or the other items I nominated) could easily be spirituality or an aspect of it, which is what we were discussing.



Self actualisation is exactly what AA empowers and directs one to achieve.

How does one self actualize be sucking up to a higher power?
 
I'm reminded of a scene from the American TV series "West Wing".

It was about alcoholism, and this bit might be helpfull to some that find it difficult to see how AA can help, while not clinging to the idea of a higher power.

"This guy's walking down the street when he falls in a hole. The walls are so steep he can't get out. A doctor passes by and the guy shouts up, 'Hey you. Can you help me out?' The doctor writes a prescription, throws it down in the hole and moves on. Then a priest comes along and the guy shouts up, 'Father, I'm down in this hole can you help me out?' The priest writes out a prayer, throws it down in the hole and moves on. Then a friend walks by, 'Hey, Joe, it's me can you help me out?'. And the friend jumps in the hole. Our guy says, 'Are you stupid? Now we're both down here.' The friend says, 'Yeah, but I've been down here before and I know the way out.'"

It's not perfect, but I think worth a thought.

Does it matter if the doctor was an alcoholic, or the friend a priest? I'm sure to the guy it didn't matter. He was looking for help.

What motivated the friend to help? What was the priest and/or doctor lacking?

Would the friend say he would help only if the guy promised to go to church on Sundays? Would the doctor say he would help only if he promised to make an appointment? On this point, I agree that may be the case. Yet having been helped, will not the guy be in a better place, able to re-evaluate his experience, better able to make rational decisions based on the evidence? Can the guy decide that he was helped by a flawed human?

This is why many people go to AA, because they know A certain way out. The doctor can be a priest, the guy an atheist, any combination.

A simple story, but I wonder if some people might think the friend wanted to recruit the guy, or deceive him, with only a secondary motive of helping. On this point I disagree with many here. I take from the story that the friend only wanted to help, and the friend could.

Am I naive?
 
Last edited:
I'm reminded of a scene from the American TV series "West Wing".

It was about alcoholism, and this bit might be helpfull to some that find it difficult to see how AA can help, while not clinging to the idea of a higher power.

"This guy's walking down the street when he falls in a hole. The walls are so steep he can't get out. A doctor passes by and the guy shouts up, 'Hey you. Can you help me out?' The doctor writes a prescription, throws it down in the hole and moves on. Then a priest comes along and the guy shouts up, 'Father, I'm down in this hole can you help me out?' The priest writes out a prayer, throws it down in the hole and moves on. Then a friend walks by, 'Hey, Joe, it's me can you help me out?'. And the friend jumps in the hole. Our guy says, 'Are you stupid? Now we're both down here.' The friend says, 'Yeah, but I've been down here before and I know the way out.'"

It's not perfect, but I think worth a thought.

Does it matter if the doctor was an alcoholic, or the friend a priest? I'm sure to the guy it didn't matter. He was looking for help.

What motivated the friend to help? What was the priest and/or doctor lacking?

Would the friend say he would help only if the guy promised to go to church on Sundays? Would the doctor say he would help only if he promised to make an appointment? On this point, I agree that may be the case. Yet having been helped, will not the guy be in a better place, able to re-evaluate his experience, better able to make rational decisions based on the evidence? Can the guy decide that he was helped by a flawed human?

This is why many people go to AA, because they know A certain way out. The doctor can be a priest, the guy an atheist, any combination.

A simple story, but I wonder if some people might think the friend wanted to recruit the guy, or deceive him, with only a secondary motive of helping. On this point I disagree with many here. I take from the story that the friend only wanted to help, and the friend could.

Am I naive?

No you are not naive. This phenomena called AA has been helping folks for 70's years. We know this, this is why in your story the guy jumped in the hole. We have all jumped in the hole to help another. I laugh so hard when I am referred to as a apologist, recruiter, devious, stepper and so on. I could not be any further away from these characteristics. I know AA helps alcoholics, I really don't need to justify this here, I do this because I hope to educate the fence sitters.
People who choose to become members of AA, will find out in short order that AA can be religious, spiritual, Atheistic, Agnostic or whatever you want it to be.
Bill Wilson explained his path it did not mean we all had to follow his way. Quite the opposite Bill left room for members to find their way. He knew he could not dictate to alcoholics (tell them what to do) and I believe Bill also understood that religion would play a part in AA (especially for him and folks like himself) but for others it would play little if any. This is where I believe Bill came up with the clause, "A God of our understanding". For Bill this was the best he could do under his circumstances, he believed in God.
For myself understanding AA and the difficultly they had in the beginning years separating religion from AA (so AA would be more inclusive) I can see the latitude I have in AA with my beliefs. I don't believe like Bill and if Bill was here I believe he would have no reluctance saying that didn't matter at all.
 
Does that statement actually mean something to someone?

Should. Mcgowdog said, "For religion, I've got to get dressed, cross the T's and dot the I'S, SITSTANDKNEEL, SING, eat drink, and PraisetheLord Pass the Basket.

In A.A. we say one little PRAYER and everybody gets their shorts in a bunch."

I spoke directly to his highlighted statement. AA claims to be secular, so having prayers in it seems hypocritical. His church ostensibly doesn't claim to be secular. Get the point now?


You're minimizing the ability of an alcoholic to find reasons to be offended and a good excuse to go have a few drinks.

Don't particularly care about a person who will go to any length to find an excuse to keep drinking. You don't seem to understand; I'm not providing anything, he's seeking any excuse whatsoever. It doesn't matter what I do or say or don't do or say to him. Get it now?


A trite and rather useless set of statements for most drinking alcoholics.

And you know this by the extensive research that you've done, right? Or maybe you believe that alcoholism is a spiritual problem that requires a spiritual solution. The work done by scientists and researchers into the problems of addiction show that it isn't the case.


Evidence?

For which statement?


Maybe someone should demonstrate the problem exists before too many people worry about it.

The problem that mentally ill people attend AA who would be far better and capably served by seeing that their alcoholism could be treated through medications rather than viewing their problem as a spiritual disease? This problem?



As many who've been in the program awhile will explain to you GOD = Good Orderly Direction; what an alcoholic lifestyle lacks.

Without Good Orderly Direction (GOD) there is no "program"; just a bunch of drunks.

Ah. So you like the made-up version that AAs love to spout to make God more palatable. How do you turn your life and will over to Good Orderly Direction? And what, exactly is Good Orderly Direction? Where does AA lay that out?


Self actualisation is exactly what AA empowers and directs one to achieve.

Evidence that self-actualization is what AA directs one to achieve?
 
On this note, I'm gonna have to duck out of this thread.

I just can't agree with you on that one whatsoever. I'm not even going to argue with you anymore because we are on two different planets here.

But it was good talking to you folks. It's been fun. You can dm/pm me if you would like.

Have a good day.

Alright, no problem. I'm responding to this for lurkers and other interested readers.

I mean by my statement, "the book's authors had no clue what alcoholism was about," that 75 years ago, doctors didn't know much about the dynamics of alcoholism and anyone's theory or concept of alcoholism could have worked. Then again, it may not have. It is well-known that Bill W. massaged the numbers to make AA look more successful than it was. Anyway, my point is that alcoholism/addiction isn't viewed in that way any longer by scientists and researchers and other interested parties. Chemistry, physiology, psychology... all fields which have some amazing inroads towards understanding and successfully treating addiction. Not saying that it's a solved puzzle.

But it sure ain't a spiritual disease, whatever that is.
 
I'm reminded of a scene from the American TV series "West Wing".

It was about alcoholism, and this bit might be helpfull to some that find it difficult to see how AA can help, while not clinging to the idea of a higher power.

"This guy's walking down the street when he falls in a hole. The walls are so steep he can't get out. A doctor passes by and the guy shouts up, 'Hey you. Can you help me out?' The doctor writes a prescription, throws it down in the hole and moves on. Then a priest comes along and the guy shouts up, 'Father, I'm down in this hole can you help me out?' The priest writes out a prayer, throws it down in the hole and moves on. Then a friend walks by, 'Hey, Joe, it's me can you help me out?'. And the friend jumps in the hole. Our guy says, 'Are you stupid? Now we're both down here.' The friend says, 'Yeah, but I've been down here before and I know the way out.'"

It's not perfect, but I think worth a thought.

Does it matter if the doctor was an alcoholic, or the friend a priest? I'm sure to the guy it didn't matter. He was looking for help.

What motivated the friend to help? What was the priest and/or doctor lacking?

Would the friend say he would help only if the guy promised to go to church on Sundays? Would the doctor say he would help only if he promised to make an appointment? On this point, I agree that may be the case. Yet having been helped, will not the guy be in a better place, able to re-evaluate his experience, better able to make rational decisions based on the evidence? Can the guy decide that he was helped by a flawed human?

This is why many people go to AA, because they know A certain way out. The doctor can be a priest, the guy an atheist, any combination.

A simple story, but I wonder if some people might think the friend wanted to recruit the guy, or deceive him, with only a secondary motive of helping. On this point I disagree with many here. I take from the story that the friend only wanted to help, and the friend could.

Am I naive?

Perhaps a little. I have no doubt that many, certainly most, people at AA meetings have strong altruistic motives and want to guide you out of the manhole, to keep the analogy. The issue I personally have is with the organization itself, which relies strongly on woo and has not proven effective when compared to trying to quit on your own,

- There is absolutely no conclusive evidence of efficacy.
- “Spirituality” is a weasel word used by defenders of faith-based ideologies, to distance their intentions from organized religion.
- All thinking happens in the brain. Not the inexistent “spirit”.
- Growing as a social individual, and improving your behaviour, becoming more honest with yourself and others, making an effort to lead a life that is not self-destructive, or that doesn’t greatly reduce the quality of life of the people around you and the people who love you, etc., are worthy goals, but they are to be achieved with cognitive processes. Not with woo based on bronze age myths.
- A worldwide organization should be adequately transparent, and demonstrate accountability.

So why can AA not be secular (for real), with a structure that allows for transparent leadership? They could keep and publish data. They could improve. They could have an evolutionary process that brings eventual results. I have nothing but respect for anyone who takes the time to help their fellow sufferers, but AA does not give them the tools they need. Somebody do something. Constantly gazing at one’s own belly button and pretending everything is working just fine is not going to help anyone. AA should either change, or accept criticism gracefully.

Apologists can defend the institution until they are blue in the face, but the above points are important flaws in my opinion because they hinder efficacy and progress. That’s a big deal.
 
So what would a person who lacks spirituality be like? They'd have no purpose, inner peace or foundations for happiness. That sounds like a definition of a depressed person.

Me too.
I do a poll with each of my rehab groups about once a fortnight where I see 80 - 90 % of the clients having some form of comorbidity. Depression features very highly.

Is spirituality really just being used to describe "normal"? Are there non-spiritual people who live normal happy lives, or is, that by definition, impossible?

Under the definition I have given, who would you describe as "non spiritual"?

I believe every "normal" person has some level of spirituality - and obviously this does not have to mean religion. For some it is family, work, sport, goals (in fact goal setting is hugely important), education etc.

Simply put, for the practicing alcoholic their spiritual core is self destructive manifesting itself in the alcoholic obsession. A change in their spiritual objectives or focus is essential for recovery imho.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom