Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi, Alfie.

I won't quote all that, but I think the people you quoted are good people that want to help us addicts. They should be applauded for this. I enjoy having a healthy debate now and then, but I think we ALL have the best interest of others on our minds. We just approach the problem differently.
 
Yes loathe.

You really don't think people haven't been hurt or killed by the kind of dogma?

Really?

Yes really.
Evidence and/or an explanation as to how exactly AA kills or hurts people"

No one is denying AA helps people. It's just posters like yourself and A.A Alfie Danny seem incapable of understanding have seen no evidence as to how AA can hurt people.

ftfy
Perhaps, as skeptical thinkers we like to see a little thing called EVIDENCE.
 
I doubt this will help you with others here. Why? Because you said 'backround', when we are talking about today. And to many, it's not as obvious as it is to you and I.

OK, I will try to be aware of this.
 
Hi, Alfie.

I won't quote all that, but I think the people you quoted are good people that want to help us addicts. They should be applauded for this. I enjoy having a healthy debate now and then, but I think we ALL have the best interest of others on our minds. We just approach the problem differently.

For the most part I agree, people here are inquisitive and want to know. There are a number however whose single-minded goal is to discredit AA and its members at every turn.

Having been at this for some time it is not difficult to see which is which.

Good posting.
 
OK.
Lets throw this out there, bare with me please. I am not as eloquent a writer as some here.
I few here have said that I am saying something quite differently then others here concerning AA'ers being cognizant (knowing) AA was built on religious ideas.
I have tried to explain my understanding based upon over 2 decades of experince. My explanations have been dismissed and even been called outright lies. Now I believe some of the more drastic comments came because of my previous grating comments.
So I guess we can say we are even. I would like to continue this conversation in a more congenial manner and understand what is the wall here we can't seem to overcome.
I would like to ask some questions, seriously (or at least I am trying to be serious). If anyone else has legitimate questions please get involved.

First....... Why can't AA be spiritual for some, be religious for others and neither for the few?
Second....Why can't someone in AA do the steps they way they want? Who or what determines why they would not work if done this way?
Third.......How do you think the Atheist and Agnostic do their steps? Who or what can say they did them wrong?
Fourth.....Why are we so stead fast on taking everything Bill W. said or wrote so literal?
Fifth........Is AA a suggestive design for living? Some of the comments I have read here would suggest, no, is this true?
 
Last edited:
I understand you, Complexity. Some do have that agenda, but I suppose I just see what they are doing, and it doesn't bother me. Many more are helped than hurt, and AA is just an option, a resource if used correctly.

Thanks, Ketyk, for your thoughtful comments. One thing I'd like to gently point out, though, is that we really don't know if many more are helped than hurt. I think that's the point of many a poster (such as Alfie and myself) here -- we're wanting some hard numbers to help show whether or not people are helped and by how much. This is, of course, not to say there haven't been legitimate studies done; there needs to be more done. Of those studies, not many have shown AA to be superior to other treatment avenues or coping mechanisms.

And as I've pointed out before, AA isn't the only free program out there.
 
That is being actively promulgated by several posters, at least some of whom appear to have little first-hand knowledge of what occurs in closed discussion meetings.

What exactly are your criteria for people to post authoritatively on the subject of AA then?
 
Whoosh.

You missed the point entirely. The point I was making was that a study provided - as claimed by some here - told us that talking to your doctor was the most effective way to treat alcoholism.

Know what a meta-study is? Hint: arguing against meta-study findings does in no way argue against the findings of the individual studies.


Which ones do you recommend and what are their recovery rates?

Since you like to sincerely promote AA as a program of recovery to clients or other parties, what are the recovery rates for AA? If there are no reliable studies done on AA, then how do you really know enough to recommend it to clients?
 
Norseman I have great respect for your style of posting. It is most always considerate and never condescending. But hey my friend you took some liberties here. I don't remember ever ignoring a post from someone active in AA with criticisms.

I'm pointing out that you are coming across to me as doing so. As always, I could be wrong.

I appreciate the compliment about my posting style, though. I have learned a great deal from posters here on JREF whom I admire and I try to keep to the maxim, "it's only the internet". I have to remind myself sometimes on a daily basis, but I generally don't take it as personally as I used to.

I am that person if you really want to know the truth. My pet peeve is having to read peoples posts that are way over the top with their criticism and they really have no experience at all with AA. You can read it in their posts, you know they have limited knowledge. There just fired up because their friend Joe is more or less.

Alright, I can see that. It seems that you might have something to contribute to the thread and, in my opinion, you spend a little too much time on those with whom you think have little to no experience rather than focusing on the issues raised.


I don't think you understand at all where Alfie is coming from, just my opinion.

Maybe I am missing something. Would you care to offer your thoughts on what you see that I may not be?

This may be your point but I don't believe it was everyone's.

Ah. Well, the Original Post asks "why do people insist AA is not religious" so that is, in fact, the main point of this thread. It has drifted off topic thither and yon, back and forth, over hill and over dale and I have contributed sometimes greatly to that thread drift. Nonetheless, the topic of religiosity in AA is technically the only points that should be raised. (I am glad that it hasn't been closed due to severe topic drift though.)
 
I have been researching if the step about making amends is mandatory in AA. This could be difficult for many people, and may block recovery if they can't do it.
 
I have been researching if the step about making amends is mandatory in AA. This could be difficult for many people, and may block recovery if they can't do it.

This is a tricky question. Steppers will be the first to tell you that nothing is mandatory, and everything is "suggested."

but

In practice you'll get blowback in the form of a slogan "are you in AA, or around AA?" (being in AA is like falling into a slogan convention). Or, you could get blowback with a quote from AA scripture: "Half measures availed us nothing. We stood at the turning point. We asked His protection and care with complete abandon.” (Big Book p. 59) Or, you'll get the anecdotal arm twist with a side order of dogma: "I also looked for an easier, softer way; but until I gave over fully to the program, I never attained a spiritual awakening."


As for the amends thing itself, I would suggest anyone who needs an instruction manual for basic human decency, is not really contrite. It comes across as disingenuous, like a teacher pulling one kid by ear to another kid in order to apologize to them. We have had on our blog feedback from recipients of the amends who felt violated that they were sucked back into something they had forgotten, or made peace with. People someone has harmed, who want nothing to do with him/her, shouldn't be pawns in that person's spiritual journey. Opening new wounds in others in order to give yourself absolution is a selfish act.

It also doesn't get a person sober. Like the other steps, it has zero to do with drinking. This is one the original Oxford Group steps. The book Soul Surgery, written by and for OG adherents, describes it as part of the ego deflation, and an exercise in humility. It's a step toward religious conversion, and is supposed to bring one closer to God (or the new-age steppers; their light socket, pet cat, electric can opener, or whatever object to which they turn their will and lives over).
 
I have been researching if the step about making amends is mandatory in AA. This could be difficult for many people, and may block recovery if they can't do it.

What seems difficult about it to you?
Give me an example or two of where you might have a problem and I can give you my take on it.
 
This is a tricky question.....a big snip of silly ....


Very quickly...

What is actually intended is to clear ones mind of past guilt so one no longer needs to drink on them (feelings of guilt). For many alcoholics those past wrongs cause much angst and are a trigger for their drinking. It is a great relief to remove those concerns and have them settled.

Are your observations based on those writings in "real clinical psychology" you mentioned earlier? I am pretty sure you are wrong again here. But I am happy for you to show us otherwise.

It's ok, I can wait. :)
 
Last edited:
I have been researching if the step about making amends is mandatory in AA. This could be difficult for many people, and may block recovery if they can't do it.

Um, no step is mandatory.

In cognitive terms it is about accountability and reducing the guilt that drives stinking thinking.

Making amends should harm neither individual, it can be very powerful for both as well. It can also be very destructive.
 
Are your observations based on those writings in "real clinical psychology" you mentioned earlier? I am pretty sure you are wrong again here. But I am happy for you to show us otherwise.

You asked for examples of other treatments that would prevent people from killing themselves, and I suggested clinical psychology, which encompasses a broad range of treatments. Obviously, it was a rhetorical question, as you don't really care to discuss it. But since you brought it up, I'll compare the two approaches.

The AA program is an amalgamation of of the teachings of the religious cult Oxford Group; and the deluded, belladonna induced vision of a failed stock promoter with no education in psychology. Its counselors can be anyone from garbage men to truck drivers, who have no accountability, who may or may not have psychological problems of their own, whose understanding of the AA program is completely subjective.

Clinical Psychology utilizes the best current understanding of science, by people with advanced degrees who must meet and adhere to a professional code of conduct. It is constantly refining and improving upon itself.
 
Hang on Jack, you said:

"AA has killed people I know. People who were desperate and helpless, and needed to see that their were treatment options other than AA".

I asked what other treatments. And you responded "real clinical psychology" and finally gave me that lovely even handed and objective comparison above. :rolleyes:

Now I want to know what the efficacy of this so called "real clinical psychology" is in treating alcoholics?
Have you some studies or are you making things up like those in the ST forum?
 
This is a tricky question. Steppers will be the first to tell you that nothing is mandatory, and everything is "suggested."

And then having said that, they don't protest the decertification of the two Toronto groups who dropped the word "god" from the AA program for there meetings. Apparently, it's only a suggestion as long as you follow it to the letter.

(being in AA is like falling into a slogan convention).

I don't even belong to AA but every Saturday, after my brother-in-law goes to his meeting, I am treated to the "slogan of the day." Plus, I hear first hand from a longtime member of AA all the immoral crap that goes on in the meetings. Of course, he doesn't see it that way, he thinks it is fine because it has always gone on.

Last week was a rant on "losers" (New people in the group) who think because they have been going for a couple of years they can tell longtimers how things should be done and how a significant amount of time was spent straightening them out. :rolleyes:

A week or two before that it was a complaint about how these "losers" thought they had drinking problems. Apparently, no one has had a "real" drinking problem since the last longtimer joined. Everything is bigger and more important in the mind of an AAer. :rolleyes:

And the slogans!

"One day at a time" - No ****** What did you think, I wanted Saturday and Sunday to be rolled together so the weekend is only half as long?

"Stinking Thinking" - It hasn't gotten any better since you stopped drinking!

Just shoot me now! :D
 
Hang on Jack, you said:

"AA has killed people I know. People who were desperate and helpless, and needed to see that their were treatment options other than AA".

No, I never said that.

I'm not going to give you a dissertation on clinical psychology.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom