Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
But being a non-religious member of a non-religious program would mean that my request to end a religious prayer is in fact the right thing to do, isn't it?

No.

It is, however, a way to demonstrate where your priorities lie. Good luck with your sobriety, my friend. I mean that quite sincerely.
 
No.

It is, however, a way to demonstrate where your priorities lie.

I love it.

When an AA group holds prayers at its meetings, AA defenders insist it means nothing.

When an regional authority de-lists a group for taking the God references out of the 12 steps, they insist it means nothing.

But when a member asks that the prayers be saved for after the meeting, it says something about where his priorities lie.
 
I love it.

When an AA group holds prayers at its meetings, AA defenders insist it means nothing.

When an regional authority de-lists a group for taking the God references out of the 12 steps, they insist it means nothing.

You might be confusing me with one of the (non-existent, as far as I can tell) people who insist that AA is not religious. It has religious elements. The big book contains religious wording. Whoopty doo! I receive support in my decision to lead a sober life, and this support has proven very helpful. If people want to pray, as most in the world seem to want to do, more power to them. It's not, however, what I'm there for. Nor am I there to cleanse AA of religiosity.

But when a member asks that the prayers be saved for after the meeting, it says something about where his priorities lie.

Indeed.
 
Last edited:
I had read the OP, and re-read to stay on topic.

It is my opinion that AA is a Christian organization, and when it says it is not, it is being disingenuous. Having said that, I don't think AA tries to convert anyones religious beliefs. Some people do convert from to Agnostic or Atheistic to Christianity, and vice versa. That's free will.

Some might say it should change its approach, and say it is Christian, but I think it was and is just trying to be open to anyone that needs help.
I could quibble with several of your points (such as whether AA tries to convert, or the free will comment), but I'll stick to the main point.

I maintain that while AA is religious, and while it clearly originated in the Oxford Group which was clearly Christian, AA has become a separate religion from Christianity. Here's my argument:

Does AA say that one must believe in Jesus Christ or that Jesus Christ is the Son of God? No. Does AA promote Christian church attendance? No - many meetings are held in Christian church buildings, but AA doesn't promote attendance at church services.

AA doesn't say where you will go or what will happen to you when you die. Christianity says if you believe in and follow Jesus Christ, you will go to heaven.

AA does promote belief in "God, as we understood Him" and thus it IS religious. AA does promote attendance at its own AA meetings.

Many Christian churches do have "Christ-centered 12-step meetings" (usually using Christian-oriented 12-step literature such as the "Serenity Bible") but they are run as part of the church, and are apparently not as common as AA or Al-Anon. There's also at least one outright Christian 12-step group that few have heard of despite it being perhaps the very first offshoot of AA (apparently well before Al-Anon): Alcoholics Victorious.

But AA is not any of these Christian oriented groups, it is its own religion.
 
...
But AA is not any of these Christian oriented groups, it is its own religion.

Thanks Ben. I agree with everything you said except the last line. That one I will think about for a bit. I'm not prepared to say one way or the other, I'll consider it. It may be a valid argument.

I hope you also see it is pointless to group everyone that goes to AA as the same. I've been from the start willing to consider someone’s point view, and done so without categorizing and ridiculing them.

AA is too religious. I am a member AA. I am agnostic (most of the time).

Does that statement mean I have lost my integrity or am a liar?
 
I'll try to be non-judgmental about your integrity. :)

But you say AA is "too religious." I'm wondering just how much religion is too much - it seems to me that being religious is like what AA says about being alcoholic - it's like being pregnant, you are or you aren't.

As you may have inferred from my earlier posts in this thread, I'm a FORMER member of AA. I no longer consider or label myself an alcoholic. If I use any "label" for myself, it's human being.
 
Hang on Jack, you said:

"AA has killed people I know. People who were desperate and helpless, and needed to see that their were treatment options other than AA".

I asked what other treatments. And you responded "real clinical psychology" and finally gave me that lovely even handed and objective comparison above. :rolleyes:

Now I want to know what the efficacy of this so called "real clinical psychology" is in treating alcoholics?
Have you some studies or are you making things up like those in the ST forum?

So what are the efficacy numbers of AA then, Alfie? And you said earlier in this thread that you also suggest other treatment methods to your clients. What numbers and studies have you read to make those recommendations?
 
Do you really think that AA members would subject themselves to meta-studies because you and others doubt the validity of AA. I sincerely would not bet on it. I believe they are convinced it is working for them by their own personal triumphs.
Norseman people seem to think here (Jack, Ben, Complexity ect...) that there is just a bunch of uneducated whackaloon robots in AA, that need to be saved from the evil abusive ghost of Bill W and his writings.
AA is filled with all types, on average from my experience they are professional people. Judges, Doctors, White Collar, Blue Collar, Business owners (sm and lg) Factory workers ect.....
We are not ignorant, most of us have gone on to learn more about alcoholism, we share the same opinions of most here both pro and con but want to stay with AA. We have even gone on to receive additional help from professionals as Bill W. himself suggested in the BB.
Just some thoughts.

Thank you for your thoughts. Just one clarification, however, if I may. A meta-study is when researchers examine many other studies that have been done regarding one particular area, so AAs are not subjecting themselves to a meta-study at all. They may become involved in a study about... well... whatever the researchers are wishing to study.

And I don't believe for an instant people will become part of a study simply because some other people are sceptical of the validity of AA. I believe one of the larger AA studies was done from a very pro-AA researcher who wanted to prove how effective he thought AA was and the results were seemingly a surprise to him. (I'm sorry, I don't have a link to that study, but it was one which was posted in this thread and was brought up earlier.)

If I saw some studies which showed a major improvement in helping people stop drinking with AA, then I'd do much, much more to help make it available to a far larger audience by helping to remove what I consider to be the god-nonsense.

Thanks to this thread, I have been exposed to secular alternatives and have promoted them enthusiastically whenever and wherever I could. The more FREE alternatives, the better as people will have resources available that they feel comfortable with in seeking help from addiction.
 
Data does not seem to show any other type of mentoring to be better, unless you believe the PDA and DDD stats are meaningful for the alcoholics Alfie, I, and others have first-hand experience with.

From our experiences those those alcoholics eventually discover that both Percent Days Abstinent (PDA) and Drinks per Drinking Day (DDD) greater than zero don't work, and one is sooner or later -- usually sooner -- right back where they were before noticing all the same problems are there and worse rather than better.

So you disagree with the DDD and PDA criteria. So what then, are your criteria that you can measure meaningfully?
 
Very few, if any, have denied that there are many in AA whose programs are religious in nature and practice, or that the big book is rife with religious overtones. What you may be reading as denial is the statement of the fact that participation in AA does not have to be religious in nature. There are no religious requirements in AA, regardless of how many statements you may read to the contrary, and, consequently, it is easily possible for an individual to participate in AA without adhering to any religious belief. This is neither a denial of, nor an apology for, religiosity within AA. It is simply a statement of fact.

I might also point out that labelling someone an apologist does not necessarily mean that his argument is without merit. To use the label in such a way is fallacious.
Why do people insist that AA is not religious? I've yet to see anyone make such an insistence.

Complexity has not said, "you're an apologist, therefore you're wrong" or anything resembling that.

What he's said is, "apologists say this, and they're wrong because of xyz."

Not a fallacy.
 
Yes.

Being a non-religious member, however, I see no benefit in trying to bend others to my will. It's not what I'm there for. I'm guessing that it would be met with about as much respect as was shown in making the request in the first place. "I don't respect your world-view; please respect mine..."

"A member calls a group conscience meeting ...". Not.

I only hope most closed discussion groups would tell you to shut up and/or leave, since they are there to assist one another in their efforts to not drink, and you apparently have some other agenda.

You might be confusing me with one of the (non-existent, as far as I can tell) people who insist that AA is not religious. It has religious elements. The big book contains religious wording. Whoopty doo! I receive support in my decision to lead a sober life, and this support has proven very helpful. If people want to pray, as most in the world seem to want to do, more power to them. It's not, however, what I'm there for. Nor am I there to cleanse AA of religiosity.

Indeed.


Yes, exactly! If people are there to get sober and stay sober, then why recite the Lord's Prayer in the first place? Why keep that tradition going after 75 years if, as you seem to all agree, it has no place in a sober support meeting that claims it's not religious?
 
It is, however, a way to demonstrate where your priorities lie. Good luck with your sobriety, my friend.

So one should endure being in a group which _promotes_ religion in order to get sober ? Convert, perhaps ? What if someone says "I'm an atheist, so I won't participate in the prayer" ? Do you think this will be met with nods of approval ?
 
What if someone says "I'm an atheist, so I won't participate in the prayer" ? Do you think this will be met with nods of approval ?

No, I think the person taking such a stand will be ostracized by most members of the group. This person will experience the "inside AA", which is different than that presented to the general public. The "inside AA" is religious. The "outside AA" is a self-help group, whose only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.
 
Gosh, so much to respond to....

I see a problem with trying to get actual numbers on the efficacy of AA, and AA compared to clinical psychology.

We are told by the AA bigots that 5% is the figure. These same people continually claim there are better treatments with better number (I paraphrase). One poster has suggested that "real psychology" is better. I would like to see why they think that and where the numbers are.

There is absolutely no reason to encourage anyone to go to AA.

There are many reasons to encourage AA to people with alcoholism. If you don't know them I am amazed you are posting here. They provide many positive things including friendship, guidance, self management and life skills, support networks, powers of example and spirituality, just to name a few. There are others and one can pick and choose what they want within the framework.

Alfie and his ilk refuse to acknowledge that AA is religious, which is the subject of this thread.

This is absolutely untrue.

This statement is not true.

quite

Let me elaborate upon my statement, then.

Several AA apologists have maintained that AA is not religious in nature or in practice.

Who? Where and when?

Some AA apologists have admitted that AA core materials advocate religious belief and tell people that religious belief is necessary to advance far in their efforts to overcome their addiction to alcohol.

People here?
Who, where and when?

These same AA apologists maintain that an AA participant can interpret these deistic religious teachings and expectations any way s/he wishes, that s/he can tailor the AA experience to be as religious or non-religious as desired and still be regarded as propertly pursuing the AA program.

This is correct.

I used the phrase 'Alfie and his ilk' originally. That was imprecise and inaccurate of me, for it obscured a crucial difference between AA apologists that these first two points bring out.

I do not understand what you are saying here, please explain.

Finally, the original topic of this thread was whether AA is religious in nature and in practice and why so many AA participants deny that it is.

Who, where and when?

Homophobic much?

It actually has a lot to do with AA. This guy needed real therapy, but was instead treated to spiritual faith healing by an abusive sponsor. Standard AA protocol.

The example was totally anecdotal and third (maybe fourth) hand. Your accusations are vile in the extreme and totally unsupported.
If this is indeed what happened then that "sponsor" should be tarred and feathered prior to a long incarceration.

That said, it is your tactics here that should be called to account; they are the classic ST hate-group protocol where one can say anything without having to provide proof.

Suicide rates among alcoholics are higher, and most are "treated" through AA and 12-step faith healing. I'm not going to cite data to you, because it wouldn't matter, anyway.

I suspect what is true is that as usual you make claims you cannot support. I am calling you on this one Jack. Where is the "data"? :covereyes:mad:

As long as you and yours are here doing Bad Things, I will be here to point them out to you and everyone else.

Whay "bad things" are we doing? And who gets to decide what is bad? You?

It's a good thing i'm not a stepper, I suppose. Just a guy looking to improve myself, which AA and this thread have done.

Where can I read these studies?

They will be non-existent I suspect. ;)

If not secular then religious, right? Or is there a middle ground that introduces shades of gray regarding the question? The "spiritual not religious" angle does not adequately settle this question in my opinion, as practicing spirituality is typically expressed through the observance of religious ritual, the likes of which abound in AA.

The spiritual definition is the one most of us prefer to use. It's a shame you don't find it "adequate" but we won't be losing sleep over it. ;)

Humorous to you, perhaps; not to me.

I got it too. I thought it was pretty funny. I guess you had to be there. :rolleyes:

While I wish not to rest on it, this kinda proves the point that only one alky can understand another. Ergo, you - not being an alky - just wouldn't get it would you?

The other thing is that many of us have learned not to take ourselves too seriously. You seem to want to take us more seriously than we do ourselves. :boggled:

I admit being a humorless pedant doesn't appeal to me.

Me either. See above about taking ourselves too seriously.

Can a non-religious member therefore ask the religious ones to refrain from praying at the end of the meeting? Will their wish be respected?

Where I come from, the request could be made at a group conscience and would then be voted upon by the group members. The result of the vote would determine future proceedures.

Democracy in action... who'dathought? :rolleyes:

Let's say a member calls a group conscience meeting in order to vote on ending the lord's prayer The vote is tallied and the majority of members vote for retaining the prayer. Wouldn't the meeting at that point be considered religious because it is following the dictate of the majority, which consists of individual members who are religious?

It might, but that doesn't necessarily mean that AA worldwide is religious now does it? Nor does it mean that all members are religious and that the program is. It simply means that the group chooses (as a group) to use the lords prayer.
I think we can safely assume that the majority of the members are Christian.

It's been said in meetings that taking the steps is "suggested" in the same way that if you jump out of an airplane wearing a parachute, it's "suggested" you pull the ripcord. It's along the lines of saying "if you don't want to recover from alcoholism, then you don't have to take these 12 steps."

What a load of nonsense. You may have heard that in an AA meeting but that is not how it happens in practice. I have bent the steps every which way for myself and my sponsees over the years. They are very versatile and work just fine as long as you make some effort.

Also, AA has no suggestions other than taking the 12 steps.

What would you "suggest" they do, recommend something they haven't seen work? Maybe AA members should be referring members to some evidenced based treatments. We might be able to do that if we actually had the evidence. Have you got some to share?

All that is the roundabout AA way of saying "the step about making amends" is indeed mandatory in AA.

Rubbish!

And just by way of an explanation:
As someone else said, some are non verbal.

People we make amends to fall into four basic categories:
1. Those who we ought to deal with as soon as we become reasonably confident we can maintain our sobriety (e.g. we may have had a huge row with a family member recently).
2. Those who we can only make partial restitution to, lest complete disclosure does them or others more harm than good (eg. repay stolen money in part or anonymously as we may go to gaol which would harm our family).
3. Other cases where action ought to be deferred (eg. That person has threatened to kill us).
4. Some we shall never be able to make personal contact with (eg. Total strangers that I ‘punched out’ breaking their jaws – our amends is to not do that any more.

I maintain that while AA is religious, and while it clearly originated in the Oxford Group which was clearly Christian, AA has become a separate religion from Christianity. Here's my argument:

Does AA say that one must believe in Jesus Christ or that Jesus Christ is the Son of God? No. Does AA promote Christian church attendance? No - many meetings are held in Christian church buildings, but AA doesn't promote attendance at church services.

AA doesn't say where you will go or what will happen to you when you die. Christianity says if you believe in and follow Jesus Christ, you will go to heaven.

AA does promote belief in "God, as we understood Him" and thus it IS religious. AA does promote attendance at its own AA meetings.

Ergo, no specific god, no christ, no religious dogma, just a total freedom to practice my spirituality in any way I please, equals spirituality for mine.

So what are the efficacy numbers of AA then, Alfie? And you said earlier in this thread that you also suggest other treatment methods to your clients. What numbers and studies have you read to make those recommendations?

Actually I have no studies I could rely on with any real satisfaction, hence my desire to see something qualitative.
And for the record, I have never professed that AA is anything but a good maintenance and support group that helps people in need.

My clients and I will look at some of the alternatives available (SMART, detox and rehab, psychology, CBT, general counselling etc), and consider what might be worthwhile. Some clients require mental health support and treatment as well and that is usually the best place to start while we do some general education (or similar) around addiction.
Other clients (PTSD, sexual abuse etc) need help in a specific area and many, once having found ways to manage or repair the damage have lost their major triggers.

In other words, there are quite a few options available depending on the problem. It is impossible to determine which will best suit (and let's face it, a lot it hit or miss) until we have made a sound assessment of the client.
If I have someone whio just can't stop drinking I will usualy suggest detox, rehab and maintenance. AA will sometimes form part of that maintenance.

At the hospital I work at we have many outpatient support groups. I have my own gigs twice a week. We have some 250 outpatients per month come to do things like lifeskills & relapse prevention (that's mine), mindfulness, art therapy, men's and women's support groups (I do one of the men's), family support groups etc. For our rehab clients these are a fantastic form of maintenance; we have something of our own outpatient community going, it is quite a thing to be honest.

I would love to see a pretty comprehensive list and their efficacy rates. Some of the AA bigots and hate group members have come here and said they have this data. I would like to see what they have but I suspect as usual, they are telling big fat pork pies.

So one should endure being in a group which _promotes_ religion in order to get sober ? Convert, perhaps ? What if someone says "I'm an atheist, so I won't participate in the prayer" ? Do you think this will be met with nods of approval ?

No one cares if they say the prayer or not.
 
Asking a group of steppers to take God and prayer out of their meetings won't happen. It's essential for the bait and switch routine. Here is how Bill Wilson explains it in the Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, which along with the 'Big Book', anyone attending a 12-step rehab will be given to study:

"So, practicing these Steps, we had a spiritual awakening about which finally there was no question. Looking at those who were only beginning and still doubted themselves*, the rest of us were able to see the change setting in. From great numbers of such experience*s, we could predict that the doubter who still claimed that he hadn't got the 'spiritual angle,' and who still considered his well-loved AA group the higher power, would presently love God and call Him by name."
- page 109
 
Jack, am I a 'stepper' in your mind. Please do not ask what I think, because I was unfamiar with the word before this thread. I have a good idea of what you mean, though.

Am I in your mind in the catagory of 'steppers'?
 
It might, but that doesn't necessarily mean that AA worldwide is religious now does it? Nor does it mean that all members are religious and that the program is. It simply means that the group chooses (as a group) to use the lords prayer.
I think we can safely assume that the majority of the members are Christian.

So the group can be considered religious at this point by virtue of the majority choosing to retain a religious prayer, correct?

Could this logic be expanded, say, at the area/district level if the majority of groups that constitute the area/district also have voted to retain the lord's prayer? In other words, the area/district can now be viewed as religious because a majority of its constituent groups are religious.
 
Alcoholism == self-will run riot.

What is atheism?

I feel sorry for all suffering alcoholics who can't fill in the blank in the serenity prayer:

________ grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference.

With wisdom, most notice the things "I" can change are limited to personal behaviors. Other people's behaviors are their own problems.

Understanding, Purpose, Speech, Conduct, Vocation, Effort, Mindfullness, & Meditation cover personal behaviors.
 
I feel sorry for all suffering alcoholics who can't fill in the blank in the serenity prayer:

________ grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference.

This atheist quite likes the serenity prayer, with the following modification:

"I shall strive to have the serenity...."
 
Alcoholism == self-will run riot.

What is atheism?

I feel sorry for all suffering alcoholics who can't fill in the blank in the serenity prayer:

________ grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference.

Why does the "prayer" need to phrased in such a way that an external force must cause the change? What if the force decides not to? Can an alcoholic make the force obey his demand?

It seems that requesting a higher power to do one's bidding is just another example of trying to control things.

How about: "I seek the serenity..."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom