Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by The Norseman View Post
And I say, "it ain't AA" because nowhere is it written in the official literature and any of the sponsors I've ever dealt with and heard about, say that you can pick and choose whatever you feel like.

A.A.Alfie says
Which is contrary to my experience. Some are AA nazi's, some aren't.

Ditto!!!
 
[snippity]
You really think it just comes down to this inner fight individuals have about religion covenants. I can tell you most alcoholics like most Americans don't really make decisions concerning there life based entirely or proportionally upon their religious beliefs today. It is a after thought if at all for most alcoholics upon coming to AA. Then once in for any length of time the person begins to sort out whether and how (if at all) religion/spirituality will play a part in their recovery.
derogatory remarks towards alcoholics struggling to get sober. It is easy for you to make up the problem that AA should be in total anarchy because it was based upon religion. It is not, AA works quite well for the folks that want it and they are able to compensate for the religious overtones.
People don't insist AA is not religion, they insist upon determining if religion, spirituality or the lack of will play a part in their lives while learning the 12 steps ect....
Evidence?
And people do insist AA is not religious. All the time.
 
Which is contrary to my experience. Some are AA nazi's, some aren't.

I would say most steppers aren't AA Nazis. In fact, I would say it's a minority. The problem is with the lucidity filter:

According to AA's Triennial surveys, half of every person showing up disappears in three months. Ninety-percent of the balance of who is left after three months is gone in a year. The reasons for leaving vary, but high among them is that when people see what AA actually is, they run like hell. This filters out rational thinkers, and leaves the rest.

Most people go to AA because they think it's a quit drinking support group. Then they get there and see it's a religious cult. Those who stay are the types who actually buy into the hocus pocus, but they are few and far between. The ninety-five out of a hundred who drop out that first year are replaced with new pigeons (AA slang for "newcomer"). So there will always be a fresh crop of shiny faces, who haven't bought into the dogma, simply because they're too new to understand it.

Of our local group of 50 here in this relatively small town, about ten are Big Book Nazis, about ten Unitarian types who use things like donkeys and "the group" as the god they turn their lives over to; and about thirty new sheep, 28 of whom will be gone within a few months.
 
Last edited:
Why are are saying I've never been to a closed meeting? How could you possibly know this? I've actually been to many,
Quite frankly, I don't believe you based on the general content and accuracy of your posts here.

and I assure you the only difference between them is in the degree of crazy and religious delusion.
I assure you you are wrong in that assessment as it pertains to any CD meeting I've been in, and that's a fair number, unless you or someone with you brought the "crazy and religious delusion".
 
This is tiresome.

AA promotes the belief in a 'higher power'. Many use this to promote their particular brand of crazy (i.e. religious belief). This is wrong and should be stopped.

Regardless of any possible benefits that the current practice of AA may provide (and I am not yet persuaded that there are any), imagine what it could do if it discouraged superstition rather than required it, if it enabled people to heal without substituting one crutch with another.

Quit being apologists for a lost cause and grow some integrity.
 
Last edited:
Evidence? :rolleyes:

In fact the evidence here by virtue of individual testimonies, is that people do admit it is religious. That said, they admit it is religious if the person wishes it to be.

The lords prayer is found in every AA meeting in Ireland. It's a central Christian prayer
 
The lords prayer is found in every AA meeting in Ireland.

Evidence please.
So..... you have been to every AA meeting in Ireland?

By the way, I have been to hundreds in Australia for nearly 15 years and I have yet to hear the Lords Prayer in an AA meeting, ever.
 
Evidence please.
So..... you have been to every AA meeting in Ireland?

By the way, I have been to hundreds in Australia for nearly 15 years and I have yet to hear the Lords Prayer in an AA meeting, ever.


Several dozen family members and myself included. I've been to meetings in the most secular parts of Ireland and it's still always said.

It's there.

Secondly even if I did provide evidence would you just say the religious aspect is just a element and you can take or leave it?

But since you ask

Q. What is the history behind reading The Lord’s Prayer at meetings?
A. It is mentioned in Dr. Bob and the Good Oldtimers that the prayer was used from the very beginning in the Fellowship, at least as early as 1938 and 1939. In those days there was no AA literature, so the early groups relied heavily on existing prayers, and on the Bible and Oxford Group literature, for inspiration and guidance.
Bill W. commented several times in his correspondence about the early use of the Lord’s Prayer. He wrote a letter to a member in 1959 in which he stated:
“This practice probably came from the Oxford Groups who were influential in the early days of A.A. You have probably noted in A.A. Comes of Age what the connection of these people with A.A. really was. I think saying the Lord's Prayer was a custom of theirs following the close of each meeting. Therefore it quite easily got shifted into a general custom among us.”
​
Bill also wrote the following in a 1955 letter:
“Of course there are always those who seem to be offended by the introduction of any prayer whatever into an ordinary A.A. gathering. Also it is sometimes complained that the Lord’s Prayer is a Christian document. Nevertheless, this Prayer is of such widespread use and recognition that the argument of its Christian origin seems to be a little far-fetched. It is also true that most AA’s believe in some kind of god and that communication and strength is obtainable through his grace. Since this is the general consensus, it seems only right that at least the Serenity Prayer and the Lord’s Prayer be used in connection with our meetings. It does not seem necessary to defer to the feelings of our agnostic and atheist newcomers to the extent of completely hiding ‘our light under a bushel.’
However, around here, the leader of the meeting usually asks those to join him in the Lord’s Prayer who feel that they would care to do so. The worst that happens to the objectors is that they have to listen to it. This is doubtless a salutary exercise in tolerance at their stage of progress.”
​
As Bill’s 1955 letter indicates, recitation of the Lord’s Prayer at meetings has clearly been controversial in some circles almost since the beginning. The GSO has responded to letters on this issue since the 1940s and 1950s. It is continually addressed in articles in Box 459 and the AA Grapevine, and has often been asked about at the General Service Conference. For example, at the 1962 Conference, in one of the Ask-It Basket questions, this subject was broached: “Question: What is the procedure for dealing with individuals who refuse to stand during recitation of the Lord's Prayer? Answer: Participation--or non-participation-in recitals of the Lord's Prayer should be considered a matter of personal conscience and decision.”

http://www.aa.org/subpage.cfm?page=287

http://www.soberrecovery.com/forums/alcoholism-12-step-support/214409-lords-prayer-aa.html
 
Last edited:
Secondly even if I did provide evidence would you just say the religious aspect is just a element and you can take or leave it?


I suppose they'd say that because you can attend a catholic school, attend mandatory religious services and classes on religion, but could 'take it or leave it', that the catholic school is not religious.
 
I suppose they'd say that because you can attend a catholic school, attend mandatory religious services and classes on religion, but could 'take it or leave it', that the catholic school is not religious.

The religion was optional, the feeding of funds and power to the catholic hierarchy wasn't. Neither was the paedophilia.

I defy you to claim that a organisation that expects you to sit through the lord's prayer isn't religious.

I equally defy you to keep a straight face when someone tries to explain to you that it's a "metaphorical" prayer. By which you could take "
"Give us this day our daily bread,and forgive us our debts,as we also have forgiven our debtors.And lead us not into temptation,but deliver us from evil."As a Metaphor for give us willpower, and forgiveness, and the strength to let others forgive us too.

They do kind of shut up when they get to this point

"Our Father in heaven,hallowed be your name.Your kingdom come,your will be done,on earth as it is in heaven."
 
I would say most steppers aren't AA Nazis. In fact, I would say it's a minority.

I would have to disagree with you. This is the same claim often made about religious people, that they are not fundies. However, they are only polite as long as non-believers keep their mouths shut and let the believer spout all the non-sense they want.

From experience, if you question/doubt even the most casual AA member you are going to get an earful of the same tripe/lies we have been getting from the AA'ers in this thread.

These people are not the exception, they are the rule.
 
I suppose they'd say that because you can attend a catholic school, attend mandatory religious services and classes on religion, but could 'take it or leave it', that the catholic school is not religious.
I can go with Bill W as the pope; now when you identify the closed meeting "mandatory religious service and classes on religion" you'll have a working analogy. :)
 
I would say most steppers aren't AA Nazis. In fact, I would say it's a minority. The problem is with the lucidity filter:

OK!!! Now we are getting actual facts. 99.9% of AA members are not AA Nazis's, they are your average garden variety American, who just so happen to have a adiction dependance their trying to recover from.
Jack, they are not crazy, insane, abnormal, steppers and are just as lucid as yourself.

According to AA's Triennial surveys, half of every person showing up disappears in three months. Ninety-percent of the balance of who is left after three months is gone in a year. The reasons for leaving vary, but high among them is that when people see what AA actually is, they run like hell. This filters out rational thinkers, and leaves the rest.

Well here once again Jack, you are way out on a limb. Their is no way you personally could know this. You do not associate (your words) with active AA'ers to know this.
This statistical info is just false, 100% of the people who leave AA within the first month leave because they don't want what AA has to offer, this repeats itself for 3 months, 6 mons, a year ect.....does that make these people failures, hell no. It is a program that is suggested (unless you are forced by the judicial system or a treatment center), in this case being forced I would probably run like hell when given the chance.


Most people go to AA because they think it's a quit drinking support group. Then they get there and see it's a religious cult. Those who stay are the types who actually buy into the hocus pocus, but they are few and far between.


Well this is where that Masters of Harvard is not being put to use. Most people who do go to AA ARE going to stop drinking, this is correct.
Where you get this religious cult from is beyond me. Jack, AA is not in chaos over religion and if you had any idea of what you are talking about you would know this. Yes people leave AA because of the religious overtures, but most see after a short while that they can move around freely with their understanding.
You are here I think trying to drum up business for your advocacy, dearly trying to make folks here believe AA has a religious problem.
AA is religious, Jack, and everyone know this, except you.


The ninety-five out of a hundred who drop out that first year are replaced with new pigeons (AA slang for "newcomer"). So there will always be a fresh crop of shiny faces, who haven't bought into the dogma, simply because they're too new to understand it.

Pigeons, is a slang word that went out of favor with your grandfather, Jack. Your lack of personal and up to date knowledge is really showing. I wish you would stop trying to act like you know the "inside of AA" because you don't. Which is fine nobody will look at you any different. Your comments concerning religion being a part of AA are of interest. Being that you are a religious person.
You do have a penchant though for degrading AA and the people that go, this I find very interesting, it goes beyond religious prejudices.
Just so you know Jack, 12 step calls at Hospitals, Prisons, Institutions ect....is at a all time low, calls coming in to "intergroups" from people asking for help (where someone actually goes to the home) all time low. Going to people homes is low because of the threat issue, violence has had a uptick over the last 30-40 years so AA'ers tend not to want to go to homes.
So we (AA) are not replacing the "new comer" they are just walking in or are persuaded by friends or family to come, also by the Judicial System and Treatment Centers.


Of our local group of 50 here in this relatively small town, about ten are Big Book Nazis, about ten Unitarian types who use things like donkeys and "the group" as the god they turn their lives over to; and about thirty new sheep, 28 of whom will be gone within a few months.

I will not even bother to respond to this. Where you got these monikers is anyone's guess. Your inexperience is showing here.
 
I would have to disagree with you. This is the same claim often made about religious people, that they are not fundies. However, they are only polite as long as non-believers keep their mouths shut and let the believer spout all the non-sense they want.

From experience, if you question/doubt even the most casual AA member you are going to get an earful of the same tripe/lies we have been getting from the AA'ers in this thread.

These people are not the exception, they are the rule.

Couldn't we say the same thing about you and your beliefs of AA. Every time I have tried to have a conversation with a Anti-AA'er it will go good for about 3 sentences and then the insults start getting hurled at me. Your (anti-AA) excuse is I was traumatized while in AA and I am being insensitive.
 
I can go with Bill W as the pope; now when you identify the closed meeting "mandatory religious service and classes on religion" you'll have a working analogy. :)


I was alluding to the step that requires acknowledgement of a 'higher power'.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom