Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps I am picking this up wrong, but was not the principle "take what you need and leave the rest" propounded?





If that is the case, then one individual could say "I want steps 2, 6 and 9 and I will leave the rest".

Individual #2 could say "I want steps 4, 5 and 11, and I will leave the rest".

I can assure you, there's nothing about leaving particular steps. Try that concept out for size and you'll be smacked down six ways to Sunday at the average meeting.

The point is, none of the steps are necessary.

This is in no way a scientific program as far as I can see, if one can cherry pick a subset of the 12 steps at will.

This is not a scientific program period.

Look at steps 2 and 3

2) Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.

3) Made a decision to turn our will and our lives our to the care of God as we understood Him.


How on earth can you possibly imagine there's anything scientific about AA's approach when these are the foundations of the program.
How can it possibly have any scientific merit, if one can nibble some bits, while spitting out others at random, depending on ones personal beliefs?

It has no scientific merit period. And you can't nibble at one or at another. You cannot do the program without doing all the steps, but the steps aren't scientific they're dogma.
 
I can assure you, there's nothing about leaving particular steps. Try that concept out for size and you'll be smacked down six ways to Sunday at the average meeting.
This is not a scientific program period.

Look at steps 2 and 3

2) Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.

3) Made a decision to turn our will and our lives our to the care of God as we understood Him.


How on earth can you possibly imagine there's anything scientific about AA's approach when these are the foundations of the program.


It has no scientific merit period. And you can't nibble at one or at another. You cannot do the program without doing all the steps, but the steps aren't scientific they're dogma.

While I agree with what you're saying, I would caution that we are discussing whether or not AA is religious, not whether or not religious practices might have scientific merit.
 
Belz, no... It's not false for me.

I'm sorry to break this to you, but truth isn't different from one person to the next. Until evidence is presented, God doesn't exist and thus doesn't have any form of impact on reality. Therefore it cannot solve your problems.

Now, I might be inclined to agree that your belief in god may help.

What I have a problem with is imposing this belief on unsuspecting members of AA.

God solves my problem, which is not alcohol. Alcohol is "but a symptom". When God solves my "problem" (note the singular form), which is deep within me, I straighten out mentally and physically.

I again disagree strongly. There is no "spiritual" problem behind alcoholism any more than there is a spiritual problem with my potato chip abuse.
 
While I agree with what you're saying, I would caution that we are discussing whether or not AA is religious, not whether or not religious practices might have scientific merit.

I'm sorry can you consider either of those concepts of having any sort of scientific merit?
 
I can assure you, there's nothing about leaving particular steps. Try that concept out for size and you'll be smacked down six ways to Sunday at the average meeting.[/SIZE]
This brings up a point about meetings that confused me for the longest time (and thus helped brainwash me to where I bought into everything for several years). It's like a game where they don't tell you what the object of the game is (because they don't know themselves), but the object is to learn the rules (the steps and traditions, while rules in themselves, aren't "the rules" for the point of my discussion here). The "take what you like and leave the rest" is said mainly to newcomers, and it clearly does NOT mean you can take the steps cafe style. But you'll never find that out (except for indirectly, seeing that people don't question doing anything with the steps except taking them in order), unless you or someone else says "I just like step 4, so I'll take that one and leave the rest of them." The response to such a statement is usually shaming ("I once did the steps like that. I got drunk." and of course getting drunk is the WORST thing that could happen to anyone in AA). To sum up this paragraph, it's a mind****.
 
I can assure you, there's nothing about leaving particular steps. Try that concept out for size and you'll be smacked down six ways to Sunday at the average meeting.
This brings up a point about meetings that confused me for the longest time (and thus helped brainwash me to where I bought into everything for several years). It's like a game where they don't tell you what the object of the game is (because they don't know themselves), but the object is to learn the rules (the steps and traditions, while rules in themselves, aren't "the rules" for the point of my discussion here). The "take what you like and leave the rest" is said mainly to newcomers, and it clearly does NOT mean you can take the steps cafe style. But you'll never find that out (except for indirectly, seeing that people don't question doing anything with the steps except taking them in order), unless you or someone else says "I just like step 4, so I'll take that one and leave the rest of them." The response to such a statement is usually shaming ("I once did the steps like that. I got drunk." and of course getting drunk is the WORST thing that could happen to anyone in AA). To sum up this paragraph, it's a mind****.[/quote]

It's a wonderful catch 22.

I was told I was "just saying what people wanted to hear" after a few months, which is weird because at the start I was constantly being told "fake it till you make it"*

*Or keep repeating the mantras until they're in rote in your brain.
 
I'm sorry can you consider either of those concepts of having any sort of scientific merit?

I don't consider religion to have scientific merit, unless there are elements of religious practice that can be proven by science to be beneficial. I think such a discussion is outside the scope of this thread.
 
Perhaps I am picking this up wrong, but was not the principle "take what you need and leave the rest" propounded?

As was mentioned here, I don't believe this middle of the road slogan for a second.

If I say anything that contradicts the 164, I'm wrong. Show me from pages 164 of the book Alcoholics Anonymous and prior... to the title page where it says that and we'll discuss it further.

The A.A. program that I know and the one y'all know are two different things.

gayak, you're probably right. It is a contradiction. It is my faith. It probably doesn't make sense. Who cares? It works for me. God gave me a new mind that doesn't want to drink. I can ill afford to drink booze again. When I do, I sink straight to the bottom. I tear hotels apart, do mischievous things and darn near drink myself to death. Now, it would take a long string of lies for me to drink again. It would take me a lot to unravel. It's more likely that I would drink over a truth today than a lie. One good case of the eff-its and I could be off. But I've been through stuff, and the power of choice in drink has just been removed from me. It just does not exist. I'm in a position of neutrality and all I have to do is follow a few simple rules. I do steps yearly. I'm down to a couple of meetings a month. I'd like to make more, but my plate is full with work and family.

I'm not dependent on A.A., the book, my current conception of God, you, a sponsor, etc. on my sobriety.

I'm free.

I found this in A.A. and good one-time-through sponsorship. I got sponsor-free after I completed my first set of steps over 7 years ago. Some would consider this blastphemous. But show me in that book where this isn't so.

My experience with A.A. is more of a removal of the garbage and a finding of the real truth in that program. Same thing with my practical experience with God... it's a removal of the bs about my truth of myself, you etc. than it is a matter of obtaining something.

To me, you invoke the word of God in the 3rd step, then at the conclusion of the 7th Step, you say, "amen". To me, that's all just one big prayer... that set of action.

It is in my 6th step when I become willing to turn loose of a newly found defect of character that I get free of it; not when I go make that amend to the ones I've harmed with it. To set right the wrong is icing on the cake.

There's a lot of folks around the world doing what they call "A.A." I don't know what the heck they're up to, but they seem to add something to it everyday... a new stupid slogan.

Abaddon, so in a sense, I don't take what I want. What I want usually is a mess, given the context. When I was newly sober, I didn't know what the heck I wanted. Up was down and down was up for me for a while. I was lead into step 4 almost immediately. I was told to be done and have it 5th stepped inside of 21 days. I did it in 22. It did me no harm. I got free of booze and have worked on putting together a life that's worth living.

Once I get what I need, I find out that it's what I wanted all along- Paul Martin, RIP.
 
From the link http://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/...705-1h0o2.html

...the biggest misconception about AA is that it's a religious cult. ''AA is spiritual. There's a chasm of difference between religious and spiritual,'' Jurd says. Presented with the adage that religion is for people who don't want to go to hell while spirituality is for people who don't want to go back there, he concurs.

''Yeah, I suppose. It doesn't demand you believe in God. ''It merely suggests you remember you're not God yourself. Because that's what alcoholics do in trying to beat alcohol by willpower. They're playing God. Unsuccessfully.''
Hard to state the truth, and the problem it gives atheists, any more clearly.
 
Danny, organized or not, a belief system can still be considered a religion, can't it? In the case of AA, the religious aspect is comprised of giving one's will and life over to a God of one's understanding, and improving one's conscience contact with this God through continued prayer and meditation.

Honesty Bamberger, you will probably get as many answers to that question as people. Bill I believe wanted a religious AA, because in his mind this kept everything organized and help people to develop. Jack has said it several times I believe, the carrot on a stick. Problem was, this sort of all fell apart if you didn't believe in God, so what to do. Well, I am an example. I believe in people (friends and family) and I also believe that there is a greater host out there (whatever shape or purpose that created this universe). I wanted to become a better person because of the people in my life and the purpose in my life I wanted to expand.
All of what I just said has nothing to do with God nor was influenced by God.
In 1934 Medical science just wasn't achieving the results doctors wanted and alcoholics needed. So Bill stayed with his hard fast religion and in his mind and many others they helped one another. I believe this for them. I also believe that these same people believe in how I do AA.
 
Last edited:
That's the key point. It can't. In reality, "take what you want and leave the rest" was originally meant to apply to opinions one hears from other AAers - not the program itself. I won't speak for McGowdog, but would bet big money he disagrees with the idea that AA is an a la cart program. I would bet bigger money he would find this statement from Alfie way off, and would like to hear his opinion:

You keep saying that AA members can't take some and leave the rest because this does not make sense, it is not scientific or the steps would not work. This is a false statement that bears no solid proof at all.
Many AA members have never taken the steps, none of them, they read the book, talked with another and found that to be enough. Many AA members wanted nothing to do with the fourth step or fifth step, found it to be invasive and refused to have anything to do with it. Some just had a conversation with another (not even an alcoholic) and that was that.
This is Treatment Center talk Jack, not AA with the suggestive principles of AA.
Bill wanted to promote his idea of AA, not everyone agreed in 1934 and not everyone agrees today. (AA members)
My sponsor of 47 years never did the steps as suggested in the Big Book and doesn't promote Bill's version today.
Charles Diederich (AA member) from Synanon back in the fifties with Bill's knowledge took AA in another direction further away from the God will help you get sober idea. When he introduced confrontational therapy and the idea one addict helping another being all powerful.
Whether you know it or not Jack, AA is not regimented religiously or studiously as one might think. People do it the way that best serves them regardless what Bill W. might have said in the book.
Yes there are AA Nazis, there are groups that go way off the ranch "MidTown Group" Washington D.C. and there are sponsors that say some very ignorant things to sponsees. But for the most part everyone has there way of doing the religious part of AA and the steps. Mcgowdog, as you and I know does have his way, I respect that but I sincerely doubt that he would talk for all of AA, here. He may agree with your point but that doesn't mean he speaks for AA. Neither do I, I speak for myself and a few others I have witnessed.



"The big book is an historical document with some good ideas and many that have outgrown their usefulness."

I disagree.

A human can live without an arm, or an organ, or any one of or combination of parts; and still be considered a viable person. The working human brain/mind can be considered the seat of human consciousness, and the one thing can't not have, and still be considered viable. Ask someone advocating this take what you want program what is the essential element, and you'll get nothing. "Take what you want and leave the rest" can mean a person can leave out literally everything except drinking the coffee at meetings, or only go to donate money into "the hat," or use AA to pick up women; and it would be considered AA. When that person stops drinking, AAers will give the program credit.

This would be your interpretation but I sincerely doubt if any AA member would agree with ideas you expressed above.
Sometimes it is best if you just ask AA members what it is they are doing, Jack.
 
Belz wrote:
What I have a problem with is imposing this belief on unsuspecting members of AA.


This has probably been said a hundred times since this thread has been started but no one is sneaking up on unsuspecting people (they aren't members yet) and throwing religion at them. A large amount of folks who come to AA the first time are well aware of the religious cogitations. We have the internet today, Family Doctors, friends ect....AA isn't hidden in the closet anymore. :)
 
Last edited:
I'm glad this discussion will continue.

I have some thoughts on this subject that I don't think have been brought up.

Here is one: in a different world, there is 'AA.3'. It says, to paraphrase, that it is in fact religious. That it is christian. No more hypocracy.

Would that be better?
 
Originally Posted by Bamberger View Post
Does anyone think that it might benefit AA and the public if the organization were to formally declare itself a religion?

It would definitely benefit the public for umpteen reasons.

But it will kill AA, and here is why:

Their "attraction, not promotion" tradition is another lie. 2/3 of their new members are forced there by the courts. This would dry up the inflow of impaired drivers, domestic abusers and various other criminals who use AA as get-out-of-jail-free card. This has actually had a small impact already, as every court who has ruled on the question has ruled that AA violates the establishment clause (the actual rulings are at the bottom of this link), although most jurisdictions ignore this because of budget constraints, and won't address the issue unless a defendant complains (Which is rare, because anyone would happily take mandated religion over time in the joint. I know I would).

In an interesting twist on this, a guy named Paul Cox confessed to murder in an AA meeting (he was actually forced into AA originally for a lesser offense). His argument was that because AA is a religion, and was ruled such by Federal District Courts, then his confession to his fellow steppers was tantamount to confessing to a priest, and covered under clergy privilege. The court ruled in his favor [Cox v. Miller]. It was overturned by the appellate court, because they ruled that confessing to his fellow congregants is not the same as confessing to a priest.

Then you've got your 12-step treatment centres who take in insurance money, which they could not if they admitted they are treating the disease with spiritual faith healing. They funnel the new AA sheep into the the program, and re-funnel them back in after each relapse. This, along with the court ordered attendees, is the life blood of AA.

You'll notice that the U.S. is the only area of the world where AA maintained its position, even though it's stagnated in the last twenty years. Also, because of America's puritanical bent, it's conducive to a program like AA. Private insurance and the court system is the primary reason it has remained the same size, and declaring themselves religious would shut off the flow of new sheep, and dry it up.

Jack I think the comments you made here are a bit disingenuous. First off you are plugging your Blog that you are the Admin of "Stinkin Thinkin", second these are the same unsubstantiated claims you have been making there, since you started the Blog. You have brought no proof what so ever, here.
I have been with AA for a quarter century and have seen none of the statistical numbers you are talking about. AA is not made up of 75% Judicial and Treatment Center referral. Not even close. Not one active AA member has verified this either.
What the Ninth Circuit Court decided was fair and accurate but it seems no one in the Judicial System wants to abide by the ruling. Once again no one is arguing AA can be religious.
AA numbers world wide are as healthy as they have ever been. Why does AA numbers have to grow. Do you know what it means if AA numbers were to grow, there are more alcoholics. I am happy seeing the numbers dwindle, maybe it means the message is getting out, you can get help.
 
Last edited:
I'm glad this discussion will continue.

I have some thoughts on this subject that I don't think have been brought up.

Here is one: in a different world, there is 'AA.3'. It says, to paraphrase, that it is in fact religious. That it is christian. No more hypocracy.

Would that be better?

There already is that world. It's the world of Dick B., AA historian extraordinaire. Check it out here: Dick B's Website.

He does have some good information on AA history, and he'll answer any question you may have about AA's origins and its religious, Christian roots.
 
I'm glad this discussion will continue.

I have some thoughts on this subject that I don't think have been brought up.

Here is one: in a different world, there is 'AA.3'. It says, to paraphrase, that it is in fact religious. That it is christian. No more hypocracy.

Would that be better?


It would be far more honest.

I can only hope that it would seriously reduce the number of people who would get sucked into it, and that the government would no longer funnel people into its maws.
 
I have been with AA for a quarter century and have seen none of the statistical numbers you are talking about. AA is not made up of 75% Judicial and Treatment Center referral. Not even close. Not one active AA member has verified this either. .

I also have been deeply involved in all aspects of AA (including substantial time at GSO in NY) for a similar amount of time. Anecdotally, on the west coast of the USA (where I've lead/attended more meetings, conferences, district & area events than elsewhere) I would say that in terms of newcomers, brand new presented to the program for the first time, at least 50% come from the courts, with many areas hitting 90% when you add treatment center 'graduates' to the court mandated count. 75% court mandated by itself is probably a bit high for an average, but I'd feel completely comfortable supporting a statement of 50% on average (note I'm only referring to new people hitting AA for the first time).

Quibbling about such numbers when AA itself won't let others do research - and certainly won't start any studies on their own - is nit picking and unproductive as far as the topic is concerned.

Per the topic, the information in this thread coupled with my own experience has certainly confirmed the point that the AA program as written and promoted is religious, a point that AA & it's members go to great lengths to deny.
 
This has probably been said a hundred times since this thread has been started but no one is sneaking up on unsuspecting people (they aren't members yet) and throwing religion at them.

Considering the state of mind of several people who attend AA, I don't think they necessarily are fully aware of the implications so, in a way, yes, they are.
 
Honesty Bamberger, you will probably get as many answers to that question as people.

Danny, I'm not sure how I can get as many answers as there are people if the question I am asking is binary (yes/no) in nature. I could get a higher percentage of one answer than the other though.

The question was:

Organized or not, a belief system can still be considered a religion, can't it? In the case of AA, the religious aspect is comprised of giving one's will and life over to a God of one's understanding, and improving one's conscience contact with this God through continued prayer and meditation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom