Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hey Complexity, do us/me a favor and stop being snarky by calling us/me names. I am not a apologists, loon, criminal, whackjob, stepper or any of the others names you and others have called us. We are AA members or how about this, DannyB II or just Danny.
If you want respect then give it.
OK you don't like AA and you feel it hurts people. That is your opinion or experience, I respect that and will continue from this point on.


Of the terms that you mentioned, I have only used 'apologist' to describe those who are defenders of AA. I think it is accurate and will continue to use it, for it is both descriptive and carries with it, for me, a negative connotation that I think is appropriate.

I do not like your defense of AA's religious orientation, materials, intentions, and practices - I think those things are harmful and it would be wrong to pretend otherwise. I do not respect anyone's holding those beliefs. I think that each of the people I have referred to as 'apologists' has been less than honest with themselves and/or with us.

That you have had good experiences with AA, or that others have not, is not the issue. The question is: Is AA religious? I think that question has been answered and that this thread should been brought to a close a long time ago.

If you want to have an AA appreciation thread, or a thread discussion studies on the efficacy of AA as compared with other treatment/recovery options, start one. That stuff doesn't belong here.
 
Last edited:
What we have been saying is that simply because someone is an alcoholic and (hopefully) on the road to recovery does not make that person competent to mentor others on how to do the same.
Data does not seem to show any other type of mentoring to be better, unless you believe the PDA and DDD stats are meaningful for the alcoholics Alfie, I, and others have first-hand experience with.

From our experiences those those alcoholics eventually discover that both Percent Days Abstinent (PDA) and Drinks per Drinking Day (DDD) greater than zero don't work, and one is sooner or later -- usually sooner -- right back where they were before noticing all the same problems are there and worse rather than better.
 
Sad story having little or nothing to do with AA. I don't doubt an alcoholic bi-sexual might decide to kill himself, in or out of AA.



What does someone's being 'bi-sexual' have to do with it?

What the hell does someone's being 'bi-sexual' have to do with it?
 
Last edited:
Data does not seem to show any other type of mentoring to be better, unless you believe the PDA and DDD stats are meaningful for the alcoholics Alfie, I, and others have first-hand experience with.

From our experiences those those alcoholics eventually discover that both Percent Days Abstinent (PDA) and Drinks per Drinking Day (DDD) greater than zero don't work, and one is sooner or later -- usually sooner -- right back where they were before noticing all the same problems are there and worse rather than better.


Not really relevant to the point under discussion - I was not referencing PDA or DDD. Feel free to cite studies if you can.

By the way, you made a comment that I was a late participant in this thread. Was curious and checked. I made the third comment in the thread a long time ago, not that when one joins a thread matters in the least.
 
Last edited:
Sad story having little or nothing to do with AA. I don't doubt an alcoholic bi-sexual might decide to kill himself, in or out of AA.

Homophobic much?

It actually has a lot to do with AA. This guy needed real therapy, but was instead treated to spiritual faith healing by an abusive sponsor. Standard AA protocol.


Suicide rates among alcoholics are higher, and most are "treated" through AA and 12-step faith healing. I'm not going to cite data to you, because it wouldn't matter, anyway. You steppers have dismissed literally every bit of evidence presented in the year that this thread has been alive. I won't argue against delusion.
 
Finally, the original topic of this thread was whether AA is religious in nature and in practice and why so many AA participants deny that it is.

Very few, if any, have denied that there are many in AA whose programs are religious in nature and practice, or that the big book is rife with religious overtones. What you may be reading as denial is the statement of the fact that participation in AA does not have to be religious in nature. There are no religious requirements in AA, regardless of how many statements you may read to the contrary, and, consequently, it is easily possible for an individual to participate in AA without adhering to any religious belief. This is neither a denial of, nor an apology for, religiosity within AA. It is simply a statement of fact.

I might also point out that labelling someone an apologist does not necessarily mean that his argument is without merit. To use the label in such a way is fallacious.

Why do people insist that AA is not religious? I've yet to see anyone make such an insistence.
 
I'd like to get a bit off the OP to respond to questions posed to me and others regarding AA efficacy.

From:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19207347

We have:
"CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that treatment providers can use a 12-Step-based directive approach to effectively facilitate involvement in AA and thereby improve client outcome."
 
Last edited:
Of the terms that you mentioned, I have only used 'apologist' to describe those who are defenders of AA. I think it is accurate and will continue to use it, for it is both descriptive and carries with it, for me, a negative connotation that I think is appropriate.

I do not like your defense of AA's religious orientation, materials, intentions, and practices - I think those things are harmful and it would be wrong to pretend otherwise. I do not respect anyone's holding those beliefs. I think that each of the people I have referred to as 'apologists' has been less than honest with themselves and/or with us.

That you have had good experiences with AA, or that others have not, is not the issue. The question is: Is AA religious? I think that question has been answered and that this thread should been brought to a close a long time ago.

If you want to have an AA appreciation thread, or a thread discussion studies on the efficacy of AA as compared with other treatment/recovery options, start one. That stuff doesn't belong here.

Since you seem to think this thread has served its purpose, why don't you leave then. At least then you could be disrespectful to others.
My comments to you have nothing to do with the pro or con of this thread. I am asking for common decency and respect. I am not calling you names because I don't agree with you. I call you by your username.
I thought my request was reasonable but I guess not. Have it your way.
 
I'd like to get a bit off the OP to respond to questions posed to me and others regarding AA efficacy.
IMO, the religious / not-religious have made their positions clear and no mind-changing will be occuring.

As to the comments on sexual orientation and suicide, whoever wants to discuss that should start a thread to discuss it. Data exists on both sides of that issue too.

ymmv

From:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19207347

We have:
"CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that treatment providers can use a 12-Step-based directive approach to effectively facilitate involvement in AA and thereby improve client outcome."

See also http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2857524/

Conclusions
AA attendance was both concurrently and predictively associated with improved alcohol outcomes. Although AA attendance was additionally associated with subsequent improvements in depression, it did not predict such improvements over and above concurrent alcohol use. AA appears to lead both to improvements in alcohol use and psychological and emotional well-being, which, in turn, may reinforce further abstinence and recovery-related change.
 
I'd like to get a bit off the OP to respond to questions posed to me and others regarding AA efficacy.

From:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19207347

We have:
"CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that treatment providers can use a 12-Step-based directive approach to effectively facilitate involvement in AA and thereby improve client outcome."

This is one a few studies that correlates AA attendance with reduced drinking. It doesn't, and is not supposed to measure the effectiveness of AA in getting people to quit drinking. There's nothing wrong with the study, but it is what it is. Steppers use this and the Moos studies to try and prove AA's effectiveness at getting people to quit drinking, but they simply aren't designed to show this.

In every other discipline, a study that correlates two things - the key word in this abstract being "suggests," is followed up with a study determining actual cause. 12-steppers avoid these kinds of studies like the plague. One good thing about this study is, it should prove to you anonymity is not an issue in performing research on AA.

Every study or survey that does look at AA's effectiveness to in getting people to quit, shows 5% or less, which means zero efficacy (because 5% is the baseline remission). Of course, steppers pretend these don't exist.
 
Homophobic much?

It actually has a lot to do with AA. This guy needed real therapy, but was instead treated to spiritual faith healing by an abusive sponsor. Standard AA protocol.


Suicide rates among alcoholics are higher, and most are "treated" through AA and 12-step faith healing. I'm not going to cite data to you, because it wouldn't matter, anyway. You steppers have dismissed literally every bit of evidence presented in the year that this thread has been alive. I won't argue against delusion.

We are not Doctors of Psychology here, so why are we stating this topic here. It sounds like this info was 3rd hand and even then it didn't come from a professional. Were talking about a life here that was taken by the person himself. We should at least leave the conversation for the people who knew him most and loved him.
I think the comments above were over the top in so far as stating suicide being a major problem here in AA. It is the person himself and the decisions he/she makes that is the problem. So many die before they even get to AA.

This is just one article and study (Lancet).
Here is a article on Alcohol Related deaths: http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1907408,00.html

Excerpt from article:
One in 25 deaths around the world is caused by alcohol consumption, and booze is now as damaging to global health as tobacco was a decade ago, according to a new study in the British medical journal the Lancet.

The last global statistical analysis of the damage caused by alcohol, undertaken in 2000, found that 3.2% of deaths worldwide were the result of alcohol consumption. The new study, part of the Lancet's "Alcohol and Global Health" series published last Saturday, used the same statistical tools as the previous one, and found that for 2004 the figure had increased 0.6%. Alcohol-related causes of death include accidents, violence, poisoning, mouth and throat cancer, colon rectal cancer, breast cancer, suicide, stroke and many others.
 
Last edited:
Since you seem to think this thread has served its purpose, why don't you leave then. At least then you could be disrespectful to others.
My comments to you have nothing to do with the pro or con of this thread. I am asking for common decency and respect. I am not calling you names because I don't agree with you. I call you by your username.
I thought my request was reasonable but I guess not. Have it your way.


I see it as both my obligation and my pleasure to fight ignorance, delusion, superstition, and other Very Bad Things where I find them.

As long as you and yours are here doing Bad Things, I will be here to point them out to you and everyone else.

I only give respect where I feel it is deserved. To do otherwise would be to insult the idea of respect and weaken its power, which would be wrong.

If I have cause to refer to you by name, I may do so. So far, if I'm not mistaken, I haven't felt the need to refer to you individually - I've referred to the group of those who think like you, the defenders of AA, as 'apologists'. I shall continue to do so.

If you don't like being lumped in with apologists, quit behaving like one.
 
Last edited:
It actually has a lot to do with AA. This guy needed real therapy, but was instead treated to spiritual faith healing by an abusive sponsor. Standard AA protocol.
And you are guessing since I am damn sure the sponsor didn't talk to you, and I doubt anything you might have heard from the alcoholic with that problem, and obviously other problems, to face.

Suicide rates among alcoholics are higher, and most are "treated" through AA and 12-step faith healing.
Where do you find data that demonstrates 'most are "treated" through AA and 12-step faith healing'?

Until you find some I don't believe that to be true, other than I suspect alcoholism is positively correlated to risk of suicide.

eta: correlation as demonstrated by DannyB's link above
 
Last edited:
...One good thing about this study is, it should prove to you anonymity is not an issue in performing research on AA. ...

Yes, I think I might have been wrong about this point earlier in this thread.
 
...Every study or survey that does look at AA's effectiveness to in getting people to quit, shows 5% or less, which means zero efficacy (because 5% is the baseline remission). Of course, steppers pretend these don't exist.
It's a good thing i'm not a stepper, I suppose. Just a guy looking to improve myself, which AA and this thread have done.

Where can I read these studies?
 
Where do you find data that demonstrates 'most are "treated" through AA and 12-step faith healing'?

Until you find some I don't believe that to be true, other than I suspect alcoholism is positively correlated to risk of suicide.

eta: correlation as demonstrated by DannyB's link above

90% of U.S. treatment facilities are 12-step based, and they all use AA as their aftercare program. This is a fact, which means it doesn't matter to you.

Of course alcoholism is correlated with suicide. That's the problem. AA does not help alcoholism. It also ignores the point that alcoholism is often a consequence of an underlying psychological condition like PTSD. Even if AA worked to quit drinking, it doesn't address the primary problem in someone with a psychological condition. It actually exacerbates the problem because it's the crazy old-timers and sponsors who serve as de facto psychologists.
 
Every individual picks their own sponser. (or rather they ask someone if they might be a sponser to them) I'd advise against picking a crazy old-timer, I prefer intelligent and thoughtful old-timers.
 
BTW, I go to my psychiatrist for psychiatric needs. He is old, intelligent and thoughtful.
 
Every individual picks their own sponser. (or rather they ask someone if they might be a sponser to them) I'd advise against picking a crazy old-timer, I prefer intelligent and thoughtful old-timers.

Sponsors are like cats. Everyone thinks theirs is different.
 
Yes, on balance it's religious

I believe AA to be a religious program. Look at it this way. Imagine someone were to turn the question around and ask if AA is a secular program. I think even its staunchest defenders would have to say "no".

If not secular then religious, right? Or is there a middle ground that introduces shades of gray regarding the question? The "spiritual not religious" angle does not adequately settle this question in my opinion, as practicing spirituality is typically expressed through the observance of religious ritual, the likes of which abound in AA.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom