Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Considering the state of mind of several people who attend AA, I don't think they necessarily are fully aware of the implications so, in a way, yes, they are.

So... when you say "several people who attend AA", do you mean four people?

Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for moderated thread.


Perhaps Danny was talking about a continuum of folks along the "religious" belief system line. I would think a rational person could imagine those that are "slightly" religious to those that are "deeply" religious; a woman who teaches Sunday school and all, but has a tramp stamp... as opposed to a woman who is the number 12 wife.

So, to throw the word "religious" out there indiscriminately just becomes tiresome.

Now belz,

I'm sorry to break this to you, but...
You were saying something about "us" imposing on others? If you mean magnificent due to its stateliness and dignity, then I suppose.

A.A. cannot and will not attempt to sell you anything... not good behavior nor punishment for bad behavior. Since when does punishment for bad behavior change the behavior? If it did, then "Go sit in the corner" would prevent children from temper tantrums. The child will moderate their behavior... to the best of their ability... until your eyes are no longer on them. When you look away... the cat's tail is once again in peril.

A.A. merely bases its work on enabling the step worker an environment in which they can get a look at certain behaviors... and to determine for themselves whether or not it is objectionable... and whether or not they might want said behavior to be cast out.

You may find this all silly without the certainty of a Higher Power... but if it works for some, would you really question their "level of awareness"?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Danny, I'm not sure how I can get as many answers as there are people if the question I am asking is binary (yes/no) in nature. I could get a higher percentage of one answer than the other though.

The question was:

Organized or not, a belief system can still be considered a religion, can't it? In the case of AA, the religious aspect is comprised of giving one's will and life over to a God of one's understanding, and improving one's conscience contact with this God through continued prayer and meditation.


Yes, not only that but the belief system that is the root of AA is that alcoholics suffer from a spiritual disease which requires a spiritual solution. As mcgowdog has so aptly pointed out, according to the beliefs of AA, alcoholism is but a symptom of a larger issue. In other words, "ALCOHOLICS Anonymous" treats ALCOHOLISM as a secondary issue. I see it as a part of the systematic exploitation of people who are suffering, whether the exploitation is conscious or not.
 
Perhaps Danny was talking about a continuum of folks along the "religious" belief system line. I would think a rational person could imagine those that are "slightly" religious to those that are "deeply" religious; a woman who teaches Sunday school and all, but has a tramp stamp... as opposed to a woman who is the number 12 wife.

So, to throw the word "religious" out there indiscriminately just becomes tiresome.

The point is not that various members may or may not be some sort of level of religious; the point is that AA as a group, as an organization, is religious. A woman teaching Sunday school could be an atheist, but I would think she'd be hard-pressed to claim the Sunday school was not religious.


Now belz,

You were saying something about "us" imposing on others? If you mean magnificent due to its stateliness and dignity, then I suppose.

A.A. cannot and will not attempt to sell you anything... not good behavior nor punishment for bad behavior. Since when does punishment for bad behavior change the behavior? If it did, then "Go sit in the corner" would prevent children from temper tantrums. The child will moderate their behavior... to the best of their ability... until your eyes are no longer on them. When you look away... the cat's tail is once again in peril.

AA can and does attempt to sell you something: selling a clean spirit which, when applied correctly according to the big book, will also alleviate your alcoholic symptoms.

"When you want what we've got and will go to any length to get it" -- selling inclusion, acceptance in a group

"If not AA, then jails, institutions, or death await you." -- if that kind of thinking isn't typical of punishment, I don't know what is. And punishment, ostracism, shunning... these all are incredibly effective for governing behavior.



A.A. merely bases its work on enabling the step worker an environment in which they can get a look at certain behaviors... and to determine for themselves whether or not it is objectionable... and whether or not they might want said behavior to be cast out.

You may find this all silly without the certainty of a Higher Power... but if it works for some, would you really question their "level of awareness"?

AA "merely bases" its work on the concept that alcoholism is a spiritual problem which requires a spiritual solution. As I've said before in this thread, there are more relevant, more accurate ways of describing alcoholism and treating it.
 
It would be far more honest.

I can only hope that it would seriously reduce the number of people who would get sucked into it, and that the government would no longer funnel people into its maws.

I think if there was a big sign out front saying "AA is religious" I think it'd steer alot of people onto other less dogmatic paths.

And I think it'd allow plenty of court cases like the ones where people object to being sentences to AA as a violation of their first amendment rights.
 
I also have been deeply involved in all aspects of AA (including substantial time at GSO in NY) for a similar amount of time. Anecdotally, on the west coast of the USA (where I've lead/attended more meetings, conferences, district & area events than elsewhere) I would say that in terms of newcomers, brand new presented to the program for the first time, at least 50% come from the courts, with many areas hitting 90% when you add treatment center 'graduates' to the court mandated count. 75% court mandated by itself is probably a bit high for an average, but I'd feel completely comfortable supporting a statement of 50% on average (note I'm only referring to new people hitting AA for the first time).

Quibbling about such numbers when AA itself won't let others do research - and certainly won't start any studies on their own - is nit picking and unproductive as far as the topic is concerned.

Per the topic, the information in this thread coupled with my own experience has certainly confirmed the point that the AA program as written and promoted is religious, a point that AA & it's members go to great lengths to deny.

From 1993- 1997 I was frequently at AA/GSO NYC, I was also not only deeply involved but was one of the Representatives for the State of Tennessee, I have been "deeply" involved for 15 years advocating for less involvement from Treatment Centers and the Judicial System. I could go on and on. So not to one up you but I know exactly what I am talking about from the top of this problem to the bottom. I am also a alumni from one of the worst Treatment Centers God ever put on this earth. I am right now involved in the Treatment Center Industry. Since this is a entirely different subject I will stop here.
AA has about a 2-3% referral from the Judicial System with the Treatment Centers adding another 33%. This has not changed for the last 20 years or so. Back in the late 60's , 70's and early 80's I might have agreed with you that AA was about 50% referral from Treatment Centers. But with the aftercare programs the Treatment Centers have today and the lack of need for many of the people to go to AA, numbers have dropped.
Guys this is a good thing, people are getting help earlier and avoiding the pitfalls of years of addiction.
Religion I don't think really plays a part in whether one will attend AA or not. It is 2011 people can do or do without religion. Just take a look in the households of your average Americans over the last two generations. My parents went 50% of the time yet their parents went practically everyday. They were Catholics. I had no inclination towards religion nor was any pushed on me after I was 13 years old.
As far as new people who come to AA, I find a large % are brought by other AA members. My brother and sister live in LA and have for over 30 years, they both were a part of AA (are not now). My brother since 1972 and my sister since 1979, neither one agreed with your post in general. My brother pointed out that you can go to inner cities and find certain home groups or clubs who cater to rehabs and probation officers but this is not indicative of AA everywhere (I know that wasn't your point) but you tried to inflate the number broadly, it isn't valid.
They are an overwhelming amount of meeting with members that are not a part of the judicial system or the treatment centers nor are their home groups/clubs.
Example Cherokee County GA. and Cobb County there is one Club in both counties that the Treatment Centers and Judicial System send 99% of the referrals. There are 100's of meetings in these two counties.
Just saying.
 
So... when you say "several people who attend AA", do you mean four people?

I assume this was a rhetorical question. In case it wasn't, no. I don't think AA has fooled only four people into religious nonsense.

Perhaps Danny was talking about a continuum of folks along the "religious" belief system line.

And here we have a boolean value: religious or non-religious.

I would think a rational person could imagine those that are "slightly" religious to those that are "deeply" religious; a woman who teaches Sunday school and all, but has a tramp stamp... as opposed to a woman who is the number 12 wife.

What does this have to do with this thread ?

So, to throw the word "religious" out there indiscriminately just becomes tiresome.

Have you been reading this thread at all ? Now, we may disagree, but most participants have been relatively discriminate about what "religious" means, and AA certainly fits the bill.

You were saying something about "us" imposing on others? If you mean magnificent due to its stateliness and dignity, then I suppose.

I have no idea what that means or if it's really directed at me.

A.A. cannot and will not attempt to sell you anything...

Of course it will. As has been explained in this thread several times already. It tries to sell the idea that alcoholism is a spiritual disease with god as the cure. Now, it may not cost you dollars, but it will cost you something to buy that.

Since when does punishment for bad behavior change the behavior? If it did, then "Go sit in the corner" would prevent children from temper tantrums. The child will moderate their behavior... to the best of their ability... until your eyes are no longer on them. When you look away... the cat's tail is once again in peril.

Punishment DOES change behaviour, then.

You may find this all silly without the certainty of a Higher Power... but if it works for some, would you really question their "level of awareness"?

Because A) It doesn't actually work, so it doesn't help the alcoholic take control of his addiction and B) because some members who join AA might not expect to be indoctrinated.
 
The Sunday school teacher may also be mildly religious and wife #12 may be a skeptic... with really long hair.

A.A. is too autonomous for you to paint it with such a broad brush. I go to a couple of groups that just simply are not religious. They don't go far enough to take you there.

Now, if you're sufficiently anti-religious and are looking for an argument about this, you'll succeed.

I'm on the side of open-mindedness on the issue of religion. My definition of moral is simply, "Does it work?" This is what works for me, so this is where I stand.

For religion, I've got to get dressed, cross the T's and dot the I'S, SITSTANDKNEEL, SING, eat drink, and PraisetheLord Pass the Basket.

In A.A. we say one little PRAYER and everybody gets their shorts in a bunch.

If you could help another drunk, would you?

I haven't been to a meeting in a couple of weeks. I wonder if I'll get scowled at. They'll snub me and not invite me to eat dinner with them.

Wonder where I can get this nasty Spirit washed. Oh yeah. I'll go see Marcelas Walace.
 
"When you want what we've got and will go to any length to get it" -- selling inclusion, acceptance in a group

Oh no it's not. They are not selling anything. This is a condition. This is a ticket out. This is an off ramp out of the "organization" as you put it. It's a fellowship, a program, and a book btw... as experienced at the individual/group level.

"If not AA, then jails, institutions, or death await you." -- if that kind of thinking isn't typical of punishment, I don't know what is. And punishment, ostracism, shunning... these all are incredibly effective for governing behavior.

There again, no they don't. Not for the "real" alcoholic. I bet y'll love that "real" term. But the book talks about real alcoholics.

No thread of those things can carry the depth and weight to keep an alcoholic from the next first drink. The book talks about mental blank spots, the humiliation and suffering of even a week ago do not crowd into mind to deter us. The statement that booze can lead an alcoholic to insanity, death, or even jail is not a threat or an opinion.

Haven't you ever drank too much and wound up in the hospital? I have. At the age of 10, my mom wanted our family doctor to come see me when I was totally bombed. I could have died of alcohol poisoning. The doc told my mom to leave me be and let me sleep it off.

Haven't you ever gone to jail while drunk? I have. Haven't you ever had the cops take you to the psych ward on your way to jail? I have. This would be one of my last drunks and the dreaded "hotel" incident.

So, these are not manipulative threats or attempts to "govern" our behavior. These are just little strolls down memory lane for some of us.

AA "merely bases" its work on the concept that alcoholism is a spiritual problem which requires a spiritual solution. As I've said before in this thread, there are more relevant, more accurate ways of describing alcoholism and treating it.

You may have said a lot of stuff in this thread. I'm "new blood" here. I've got 4 posts under my belt since my recent loggin and I'm averaging about one post a day... so I've got to make the most of it... assuming this makes it.

If you want to steer this thread to those other methods, great! This was the only thread discussing A.A. here that I've seen as of yet, so this is what I'm here to discuss.

What I was interested in discussing is whether A.A. is a religion or not. If A.A. absolutely must be a religion... I think we should own it and go big. I'm sick of being stuck in scummy and mildewed church basements. I think we should go top floor, get our own steeples and spires... maybe have an amulet and a fuming incense stencher. God knows I put enough damned money in the basket. Cheapskates.
 
Alfie, would you contend that AA is in fact religious in nature, or at least has enough components associated with religion that could lead one to reasonably refer to the organization as such?

I have said that AA has roots in religion, I have also said that many in AA are religious. That said, AA in practice does not have to be religious, there is sufficient room within the program (whatever that means for you) for it not to be.
Is AA religious? It can be.
Is it spiritual? Most certainly.

To label it religious would be a complete misnomer. Why? I would answer this way... what religion is being taught? what are the tenets and teachings?

The problem is telling people, as AA does, that their problem is spiritual and that God can remove their problem and make them sober again. This ignores quite a bit of science and can be terribly damaging.

Experts in psychology seem to disagree.

http://psychcentral.com/news/2007/03/19/spirituality-aids-alcohol-recovery/692.html

"These findings suggest that including spirituality of all kinds into the delivery of recovery services for alcoholism may indeed help"


What and how can it be "terribly damaging"? (my bold)

That's the key point. It can't. In reality, "take what you want and leave the rest" was originally meant to apply to opinions one hears from other AAers - not the program itself.

You mean like the steps? Which are "suggested".

Sounds to me like you can take what you want and leave the rest.

I'm sorry to break this to you, but truth isn't different from one person to the next.

Sure it is.
My truth can be a great deal different to yours or anyone elses.

I again disagree strongly. There is no "spiritual" problem behind alcoholism ...

Many experts disagree (see above).
btw, that is just one link from one quick search, there will no doubt be plenty of others.
 
What I was interested in discussing is whether A.A. is a religion or not. If A.A. absolutely must be a religion... I think we should own it and go big. I'm sick of being stuck in scummy and mildewed church basements. I think we should go top floor, get our own steeples and spires... maybe have an amulet and a fuming incense stencher. God knows I put enough damned money in the basket. Cheapskates.

Although AA must not be a formal religion per se (although that would be honest), it should be more up front about its religious nature. For example, the AA pamphlet titled "This is AA" is likely to be one of the first pieces of written information that a prospective member or caregiver will read. The pamphlet is 21 pages long. On page 15 of the pamphlet the concept of God (or higher Power) is first introduced as the path to recovery from alcoholism. The pages leading up to that talk about the problem of alcoholism in general terms. The preamble that is found at the beginning of the pamphlet would lead no one to believe that the program is religious in nature.

It is only when one starts to get deeper into the program that they are introduced to the monotheistic God of AA. The first 164 pages of the big book are chock full of references to God, as are the 12 steps and traditions. Again, the prospective newcomer will not immediately be subject to these texts when he enters the halls. But they await him. This is why AA is termed a bait-and-switch program (as far as religion is concerned) by many people.
 
http://psychcentral.com/news/2007/03/19/spirituality-aids-alcohol-recovery/692.html

"These findings suggest that including spirituality of all kinds into the delivery of recovery services for alcoholism may indeed help"

How can including spirituality help in any way if there are no such things as spirits ?

Sure it is.
My truth can be a great deal different to yours or anyone elses.

No. What you're talking about is interpretation. The truth does not change. Or perhaps you'd like to explain how 23 degrees C for me can be different for you ?
 

Did you actually read this study? I'm guessing no, or if you did you didn't understand it. The study doesn't establish, and was not meant to determine, a causal relationship. And just to make this point once again - every study on AA that has determined that relationship has shown it to be either completely ineffective, and to have a negative effect.

From the study:

"The study does not establish the direction of the relationship."

It's also interesting to see what these "researchers" were trying to quantify (in a non-religious way):

-Loving God Scale
- Controlling God Scale
- Beliefs
- Forgiveness (of others, and from God)
 
Oh no it's not. They are not selling anything. This is a condition. This is a ticket out. This is an off ramp out of the "organization" as you put it. It's a fellowship, a program, and a book btw... as experienced at the individual/group level.



There again, no they don't. Not for the "real" alcoholic. I bet y'll love that "real" term. But the book talks about real alcoholics.
Of course a "real alcoholic" is one who cannot stay abstinent from alcohol without attending AA meetings and taking the 12 steps of AA. I've done that, so clearly I'm not a "real alcoholic."

It's interesting that one can only "truly" find out if one is a "real" alcoholic by stopping doing the program of AA, thus the determination can only be made in retrospect. This makes makes it a "Pascals Wager" type situation - just as the cost-benefit ratio of being Christian if there's no (Christian) God is much greater than NOT being Christian and finding out there IS a (Christian) God, it's much "cheaper" to believe one is alcoholic and continue AA meetings even if one is not, than to believe one is NOT an alcoholic and stop attending AA.

No thread of those things can carry the depth and weight to keep an alcoholic from the next first drink. The book talks about mental blank spots, the humiliation and suffering of even a week ago do not crowd into mind to deter us.
That sounds exactly like me, years after stopping drinking - the humiliation and suffering of even a week earlier still didn't deter me from going back to an AA meeting!

Okay, I do admit "the love of the program" as presented to me by sponsors and others (and as I mentioned before, hearing of the suicides of people I had met and hearing the death ALWAYS blamed on "the disease of alcoholism" and "he just couldn't be honest with himself") did finally drive me away from the program.
The statement that THE EXCESSIVE CONSUMPTION OF booze can lead an alcoholic A PERSON to insanity, death, or even jail is not a threat or an opinion.
Oh, I agree (as edited). And you forgot to mention what was impressed on me as the worst possible result, a wet brain.
Haven't you ever drank too much and wound up in the hospital? I have. At the age of 10, my mom wanted our family doctor to come see me when I was totally bombed. I could have died of alcohol poisoning. The doc told my mom to leave me be and let me sleep it off.

Haven't you ever gone to jail while drunk? I have. Haven't you ever had the cops take you to the psych ward on your way to jail? I have. This would be one of my last drunks and the dreaded "hotel" incident.

So, these are not manipulative threats or attempts to "govern" our behavior. These are just little strolls down memory lane for some of us.
Attendance at AA meetings often leads to reinterpretations of these incidents as being caused by "the spiritual disease of alcoholism."

You may have said a lot of stuff in this thread. I'm "new blood" here. I've got 4 posts under my belt since my recent loggin and I'm averaging about one post a day... so I've got to make the most of it... assuming this makes it.

If you want to steer this thread to those other methods, great! This was the only thread discussing A.A. here that I've seen as of yet, so this is what I'm here to discuss.
This may be the only discussion of AA or 12-step groups EVER on JREF/randi.org. As I've said in the links I posted earlier in this thread (I've only been here a few weeks myself), there's not nearly enough discussion of AA and other 12 step groups on skeptical Internet discussions, whereas groups with lesser "public relations policies" such as Scientology are regularly pointed out as specious belief systems.
What I was interested in discussing is whether A.A. is a religion or not. If A.A. absolutely must be a religion... I think we should own it and go big. I'm sick of being stuck in scummy and mildewed church basements. I think we should go top floor, get our own steeples and spires... maybe have an amulet and a fuming incense stencher. God knows I put enough damned money in the basket. Cheapskates.
You may be pleased to know that AAWS main offices are in something called The Interchurch Center. However, the addresses I've seen on official AA websites only gives a street address, and don't actually have "Interchurch Center" or "Interchurch Building" in the address.

AAWS and the AA Grapevine are listed as tenants here:
http://www.interchurch-center.org/?q=tenantagencies

But then AA calling itself a religion would only stop only one of many misrepresentations that are regularly made in AA meetings and by AA members.
 
Of course a "real alcoholic" is one who cannot stay abstinent from alcohol without attending AA meetings and taking the 12 steps of AA. I've done that, so clearly I'm not a "real alcoholic."
And all this time I understood a real alcoholic was someone whose drinking interferred inappropriately with his life; at home, acquaintainces, work, etc.

Some alcoholics certainly stop drinking without AA; I know several who did so.


But then AA calling itself a religion would only stop only one of many misrepresentations that are regularly made in AA meetings and by AA members.
I've seen more misrepresentations concerning AA in this thread than ever occurred in my fairly long experience with AA.
 
You may be pleased to know that AAWS main offices are in something called The Interchurch Center. However, the addresses I've seen on official AA websites only gives a street address, and don't actually have "Interchurch Center" or "Interchurch Building" in the address.

AAWS and the AA Grapevine are listed as tenants here:
http://www.interchurch-center.org/?q=tenantagencies

But then AA calling itself a religion would only stop only one of many misrepresentations that are regularly made in AA meetings and by AA members.

This would be "The God Box." From their mission statement:

"“The Interchurch Center is owned and managed under the auspices of several Christian Organizations as a Class A office facility, with the mission to provide a working environment that is conducive to ecumenism and interreligious involvement.”
 
It is only when one starts to get deeper into the program that they are introduced to the monotheistic God of AA...

Bam, I agree with your conclusions and I am understanding your argument and all... but the A.A. I know is just different than the one you must and most people know. I've been to so many different meetings/groups across the US and abroad even.

Most meetings are very similar. But there's a group of folks in Denver nicknamed the God Squad for peat sakes. But they have such a fundamental and simple to the book grassroots approach, that it doesn't even resemble most meetings I've seen anywhere.

They are definitely pro-God people. But they are off the hook in their own individual ways in seeking this thing we all call God. Some do Course in Miracles. Some do kundalini, some do yoga, some do chanting, some do mentations, some do Catholicism, some just do the Big Book stuff... But they come together and when appropriate, discuss their current experience in their seeking of this... God.

I capitalize God because I consider God the Source... of all things manifest and the unmanifest... or the Void of pure potentiality. I'm not trying to be a smart-aleck or a big shot here. But I've truly gone down and been on this path for at least since 1994.

Why does the seeking of this God have to be a religion? I've got an author on my blog... a sort of internet friend, peer, and spiritual guide, who says that he in not a Christian, but he is a follower of Jesus. He's native American too, so he's got his own "path" to this thing some of us call God.

I feel, like some of my peers that do A.A., that I could walk away from A.A. now and live a God-centered life and do pretty well... and stay sober. But I know some good folks in that A.A. I really do.

A.A. does work. It really does. I shouldn't even be here or need to be here defending it. But what I have to say is that so many folks are doing something vastly different than A.A., but they are calling it A.A.

Who am I to judge A.A.? I am someone who just knows... from down on the street level. I've seen middle of the road... and folks defend it to the almost death. They want to explain their simplified, comfortable, don't upset the cart method to sobriety... and they want to appologize for the mention of God... don't want to scare off the new man with this talk of God! It's sickening because it's not A.A. and it don't work for folks like me.

But I'm told by you anti/XAers (Anti A.A.ers and/or ex-A.A.ers) that it's all A.A. That means I'm responsible for bad A.A. too.

Well because of that, I will stand up for good A.A. and at least try to describe my experience in that. But some of you folks will just say, "Well he's just a step Nazi. He's the worst kind."

I hear that you can gauge your effectiveness by the quality of your enemies. I just wish I could see one of you folks in the f2f world and not just here on the internet.
 
Bam, I agree with your conclusions and I am understanding your argument and all... but the A.A. I know is just different than the one you must and most people know. I've been to so many different meetings/groups across the US and abroad even.

Did you find that the mention of God and the use of prayer at closing was a common factor in the majority of these meetings?
 
How can including spirituality help in any way if there are no such things as spirits ?

Sprirituality does not have to include spirits. This really isn't a difficult concept to grasp.

No. What you're talking about is interpretation. The truth does not change. Or perhaps you'd like to explain how 23 degrees C for me can be different for you ?

My truth changes compared to yours, At 23C an Innuit would be hot and a desert dweller cold. One is hot - his truth, one cold her truth.

Did you actually read this study? I'm guessing no, or if you did you didn't understand it. The study doesn't establish, and was not meant to determine, a causal relationship.

You might need to show me where I said that it did. Did you actually read the earlier posts? I'm guessing not; we were discussing whether alcoholism could be a spiritual based problem (in part). Many psychologists believe it does which supports some of the arguments that AA and others here have been making.
 
And all this time I understood a real alcoholic was someone whose drinking interferred inappropriately with his life; at home, acquaintainces, work, etc.

Some alcoholics certainly stop drinking without AA; I know several who did so.
That's more of a secular, "outside meetings" definition of alcoholic. In meetings alcoholism is all about negative feelings, anger, resentment, selfishness and self-centeredness, as described in Chapter 5 on the fourth step.

And yes, of course there have always been many who quit without AA, but AA members dismiss their abstinence as either they weren't "real" alcoholics or they're on a "dry drunk" because they're not working the spiritual program of AA. I recall several articles talking about how President George W. Bush was a "dry drunk" and had those negative feelings and characteristics of an alcoholic.

I never heard "jails, institutions, death or stopping drinking without AA" said in all the meetings I attended or by any AA member.
I've seen more misrepresentations concerning AA in this thread than ever occurred in my fairly long experience with AA.
I've alos seen a lot of misrepresentations in this thread, but I suspect we wouldn't agree on which statements are misrepresentations.
 
I'm on the side of open-mindedness on the issue of religion. My definition of moral is simply, "Does it work?" This is what works for me, so this is where I stand.

According to what little information we have, it doesn't work for the vast majority of people. Too bad only one circuit court in the US ruled that alternatives to AA had to be pushed. So, are the courts *really* interested in 'effective'?


For religion, I've got to get dressed, cross the T's and dot the I'S, SITSTANDKNEEL, SING, eat drink, and PraisetheLord Pass the Basket.

In A.A. we say one little PRAYER and everybody gets their shorts in a bunch.

If you could help another drunk, would you?

Is your religion claiming to be secular?

And you're minimizing the God-talk in AA if you think all that people's shorts are bunching over is "one little PRAYER."



There again, no they don't. Not for the "real" alcoholic. I bet y'll love that "real" term. But the book talks about real alcoholics.

The book['s authors] had no frikkin' clue about what a 'real' alcoholic is or not.


No thread of those things can carry the depth and weight to keep an alcoholic from the next first drink. The book talks about mental blank spots, the humiliation and suffering of even a week ago do not crowd into mind to deter us. The statement that booze can lead an alcoholic to insanity, death, or even jail is not a threat or an opinion.

I believe it is used as such, and I stand by my opinion. In fact, it isn't really known yet how addiction ties in with other mental illnesses. It is thought that the alcoholic uses alcohol as a self-medicating routine to alleviate the symptoms of the mental illness. In these cases, alcohol in and of itself isn't really the issue at all.

But many alcoholics who might fit this criteria won't ever learn this because they're attending meetings which views alcoholism as a spiritual illness which requires a spiritual solution, i.e., God as you understand Him.

When AA doesn't even view the central issue as a medical one, then how will the untrained masses who attend AA even be on the lookout for it?



Why does the seeking of this God have to be a religion?

What does the seeking of this God have anything to do with alcoholism?

Apparently googling for "christian aa" returns many groups which are hard-core religious with a little booze thrown in. Why keep the farce going that AA itself is not religious then? If the AA World Intergroup truly thought AA as an organization was "spiritual and not religious" then why did those groups in Canada get de-listed? They didn't remove the spirituality, just the God. Oops.

Seventy five years ago, I could see it. Now, not so much.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom