Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bamberger - I agree with you, and welcome to the forums.

While a religious person can accomodate himself to secular program by privately augmenting it with his religious beliefs without a loss of integrity, the same can not be said for the converse: A non-religious person can not accommodate himself to a religious program by privately stripping it of its religious aspects, or pretend to accept them, without a loss of integrity.
 
A non-religious person can not accommodate himself to a religious program by privately stripping it of its religious aspects, or pretend to accept them, without a loss of integrity.

Thanks for the welcome, complexity. I agree, and this is why I am troubled by the public face that AA presents vs. what goes on inside the halls. There is an altruistic front (made famous through the media), behind which an evangelical faith lies in wait. A vulnerable person may at first be grateful for having a place to go where abstinence is encouraged. This same person (assuming they are secular or non-Christian) is likely to face a dilemma not too far down the road as they are told: "the elevator to recovery is broken, you need to take the steps". As you point out, they will ultimately have to sacrifice their integrity in order to maintain friends in the group.
 
Every individual picks their own sponser. (or rather they ask someone if they might be a sponser to them) I'd advise against picking a crazy old-timer, I prefer intelligent and thoughtful old-timers.

Isn't this "right" a good thing to have, picking our mentors. This is why the integrity of AA has stood the test of time. Freedom, choices and suggestive practices are the hallmark principles of AA.
:)
 
... they will ultimately have to sacrifice their integrity...
As I said before, most drunks have sacrificed their integity in many ways prior to considering they need help with a drinking problem. So what integrity will they sacrifice? Gathering with a group of other drunks who have quit or are trying to quit, most of whom are not hard-core atheists?

in order to maintain friends in the group.
If friendship is what you're after AA may not be the best place to look for it.

ymmv, I suppose
 
If friendship is what you're after AA may not be the best place to look for it.

ymmv, I suppose

Ok, let's assume one is just going to get sober, not make friends. In this case it's still possible to lose one's integrity (e.g. as a secularist, by engaging in religious practices) in order to avoid being ostracized, isn't it?
 
Ok, let's assume one is just going to get sober, not make friends. In this case it's still possible to lose one's integrity (e.g. as a secularist, by engaging in religious practices) in order to avoid being ostracized, isn't it?
I've been to many meetings that included irreligious people, if hard-core athiests I don't know, that topic never having come up in my presence, and have never observed such ostracism. Sorry it occured to you, and if not you, who?

I suppose such ostracism is possible, and if I recognized it, I would look for a different group.

I've never seen one is forced to join in a circle reciting the lord's prayer, which is a meeting-end feature in some groups, although I've seen people who left rather than joining in. No one cared to the best of my knowledge.
 
I've never seen one is forced to join in a circle reciting the lord's prayer, which is a meeting-end feature in some groups, although I've seen people who left rather than joining in. No one cared to the best of my knowledge.

The lord's prayer is Christian. This alone makes any group that recites it religious, doesn't it?
 
The lord's prayer is Christian. This alone makes any group that recites it religious, doesn't it?
Members of the group, maybe even all of 'em, may be individually religious. The AA Meeting is not for those who don't want it to be so.
 
Members of the group, maybe even all of 'em, may be individually religious. The AA Meeting is not for those who don't want it to be so.

Can a non-religious member therefore ask the religious ones to refrain from praying at the end of the meeting? Will their wish be respected?
 
Can a non-religious member therefore ask the religious ones to refrain from praying at the end of the meeting?

Yes.

Being a non-religious member, however, I see no benefit in trying to bend others to my will. It's not what I'm there for.

Will their wish be respected?

I'm guessing that it would be met with about as much respect as was shown in making the request in the first place. "I don't respect your world-view; please respect mine..."
 
So, alcoholics have no integrity, but....

AA just tries to restore it. Some here appear to need a few more meetings.

And yet, the standard dismissal of AA's own surveys, given to steppers in the program showing no effectiveness is:

Studies/Surveys conducted by questionnaires filled out by people who are notorious liars, those people being alcohol abusers.

Awesome.

You know, I've always wondered why you steppers use the "we alkies lie" excuse. If AAs are a pack of liars, and I agree with you that they are, they wouldn't lie that they started drinking again. They would lie about falling off the wagon, and claim they are still sober. Which means that 5% is a best case scenario if nobody lied about slip. And as you two have effectively argued, that ain't gonna happen.
 
Unknown. If that's more important to you than trying to alleviate your drinking problem, try it and let us know.


Let's say a member calls a group conscience meeting in order to vote on ending the lord's prayer The vote is tallied and the majority of members vote for retaining the prayer. Wouldn't the meeting at that point be considered religious because it is following the dictate of the majority, which consists of individual members who are religious?
 
I have been researching if the step about making amends is mandatory in AA. This could be difficult for many people, and may block recovery if they can't do it.
It's been said in meetings that taking the steps is "suggested" in the same way that if you jump out of an airplane wearing a parachute, it's "suggested" you pull the ripcord. It's along the lines of saying "if you don't want to recover from alcoholism, then you don't have to take these 12 steps."

Also, AA has no suggestions other than taking the 12 steps.

All that is the roundabout AA way of saying "the step about making amends" is indeed mandatory in AA.

Whether not doing it "may block recovery" is another discussion. Certainly AA members will say not doing it does block recovery.
 
Yes.

Being a non-religious member, however, I see no benefit in trying to bend others to my will. It's not what I'm there for.

But being a non-religious member of a non-religious program would mean that my request to end a religious prayer is in fact the right thing to do, isn't it?
 
Can a non-religious member therefore ask the religious ones to refrain from praying at the end of the meeting? Will their wish be respected?

Thanks for joining in on the discussion Bamberger. If you take a quick look at the beginning of this thread you'll see my 'qualifications', if you will, to speak on this issue: in summary, more than 20 yrs sober working within AA, frequently at near the highest levels, to remove the godbothering from AA and bring a scientific, results-based examination of the AA program (as described in the Big Book & the 12x12) to fruition, in order to see what parts (if any) of AA might be effective, what parts can be used in an inclusive way, etc. Additionally , I personally have lead or attended many thousands of meetings, created districts & clubs from scratch, etc.

In all of this time, I have never seen an AA member ask such a question - the amount of pressure on new members to conform to the will of the group is too strong - that, coupled with the extreme vulnerability of many new members, prevent that from happening.

I myself have done it, and the amount of negative, out-group responses is significant.

One more thing I've mentioned before in this thread: To help answer the question on the religious nature of AA, anyone at a meeting can make the following statement & observe the reactions (note: do not do this without long thought on the consequences):

Statement: "Neither any god, nor higher power, is necessary for me to get, maintain, & live a happy, productive, sober life".

I've said that many times, in front of 100's & 1000's of people (as an invited speaker) - in every case, massive, immediate & long lasting negative reactions was the result, from a near majority of attendees. I don't recommend anyone in AA do this unless they are very prepared (emotionally).

In any case, enjoy your time here!
 
It's been said in meetings that taking the steps is "suggested" in the same way that if you jump out of an airplane wearing a parachute, it's "suggested" you pull the ripcord. It's along the lines of saying "if you don't want to recover from alcoholism, then you don't have to take these 12 steps."

Also, AA has no suggestions other than taking the 12 steps.

All that is the roundabout AA way of saying "the step about making amends" is indeed mandatory in AA.

Whether not doing it "may block recovery" is another discussion. Certainly AA members will say not doing it does block recovery.
•Step Nine: Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.


What is it that you don't undertand about "except when to do so would injure them or others"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom