Jack Astor
Thinker
- Joined
- Jun 20, 2011
- Messages
- 142
And it's a position that offers an alcoholic another opportunity to keep drinking; most when thinking alcoholically would rather be a drunk atheist than a sober not-atheist.
This is the false dichotomy that AA manipulates people into believing.
People are suckered into the program by being told it is not religious. When they balk at the actual program, which necessitates a person hand their life over to God, they are told these are just "suggestions." Then they are presented with this false choice: do you want to be a drunk atheist, or a sober theist?
This is a bait and switch religious conversion routine I've seen umpteen times. It not only smacks in the face of an atheist, but also to those non-atheists who believe God has given individuals freewill.
Also, "alcoholic thinking" is a catch-all term commonly used in AA meetings. It's a shutdown term, and applies to any expressed thought that goes against what AA teaches in the 'Big Book'. A lot of normal human emotions that are considered pejoratives in the AA world - such as anger - fall under the the umbrella of "alcoholic thinking," aka "stinking thinking." For some reason, AA's think everyone with a drinking problem is pissed off.
Steppers have a different point of reference than those not under the spell of AA, and when they say something such as, "you sound angry," there is a subtext to it that "normies" don't understand. It implies, you aren't really sober, and you are thinking like an alcoholic. "Alcoholic thinking" is just another thing AA pulled out of thin air, with zero clinical foundation in believing it. There is, however, a religious foundation to it.