Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Danny, would you agree that AA stresses the concept of 'God' more than it needs to?
 
AA injures people and lies about its foundations and practices.
AA does no such thing. Alcoholics injure people. People discuss possible interpretations of its foundations and practices, historical and current.

It should be brought to an end.
You are welcome to your viewpoint; others disagree, and many of them appear to me better informed of positive aspects of AA than you and other denigrators seem to be.
 
I hope no one thinks AA is either trying to hurt people, or trying to convert them.

It is a chance for people to help themselves, which can enpowering. It can also be a bad choice for those that need something different. The 'God' issue is less important to me than the idea that says 'if you want what we have(happy and sober), do what we do'. That is not true.

Again, to stick to the OP, it is religious, and it helps me. I'm Agnostic 80% of the day, Atheist 10%, and awed by the kindness of people the other 10%. Feeling that there must be a Higher Power, unexplainable though that might be.

That looks wishy-washy, and conflicted, but I'm human.
 
Being told you're powerless and are incapable of managing your own life is empowering?
No.

I sank pretty low, actually. Didn't pay my bills. I wasn't there for my family when they needed me, etc...

AA is giving me a chance to turn that around. To see people that have struggled like I am now, and went on to lead happy fulfilling lives. Sometimes that seems so far away to me. It feels good to have people say, 'You can do it.'

It must be one of the many "paradoxes of the program."

Yes, there are many paradoxes in AA.
 
I hope no one thinks AA is either trying to hurt people, or trying to convert them.

AAs aren't trying to hurt people. Most honestly believe the dogma, and believe it helps people. A lot like Scientologists aren't trying to hurt people, and believe that nonsense.

But they definitely try and convert them. The 'Big Book' provides an instruction manual on it, and is a conversion tool in itself. The whole 12th step is about conversion. The drunkalog is essentially a conversion narrative. Techniques used to manipulate people into doing the steps, encouragement of suspension of critical thinking, is all about conversion.
 
I hope no one thinks AA is either trying to hurt people, or trying to convert them.


I never said that AA or people in it are trying to hurt people, but there is no doubt that many are being injured by their participation in AA.

I suspect that the founders of AA constructed it so that it would further their goals, one of which was christian proselytization.

Whether or not this is true, there is no doubt that many people in AA take advantage of their AA interactions with people to push their religious beliefs on others.
 
AAs aren't trying to hurt people. Most honestly believe the dogma, and believe it helps people. A lot like Scientologists aren't trying to hurt people, and believe that nonsense.

I'd agree for the most part, but 'nonsense' is a bit harsh. If it help me, it makes sense.
But they definitely try and convert them. The 'Big Book' provides an instruction manual on it, and is a conversion tool in itself. The whole 12th step is about conversion. The drunkalog is essentially a conversion narrative. Techniques used to manipulate people into doing the steps, encouragement of suspension of critical thinking, is all about conversion.
Again I agree with most said above. However, a Drunkalog is actually someone recounting all the horrible things they have done to the point that the listener says, 'OK, I get the point' Can we move on?'.

Regarding Conversion, that is true, but it's not conversion from one religion to another, at least not for me. Rather it is a Conversion from being irrsponsible to responsible, sad to happy, dishonest to honest. I would never try to change someones religion, or lack thereof.

You make valid points.
 
Complexity said:
AA injures people and lies about its foundations and practices.

AA does no such thing. Alcoholics injure people. People discuss possible interpretations of its foundations and practices, historical and current.

Rubbish telling people they have a incurable disease and that they have to hit "rock bottom" before they can attempt to find the cure is quiet literally the worst thing you can tell a addict at a certain junction of their addiction.

You are welcome to your viewpoint; others disagree, and many of them appear to me better informed of positive aspects of AA than you and other denigrators seem to be.
There are plenty of positives about AA. It helps alot of people getting better. It does not help people when AA tells people that those who fail at AA's path are doomed and have less than average chances at survival? That they are botched and damaged?

Perhaps if AA said "Y'know those who don't like AA, then there are other chances and alternatives" rather than saying "fail at AA and then you're mostly likely going to die?" Perhaps THEN and only THEN will I have a modicum of respect for AA.

AA tell people, people who are vulnerable and desperate, that alcoholics who don't like or don't accept AA, that they're most likely going to die. It's reprehensible disgusting and beneath contempt. And why I loathe AA.
 
Last edited:
I never said that AA or people in it are trying to hurt people, but there is no doubt that many are being injured by their participation in AA.

I suspect that the founders of AA constructed it so that it would further their goals, one of which was christian proselytization.

Whether or not this is true, there is no doubt that many people in AA take advantage of their AA interactions with people to push their religious beliefs on others.
I understand you, Complexity. Some do have that agenda, but I suppose I just see what they are doing, and it doesn't bother me. Many more are helped than hurt, and AA is just an option, a resource if used correctly.
 
Last edited:
I hope no one thinks AA is either trying to hurt people, or trying to convert them.
That is being actively promulgated by several posters, at least some of whom appear to have little first-hand knowledge of what occurs in closed discussion meetings.

It is grating to us recovering alcoholics who feel we owe AA a major debt of gratitude.
 
Rubbish telling people they have a incurable disease and that they have to hit "rock bottom" before they can attempt to find the cure is quiet literally the worst thing you can tell a addict at a certain junction of their addiction.

There are plenty of positives about AA. It helps alot of people getting better. It does not help people when AA tells people that those who fail at AA's path are doomed and have less than average chances at survival? That they are botched and damaged?

Perhaps if AA said "Y'know those who don't like AA, then there are other chances and alternatives" rather than saying "fail at AA and then you're mostly likely going to die?" Perhaps THEN and only THEN will I have a modicum of respect for AA.

AA tell people, people who are vulnerable and desperate, that alcoholics who don't like or don't accept AA, that they're most likely going to die. It's reprehensible disgusting and beneath contempt. And why I loathe AA.
Wow! Loathe? I don't agree with this aspect either, but Loathe? Actually I understand that some people dislike how they do things.

The problem is that AA is to rigid and religious. Too pius and judgemental. I know. But I know alternatives. Maybe someday they will change, but I doubt it. They don't want to change, because they were helped this way, and want to give back.
 
That is being actively promulgated by several posters, at least some of whom appear to have little first-hand knowledge of what occurs in closed discussion meetings.

It is grating to us recovering alcoholics who feel we owe AA a major debt of gratitude.

I know. Religion has a way of dividing people. I prefer Unity.
 
Wow! Loathe? I don't agree with this aspect either, but Loathe? Actually I understand that some people dislike how they do things.

Yes loathe.

You really don't think people haven't been hurt or killed by the kind of dogma?

Really?

I have. Hence loathe. And despise.
 
That is being actively promulgated by several posters, at least some of whom appear to have little first-hand knowledge of what occurs in closed discussion meetings.

Why don't you name the posters who you don't think have this information?

It is grating to us recovering alcoholics who feel we owe AA a major debt of gratitude.

No one is denying AA helps people. It's just posters like yourself and A.A Alfie Danny seem incapable of understanding how AA can hurt people.

In fact Danny seems to flat our contradict your understanding of AA, and yet you don't seem bothered to challenge him at all. Why is that?
 
Danny, would you agree that AA stresses the concept of 'God' more than it needs to?

Yes I would. As I have been saying all along AA came from a religious background. This is an obvious assumption.
How people practice the principles is their own business and AA made an allowances for it.
 
8den, I'm sorry to here that. But I do understand. Again, I'm very sorry.

I'll try to talk to Danny. I posed a question to him earlier today ( I just started here today).
 
Oh Alfie Alfie Alfie you yourself said a few pages ago that there lacked scientific consensus as to what exactly is a Alcoholic. Now you want efficacy figures for these programs when dealing with alcoholics?

Now suddenly you've changed your tune to "ah but how many "other" groups can cure chronic alcoholics"? The alkies AA cures them.

Whoosh.

You missed the point entirely. The point I was making was that a study provided - as claimed by some here - told us that talking to your doctor was the most effective way to treat alcoholism.

Of course, since the only true alcoholics are in AA it follows that only AA can cure true alcoholics.

Whoosh here too.

Real clinical psychology is a good place to start.

Show us then.

But they definitely try and convert them. The 'Big Book' provides an instruction manual on it, and is a conversion tool in itself. The whole 12th step is about conversion. The drunkalog is essentially a conversion narrative. Techniques used to manipulate people into doing the steps, encouragement of suspension of critical thinking, is all about conversion.

Er... when did this become a CT thread?

I never said that AA or people in it are trying to hurt people, but there is no doubt that many are being injured by their participation in AA.

How are they "injured" exactly?

Whether or not this is true, there is no doubt that many people in AA take advantage of their AA interactions with people to push their religious beliefs on others.

Sounds scary.
Most try and help a suffering alcoholic.

Rubbish telling people they have a incurable disease and that they have to hit "rock bottom" before they can attempt to find the cure is quiet literally the worst thing you can tell a addict at a certain junction of their addiction.

But this is actually true to a very large extent. One will not make a change in life until there is sufficient motivation to do so. This motivation might be described by the addict as the pain of rock bottom. Sometimes it is easy to see, sometimes not so much.

eg. I put on about four kilograms recently and my pants got tight. That was enough for me to make a change. My motivation was based on vanity, health and the fact that I didn't want to buy new pants. What of the person who hits middle age and says "stuff it" and puts on 20kg before they make the decision to make a change? Their motivation is different. Why? Who the hell knows, it just is.

Finding the rock bottom you speak of is a very good thing indeed. In the stages of change (you might want to check that out) it equates to the 'decision' stage and a decision can only be made when there is sufficient motivation.

What you scoff at it a very basic psychological model that is taught day #1. For someone who imagines they know a lot, you really don't.

Perhaps if AA said "Y'know those who don't like AA, then there are other chances and alternatives" rather than saying "fail at AA and then you're mostly likely going to die?" Perhaps THEN and only THEN will I have a modicum of respect for AA.

Which ones do you recommend and what are their recovery rates?

AA tell people, people who are vulnerable and desperate, that alcoholics who don't like or don't accept AA, that they're most likely going to die.

So are you saying that alcohol doesn't kill alcoholics?
 

Yes I would. As I have been saying all along AA came from a religious background. This is an obvious assumption.
How people practice the principles is their own business and AA made an allowances for it.

I doubt this will help you with others here. Why? Because you said 'backround', when we are talking about today. And to many, it's not as obvious as it is to you and I.
 
Last edited:
The point in reality is that DannyB is continually stating that any criticisms of AA are unfounded based on the idea that he has that the person making the criticisms isn't active in AA, so therefore isn't in a position to make criticisms. (He then seems to ignore those who are very active in AA, yet also have legitimate criticisms of AA.)


Norseman I have great respect for your style of posting. It is most always considerate and never condescending. But hey my friend you took some liberties here. I don't remember ever ignoring a post from someone active in AA with criticisms. I am that person if you really want to know the truth. My pet peeve is having to read peoples posts that are way over the top with their criticism and they really have no experience at all with AA. You can read it in their posts, you know they have limited knowledge. There just fired up because their friend Joe is more or less.


And as another poster pointed out (I'm sorry, I don't recall who at the moment), there is no interaction at all between DannyB and AA Alfie, for example; they are both staunch AA supporters, yet DannyB claims AA is religious and Alfie says the opposite.

I don't think you understand at all where Alfie is coming from, just my opinion.

Which is exactly the point of this entire year-long thread.

This may be your point but I don't believe it was everyone's.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom