Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Alcoholism == self-will run riot.

Let's take a look at how this is addressed through AA:

"The alcoholic is an extreme example of self-will run riot, though he usually doesn’t think so. Above everything, we alcoholics must be rid of this selfishness. We must, or it kills us! God makes that possible. And there often seems no way of entirely getting rid of self without His aid. Many of us had moral and philosophical convictions galore, but we could not live up to them up to them even though we would have liked to. Neither could we reduce our self-centeredness (or Alcoholism) much by wishing or trying on our own power. We had to have God’s help.
 
Let's take a look at how this is addressed through AA:

"The alcoholic is an extreme example of self-will run riot, though he usually doesn’t think so. Above everything, we alcoholics must be rid of this selfishness. We must, or it kills us! God makes that possible. And there often seems no way of entirely getting rid of self without His aid. Many of us had moral and philosophical convictions galore, but we could not live up to them up to them even though we would have liked to. Neither could we reduce our self-centeredness (or Alcoholism) much by wishing or trying on our own power. We had to have God’s help.

It seems to me that AA is promoting a monotheistic deity as the means of attaining the miracle of character conversion. Isn't this concept deeply rooted in the theology of mainstream religions? AA appears to be acting as a religion by borrowing such an approach.
 
Welcome, Bamberger.

It would seem so. I wouldn't disagree that it does.

But so what? I'm not there for a religious conversion. I go there to hear other people, and how they dealt with addiction. Many did it with a religious overtone, but many did not. If they found that this aspect helped them, so what? Let them, if it helps them.

Me on the other hand choose not go that route, and I have not been osticized for doing so. I've met hundereds of people in AA meetings, and never once has someone told me I will never achieve sobriety because of my stand on the subect. Yes the big book says that. I choose to diagree.

ETA: in my ongoing reseach on what a religion is, It seems as though it is a religion. But since I don't really care if it is, I don't have a problem with that. I would never tell someone that they are wrong in believing in a diety, because that would doing something that imposes my belief system on another, which I think is what you are saying AA is doing. IF AA is wrong, why aren't you equally at fault (by telling others that they are wrong or at least lacking in integrity or lying)
 
Last edited:
Alcoholism == self-will run riot.

An outmoded, incorrect way of viewing alcoholism that's pushed by AA and it's spiritual problems which require a spiritual solution.


What is atheism?

The subject for a different thread.


I feel sorry for all suffering alcoholics who can't fill in the blank in the serenity prayer:

________ grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference.

With wisdom, most notice the things "I" can change are limited to personal behaviors. Other people's behaviors are their own problems.

Understanding, Purpose, Speech, Conduct, Vocation, Effort, Mindfullness, & Meditation cover personal behaviors.

*I* certainly can fill in the blank and have done so hundreds of times before I realized that it was completely unnecessary for achieving and maintaining sobriety (you know, the supposed goal of AA).


Why does the "prayer" need to phrased in such a way that an external force must cause the change? What if the force decides not to? Can an alcoholic make the force obey his demand?

It seems that requesting a higher power to do one's bidding is just another example of trying to control things.

How about: "I seek the serenity..."

I prefer the opening I said last year some time... "Today I have the serenity..."

I would much rather focus on the fact that I have exactly what I need at any given moment when it comes to positive and strong drives to succeed. I'm not desperate; I'm not flailing about; I'm not needing a grant for something which I already have in abundance; I need only merely remind myself of this.
 
Sorry, folks, I did a horribe job on my last post, and edited it a whole bunch. I'd appeciate a re-reading.
 
Welcome, Bamberger.


ETA: in my ongoing reseach on what a religion is, It seems as though it is a religion. But since I don't really care if it is, I don't have a problem with that. I would never tell someone that they are wrong in believing in a diety, because that would doing something that imposes my belief system on another, which I think is what you are saying AA is doing. IF AA is wrong, why aren't you equally at fault (by telling others that they are wrong,)

Thanks for the welcome, Ketyk, and thanks for your assessment. I am not telling anybody they are wrong in believing in a deity. That is their business. I want to address the topic at hand: whether AA is a religion or not.
 
An outmoded, incorrect way of viewing alcoholism that's pushed by AA and it's spiritual problems which require a spiritual solution.
Are you, or anyone, making positive headway helping alcoholics under your new & better secular-humanism based definition?

What is that definition?
 
Yes, I believe so. Insofar as AA not declaring itself a religion.
Yeah, I know, I agree, but what can ya do about it. Would you go to a meeting and say something like 'Let's not do this anymore.' Me, I just hold hands, and think about any insights I might have had that day that works toward my sobriety, if any.
 
Yeah, I know, I agree, but what can ya do about it. Would you go to a meeting and say something like 'Let's not do this anymore.'

I'm not saying there is anything to do about it. I just want to establish that it is a religion.
 
Are you, or anyone, making positive headway helping alcoholics under your new & better secular-humanism based definition?

What is that definition?

Of course there's better headway made in helping addicts/alcoholics. It's analogous to making better headway in treating epilieptics; it was once thought that the person suffering a siezure was under demonic possession. Now, we know better and can treat symptoms with drugs.

Bill W. sincerely believed alcoholism is a spiritual problem requiring a spiritual solution. Seventy five years of research into the human brain, addiction, what is volition, how do drugs like alcohol affect the body and mind...

The definition I use is based on the DSM-IV, though I have recently read other definitions based on slightly different medical models so I may be leaning more towards that.
 
Yeah, I know, I agree, but what can ya do about it.

Get rid of it? Complain to people that it's unneccessary?

Would you go to a meeting and say something like 'Let's not do this anymore.' Me, I just hold hands, and think about any insights I might have had that day that works toward my sobriety, if any.


Scandalamity! I've been the chair of meetings and simply refused to close with the Lord's Prayer, for example. I lost a few members because of it.

I guess they thought prayer in their AA meetings was more important than sharing their experience, strength and hope with other fellow alcoholics. I guess that says where their priorities lie.
 
Thanks Norseman for the clear and precise reply.

The snipeing at eachother was getting to me.
 
Welcome, Bamberger.

It would seem so. I wouldn't disagree that it does.

But so what? I'm not there for a religious conversion. I go there to hear other people, and how they dealt with addiction. Many did it with a religious overtone, but many did not. If they found that this aspect helped them, so what? Let them, if it helps them.

Me on the other hand choose not go that route, and I have not been osticized for doing so. I've met hundereds of people in AA meetings, and never once has someone told me I will never achieve sobriety because of my stand on the subect. Yes the big book says that. I choose to diagree.

ETA: in my ongoing reseach on what a religion is, It seems as though it is a religion. But since I don't really care if it is, I don't have a problem with that. I would never tell someone that they are wrong in believing in a diety, because that would doing something that imposes my belief system on another, which I think is what you are saying AA is doing. IF AA is wrong, why aren't you equally at fault (by telling others that they are wrong or at least lacking in integrity or lying)

This is a very good point, Ketyk. It is balanced and poignant. Thanks.
 
An outmoded, incorrect way of viewing alcoholism that's pushed by AA and it's spiritual problems which require a spiritual solution.




The subject for a different thread.




*I* certainly can fill in the blank and have done so hundreds of times before I realized that it was completely unnecessary for achieving and maintaining sobriety (you know, the supposed goal of AA).




I prefer the opening I said last year some time... "Today I have the serenity..."

I would much rather focus on the fact that I have exactly what I need at any given moment when it comes to positive and strong drives to succeed. I'm not desperate; I'm not flailing about; I'm not needing a grant for something which I already have in abundance; I need only merely remind myself of this.

Norseman, sounds like you got the help you needed. Did AA have anything to do with your "positive and strong drive to succeed"?
 
Last edited:
Norseman, sounds like you got the help you needed. Did AA have anything to do with your "positive and strong drive to succeed".


Why do you feel the need to claim credit for AA in every success when many successes are accomplished in spite of AA?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom