Hi everybody. I've not posted for a long time here. I was using the forum for something besides recovery from alcohol, but I came across the thread from elsewhere... while discussing A.A.
I was going to respond to the OP, but being new here, I've no idea if the OP is even still around. It appears to be a hot topic nonetheless.
It appears to me that there are a lot of folks that are against A.A. and mimic some of the same arguments that Agent Orange has been known for.
If anyone thinks that society at large would benefit from labeling A.A. as a religion, then it should be done.
I know of folks that were incarcerated and took it upon themselves to participate in an A.A. group from within without signing any papers and without receiving any benefit due to their participation. A.A. was intended to be voluntary and that is the way it should remain.
I personally enjoy the Lord's Prayer and it is used in most meetings in my locale. I don't "chant" the prayer when I say it. When I say it, I mean it and I savor every word and consider its meaning.
The way I see A.A., it's always been one road in and 4000 roads out. At each and every turn is an out. A.A. should be voluntary and it should be for those that need it, for those that want it, but inevitably, it's for those that "do" it.
The A.A. that I know starts off with a qualification and and identification. If I don't fit the qualification, then I'm encouraged to leave and try something else. This process is initiated with the question, "What brings you here. Tell me/us about your drinking." After swapping experiences, and if one is considered to be a potential alcoholic, the question is then asked, "Do you want to do something about it? They may ask, "Are you ready to quit for good and all?"
What ensues from there is a series of considerations that look at control... to attempt to distinguish from the different types of drinkers. The A.A. program considers the alcoholic to be one who lacks control and two key issues; Can you control the amount of booze consumed once you start? ... and Can you keep yourself from the first drink... save for some ridiculous and/or trivial excuse?
If a person lacks control in BOTH of the above, then the consideration is put on them that they may perhaps be beyond human aid. The book says something to the effectt that "Whether such a person can quit upon a nonspiritual basis depends upon the extent to which he has already lost the power to choose whether he will drink or not."
So, if you feel like you can choose to drink or not or if you can choose to control the amount once you start, you may or may not need to accept a spiritual solution.
It's pretty obvious to me what the solution for alcohol is for the alcoholic in A.A. That solution is God. That may offend some people. But it doesn't offend me. But, to say that it must be such and such brand of religion, I've not seen it. What I've found to be true of this God in the A.A. program is that it must be personal to the individual. It must make sense to them. The book even says that the "fundamental idea of God is deep down within every man, woman, child..." So from there, I can chose my own conception of God.
Today, I'm way beyond a conception. I'm into consciousness. I do steps, yearly. I hear a lot about what A.A. is supposed to be in meetings and on these message boards. It's worlds away from the program that I've been presented in "that Book". That "Book" is like our BS sifter. God knows there's enough bs to go around.
I've been sober 7 and a half years now and I'm not even thirsty for booze. To me, religion is man-made. Even with those limitations, I'm encouraged to have an open mind and make use of religion where possible. "Be quick to point out where religious people are right. Make use of what they offer."
Religion doesn't scare me. Science fascinates me. If A.A. is not for you, great. Find something else. Whether you're in A.A. or not, drunk or sober, it is up to you to find a way of life where you find a sufficient substitute to booze and/or dangerous mind-altering drugs... not playing doctor here. If your meds work for you, great. Follow the directions and get on with life.
Some A.A. skeptics love to tell me, "Well, you choose to drink or not." That maybe so. I disagree with it based on my experience. Or another way to look at it is to say, "Well ok. But I always choose the wrong thing when faced with the choice." I do these crazy things called steps and the choice doesn't seem to cross my mind. For 7 and a half years, I've not chose to "not drink" booze. The issue does not come up. I don't have to avoid temptation. I don't have triggers. I don't have to think my way through the drink. I don't have to keep it green. I like being sober. I follow a few simple rules. It's a neat deal.