Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The universe is not a "power", and you can't really appeal to it for help with your drinking issues...

Helping me to find my car keys on the other hand.....

Incidentally Danny are the AA going to start coming out and saying
"By the way this whole business is a religious thing". They'd might spare a few red faces, and alot of lives.
 
You didn't finish that saying that I hear in the rooms, which goes:

"If you want what we have, do what we did"

Now the question is "what did they do"? Where I come from, we took what we needed and left the rest.

How could I possibly finish a saying that's said in meetings that happen on the other side of the planet from me?

The answer to "what did they do" was exactly what I said: "Read the Big Book." "Work the steps." "Get a sponsor." "Do ninety in ninety." "Keep comin' back -- it works!"

The best formula for success according to the AA philosophy is to work the steps -- all of them, in order, and it's no shame to work them multiple times. In fact, as I'm sure you're well aware, it's a source of pride for some AAs to have worked the 12 steps to completion many times in their lives. But according to AA, skipping steps because you feel like it is akin to skipping taking insulin for your diabetes because you don't feel like it. It probably won't kill you, but why take the chance it might?

Remember what AAs say: JAILS, INSTITUTIONS, DEATH!!!eleventy11!!
 
Several dozen family members and myself included. I've been to meetings in the most secular parts of Ireland and it's still always said.

It's there.

Secondly even if I did provide evidence would you just say the religious aspect is just a element and you can take or leave it?

But since you ask

http://www.aa.org/subpage.cfm?page=287

http://www.soberrecovery.com/forums/alcoholism-12-step-support/214409-lords-prayer-aa.html

Interesting. Seems ol' Bill W. was as prejudiced against atheists/agnostics in 1955 as he was in 1935.
 
I am of the opinion the universe is a power higher than me. For that matter so is power available in every wall socket. :)

So what do you do to improve your conscious contact with the electricity in the wall socket and what was it like to turn your will and your life over to the electricity in the wall socket?
 
So what do you do to improve your conscious contact with the electricity in the wall socket and what was it like to turn your will and your life over to the electricity in the wall socket?

And why does this wall socket fixate on your drinking issues, but ignores things like famine and child abuse?

These AA gods are really selective about their miracle work.
 
And why does this wall socket fixate on your drinking issues, but ignores things like famine and child abuse?

These AA gods are really selective about their miracle work.

It doesn't seem to do much for the drinking issues either...
 
Last edited:
I really don't give (much of) a damn if AA is religious - I simply want them to be honest about it.

Of course, their being religious is more than enough reason for me to discourage anyone from participating in their meetings, but that's the case whether or not they are honest about it.

That and the fact that AA doesn't seem to be very (or at all) effective in helping people stop drinking.
 
Jack Astor said:
So what do you do to improve your conscious contact with the electricity in the wall socket and what was it like to turn your will and your life over to the electricity in the wall socket?

And why does this wall socket fixate on your drinking issues, but ignores things like famine and child abuse?

These AA gods are really selective about their miracle work.
Sorry guys. I didn't select the power in a wall socket as my higher power. It appeared to work at the time for the person who did. I'd guess one would have no trouble consciously connecting with it and discovering it to be an actual higher power.

As to famine & child abuse maybe you want to start a thread and see who wants to discuss those topics.
 
Last edited:
Sorry guys. I didn't select the power in a wall socket as my higher power. It appeared to work at the time for the person who did. I'd guess one would have no trouble consciously connecting with it and discovering it to be an actual higher power.

As to famine & child abuse maybe you want to start a thread and see who wants to discuss those topics.

There's your problem! That doesn't even mean anything. Unless you're talking electric shock therapy...
 
Helping me to find my car keys on the other hand.....

Incidentally Danny are the AA going to start coming out and saying
"By the way this whole business is a religious thing". They'd might spare a few red faces, and alot of lives.

I don't think so, my new friend. Most people that go to AA and study the Big Book including the steps understand the religious content there in. No red faces.
8den, you just choose to make this issue (religion) a bone of contention, I don't know if you just don't like AA or you just don't like religion or maybe both. Once again there is no issue here.
Thanks for throwing in the theatrics, AA killing people now, aye!!!
("and alot of lives") :confused:
 
No, your testimony is but one point of anecdotal evidence that is seriously outweighed by other evidence.

Complexity, you have no professional studies to outweigh his anecdotal evidence.
Btw, most of the tests/studies done were of the anecdotal type, they did not keep the people in a lab room like mice and study them. All were allowed to return home and were asked to come back at prescribed times to answer more questions.
So to summarize we are all using anecdotal evidence here and it should be the accepted norm. :)
 
How could I possibly finish a saying that's said in meetings that happen on the other side of the planet from me?

The answer to "what did they do" was exactly what I said: "Read the Big Book." "Work the steps." "Get a sponsor." "Do ninety in ninety." "Keep comin' back -- it works!"

The best formula for success according to the AA philosophy is to work the steps -- all of them, in order, and it's no shame to work them multiple times. In fact, as I'm sure you're well aware, it's a source of pride for some AAs to have worked the 12 steps to completion many times in their lives. But according to AA, skipping steps because you feel like it is akin to skipping taking insulin for your diabetes because you don't feel like it. It probably won't kill you, but why take the chance it might?

Remember what AAs say: JAILS, INSTITUTIONS, DEATH!!!eleventy11!!

I understand that you have really no understanding of the inner working of AA. You are not a alcoholic first and second you have never even tried to integrate the steps into your life and last you have never felt the desperation to change your life as only a alcoholic could.
All that gibberish you spouted above is heard in the parking lots of many a AA meeting. If you want to get serious about what we do in AA, PM me, we can have a serious conversation. Because all you are doing here is acting like Jack and spouting fellowship rubbish that is immature.
AA is suggestive, period. There is no arguing that, thousands of people are doing AA they way they want to and will continue to do so. Just because you say Norseman it isn't supposed to be done this way, doesn't make it so.
This is your only way to make a argument, is by critiquing AA's upside down triangle and its governess society. Get in line they have been doing it for 7 decades.
 
Last edited:
Complexity, you have no professional studies to outweigh his anecdotal evidence.
Btw, most of the tests/studies done were of the anecdotal type, they did not keep the people in a lab room like mice and study them. All were allowed to return home and were asked to come back at prescribed times to answer more questions.
So to summarize we are all using anecdotal evidence here and it should be the accepted norm. :)


Nonsense. Let's start with the following, which I excerpted from the Wikipedia article on 'Twelve-step program' (relevant text made red, bold by me):



These are the original Twelve Steps as published by Alcoholics Anonymous:[10]
  1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become unmanageable.
  2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.
  3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.
  4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.
  5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.
  6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
  7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.
  8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all.
  9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.
  10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly admitted it.
  11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.
  12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our affairs.

I count 7 out of 12 of these AA steps as being religious in nature.


This is not anecdotal evidence.

This should be sufficient evidence to put an end to this discussion, but I suspect that it will go on and on and on...
 
Last edited:
I have been reading this whole thread as it developed.

I had occasion to attend an AA meeting as moral support for a friend.

It was so overtly religious, it was all I could do NOT to run out of the place.

At the end everyone stood and recited the lords prayer.

How can one possibly claim that it is not religious in nature, when it clearly is?

Freaked me out completely. It was like a cult.
 
Regarding the post that I just made regarding AA's original 12 steps:

Some will argue the following:

- 'Power greater than ourselves' doesn't have to mean a god
- 'God as we understood Him' doesn't have to mean a religious 'god'
- 'spiritual awakening' doesn't have to be religious, it could simply be 'spiritual'

Nonsense.

The 'God' described in these 12 steps is able to:

- Have the will and life of a person turned over to it
- Remove all defects of character from a person
- Have conscious contact with a person
- Convey to a person 'His will'
- Grant to a person 'the power to carry that [His will] out'

They aren't talking about some uncaring universe or life force, they are talking about a personal deity that cares for people, has a plan (will) for their lives, can interact with them, can hear their confessions, and remove their defects.

They are talking about something just like the judeochristianmuslim conception of 'god'.

To pretend otherwise is dishonest, insulting, and unworthy.
 
Last edited:
Regarding the post that I just made regarding AA's original 12 steps:

Some will argue the following:

- 'Power greater than ourselves' doesn't have to mean a god
- 'God as we understood Him' doesn't have to mean a religious 'god'
- 'spiritual awakening' doesn't have to be religious, it could simply be 'spiritual'

Nonsense.

It's more of a bait and switch con game of religious conversion. You're right. The AA God is specific. This is from the "We Agnostics" chapter of the 'Big Book':

"...We found that as soon as we were able to lay aside prejudice and express even a willingness to believe in a Power greater than ourselves, we commenced to get results, even though it was impossible for any of us to fully define or comprehend that Power, which is God."

In practice, a higher power™ is used as a proxy god for those willing to suspend their disbelief long enough to be brainwashed into the surreal AA world you see expressed by AA apologists.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom