Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Alfie has constantly made this claim. His claim is that if you were cured by any other means besides AA, you were not a true alcoholic.

I seem to recall you and several others making the same claim at the beginning of this thread as well.
And of course the "not an alcoholic" observation is always made in hindsight. True science in action...

On another forum, after I said I have remained abstinent for many years after stopping attendance at AA meetings, I was told I'm "not a real alcoholic." Okay, whatever. No one in all the meetings I went to ever said I wasn't a "real alcoholic" or "true alcoholic" but this guy who knows me only from a few forum posts knows better...

AA members make other absolute claims with little or no observation as well. I never heard of a suicide in AA that wasn't attributed to "the disease of alcoholism."
 
And of course the "not an alcoholic" observation is always made in hindsight. True science in action...

Yeah. The "no true Scotsman" fallacy they love to toss out there.

If you quit on your own, you weren't a real alcoholic.

If went back on the wagon while you're in, you weren't a real alcoholic. Or, you didn't properly work the program, which contradicts the take-what-you-want-and-leave-the-rest crowd.

It gets even more tricky for those who've been declared real alcoholics, but then leave the program and stay quit. This is when AA's dicey definition of sobriety kicks in, and that person is declared a "dry drunk."
 
8den,
Your missing their point, they know AA is religious as far as where AA originated from and the founder Bill W. motivations. No one is arguing this.


Not true, I'm afraid. Several AA apologists are claiming in this thread that AA is not religious. I've heard that from several others, as well.

But as you can see the first 100 had a problem with the Book being to religious, hence chapter 4 "We Agnostics". Regardless how we feel about how disingenuous this chapter is, it was the best a few could do at the time to appease the Atheist and Agnostic.


If they were concerned with 'appeasing' atheists and agnostics, they could simply have made their program truly free from religion, spirituality, and other superstitions. What they did in that horrid chapter was insult our intelligence, not appease us. Shame on them and shame on you for being an apologist for them, the lousy bastards.

The rest of the fence sitters said well I will just consider this a spiritual experience. If you hadn't notice more people today are rejecting organized religion, they abhor what is going on within the different religions. So they seek out their own interpretation of a higher power. Science or God, it is all spiritual to me.


There is no way of interpreting the original twelve steps in a way that is not deistically religious, in spite of what is claimed by apologists. And even if it were merely 'spiritual', that is unabashedly superstition in its own right.

The way to help people is not to tell them to turn off or corrupt their minds, to lie to themselves and others about what they believe. Shame!

It doesn't make a bit a difference to me or the hundred of thousands others if you want to see AA as religious or not because we don't work our steps in a religious manner.


This is an outright lie, for many AA members do work their steps 'in a religious manner'. Proselytization is part of the game and one of the main reasons, I suspect, why AA was started up in the first place.

Yes it can and does work exactly that way for many of us. This is why people say it is spiritual not religious.


Once again, AA is religious - you have said so several times yourself - and to say otherwise is lying.

BTW!! Who heck are you to judge the way another person wants to live their life. If they tell you it is spiritual for them leave it at that. Jeesh!!!


I will always challenge someone who is lying to themselves or others, especially if those lies can lead to greater harm. What AA and its apologists are doing to alcoholics who need treatment is outrageous and shameful.
 
Last edited:
Hi, folks.

I've read bits and pieces of this thread, and thought a different point of view might be of interest to some.

I consider myself an alcoholic. I've made many bad decisions in my life while under the influence. I function much better when sober, so I try and try to stay sober. AA helps me.

I was raised Catholic, and enjoyed that part of my life. I liked being part of a group that said 'If you are feeling down, maybe we can help', and "if you are happy, that's great!".

I shy away from the whole 'God" thing now, because it does not matter to me. If there is a "god'/'God', then fine. If there isn't, that's fine too. I don't dwell on it, or worry about anyone elses belief.

Unless that belief is causing harm, which is what, I think, is the topic in dispute is here. If AA helps me then I would think others would happy. If AA causes a person harm, I will try to help them. I see no agenda or recruitment, only people trying to help people. And for free, which all some people can afford. I agree that it looks like a cult, with repetition of dogma, and threats or eternal damnation, but I simply find this as an archaic and overly pius attempt to help, and almost find amusing were it not such a serious problem for others.

Thanks everyone for the discussion, and trying to remain civil. To tell the truth, I like the Humor section more than the serious stuff, but I need to test the water once in a while.
 
And of course the "not an alcoholic" observation is always made in hindsight. True science in action...

On another forum, after I said I have remained abstinent for many years after stopping attendance at AA meetings, I was told I'm "not a real alcoholic." Okay, whatever. No one in all the meetings I went to ever said I wasn't a "real alcoholic" or "true alcoholic" but this guy who knows me only from a few forum posts knows better...

AA members make other absolute claims with little or no observation as well. I never heard of a suicide in AA that wasn't attributed to "the disease of alcoholism."

Ben, people are references your posts, they read like a person who vaguely went to meeting, and if you did, you were not involved.
Jeesh Ben, I can say I went to meeting also, maybe for 3 years but what does that really mean, nothing!!
I know people who have been going to meetings for well over a decade and she has never touch a drop of Alcohol. She just likes the camaraderie and the healthy conversation that goes on. Remember you only have to have a desire to not drink.
 
Yeah. The "no true Scotsman" fallacy they love to toss out there.

If you quit on your own, you weren't a real alcoholic.

If went back on the wagon while you're in, you weren't a real alcoholic. Or, you didn't properly work the program, which contradicts the take-what-you-want-and-leave-the-rest crowd.

It gets even more tricky for those who've been declared real alcoholics, but then leave the program and stay quit. This is when AA's dicey definition of sobriety kicks in, and that person is declared a "dry drunk."

Jack, what I will only communicate with anybody other then Danny...lol.
My Masters of Harvard, your repetitive nonsense that comes from the parking lots of AA meetings is hilarious. Jack this isn't AA though, it is your idea of AA, what you would like to see AA reduced to but it isn't real, Jackie.
Your story was memorial but even your own testimony doesn't validate any time spent in AA, being a member and engaging in the steps.
This is why your opinions IMO are hollow at best. You are more of a bigot when it comes to AA then someone with a real protestation.
 
Jack, what I will only communicate with anybody other then Danny...lol.
My Masters of Harvard, your repetitive nonsense that comes from the parking lots of AA meetings is hilarious. Jack this isn't AA though, it is your idea of AA, what you would like to see AA reduced to but it isn't real, Jackie.
Your story was memorial but even your own testimony doesn't validate any time spent in AA, being a member and engaging in the steps.
This is why your opinions IMO are hollow at best. You are more of a bigot when it comes to AA then someone with a real protestation.


Many of your posts, including this one, are fairly incoherent. What sense I can make of it appears to be personal attacks that are unjustified and without merit. You are not persuasive. Your posts serve only to lend support to the people you are attacking and further weaken your AA cause.

Carry on.
 
Danny, I had hoped that people would be a bit more polite with one another.
 
Not true, I'm afraid. Several AA apologists are claiming in this thread that AA is not religious. I've heard that from several others, as well.

I am sorry you just can not grasp what it is I am explaining to you.

If they were concerned with 'appeasing' atheists and agnostics, they could simply have made their program truly free from religion, spirituality, and other superstitions. What they did in that horrid chapter was insult our intelligence, not appease us. Shame on them and shame on you for being an apologist for them, the lousy bastards.

This is how you would like to see it. Thank god most of the rational world does not. Keep trying you'll get it eventually.

There is no way of interpreting the original twelve steps in a way that is not deistically religious, in spite of what is claimed by apologists. And even if it were merely 'spiritual', that is unabashedly supperstition in its own right.

Oh but there is, I did it. Thanks for accepting my truth. :)


The way to help people is not to tell them to turn off or corrupt their minds, to lie to themselves and others about what they believe. Shame!

Once again this is only happening in your mind. I would suggest you stop with the conspiracy theories or the "madhatters" will come. ;)

This is an outright lie, for many AA members do work their steps 'in a religious manner'. Proselytize is part of the game and one of the main reasons, I suspect, why AA was started up in the first place.

Please do explain how I have lied. I stated many times there are people in AA that love the religious aspect, my old sponsor did. He was a Christian.

Once again, AA is religious - you have said so several times yourself - and to say otherwise is lying.

I can't agree more.


I will always challenge someone who is lying to themselves or others, especially if those lies can lead to greater harm. What AA and its apologists are doing to alcoholics who need treatment is outrageous and shameful.

Well I can only hope for your sake that your careful running around proselytizing to everyone. People don't take kindly to folks getting into there personal beliefs. Especially when you have not any idea of what your talking about. :confused:
 
Danny, I had hoped that people would be a bit more polite with one another.

I am being very polite, why don't you worry about your friend Complexity calling me a liar and Jack calling everyone that goes to AA a bunch of crimanals and loons.
Please read my posts they have been very pleasant as opposed to others. :)
 
Many of your posts, including this one, are fairly incoherent. What sense I can make of it appears to be personal attacks that are unjustified and without merit. You are not persuasive. Your posts serve only to lend support to the people you are attacking and further weaken your AA cause.

Carry on.


Complexity, maybe they read incoherently to you because you don't know what I am referencing or talking about.
As far as attacking, please take a step back and read your own posts. I have not attacked anyone, my posts have been pleasant with some ribbing.
So please go about your business.
 
Yeah, OK. Complexity, Danny is going to try harder, I hope you will as well.
 
Talking about a complex subject like this can bring out passionate opinions, I know.

Here is a thought. Maybe you are both right? Or better yet, neither of you is wrong.

.
 
People who think AA is trying to help 'problem drinkers' to become 'social drinkers' are wrong, and imo most AA attendees shouldn't be there in the first place since they are in that category.

I don't think anyone here thinks or has suggested that.

Quite the strawman.
 
I had read the OP, and re-read to stay on topic.

It is my opinion that AA is a Christian organization, and when it says it is not, it is being disingenuous. Having said that, I don't think AA tries to convert anyones religious beliefs. Some people do convert from to Agnostic or Atheistic to Christianity, and vice versa. That's free will.

Some might say it should change its approach, and say it is Christian, but I think it was and is just trying to be open to anyone that needs help.
 
Talking about a complex subject like this can bring out passionate opinions, I know.

Here is a thought. Maybe you are both right? Or better yet, neither of you is wrong.


The point in reality is that DannyB is continually stating that any criticisms of AA are unfounded based on the idea that he has that the person making the criticisms isn't active in AA, so therefore isn't in a position to make criticisms. He then seems to ignore those who are very active in AA, yet also have legitimate criticisms of AA.

And as another poster pointed out (I'm sorry, I don't recall who at the moment), there is no interaction at all between DannyB and AA Alfie, for example; they are both staunch AA supporters, yet DannyB claims AA is religious and Alfie says the opposite.

Which is exactly the point of this entire year-long thread.
 
Yeah, OK. Complexity, Danny is going to try harder, I hope you will as well.


Sorry, Ketyk, but Danny's way is not good for people, and I will oppose him and AA. I know you'd like a conflict-free outcome, but you're not going to get it - to allow his claims and advocacy to go unchallenged would be unjust.
 
Talking about a complex subject like this can bring out passionate opinions, I know.

Here is a thought. Maybe you are both right? Or better yet, neither of you is wrong.

.


Once again, I'm sorry, Ketyk, but what you say is not true. What Danny and I assert is contradictory. Both of us may be wrong, but it is not true that both of us may be right.

AA injures people and lies about its foundations and practices. It should be brought to an end.
 
Thank you Complexity and Norseman.

I have been in AA on and off for years, and see the problem it has regarding its position on religion. It really is too bad, because it I think it helps more people than it hurts.

I'll try to get him to respond to me, we seem to be getting along.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom