benbradley
Scholar
- Joined
- Jun 20, 2011
- Messages
- 71
And of course the "not an alcoholic" observation is always made in hindsight. True science in action...Alfie has constantly made this claim. His claim is that if you were cured by any other means besides AA, you were not a true alcoholic.
I seem to recall you and several others making the same claim at the beginning of this thread as well.
On another forum, after I said I have remained abstinent for many years after stopping attendance at AA meetings, I was told I'm "not a real alcoholic." Okay, whatever. No one in all the meetings I went to ever said I wasn't a "real alcoholic" or "true alcoholic" but this guy who knows me only from a few forum posts knows better...
AA members make other absolute claims with little or no observation as well. I never heard of a suicide in AA that wasn't attributed to "the disease of alcoholism."