Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sophomoric or not, it helps to point out that what AAs say about "God as you understand Him" and rather flippantly say "a doorknob can be your higher power" really doesn't stand up to scrutiny. As has been pointed out time and again, anything as your higher power is absurd and rather pointless.

It's a method that Bill W. clearly laid out and which is often followed to this day, to bring recalcitrant and reluctant prospective AAs into the flock.

Hey Norseman, have you really known an AA'er personally that admitted he had a doorknob, tree, spatula or something as silly as these examples as his higher power. I haven't and I have been associated with AA for 25 years.
I may have heard these examples as a joke but people in AA usually take their religious, spiritual or agnostic beliefs seriously.
Is AA religious yes, do you have to conduct yourself this way in order to benefit from AA's principles, No.
 
Last edited:
Here is something The Fix just wrote on AAers talking people out their prescription medications. This is a widespread problem. Replacing actual medication with spiritual faith healing is religion.

It's an example of the harm done when religion replaces science.

Off With Their Meds!
 
Hey Norseman, have you really known an AA'er personally that admitted he had a doorknob, tree, spatula or something as silly as these examples as his higher power. I haven't and I have been associated with AA for 25 years.
I may have heard these examples as a joke but people in AA usually take their religious, spiritual or agnostic beliefs seriously.
Is AA religious yes, do you have to conduct yourself this way in order to benefit from AA's principles, No.

Yes I've met AA members who claim a rock or a tree, one even told me where the particular tree is that they use as their higher power....

I always find it funny when people point out something is common practice in AA, the immediate retort from DannyB or A.A. Alfie is "Well not in my AA". As if their subjective experience of AA is the definitive account of this organisation.

Danny you claim everyone in AA understands it's religious, while this entire thread existence is proof that among AA members that there's a serious debate about whether AA is religious or not. Other members of AA are on this thread are saying the exact opposite. Often within posts of each other. The thread's been in existence for well over a year, and you can't breeze in and announce "everyone I know in AA knows it's religious" and not expect that this remark to be contentious. That statement goes at odds to what several AA members are saying on this very thread.

Furthermore, considering the discussion is supposed to be about whether AA is religious or not, and that there doesn't seem to be consensus among active AA members about whether this is or isn't the case. isn't it remarkable that there are several active AA members on this thread expressing polar opposite opinions, some saying "it's not religious" while others are saying "it is religious", and neither side seems interested in discussing this with each other on this thread, isn't that a remarkable?
 
Last edited:
Hey Norseman, have you really known an AA'er personally that admitted he had a doorknob, tree, spatula or something as silly as these examples as his higher power. I haven't and I have been associated with AA for 25 years.
I may have heard these examples as a joke but people in AA usually take their religious, spiritual or agnostic beliefs seriously.
Is AA religious yes, do you have to conduct yourself this way in order to benefit from AA's principles, No.

That's why I specifically stated it is said by AAs "rather flippantly" about having a doorknob as a higher power. Which falls in line perfectly with Bill W's plans for his organization -- to sell the religious aspects to people who are resistant to those messages.
 
Is AA religious yes, do you have to conduct yourself this way in order to benefit from AA's principles, No.

Danny, do you think AA should be more forthright about it religious leanings when presenting itself to the public? There is no mention of God either in their preamble or on their website's homepage.
 
Yes I've met AA members who claim a rock or a tree, one even told me where the particular tree is that they use as their higher power....

Me too. The doorknob thing goes a bit far. In fact the tree for one member was simply a representation or conduit of you like to nature as his higher power. It worked for him, and who am I to question it?

I always find it funny when people point out something is common practice in AA, the immediate retort from DannyB or A.A. Alfie is "Well not in my AA". As if their subjective experience of AA is the definitive account of this organisation.

Actually since thye very start of this thread I have consistently stated that all I could offer was my experience and understood that things happen differently elsewhere. I am certain that AA groups in Russai, China, India etc i.e. countries of different religious background do things differently.
It seems to me that if anything it is those that would denigrate AA that are making the globalised type statements.

Danny you claim everyone in AA understands it's religious, while this entire thread existence is proof that among AA members that there's a serious debate about whether AA is religious or not. Other members of AA are on this thread are saying the exact opposite. Often within posts of each other. The thread's been in existence for well over a year, and you can't breeze in and announce "everyone I know in AA knows it's religious" and not expect that this remark to be contentious. That statement goes at odds to what several AA members are saying on this very thread.

Who has ever said there is not a religious element? I asked Complexity to respond to this claim earlier, can you show me who did this? I do not believe it has happened.

Furthermore, considering the discussion is supposed to be about whether AA is religious or not, and that there doesn't seem to be consensus among active AA members about whether this is or isn't the case. isn't it remarkable that there are several active AA members on this thread expressing polar opposite opinions, some saying "it's not religious" while others are saying "it is religious", and neither side seems interested in discussing this with each other on this thread, isn't that a remarkable?

Again, I think this is an abject misrepresentation. Can you please show us who says "AA is not religious" and leaves it as cut and dried as that?
 
Again, I think this is an abject misrepresentation. Can you please show us who says "AA is not religious" and leaves it as cut and dried as that?

Alfie, would you contend that AA is in fact religious in nature, or at least has enough components associated with religion that could lead one to reasonably refer to the organization as such?
 
That's why I specifically stated it is said by AAs "rather flippantly" about having a doorknob as a higher power. Which falls in line perfectly with Bill W's plans for his organization -- to sell the religious aspects to people who are resistant to those messages.

I've never seen a doorknob as a higher power, but I've seen someone use their pet cat as one, a tree and a bridge among others. The point still remains that doorknob is perfectly acceptable.

What one calls their higher power is irrelevant, and is an illusion of choice. Whatever you call it, it has to perform the specific tasks that every other AA member's god does. It has specific characteristics:

It must have a will of its own.
It must care for you and your will.
It must be aware of human morality and character.
It must be able to remove and impose morality on you.
It must have a conscious in order to facilitate conscious contact through prayer.

The program is unambiguous about the fact that these are really just proxies for a specific god:

"...We found that as soon as we were able to lay aside prejudice and express even a willingness to believe in a Power greater than ourselves, we commenced to get results, even though it was impossible for any of us to fully define or comprehend that Power, which is God."
 
Hi everybody. I've not posted for a long time here. I was using the forum for something besides recovery from alcohol, but I came across the thread from elsewhere... while discussing A.A.

I was going to respond to the OP, but being new here, I've no idea if the OP is even still around. It appears to be a hot topic nonetheless.

It appears to me that there are a lot of folks that are against A.A. and mimic some of the same arguments that Agent Orange has been known for.

If anyone thinks that society at large would benefit from labeling A.A. as a religion, then it should be done.

I know of folks that were incarcerated and took it upon themselves to participate in an A.A. group from within without signing any papers and without receiving any benefit due to their participation. A.A. was intended to be voluntary and that is the way it should remain.

I personally enjoy the Lord's Prayer and it is used in most meetings in my locale. I don't "chant" the prayer when I say it. When I say it, I mean it and I savor every word and consider its meaning.

The way I see A.A., it's always been one road in and 4000 roads out. At each and every turn is an out. A.A. should be voluntary and it should be for those that need it, for those that want it, but inevitably, it's for those that "do" it.

The A.A. that I know starts off with a qualification and and identification. If I don't fit the qualification, then I'm encouraged to leave and try something else. This process is initiated with the question, "What brings you here. Tell me/us about your drinking." After swapping experiences, and if one is considered to be a potential alcoholic, the question is then asked, "Do you want to do something about it? They may ask, "Are you ready to quit for good and all?"

What ensues from there is a series of considerations that look at control... to attempt to distinguish from the different types of drinkers. The A.A. program considers the alcoholic to be one who lacks control and two key issues; Can you control the amount of booze consumed once you start? ... and Can you keep yourself from the first drink... save for some ridiculous and/or trivial excuse?

If a person lacks control in BOTH of the above, then the consideration is put on them that they may perhaps be beyond human aid. The book says something to the effectt that "Whether such a person can quit upon a nonspiritual basis depends upon the extent to which he has already lost the power to choose whether he will drink or not."

So, if you feel like you can choose to drink or not or if you can choose to control the amount once you start, you may or may not need to accept a spiritual solution.

It's pretty obvious to me what the solution for alcohol is for the alcoholic in A.A. That solution is God. That may offend some people. But it doesn't offend me. But, to say that it must be such and such brand of religion, I've not seen it. What I've found to be true of this God in the A.A. program is that it must be personal to the individual. It must make sense to them. The book even says that the "fundamental idea of God is deep down within every man, woman, child..." So from there, I can chose my own conception of God.

Today, I'm way beyond a conception. I'm into consciousness. I do steps, yearly. I hear a lot about what A.A. is supposed to be in meetings and on these message boards. It's worlds away from the program that I've been presented in "that Book". That "Book" is like our BS sifter. God knows there's enough bs to go around.

I've been sober 7 and a half years now and I'm not even thirsty for booze. To me, religion is man-made. Even with those limitations, I'm encouraged to have an open mind and make use of religion where possible. "Be quick to point out where religious people are right. Make use of what they offer."

Religion doesn't scare me. Science fascinates me. If A.A. is not for you, great. Find something else. Whether you're in A.A. or not, drunk or sober, it is up to you to find a way of life where you find a sufficient substitute to booze and/or dangerous mind-altering drugs... not playing doctor here. If your meds work for you, great. Follow the directions and get on with life.

Some A.A. skeptics love to tell me, "Well, you choose to drink or not." That maybe so. I disagree with it based on my experience. Or another way to look at it is to say, "Well ok. But I always choose the wrong thing when faced with the choice." I do these crazy things called steps and the choice doesn't seem to cross my mind. For 7 and a half years, I've not chose to "not drink" booze. The issue does not come up. I don't have to avoid temptation. I don't have triggers. I don't have to think my way through the drink. I don't have to keep it green. I like being sober. I follow a few simple rules. It's a neat deal.
 
Who has ever said there is not a religious element? I asked Complexity to respond to this claim earlier, can you show me who did this? I do not believe it has happened.

You, in posts 39, 47, 97, 138, 226, etc., etc.

AlBell on innumerable occasions.

It is also ironic that you ask Complexity to respond when it was he who specifically asked you to stop claiming AA was not religious and you responded by saying, "

Originally Posted by Complexity
Quit pretending that AA is not religious. It is.

You actually made the claim that AA was not religious and it was the agnostics and atheists in AA that allowed the theists to preactice their religious beliefs.

That just isn't backed up by the evidence you, Albell, or any other AA member has posted. It also isn't supported by AA literature or the actions of the national organization in delisting the Toronto meetings because they removed reference to God.

I hope you take this opportunity to clarify your position.


Ohh, Ouch!
How could I fail to be anything but impressed by such a well structured, considered and articulate argument.

The agnostics and atheists among us within AA have no issue with those that choose to use religion. We simply make a distinction between "religious" and "spiritual". It seems you and many don't like this interpretation.... meh.
 
Hi everybody. I've not posted for a long time here.

2 posts in 3 years... I'll say ! :)

I personally enjoy the Lord's Prayer and it is used in most meetings in my locale.

The problem is telling people, as AA does, that their problem is spiritual and that God can remove their problem and make them sober again. This ignores quite a bit of science and can be terribly damaging. It's not the topic of the thread per se but it's certainly related to it.

It's pretty obvious to me what the solution for alcohol is for the alcoholic in A.A. That solution is God. That may offend some people.

It doesn't offend me. It's just false.

But it doesn't offend me. But, to say that it must be such and such brand of religion, I've not seen it.

But your answer to the OP is that AA _is_ religious.

And this is another problem: that atheists, agnostics or people of faiths more-or-less incompatible with AA can be forced by the government to participate, which is a convenient indoctrination method, if you ask me.
 
It's pretty obvious to me what the solution for alcohol is for the alcoholic in A.A. That solution is God. That may offend some people. But it doesn't offend me. But, to say that it must be such and such brand of religion, I've not seen it. What I've found to be true of this God in the A.A. program is that it must be personal to the individual. It must make sense to them. The book even says that the "fundamental idea of God is deep down within every man, woman, child..." So from there, I can chose my own conception of God.

So you have no problem with the program being termed religious?
 
Hi everybody. I've not posted for a long time here. I was using the forum for something besides recovery from alcohol, but I came across the thread from elsewhere... while discussing A.A.

I was going to respond to the OP, but being new here, I've no idea if the OP is even still around. It appears to be a hot topic nonetheless.

It appears to me that there are a lot of folks that are against A.A. and mimic some of the same arguments that Agent Orange has been known for.

If anyone thinks that society at large would benefit from labeling A.A. as a religion, then it should be done.

I know of folks that were incarcerated and took it upon themselves to participate in an A.A. group from within without signing any papers and without receiving any benefit due to their participation. A.A. was intended to be voluntary and that is the way it should remain.

I personally enjoy the Lord's Prayer and it is used in most meetings in my locale. I don't "chant" the prayer when I say it. When I say it, I mean it and I savor every word and consider its meaning.

The way I see A.A., it's always been one road in and 4000 roads out. At each and every turn is an out. A.A. should be voluntary and it should be for those that need it, for those that want it, but inevitably, it's for those that "do" it.

The A.A. that I know starts off with a qualification and and identification. If I don't fit the qualification, then I'm encouraged to leave and try something else. This process is initiated with the question, "What brings you here. Tell me/us about your drinking." After swapping experiences, and if one is considered to be a potential alcoholic, the question is then asked, "Do you want to do something about it? They may ask, "Are you ready to quit for good and all?"

What ensues from there is a series of considerations that look at control... to attempt to distinguish from the different types of drinkers. The A.A. program considers the alcoholic to be one who lacks control and two key issues; Can you control the amount of booze consumed once you start? ... and Can you keep yourself from the first drink... save for some ridiculous and/or trivial excuse?

If a person lacks control in BOTH of the above, then the consideration is put on them that they may perhaps be beyond human aid. The book says something to the effectt that "Whether such a person can quit upon a nonspiritual basis depends upon the extent to which he has already lost the power to choose whether he will drink or not."

So, if you feel like you can choose to drink or not or if you can choose to control the amount once you start, you may or may not need to accept a spiritual solution.

It's pretty obvious to me what the solution for alcohol is for the alcoholic in A.A. That solution is God. That may offend some people. But it doesn't offend me. But, to say that it must be such and such brand of religion, I've not seen it. What I've found to be true of this God in the A.A. program is that it must be personal to the individual. It must make sense to them. The book even says that the "fundamental idea of God is deep down within every man, woman, child..." So from there, I can chose my own conception of God.

Today, I'm way beyond a conception. I'm into consciousness. I do steps, yearly. I hear a lot about what A.A. is supposed to be in meetings and on these message boards. It's worlds away from the program that I've been presented in "that Book". That "Book" is like our BS sifter. God knows there's enough bs to go around.

I've been sober 7 and a half years now and I'm not even thirsty for booze. To me, religion is man-made. Even with those limitations, I'm encouraged to have an open mind and make use of religion where possible. "Be quick to point out where religious people are right. Make use of what they offer."

Religion doesn't scare me. Science fascinates me. If A.A. is not for you, great. Find something else. Whether you're in A.A. or not, drunk or sober, it is up to you to find a way of life where you find a sufficient substitute to booze and/or dangerous mind-altering drugs... not playing doctor here. If your meds work for you, great. Follow the directions and get on with life.

Some A.A. skeptics love to tell me, "Well, you choose to drink or not." That maybe so. I disagree with it based on my experience. Or another way to look at it is to say, "Well ok. But I always choose the wrong thing when faced with the choice." I do these crazy things called steps and the choice doesn't seem to cross my mind. For 7 and a half years, I've not chose to "not drink" booze. The issue does not come up. I don't have to avoid temptation. I don't have triggers. I don't have to think my way through the drink. I don't have to keep it green. I like being sober. I follow a few simple rules. It's a neat deal.

This was concise and just a awesome post. Thanks Mcgowdog for your experience. I have always enjoyed reading your posts though out the net.
Yes this thread is about, "Why do people insist AA is not religious".
I am not sure who the OP is either but I must say that I have never heard anyone say AA is not based upon religion. Of course it is. Yet while this point is true, AA also made room for the no-religious members. I think this is where people get confused and also the fact that many have no interest in organized religion and choose their idea of spirituality.
 
Yes this thread is about, "Why do people insist AA is not religious".
I am not sure who the OP is either but I must say that I have never heard anyone say AA is not based upon religion. Of course it is. Yet while this point is true, AA also made room for the no-religious members. I think this is where people get confused and also the fact that many have no interest in organized religion and choose their idea of spirituality.

Danny, organized or not, a belief system can still be considered a religion, can't it? In the case of AA, the religious aspect is comprised of giving one's will and life over to a God of one's understanding, and improving one's conscience contact with this God through continued prayer and meditation.
 
Thanks Danny, and likewise.

Belz, no... It's not false for me. God solves my problem, which is not alcohol. Alcohol is "but a symptom". When God solves my "problem" (note the singular form), which is deep within me, I straighten out mentally and physically. I believe my problem is of my own making, and my Solution is within me too.

I don't have to go to church to get it.

Bam, I don't believe it's religion for me, but I'm not opposed to calling it religion in order for courts, the medical industry, the insurance industry etc. to be no longer obligated to using it.

But should A.A. remain/become non-profit and tax exempt? I don't even know what AAWS business structure is.

I'd be fine if A.A. went totally underground and split from world services. There's enough books floating around that one drunk can go find another drunk who is willing to accept help.

I think A.A.is just one beggar showing another beggar where there's bread.
 
Perhaps I am picking this up wrong, but was not the principle "take what you need and leave the rest" propounded?

If that is the case, then one individual could say "I want steps 2, 6 and 9 and I will leave the rest".

Individual #2 could say "I want steps 4, 5 and 11, and I will leave the rest".

The point is, none of the steps are necessary.

This is in no way a scientific program as far as I can see, if one can cherry pick a subset of the 12 steps at will.

How can it possibly have any scientific merit, if one can nibble some bits, while spitting out others at random, depending on ones personal beliefs?
 
Thanks Danny, and likewise.

Bam, I don't believe it's religion for me, but I'm not opposed to calling it religion in order for courts, the medical industry, the insurance industry etc. to be no longer obligated to using it.

Thanks, mcgowdog. I respect and agree with your position.
 
How can it possibly have any scientific merit, if one can nibble some bits, while spitting out others at random, depending on ones personal beliefs?

That's the key point. It can't. In reality, "take what you want and leave the rest" was originally meant to apply to opinions one hears from other AAers - not the program itself. I won't speak for McGowdog, but would bet big money he disagrees with the idea that AA is an a la cart program. I would bet bigger money he would find this statement from Alfie way off, and would like to hear his opinion:

"The big book is an historical document with some good ideas and many that have outgrown their usefulness."

A human can live without an arm, or an organ, or any one of or combination of parts; and still be considered a viable person. The working human brain/mind can be considered the seat of human consciousness, and the one thing can't not have, and still be considered viable. Ask someone advocating this take what you want program what is the essential element, and you'll get nothing. "Take what you want and leave the rest" can mean a person can leave out literally everything except drinking the coffee at meetings, or only go to donate money into "the hat," or use AA to pick up women; and it would be considered AA. When that person stops drinking, AAers will give the program credit.
 
Yet while this point is true, AA also made room for the no-religious members. I think this is where people get confused and also the fact that many have no interest in organized religion and choose their idea of spirituality.

Your claim isn't supported by the evidence. In the view of the original AA org., non-belief is just a state in which some people will come to AA but that they will be changed over time to become believers in God.

Your claim is also not evidenced by the delisting of the two atheist groups in Toronto.

http://www.thestar.com/news/article...at-aa-fight-over-god-splits-toronto-aa-groups

AA does not make room for non-religious members. If they did they would not require the use of the word God. AA tolerates non-believers until they can be made into believers.

That is a huge difference.
 
Thanks Danny, and likewise.

Belz, no... It's not false for me. God solves my problem, which is not alcohol. Alcohol is "but a symptom". When God solves my "problem" (note the singular form), which is deep within me, I straighten out mentally and physically. I believe my problem is of my own making, and my Solution is within me too.

That's a contradiction, isn't it? The problem is of your own making and the solution is within you but god solves it.

Now, I believe you on the first two claims, the problem is of your own making and the solution is inside you but what about the third, do you have any evidence that god solved it or is this just a "faith" you have?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom