Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
And it's a position that offers an alcoholic another opportunity to keep drinking; most when thinking alcoholically would rather be a drunk atheist than a sober not-atheist.

This is the false dichotomy that AA manipulates people into believing.

People are suckered into the program by being told it is not religious. When they balk at the actual program, which necessitates a person hand their life over to God, they are told these are just "suggestions." Then they are presented with this false choice: do you want to be a drunk atheist, or a sober theist?

This is a bait and switch religious conversion routine I've seen umpteen times. It not only smacks in the face of an atheist, but also to those non-atheists who believe God has given individuals freewill.

Also, "alcoholic thinking" is a catch-all term commonly used in AA meetings. It's a shutdown term, and applies to any expressed thought that goes against what AA teaches in the 'Big Book'. A lot of normal human emotions that are considered pejoratives in the AA world - such as anger - fall under the the umbrella of "alcoholic thinking," aka "stinking thinking." For some reason, AA's think everyone with a drinking problem is pissed off.

Steppers have a different point of reference than those not under the spell of AA, and when they say something such as, "you sound angry," there is a subtext to it that "normies" don't understand. It implies, you aren't really sober, and you are thinking like an alcoholic. "Alcoholic thinking" is just another thing AA pulled out of thin air, with zero clinical foundation in believing it. There is, however, a religious foundation to it.
 
How many times do I need to explain it to you? It has been done time and again.

In other words you are just claiming things and have no intention of making what are claiming clear ?

There is no definition of "spiritual" or "spirituality" that I know of which does not refer to the supernatural in some way or another. So to say that "spiritual", which is an adjective of the word "spirit", is not necessarily related to that noun is wordplay at best, and dishonest at worst.

So, again, explain it to me.
 
We could discuss what 'supernatural' means, and if there remain unknowns in physics current description of reality.

Your statement will be preaching to the 'philosophical materialists' choir anyway. Period.

And it's a position that offers an alcoholic another opportunity to keep drinking; most when thinking alcoholically would rather be a drunk atheist than a sober not-atheist.


So Al your position is that you can be a sober theist, or drunk atheist, and a atheist must surrender his personal philosophy to gain his sobriety through AA.

Rather than embrace the concept that now there are new philosophies and treatment methods available, new paths and new options, the AA supporters on this snap back "well what's their efficacy" Knowing damn well that AA aren't exactly open with the statistics of their efficacy.

And furthermore Al Bell, and A.A. Alife, why is this a problem for you? That somewhere in the last 75 years new ideas and new theories are usurping Bill W's spirituality? Why are you so threatened by alternatives?

Why can't you accept there are alternatives? Why aren't you delighted that theres more help out there?
 
Last edited:
This is the false dichotomy that AA manipulates people into believing.
Any false dichotomy is yours. Since nearly all people in the US are not-atheists so are most who show up for help at AA.

Reading comments like those posted here just throw a not-atheist alcoholic one more bad choice he can make to justify continuing to drink.

People are suckered into the program by being told it is not religious.
One more time AA is as religious, or not religious, as one chooses to make it. Of course the real choice an alcoholic needs to make is how to get help.
 
Any false dichotomy is yours. Since nearly all people in the US are not-atheists so are most who show up for help at AA.

No. The false dichotomy was yours, which exactly why I quoted it directly from you. You wrote it, not me.

Just because someone is not an atheist means nothing. Jews and Muslims aren't atheists, but just because they aren't atheist, does not mean they are willing to, or want to be roped into, accepting the Christian conception of God as the holy trinity. Believing in "a god," does not mean believing in "your god."

Just because someone happens to believe in a god, does not mean they want accept the puritanical, micro-managing god of AA. Not just denominations like Catholics or Anglicans, who believe we are given freewill; but even Christian fundamentalists see the concept of a "god of your understanding," as promoted by those AA's like yourself as religious heresy. Like this guy: My Word Like Fire. Picking a god of your choosing, whether it be a toaster oven or chia pet, goes against the first commandment.

AA is not just asking that you believe (or be willing to believe until you see the light, as stated in the "We Agnostics" chapter of the 'Big Book'). They are asking you to believe in a specific god, regardless of what you choose to call him. A god who, among other things:

- removes character flaws
- gives us a 24-hour at-a-time reprieve from addiction
- answers prayers
- fixates on alcoholism
- didn't care about you before you entered AA and performed the steps, and won't care about you when you leave

You're assuming people believe your AA god just because they believe in a deity. It's simply a wrong assumption.
 
So Al your position is that you can be a sober theist, or drunk atheist, and a atheist must surrender his personal philosophy to gain his sobriety through AA.
As answered, No!

Rather than embrace the concept that now there are new philosophies and treatment methods available, new paths and new options, the AA supporters on this snap back "well what's their efficacy" Knowing damn well that AA aren't exactly open with the statistics of their efficacy.
Other programs that don't stress anonymity may have good stats on recovery. Do they?

It is imo impossible to amass decent stats on AA rates, and control group/ longitudinal no way at all. If it's as high as 5% of all who walk through the doors it is something. Based on my time in the rooms I suspect most who show up aren't alcoholics anyway; those that are soon discover Closed Discussion groups are the actual AA, not necessarily what you read in books.

And furthermore Al Bell, and A.A. Alife, why is this a problem for you? That somewhere in the last 75 years new ideas and new theories are usurping Bill W's spirituality? Why are you so threatened by alternatives?

Why can't you accept there are alternatives? Why aren't you delighted that theres more help out there?
Efficacy?
 
And it's a position that offers an alcoholic another opportunity to keep drinking; most when thinking alcoholically would rather be a drunk atheist than a sober not-atheist.

So, your claim is that atheism leads to drinking and god belief leads to sobriety.

And where is the evidence to support this?
 
AA Alfie has also asked for statistics in greater detail. I'll humour him first.

I'm not smiling yet. Where is your evidence?

Again a moment please.

How many more moments do you need?

Can you cite real figures that demonstrate AA's effectiveness how many people have successfully tried and completed and remained sober through AA, as a percentage of the people who attend AA and continue to drink.

No-one has made any claims here that I can recall about the success or otherwise of AA. You on the other hand ....

It is nothing like a form of CBT.

Please explain why?

In other words you are just claiming things and have no intention of making what are claiming clear ?

Here is just one of a number that I have posted previously.

If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being. This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings.

There is no definition of "spiritual" or "spirituality" that I know of which does not refer to the supernatural in some way or another. So to say that "spiritual", which is an adjective of the word "spirit", is not necessarily related to that noun is wordplay at best, and dishonest at worst.

A bit more just for your further edification:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirituality

Secular spirituality emphasizes humanistic qualities such as love, compassion, patience, tolerance, forgiveness, contentment, responsibility, harmony, and a concern for others, aspects of life and human experience which go beyond a purely materialist view of the world, without necessarily accepting belief in a supernatural reality or divine being.

So, again, explain it to me.

I trust that suffices.

Rather than embrace the concept that now there are new philosophies and treatment methods available, new paths and new options, the AA supporters on this snap back "well what's their efficacy" Knowing damn well that AA aren't exactly open with the statistics of their efficacy.

So what are their efficacy statistics?
Surely you aren't saying something like "I don't have to show mine because AA doesn't show their"? Are you?

You have made a number of claims here and have not supported them, I would sincerely appreciate you stumping up with the information.


And furthermore Al Bell, and A.A. Alife, why is this a problem for you? That somewhere in the last 75 years new ideas and new theories are usurping Bill W's spirituality? Why are you so threatened by alternatives?

I for one am not threatened, nor do I have a problem with other therapies - in fact I try and embrace everything that is out there (in terms of offering clients alternatives). Anyone who has been reading this thread will have heard me say time and again that "AA does not have a monopoly on recovery". They will also have read from me that "AA doesn't work for everyone" and as such I am very interested in all other alternatives from both a personal and professional standpoint.

Your insinuation here is a little shallow to be honest. Can you provide the efficacy of these other therapies or not?

Why can't you accept there are alternatives? Why aren't you delighted that theres more help out there?

I can and do accept there are alternatives. I am (will be) delighted when I see what they are and how effective they are. Can you provide this information or not?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Secular spirituality emphasizes humanistic qualities such as love, compassion, patience, tolerance, forgiveness, contentment, responsibility, harmony, and a concern for others, aspects of life and human experience which go beyond a purely materialist view of the world, without necessarily accepting belief in a supernatural reality or divine being.



I trust that suffices.

It doesn't suffice in terms of AA because spirituality within AA is directly tied to a deity explicitly referred to as "God" in both AA program literature and in common practices found in the majority of AA meetings (namely prayer as a form of petition to this supernatural monotheistic being).
 
It doesn't suffice in terms of AA because spirituality within AA is directly tied to a deity explicitly referred to as "God" in both AA program literature and in common practices found in the majority of AA meetings (namely prayer as a form of petition to this supernatural monotheistic being).

Wrong.

The words "as we understood him" allows for any God (or not) to be used and any form of spirituality.
The "common practice" and "majority of meetings" you refer to may well be the way in your neck of the woods, however further afield both the practical application and personal interpretation allow for exactly what I am saying.

I honestly find it hard to believe you are a current AA member given your lack of understanding around this.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being. This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings.

Yeah, and if flying can be understood as the act of picking one's nose, the Wright brothers were idiots because people could already fly.

Gee, playing with definitions is FUN !!!

Secular spirituality emphasizes humanistic qualities such as love, compassion, patience, tolerance, forgiveness, contentment, responsibility, harmony, and a concern for others, aspects of life and human experience which go beyond a purely materialist view of the world, without necessarily accepting belief in a supernatural reality or divine being.

But how is it spirituality if the word no longer means anything remotely like the original meaning ? And don't we already have a word for all that stuff ? Humanism ?
 
It doesn't suffice in terms of AA because spirituality within AA is directly tied to a deity explicitly referred to as "God" in both AA program literature and in common practices found in the majority of AA meetings (namely prayer as a form of petition to this supernatural monotheistic being).

No, Bamberger you are wrong for the umpteenth time. This is your interpretation which I respect but it is clearly not the definition nor understanding of anyone here that is involved with AA. Not one member of AA that has posted here has agreed with your supposition of spirituality as it relates to AA.
 
Gee, playing with definitions is FUN !!!

But how is it spirituality if the word no longer means anything remotely like the original meaning ? And don't we already have a word for all that stuff ? Humanism ?

Maybe. But spirituality works under the definition I have provided and it is supported through psychology also (I have linked previously on this too).

When we (me anyway) use the word spiritual I see it as meaning a whole lot different that religious.

"Gay" used to mean something different too, language and cultures evolve, it's just that some people don't. ;)

The truth is that spirituality does mean different things to different people: This is both interpretation and truth. I choose to interpret it in such a way that is my truth. You choose to interpret the word another way, and that is your truth. I also don't really care how you choose.
 
It is imo impossible to amass decent stats on AA rates, and control group/ longitudinal no way at all. If it's as high as 5% of all who walk through the doors it is something. Based on my time in the rooms I suspect most who show up aren't alcoholics anyway; those that are soon discover Closed Discussion groups are the actual AA, not necessarily what you read in books.

Which is a fantastic way of saying "we're not going to be able to produce good statistical evidence of the success of AA."


Efficacy?

But we're going to demand it from everyone else.

Would you like your cake AlBell, or would you like to eat you cake?
 
Maybe. But spirituality works under the definition I have provided and it is supported through psychology also (I have linked previously on this too).

Shrinks don't usually determine what words mean.

When we (me anyway) use the word spiritual I see it as meaning a whole lot different that religious.

It's all the same bunch of woo. As I said, "humanism" covers all that you mentioned, so why not use that ?

The truth is that spirituality does mean different things to different people: This is both interpretation and truth. I choose to interpret it in such a way that is my truth. You choose to interpret the word another way, and that is your truth. I also don't really care how you choose.

There you go. "Your truth". Your entire line of argument in this thread has been saying that each person has his or her own truth. In other words we can't say anything definitive about any subject. What a useful philosophy !
 
Wrong.

The words "as we understood him" allows for any God (or not) to be used and any form of spirituality.

But doesn't the AA literature capitalize the pronoun "him" when referring to God? The phrase "as we understood Him" (as written in the AA literature) would be taken by most people to mean a supernatural being is being referred to, wouldn't it? For example, if someone asked me if President Obama's steak and eggs were ready I might say: " I already gave them to him. But if a member of my congregation asked me if I prayed to God for help I would say "I already asked Him for his protection and care.

Do you see what I mean?
 
But we're going to demand it from everyone else.

The odd thing is that no-one here that I recall has made any claims about AA. You on the other hand has said that other therapies work better (or to same effect). I assume by your continued attacks on others that you are unable to provide the evidence for your claims?

Shrinks don't usually determine what words mean.

Indeed, however psychologists are not usually shrinks. Do you have a different truth on the use of the word "shrink" than me?

That aside, word use is determined by society. Many use the word spiritual without any attachment to a deity. I assume now you understand the difference?

It's all the same bunch of woo. As I said, "humanism" covers all that you mentioned, so why not use that ?

What for? The English language has many strage idiosyncracies from country to country and region to region. You say tomatoe ......

There you go. "Your truth". Your entire line of argument in this thread has been saying that each person has his or her own truth. In other words we can't say anything definitive about any subject. What a useful philosophy !

Seems the irony was lost on you. :)

But doesn't the AA literature capitalize the pronoun "him" when referring to God? The phrase "as we understood Him" (as written in the AA literature) would be taken by most people to mean a supernatural being is being referred to, wouldn't it? For example, if someone asked me if President Obama's steak and eggs were ready I might say: " I already gave them to him. But if a member of my congregation asked me if I prayed to God for help I would say "I already asked Him for his protection and care.

Do you see what I mean?

Sure, but it was written 75 years ago by a seriously religious man. His writings are his, they are neither my beliefs nor those of many others. Should I change the writings of Homer, Shakespeare et al because the language of the day has changed (I am not comparing the quality of writing btw)?

And yes, AA has its roots in Christian religion. Bill and Bob could not have forseen the spread and breadth of AA from those humble beginnings; the movement has traversed the globe and encompasses many cultures, religions, languages etc. What is relevent to the founders is not necessarily relevant to others either in theory or practice.
 
What is important to AA is not how one defines one's own spirituality. They will accept anyone's conception, because the point is to get them into the group. But examine how this "any conception of spirituality" plays out in practice, and it's easy to see the absurdity of it all.

> You can define spirituality in its traditional religious way, like it is described in the 'Big Book'.

> It can be Alfie's secular explanation.

> It can be a new age view, like "at one with the energy in the universe."

> It be the feeling one gets from "runner's high."

> You may define 'anger' as spiritualism. (which brings up an interesting contradiction with the rest of the program).

> The feeling of nausea can be your spiritual feeling.

> Dizziness can be spiritual.

> Laughter can be spiritual.

> Even the opposite of Alfie's brand of spiritualism is acceptable. Instead "inner peace" and "the foundations of happiness." You can label inner turmoil and sadness as your spiritual guide.

Really, the sky is the limit. Yet, the only thing that matters is that you identify spirituality in some way, and that will allow you the spiritual awakening needed to bring about sobriety. Somehow if you just pick some feeling or weird premise, and identify it as "spiritual," you're working the AA program.

It's not what it is, or how it makes you feel. It is that you name it "spiritual." That's the key.

No wonder they encourage people not to think or question what they are told.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom