Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I understand that you have really no understanding of the inner working of AA. You are not a alcoholic first and second you have never even tried to integrate the steps into your life and last you have never felt the desperation to change your life as only a alcoholic could.

"Doctor, I don't think I can trust you to cure my liver cancer. I mean, have YOU ever had liver cancer ?? No ? I rest my case."
 
"Doctor, I don't think I can trust you to cure my liver cancer. I mean, have YOU ever had liver cancer ?? No ? I rest my case."


Since I, you, and others have made the same point many times over the past year in this thread, I think it fair to say that his statement shows a lack of reading efforts.
 
The hyperbole your reading and being consumed by is your own. Good luck.

me said:
If AA were honest and say "our path is religion" many people would happily walk away and think "not for me" and find another.

DannyB said:
No you are wrong. You can say this because you really have no idea what you are talking about. Every one gets it has religion built into it...lol. You are so foolish trying to argue with us.
Everyone knows AA is religious...Everyone!!!!

No Danny. No thats simply not true. Other AA members on this forum have been arguing and are arguing the exact opposite.

And I do know what I'm talking about, AA members are constantly saying it's not religious


You are being very irrational and a bit dramatic in the effort to make your point. The emotional and mental situations you discussed above need to be respected and not bandied about to make a "sick point". You should be ashamed of yourself, seriously.

I'm not being irrational or overly dramatic. Most often when people enter AA they're at their most vulnerable and painful moments of their lives. If AA were honest and said "This is a religious path and may not be for you" instead of saying;

Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those too who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.

AA tells these people "if you can't manage our simple program (Not Religious Path, Not Spiritual Journal, but Program, which suggests it's not religious but some kind of psychological training program). Well then you're a "unfortunate", someone worthy only of pity, one of the botched and the bungled, suffering from grave emotional and mental disorders, with less than average chances.

This is said IN EVERY MEETING

And every meeting you're told to keep coming back.

So you go to this "program" which is religious but doesn't say it's religious, and you do your 90 in 90, and at the end of every meeting you're reminded that hey if this simple program's fault ain't working it's not the program's fault it's you, you're broken.

Now you're desperate and frustrated and scared, and when you're a problem drinker your drinking is getting worse.

me said:
AA has killed people I know. People who were desperate and helpless, and needed to see that their were treatment options other than AA.



Now you are just being ridiculous and the conversation is over for me. Ya know if you are having a hard time making your point the overly dramatic doesn't work either.

I'm not being overly dramatic, people in that situation with AA can, and have been driven to suicide, because AA doesn't work for them, and AA tells them "Hey AA works for everyone, and if it doesn't work for you, that's your fault not AA's"

The worst part is, and this is the worst part, when someone like that dies you'll always get someone standing up in a meeting and saying;

"See his problem was he didn't work the program properly"
 
Twice now you have said:

"AA has killed people I know. People who were desperate and helpless, and needed to see that their were treatment options other than AA".

What other treatments?
 
Twice now you have said:

"AA has killed people I know. People who were desperate and helpless, and needed to see that their were treatment options other than AA".



What other treatments?
I'm sorry, which one of us is the addiction councillor? And you're asking me to tell you about alternatives to AA?

Jesus man, talkabout a bartender who can only make Gin and Tonics.

Lifering, SMART, Rational Recovery, Moderate Management. My way out. And of course the always effective "Just Stop Drinking".

The problem with AA is AA are very insistent that they are the only way, and don't say "Hey this is our path to recovery, but please try another" Again every meeting has this little spiel

Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those too who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.
It's not "rarly have we seen a person fail our path, walk away try a different path and turn out okay", it's "fail at AA, and you're a "unfortunate" with "less than average chances" and you could indeed have "grave emotional and mental disorders"
Complexity said:
A.A. Alfie - Your posts aren't responsive.

A.A.Alfie said:
Sure they are.
I think what Complexity means old bean is that you challenge something someone says, they response, and you ignore that response, and move on to something else.

And that pithy little glib response shows just how disingenuous you are.



For example, you don't seem interested in discussing this with Danny B II, you're both in AA, and you both seem to have completely different views about the role religion plays in AA, and you don't seem interested in discussing this with each other. Instead you seem to take different tacts on people who have issues with AA.

It's very odd.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, which one of us is the addiction councillor? And you're asking me to tell you about alternatives to AA?

Lifering, SMART, Rational Recovery, Moderate Management. My way out. And of course the always effective "Just Stop Drinking".

Very good - step #1 achieved.

Now what sort of efficacy do these programs achieve for alcoholics?

Alcoholics remember, not people that are just drinking a bit too much but died-in-the-wool alcohol dependent alkies?
 
Alcoholics remember, not people that are just drinking a bit too much but died-in-the-wool alcohol dependent alkies?

Can you provide evidence, other than your say so, that you were/are an alcoholic . . . or that anyone else in AA is?

So far your only support for AA consists of logical fallacies.

It's really getting pathetic, Alfonso. :rolleyes:
 
Very good - step #1 achieved.

Now what sort of efficacy do these programs achieve for alcoholics?

Alcoholics remember, not people that are just drinking a bit too much but died-in-the-wool alcohol dependent alkies?

Oh Alfie Alfie Alfie you yourself said a few pages ago that there lacked scientific consensus as to what exactly is a Alcoholic. Now you want efficacy figures for these programs when dealing with alcoholics?

Now suddenly you've changed your tune to "ah but how many "other" groups can cure chronic alcoholics"? The alkies AA cures them.

What's a alcohol dependent alkie Alfie? Do people need to be in gutter for AA to help them? What's your next goalpost shift going to be?

It's just really worrying to watch a man who claims to have a career in therapy and counselling people with addiction problems engaging in this kind of debate, on this subject matter.
 
Last edited:
Very good - step #1 achieved.

Now what sort of efficacy do these programs achieve for alcoholics?

Alcoholics remember, not people that are just drinking a bit too much but died-in-the-wool alcohol dependent alkies?

Of course, since the only true alcoholics are in AA it follows that only AA can cure true alcoholics.
 
Since I, you, and others have made the same point many times over the past year in this thread, I think it fair to say that his statement shows a lack of reading efforts.

He's just following the standard AA Defender Ad Hominem Flow Chart:

1. Have you ever had a drinking problem?
NO: Then you aren't qualified to have an opinion on this subject. LALALA I can't hear you!
YES: Proceed to 2.

2. Do you still drink?
YES: Then you aren't qualified to have an opinion on this subject. LALALA I can't hear you!
NO: Proceed to 3.

3. Did AA help you stop drinking?
YES: Then you shouldn't criticize AA, or else you're a hypocrite! LALALA I can't hear you!
NO: Proceed to 4

4. Are you sure you've stopped drinking? (Bonus points for adding passive-aggressive insinuations to the contrary)
NO: I thought so! LALALA I can't hear you!
YES: Your choice of: (a) You weren't really an alcoholic, then. LALALA I can't hear you! (b) You sound like you have some resentments. Maybe you're a dry drunk. LALALA I can't hear you!
 
Of course, since the only true alcoholics are in AA it follows that only AA can cure true alcoholics.
No one here has made that claim, but in my personal experience AA does manage to help 'hopeless cases'.

People who think AA is trying to help 'problem drinkers' to become 'social drinkers' are wrong, and imo most AA attendees shouldn't be there in the first place since they are in that category.
 
Last edited:
"AA has killed people I know. People who were desperate and helpless, and needed to see that their were treatment options other than AA".

What other treatments?

Real clinical psychology is a good place to start.

AA utilizes people I wouldn't trust to mow my lawn as sponsors who convince their sponsees not to trust their own thinking and judgment (cuz your best thinking got you here, ya know), and then applies whatever pop psychology their minds can dream up. The steps are a catch-all solution, prescribed for people with serious psychological problems. These problems are exacerbated by the attitude among a high percentage of steppers that someone taking prescription medication is not "really sober." Discouragement of people taking prescription medication is common, to the degree that it is one of the few things that the GSO actually addressed through a pamphlet, which the true believers in the spiritual awakening largely ignore.

Add to this the cult-like components, such as gaslighting and milieu control, and you've got yourself a destructive environment for someone who needs real psychological help.
 
Originally Posted by DannyB II
The hyperbole your reading and being consumed by is your own. Good luck.
Originally Posted by me
If AA were honest and say "our path is religion" many people would happily walk away and think "not for me" and find another.
Originally Posted by DannyB

No you are wrong. You can say this because you really have no idea what you are talking about. Every one gets it has religion built into it...lol. You are so foolish trying to argue with us.
Everyone knows AA is religious...Everyone!!!!

8den sez:
No Danny. No thats simply not true. Other AA members on this forum have been arguing and are arguing the exact opposite.

And I do know what I'm talking about, AA members are constantly saying it's not religious


8den,
Your missing their point, they know AA is religious as far as where AA originated from and the founder Bill W. motivations. No one is arguing this. But as you can see the first 100 had a problem with the Book being to religious, hence chapter 4 "We Agnostics". Regardless how we feel about how disingenuous this chapter is, it was the best a few could do at the time to appease the Atheist and Agnostic. The rest of the fence sitters said well I will just consider this a spiritual experience. If you hadn't notice more people today are rejecting organized religion, they abhor what is going on within the different religions. So they seek out their own interpretation of a higher power. Science or God, it is all spiritual to me.
It doesn't make a bit a difference to me or the hundred of thousands others if you want to see AA as religious or not because we don't work our steps in a religious manner.
Yes it can and does work exactly that way for many of us. This is why people say it is spiritual not religious. BTW!! Who heck are you to judge the way another person wants to live their life. If they tell you it is spiritual for them leave it at that. Jeesh!!!
 
Real clinical psychology is a good place to start.

AA utilizes people I wouldn't trust to mow my lawn as sponsors who convince their sponsees not to trust their own thinking and judgment (cuz your best thinking got you here, ya know), and then applies whatever pop psychology their minds can dream up. The steps are a catch-all solution, prescribed for people with serious psychological problems. These problems are exacerbated by the attitude among a high percentage of steppers that someone taking prescription medication is not "really sober." Discouragement of people taking prescription medication is common, to the degree that it is one of the few things that the GSO actually addressed through a pamphlet, which the true believers in the spiritual awakening largely ignore.

Add to this the cult-like components, such as gaslighting and milieu control, and you've got yourself a destructive environment for someone who needs real psychological help.

Jack, regurgitating this same nonsense that you say on every site and blog does not make it any more "true".
The responsibility of taking prescription drugs is between the Doctor and the patient. This person can and will go back to their doctor and explain their addictions and what can be done. AA or sponsors on the whole has nothing to say about these matters. The same applies to people who need advanced help emotionally and mentally, they are encouraged to seek this help.
Just because one or two people came on your blog and spouted off about how one crazy loon who was at a meeting was saying people should not take prescription drugs. This doesn't mean all sponsors or members are saying this.
OH, I am sorry if you thought this one crazy loon was speaking for AA. Just like I don't think when you speak you are speaking for your blog. ;)
 
No one here has made that claim, but in my personal experience AA does manage to help 'hopeless cases'.

Alfie has constantly made this claim. His claim is that if you were cured by any other means besides AA, you were not a true alcoholic.

I seem to recall you and several others making the same claim at the beginning of this thread as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom