Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hang on Jack, you said:

"AA has killed people I know. People who were desperate and helpless, and needed to see that their were treatment options other than AA".

I asked what other treatments. And you responded "real clinical psychology" and finally gave me that lovely even handed and objective comparison above. :rolleyes:

Now I want to know what the efficacy of this so called "real clinical psychology" is in treating alcoholics?
Have you some studies or are you making things up like those in the ST forum?

Is that why you insist AA is not religious?
 
What seems difficult about it to you?
Give me an example or two of where you might have a problem and I can give you my take on it.

What makes it difficult is sometimes people just aren't able to do this. Bringing up the past for some people is too embarrassing and painful, and if they don't do this step there will always be lingering doubts in their mind that they didn't "work the program". Like another poster mentioned with slogans like "are you in AA, or around AA?" it seems like these steps are more than suggestions, there has to be certain steps to take for recovery to be possible. As far as examples go I've seen this issue talked about on AA forums, but I don't remember the specifics.

I know I haven't given any examples but this issue probably came up with some people in AA.
 
Is that why you insist AA is not religious?

It remains as religious as anyone cares to make it; "not religious" is just fine if that floats ones' boat.

Those who can't accept this concept might discuss this with your nearest clinical pychologist. Rates start about $150/hr; you should seek to determine why you believe everyone else is required to accept to your personal worldview as Truth.
 
Last edited:
I see a problem with trying to get actual numbers on the efficacy of AA, and AA compared to clinical psychology. It’s anonimity. Many in AA prefer it not known that they attend, for obvious reasons. I would then find it difficult to do a double blind study or such where the participation rates might be skewed toward those that have no fear of being labeled. Clinical studies, on the other hand, I'm sure have a clear protocol for research in this field.

In his last public letter Bill Wilson said: "If I were asked which of these blessings I felt was most responsible for our growth as a fellowship and most vital to our continuity, I would say, the "Concept of Anonymity."
http://www.aacleve.org/component/content/article/97-bills-last-message.html
Yes that smacks of cultism, but I don't put on my resume "Active in AA". The statement is again way too religious for me, yet I still attend.

BTW, did anyone notice that this thread is second in the number of replies in the section JREF/...Religion and Philosophy? Give yourselves a hand, :clap:
 
Last edited:
[snippity]

BTW, did anyone notice that this thread is second in the number of replies in the section JREF/...Religion and Philosophy? Give yourselves a hand, :clap:

That's not a good thing...

There is absolutely no reason to encourage anyone to go to AA. I have no personal beef. I just will not defend a program based on superstition, with no transparent leadership, no accountability, and no proven results. Of course you can say "we have results, I swear, but it's hard to prove due to anonimity", but that is not a very strong argument.
 
BTW, did anyone notice that this thread is second in the number of replies in the section JREF/...Religion and Philosophy? Give yourselves a hand, :clap:


Having a lot of replies is nothing to be proud of.

Alfie and his ilk refuse to acknowledge that AA is religious, which is the subject of this thread. Their tactics of distraction, misrepresentation, and counter-attack, with the inevitable (and appropriate) posts by others trying to provide evidence and force them back to the thread topic, have inflated this thread.

The number of replies that are in this thread, in other words, are because of the intellectual dishonesty on the part of a handful of participants.
 
Their tactics of distraction, misrepresentation, and counter-attack, with the inevitable (and appropriate) posts by others trying to provide evidence and force them back to the thread topic, have inflated this thread.
There's been lots of comment, little "evidence", and yes the thread has drifted, and had done so long before your late entry.

The number of replies that are in this thread, in other words, are because of the intellectual dishonesty on the part of a handful of participants.
I see the words "It remains as religious as anyone cares to make it; "not religious" is just fine if that floats ones' boat." do not seem truthful to you; your choice of course.

Your are also free to aver those who disagree with you are intellectually dishonest, just don't confuse that with being a "scientifically demonstrable" fact rather than your interpretation.
 
Last edited:
I see a problem with trying to get actual numbers on the efficacy of AA, and AA compared to clinical psychology.

I was referring to clinical psychology in terms getting treatment for psychotic disorders, not to treat an addiction. The question was asked as to what are some options besides AA in treating people who wind up dead as a consequence of their AA involvement. The suicide rate in AA is high.

To begin with, AA is not an option. The AA program is not psychology, and an unemployed used car salesman whose only credentials is time in the AA program is not qualified to dish out therapy to someone with a mental disorder. It doesn't stop it from happening, of course. And when someone offs themselves, the response is inevitably "some must die so that others may live." It's sad.

Last week, a friend's brother-in-law killed himself. The memorial service was Tuesday. He was an AA whose sponsor gave him an ultimatum of choosing between him or his spouse. This guy was bi-sexual, and was 13th stepped by the sponsor and put through the emotional ringer. He had depression problems that may not have been caused by AA, but his sponsor made things worse by being abusive of his position, and the AA program was used to treat him. He needed real help, not religious dogma.
 
Thanks, Ketyk, for your thoughtful comments. One thing I'd like to gently point out, though, is that we really don't know if many more are helped than hurt. I think that's the point of many a poster (such as Alfie and myself) here -- we're wanting some hard numbers to help show whether or not people are helped and by how much. This is, of course, not to say there haven't been legitimate studies done; there needs to be more done. Of those studies, not many have shown AA to be superior to other treatment avenues or coping mechanisms.

And as I've pointed out before, AA isn't the only free program out there.

Norseman, I don't think Alfie is confused as to how much AA has helped people. I believe he sees success everyday in the rooms of AA. :)
 
There's been lots of comment, little "evidence", and yes the thread has drifted, and had done so long before your late entry.


A great deal of evidence has been consistently presented by those of us who maintain that AA is religious in nature and in practice. That you, AA Alfie, and others refuse to discuss or be persuaded by this evidence is your problem, not ours.

If I remember correctly, I posted in this thread occasionally before I took a break from the forums about a year ago. I have been consistent in my comments.

I see the words "It remains as religious as anyone cares to make it; "not religious" is just fine if that floats ones' boat." do not seem truthful to you; your choice of course.


The core materials and standard practices of AA have been shown to be religious in nature, to encourage religious proselytization within AA meetings and relationships, and to be intended to inculcate religious belief within AA members.

You, AA Alfie, and others have said that such religious behavior is not mandatory in AA. Perhaps it is not mandatory, but it certainly appears to be integral to the core beliefs and practices of AA.

It is no longer regarded as legally mandatory for school children to say the Pledge of Allegiance in classrooms, but many teachers, parents, and impressionable children believe otherwise. It takes a strong and confident child to refuse to participate in saying the Pledge in school, just as I think it takes a strong and confident person to stand up to religious indoctrination in many AA meetings and relationships. Unfortunately, people who get involved with AA have often bottomed out in their lives and are neither strong nor confident when they first participate in AA - they are often at their most impressionable.

In other words, AA's core materials and standard practices make many AA meetings and relationships prime hunting ground for religious proselytizers.

To insist that this is not true is some mixture of delusion and lying.

Your are also free to aver those who disagree with you are intellectually dishonest, just don't confuse that with being a "scientifically demonstrable" fact rather than your interpretation.


I stand by that interpretation.
 
Last edited:
This statement is not true.


Let me elaborate upon my statement, then.

Several AA apologists have maintained that AA is not religious in nature or in practice.

Some AA apologists have admitted that AA core materials advocate religious belief and tell people that religious belief is necessary to advance far in their efforts to overcome their addiction to alcohol. These same AA apologists maintain that an AA participant can interpret these deistic religious teachings and expectations any way s/he wishes, that s/he can tailor the AA experience to be as religious or non-religious as desired and still be regarded as propertly pursuing the AA program.

I used the phrase 'Alfie and his ilk' originally. That was imprecise and inaccurate of me, for it obscured a crucial difference between AA apologists that these first two points bring out.

Finally, the original topic of this thread was whether AA is religious in nature and in practice and why so many AA participants deny that it is.
 
Last edited:
I have been researching if the step about making amends is mandatory in AA. This could be difficult for many people, and may block recovery if they can't do it.

It is not mandatory but I would say it is highly recommended if you would like to continue relationships with the folks important in your life. Most amends I made were actually non-verbal, I just conducted myself more responsibly.
There are some amends that are recommended not to be made at all, especially in the case where the person you are making the amends to will be injured.
 
Know what a meta-study is? Hint: arguing against meta-study findings does in no way argue against the findings of the individual studies.

Do you really think that AA members would subject themselves to meta-studies because you and others doubt the validity of AA. I sincerely would not bet on it. I believe they are convinced it is working for them by their own personal triumphs.
Norseman people seem to think here (Jack, Ben, Complexity ect...) that there is just a bunch of uneducated whackaloon robots in AA, that need to be saved from the evil abusive ghost of Bill W and his writings.
AA is filled with all types, on average from my experience they are professional people. Judges, Doctors, White Collar, Blue Collar, Business owners (sm and lg) Factory workers ect.....
We are not ignorant, most of us have gone on to learn more about alcoholism, we share the same opinions of most here both pro and con but want to stay with AA. We have even gone on to receive additional help from professionals as Bill W. himself suggested in the BB.
Just some thoughts.
 
Norseman people seem to think here (Jack, Ben, Complexity ect...) that there is just a bunch of uneducated whackaloon robots in AA, that need to be saved from the evil abusive ghost of Bill W and his writings.
AA is filled with all types, on average from my experience they are professional people. Judges, Doctors, White Collar, Blue Collar, Business owners (sm and lg) Factory workers ect.....
We are not ignorant, most of us have gone on to learn more about alcoholism, we share the same opinions of most here both pro and con but want to stay with AA. We have even gone on to receive additional help from professionals as Bill W. himself suggested in the BB.
Just some thoughts.


I know that there are all types of people in AA, and I think that everyone else does too.

What we have been saying is that simply because someone is an alcoholic and (hopefully) on the road to recovery does not make that person competent to mentor others on how to do the same.
 
I'm pointing out that you are coming across to me as doing so. As always, I could be wrong.

No you are not wrong, I did come across to you (personally) that way. I felt after reading your posts that you had very limited knowledge of AA. I should calm down my comments a bit. I did get a little emotional the last few days.
I appreciate the compliment about my posting style, though. I have learned a great deal from posters here on JREF whom I admire and I try to keep to the maxim, "it's only the internet". I have to remind myself sometimes on a daily basis, but I generally don't take it as personally as I used to.

Ditto!!
Alright, I can see that. It seems that you might have something to contribute to the thread and, in my opinion, you spend a little too much time on those with whom you think have little to no experience rather than focusing on the issues raised.

Good point. Something I will look into.

Maybe I am missing something. Would you care to offer your thoughts on what you see that I may not be?

IDK. Can't put a finger on it right now. I just know that somehow you are missing something.
Then again maybe your not, maybe you just reject everything about AA. :confused:
Ah. Well, the Original Post asks "why do people insist AA is not religious" so that is, in fact, the main point of this thread. It has drifted off topic thither and yon, back and forth, over hill and over dale and I have contributed sometimes greatly to that thread drift. Nonetheless, the topic of religiosity in AA is technically the only points that should be raised. (I am glad that it hasn't been closed due to severe topic drift though.)

No argument from me. I'm guilty.
 
I know that there are all types of people in AA, and I think that everyone else does too.

Well that is nice to hear, I mean this.

What we have been saying is that simply because someone is an alcoholic and (hopefully) on the road to recovery does not make that person competent to mentor others on how to do the same.

This can be true for some but on the whole it has worked just fine for quite some time in AA. I was mentored and it worked well. I have sponsored many men in my time with AA, I don't believe I injured anyone of them.
I am really confused as to why you are even saying this. Was this an experience you had?
 
Let me elaborate upon my statement, then.

Several AA apologists have maintained that AA is not religious in nature or in practice.

Some AA apologists have admitted that AA core materials advocate religious belief and tell people that religious belief is necessary to advance far in their efforts to overcome their addiction to alcohol. These same AA apologists maintain that an AA participant can interpret these deistic religious teachings and expectations any way s/he wishes, that s/he can tailor the AA experience to be as religious or non-religious as desired and still be regarded as propertly pursuing the AA program.

I used the phrase 'Alfie and his ilk' originally. That was imprecise and inaccurate of me, for it obscured a crucial difference between AA apologists that these first two points bring out.

Finally, the original topic of this thread was whether AA is religious in nature and in practice and why so many AA participants deny that it is.

Hey Complexity, do us/me a favor and stop being snarky by calling us/me names. I am not a apologists, loon, criminal, whackjob, stepper or any of the others names you and others have called us. We are AA members or how about this, DannyB II or just Danny.
If you want respect then give it.
OK you don't like AA and you feel it hurts people. That is your opinion or experience, I respect that and will continue from this point on.
 
I was referring to clinical psychology in terms getting treatment for psychotic disorders, not to treat an addiction.
That is what it attempts to do.

After getting alcoholism controlled, clinical psycholgy may well help in the attempt to construct an unharmful lifestyle.

The question was asked as to what are some options besides AA in treating people who wind up dead as a consequence of their AA involvement. The suicide rate in AA is high.
Please link suicide to AA. Alcoholics may well be or become suicidal at rates exceeding the norm; do have actual evidence even for that?

To begin with, AA is not an option. The AA program is not psychology, and an unemployed used car salesman whose only credentials is time in the AA program is not qualified to dish out therapy to someone with a mental disorder.
True, and so what? Where and when have you verified therapy for mental disorders being an AA objective, other than alcoholism which at least some seem to believe is a "mental disorder"?

It doesn't stop it from happening, of course. And when someone offs themselves, the response is inevitably "some must die so that others may live." It's sad.
What's sad is rambling unsubstantiatable pap.

Last week, a friend's brother-in-law killed himself. The memorial service was Tuesday. He was an AA whose sponsor gave him an ultimatum of choosing between him or his spouse. This guy was bi-sexual, and was 13th stepped by the sponsor and put through the emotional ringer. He had depression problems that may not have been caused by AA, but his sponsor made things worse by being abusive of his position, and the AA program was used to treat him. He needed real help, not religious dogma.
Sad story having little or nothing to do with AA. I don't doubt an alcoholic bi-sexual might decide to kill himself, in or out of AA.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom