Can a non-religious member therefore ask the religious ones to refrain from praying at the end of the meeting? Will their wish be respected?
Thanks for joining in on the discussion Bamberger. If you take a quick look at the beginning of this thread you'll see my 'qualifications', if you will, to speak on this issue: in summary, more than 20 yrs sober working within AA, frequently at near the highest levels, to remove the godbothering from AA and bring a scientific, results-based examination of the AA program (as described in the Big Book & the 12x12) to fruition, in order to see what parts (if any) of AA
might be effective, what parts can be used in an inclusive way, etc. Additionally , I personally have lead or attended many thousands of meetings, created districts & clubs from scratch, etc.
In all of this time, I have
never seen an AA member ask such a question - the amount of pressure on new members to conform to the will of the group is too strong - that, coupled with the extreme vulnerability of many new members, prevent that from happening.
I myself have done it, and the amount of negative, out-group responses is
significant.
One more thing I've mentioned before in this thread: To help answer the question on the religious nature of AA,
anyone at a meeting can make the following statement & observe the reactions (note: do not do this without long thought on the consequences):
Statement: "Neither any god, nor higher power, is necessary for me to get, maintain, & live a happy, productive, sober life".
I've said that many times, in front of 100's & 1000's of people (as an invited speaker) - in
every case, massive, immediate & long lasting negative reactions was the result, from a near majority of attendees. I don't recommend anyone in AA do this unless they are very prepared (emotionally).
In any case, enjoy your time here!