Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I thought this was a timely article I read in the ABA journal. A Delaware group is filing suit against a county council because they are reciting The Lord's Prayer before each meeting. This is from the suit:

"By persistently sponsoring this Christian prayer, the County Council has publicly aligned itself with a single faith. In so doing, the Council sends the message to non-Christians that the Council does not represent non-Christians’ concerns," the suit maintains. The prayer also sends a message that non-Christians are "second-class citizens," the complaint asserts.

Maybe our resident steppers should contact the filing party and explain to them difference between spiritual and religious.
 
I feel sorry for people who pray to their toaster.

I can see people are is still being silly. How about contributing something more to this thread then this sophomoric college hazing ritual.
Are we from the other fraternity, us AA'ers. It almost seems like it here sometimes. :duck:
I know we can do better then this. :)
 
I can see people are is still being silly. How about contributing something more to this thread then this sophomoric college hazing ritual.
Are we from the other fraternity, us AA'ers. It almost seems like it here sometimes. :duck:
I know we can do better then this. :)


Sophomoric or not, it helps to point out that what AAs say about "God as you understand Him" and rather flippantly say "a doorknob can be your higher power" really doesn't stand up to scrutiny. As has been pointed out time and again, anything as your higher power is absurd and rather pointless.

It's a method that Bill W. clearly laid out and which is often followed to this day, to bring recalcitrant and reluctant prospective AAs into the flock.
 
So the group can be considered religious at this point by virtue of the majority choosing to retain a religious prayer, correct?

Could this logic be expanded, say, at the area/district level if the majority of groups that constitute the area/district also have voted to retain the lord's prayer? In other words, the area/district can now be viewed as religious because a majority of its constituent groups are religious.

The decision as to how a meeting is run is made at meeting/group level not at district (I know you didn't say that, but just for clarification).

If an entire city had a Christian religious bent, is that entire city religious?

And for the record, the use of the Lord's prayer is not universal. I have never ever heard it at a meeting anywhere.

An outmoded, incorrect way of viewing alcoholism that's pushed by AA and it's spiritual problems which require a spiritual solution.

In general terms I might agree. However sometimes it is a spiritual issue that needs addressing; something that helps give a person purpose, friends and other interests etc.

Yes, I believe so. Insofar as AA not declaring itself a religion.

What religion? What god? What religious practices must be observed?
These are individual choices that may or may not include a deity; that does not fit under my definition of religion.

A.A. Alfie - so much wrongness compressed into a disingenuous post.

Where is this "wrongness"?
This seems a very transparent dodge. :rolleyes:

Of course I decide what I think is right and wrong. Who else should I trust with such an important decision?

My question was will you make that decision for me? Will you decide what is right and wrong for me (and others)? Who gives you that power over others? :confused:

Your 'who, what, where?' questions are tedious and deceitful. You are fully capable of answering nearly all of them yourself.

Not really, seeing as they are not there. :boggled:
I note here that you cannot support your statements.

Your responses in general are attempts at deception. You are not providing any evidence of having a trace of integrity.

Right back at you. Non answers noted.

The issues you raised are not worth answering point by point, for they are insincere.

And.... appallingly transparent dodge confirmed.
 
Last edited:
The decision as to how a meeting is run is made at meeting/group level not at district (I know you didn't say that, but just for clarification).

Well... the decision to allow a group that is run differently to be dis-affiliated from AA is made only by the AA World Intergroup (as clearly demonstrated recently). So, those local AA groups chose to run the groups as they saw fit, and were later told that they no longer are "AA."



And for the record, the use of the Lord's prayer is not universal. I have never ever heard it at a meeting anywhere.

I personally have tried to limit my statements to less than all-encompassing statements. However, I would hope that you'd take what you read in this thread as a fairly honest assessment of how AA is run in other countries. In the US, it's apparently taken for granted that the Lord's Prayer is chanted sometime during the meeting (usually at the close) and that a member has to petition the Group Conscience and put it to a vote to limit the chanting of a Christian prayer in a supposedly non-religious meeting group.



In general terms I might agree. However sometimes it is a spiritual issue that needs addressing; something that helps give a person purpose, friends and other interests etc.

Friendships and so on are vital to a successful recovery. I don't consider them to be spiritual, however.



What religion? What god? What religious practices must be observed?
These are individual choices that may or may not include a deity; that does not fit under my definition of religion.

My question was will you make that decision for me? Will you decide what is right and wrong for me (and others)? Who gives you that power over others? :confused:

Remove mention of a higher power and God and the AA World Intergroup says "it ain't AA." So, in a sense, they get to dictate to everyone who wishes to attend AA.
 
Agreed Complexity - keep up the good fight (from outside AA), I'm doing the best I can (from the inside).

On a related note, just last night I spoke up and mentioned the lords prayer wasn't in the spirit of inclusiveness I wanted to see at meetings I lead, so they stopped and did the serenity prayer instead (still not ideal, but better than that mess of stupidity called the lords prayer).

Have a great weekend!
 
Seems that AAs' higher power is alcohol. It's what they say has power over them and is beyond their control so it must be higher than them.
 
Alfie,

Your most recent post reminded me I wanted to thank you for your reply to me in your post 4755. I forgot to do so in my last series of posts. :)
 
Last edited:
Does anyone think that it might benefit AA and the public if the organization were to formally declare itself a religion?
 
Does anyone think that it might benefit AA and the public if the organization were to formally declare itself a religion?

It would definitely benefit the public for umpteen reasons.

But it will kill AA, and here is why:

Their "attraction, not promotion" tradition is another lie. 2/3 of their new members are forced there by the courts. This would dry up the inflow of impaired drivers, domestic abusers and various other criminals who use AA as get-out-of-jail-free card. This has actually had a small impact already, as every court who has ruled on the question has ruled that AA violates the establishment clause (the actual rulings are at the bottom of this link), although most jurisdictions ignore this because of budget constraints, and won't address the issue unless a defendant complains (Which is rare, because anyone would happily take mandated religion over time in the joint. I know I would).

In an interesting twist on this, a guy named Paul Cox confessed to murder in an AA meeting (he was actually forced into AA originally for a lesser offense). His argument was that because AA is a religion, and was ruled such by Federal District Courts, then his confession to his fellow steppers was tantamount to confessing to a priest, and covered under clergy privilege. The court ruled in his favor [Cox v. Miller]. It was overturned by the appellate court, because they ruled that confessing to his fellow congregants is not the same as confessing to a priest.

Then you've got your 12-step treatment centres who take in insurance money, which they could not if they admitted they are treating the disease with spiritual faith healing. They funnel the new AA sheep into the the program, and re-funnel them back in after each relapse. This, along with the court ordered attendees, is the life blood of AA.

You'll notice that the U.S. is the only area of the world where AA maintained its position, even though it's stagnated in the last twenty years. Also, because of America's puritanical bent, it's conducive to a program like AA. Private insurance and the court system is the primary reason it has remained the same size, and declaring themselves religious would shut off the flow of new sheep, and dry it up.
 
Last edited:
It would definitely benefit the public for umpteen reasons.

Their "attraction, not promotion" tradition is another lie. 2/3 of their new members are forced there by the courts.

As usual you mistakenly aim your issues at AA rather than the judiciary. I suggest you take this issue up with them.

Just curious, but of those forced there by the courts, how many stay?
How much of AA's potential efficacy is watered down and bastardised because your government abdicates its responsibilities to its citizens?

Removing these people from AAs rooms would not kill it, in fact it would do the opposite and strengthen the membership by keeping it clean of people who wish not to attend, leaving only genuine members.
If this were not the case, AA would not thrive elsewhere throughout the world where the courts do not send their criminals.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone think that it might benefit AA and the public if the organization were to formally declare itself a religion?


It would benefit AA, for living a lie is destructive, even though I think AA would end up with far fewer participants over time.

It certainly would benefit the public, especially through the reduction in people going to / being sent to AA in the guise of a non-religious organization.
 
As usual you mistakenly aim your issues at AA rather than the judiciary. I suggest you take this issue up with them.

Just curious, but of those forced there by the courts, how many stay?
How much of AA's potential efficacy is watered down and bastardised because your government abdicates its responsibilities to its citizens?

Removing these people from AAs rooms would not kill it, in fact it would do the opposite and strengthen the membership by keeping it clean of people who wish not to attend, leaving only genuine members.
If this were not the case, AA would not thrive elsewhere throughout the world where the courts do not send their criminals.

We've already established here how AA actively participates in coercion from the courts. They actively recruit through the court system, so the blame is with AA as well as the court.

A lot of the court appointees stay. The reason is it one of few places on the planet where a sociopath is allowed to do their thing without accountability, and with complete anonymity. It's also the only place in both the U.S. and Canada where paroled felons are allowed to co-mingle. It's an environment conducive to a lot of abusive and crazy things. It's one reason so many old timers are crazy. The normal people run for the door after a while. Two of our local AA gurus have rap sheets longer than your resentment list. We have a prominent former DA who got caught taking bribes a few years back in exchange for reduced sentences (which ironically included AA attendance), and some of those who took the bribes are now his fellow AAs. It's a wacky, mixed up piece of surreality.

And AA does not thrive in other parts of the world. In fact, it is losing membership.
 
I think it would be a great idea!.


If in fact it was a religion, which it isn't.

Thanks for the candid response, alfie. As others mention, the membership pool would likely shrink but those remaining would really want to be there. I guess that the rate of recovery in the smaller fellowship might consequently improve.

The advantage for the public at large (predominantly in the USA) is that that people would much less likely be sentenced to AA, and those that did choose it as a means to mitigate their sentences would better know what they are getting into.

It's a win-win as far as I can see.
 
It is with great regret that I must announce that the level of bickering, incivility and off-topic posting has forced us to switch this thread to "moderated" status. This means that each post must be approved by a moderator before it is allowed to appear. The moderator may either approve the post, edit and approve the post, or dump the entire post.

This is a great inconvenience to members, because it may be hours or (rarely) days before they can see if their post was approved, however it is an even greater inconvenience to moderators, who must read each post in a thread that they may have no interest in reading.

The guidelines for having posts accepted in a moderated thread are the same as they are for the forum in general, however it is no secret that many posts which could well be ruled breaches of the membership agreement, will slide by in unmoderated threads, simply because they go unreported. That is no longer the case. Additionally, less leeway is given to a post made to a moderated thread because members should be aware that nothing is going to slide by.

So don't waste your time and ours by making posts that are personal attacks or off topic or just plain bickering. Address the argument ONLY and you will have no problems getting your posts accepted. If not, they will disappear into the ether.

If, in some time, it appears that you have curbed your baser instincts and are able to post civilly, we may remove the moderated status. In the meantime, DO NOT try to evade the moderated status of this thread, either by starting new threads on similar topics, or by bringing up issues from this thread in other threads. Such actions will most likely result in severe moderation, up to and including warnings, infractions, suspensions or banning.

I'm truly very sorry
Tricky
JREF Moderation Team
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom