Jack Astor
Scholar
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Earth
Posts: 58
Originally Posted by Tinyal
It'll probably be a lifetime of work for me , at my age - I hold no hope for massive change in my lifetime. But change is slowly happening (keep an eye out for a new phamplet addressing atheists & agnostics that I had a very small part in producing - unlike the insulting & stupid chapter 'we agnostics', at least the pamphlet is based on reality. AA has been losing members for a while now, staying somewhere around 1.8-2.2 million members for nearly a decade. Numbers that steady reflect people leaving at a much higher rate than before
.
People are going to AA less because of the efforts over 70 years of AA getting the message out. There are so many more options today then there have ever been, thanks to AA,NA,CA and AlaTeen and Alanon.
We also thank you Anti-AA's for your support in bringing on more options. AA has always said they were not the only solution.
Tinyal, you are one of the hundreds of thousands who are working on the nonsense that has been going on in AA. As far as your opinion on the Chapter "We Agnostics" your not changing anything their, so please stop BS'ing the forum here. These pamphlets your talking about for atheists and agnostics have been around for years (maybe not the version your talking about now) but a version has been around for the 25 years I have been here.
Originally posted by Jack Astor
Here is a good analysis of AA membership: God is Apparently Needing AA Less, Thank Gawd
Tinyal, I'm glad someone within AA is doing this, although I see it as a losing battle. I know of a group that has started to create awareness of the abuses which are rampant within AA, for which others are told to "keep their side of the street clean" and not to check another person's inventory. Naturally, most AAs pretend it isn't a problem. No doubt we'll get the standard, "I've never seen this happen" from our resident steppers.
NO what you might get is, "practice what you preach". One look at your blog "Stinkin Thinkin" would let anyone know you are completely insane and have gone way off the ranch with your message. You purposely pick out people to harass on your blog, this is abuse Jack.
What your talking about (abuses in AA) is rapes, bullying, intimidation ect...that happens outside of AA but because they are both in AA you feel that you can blame it on AA/GSO. This doesn't make any sense at all unless you are Jack.
You pull stories of people from God knows where, that were either sent to AA by the courts or went to AA on their own committed a crime of abuse with another person from AA, then blame this on AA for not protecting this person.
It is hard for AA to protect its members once they leave the premises of a AA meeting.
If people knew of the high number of felons placed in positions of trust, they would be shocked. This shouldn't come as a surprise, considering AA bottom-feeds for recruits in prisons and court systems. Not just for impaired driving cases, but rape, pedophilia, larceny and other fun things. AA attendance is a get-out-of-jail-free card. What better place to find the future sponsors and mentors for broken and vulnerable people? It just. Makes. Sense.
No!! They would not be at all surprised Jack because everyone knows already. These felons are Harvard Grads w/ a Masters, Stock Brokers, Judges, Lawyers, Doctors, CEO's, CFO's, Managers, Husbands, Wifes, Mothers, Fathers, Sons and Daughters. We are all felons that have made it (I don't mean all AA members are felons). We are back out in life doing well. I personally had at one time 6 felonies, all pardoned. I own a mid-sized business. I have a friend in Atlanta who is a Judge he at one time was sitting in jail with a felony. Jeesh these stories go on and on. The pilot that was pulled from the plane he was flying smacked with a felony. Came out of jail, paid his fines and waited his time till he got reinstated by the airlines he worked for, this was not a guarantee. His story is in the 4th edition Big Book.
AA bottom feeds, WOW!!! I am so happy you are showing your true colors here Jack, this is what your blog is all about is this malicious, rabid ripping apart people who have fallen on hard times.
Yes Jack the Judicial System does send their rapists, molesters, pedophiles, murders (Drunk Drivers who killed people) larcenists ect...they see it as a inexpensive way to handle a circumstance. Is it right NO!! Can AA do anything about it NO!! (at this time). Have the courts been asked to stop, YES!!! San Francisco (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals)
on religious grounds. Do the courts listen, NO!!
So your local "home groups" have to deal with this problem and they do. While these members are at the meeting. They have ByLaws for conduct while on the premises. They have people who are elected to enforce these laws for the protection of all.
But then again Jack, you don't know what goes on in a active AA meeting because you have never even been there.
Which leads us to why AA can't declare itself religious. It would prevent a lot of 12th-step recruiting efforts.