Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for your honesty here. Others would seem to disagree and seem to infer that death is preferable to religion. And they talk about doing harm! I find this incredible and (frankly) disgusting.

1- False dichotomy.

2- You are admit that AA is religious. Finally, some honesty. :)

3- Your claim suggests religious people don't commit suicide. :rolleyes:

4- You are attributing claims to people who never made them. :mad:

Thanks for coming out.
 
So you're agreeing that AA is religious just that it's OK because so"s the USA?
I agree that people who were previously religious may find AA to be so, and that those who are not religious will not be pressured to become religious by AA.
 
The suggestion that someone needs to be an alcoholic and a member of AA in order to discern whether or not it is a religion makes zero sense.

By this criteria, nobody can form an opinion on any group to which they don't belong. It would preclude anyone from having a valid opinion as to whether Judaism, Catholicism, Scientology, Branch Davidians or the People's Temple are religious.
 
Last edited:
The suggestion that someone needs to be an alcoholic and a member of AA in order to discern whether or not it is a religion makes zero sense.
Luckily no one said that, huh?

By this criteria, nobody can form an opinion on any group to which they don't belong. It would preclude anyone from having a valid opinion as to whether Judaism, Catholicism, Scientology, Branch Davidians or the People's Temple are religious.
Wow. Now AA has become a Religion? On equal standing with Judaism or Catholicism? Not. Branch Davidians and People's Temple remain at cult level but were based on religious teachings of some sort. As to Scientology, who knows, other than it makes a nice straw man.
 
I disagree wholeheartedly, it doesn't even come close. I do agree suicide "sucks" but the fact it is a big part of addiction can not be stated enough.
It is not a discussion blocker.


I wasn't conceding anything to those who maintain that AA is not religious, nor trying to minimize the issues under discussion, nor saying that the last word had been spoken.

I was sad.
 
Last edited:
I doubt a decent longitudinal long-term study will ever be done.

Why do you doubt it? Nobody cares enough to try and do a study? Or maybe you're thinking that doing a study with alcoholics is inherently more difficult than every other medical or sociological study that researchers and scientists have done?



"5%" gets bandied about as though it were scientific fact which it isn't.

What is your definition of success with regards to alcoholism and what numbers have you seen to support your conclusions of the success rate of AA?

I go by the standards as outlined in the DSM-IV (which is the last one I'm familiar with). I would define success as reducing those symptoms which give rise to a diagnosis of chemical dependency for six months or more. Using drugs and/or alcohol is low on my list, as a matter of fact; for me, it is not necessarily a defining factor of 'success'. If anyone would like to argue differently, I'd be happy to re-think my position.



Ya think? I think few still-drinking drunks look for anything more than 'the facts' that allow them not to seek help.

So the solution is to paint AA in glorious accolades with tales of amazing success. Or, you know, maybe just realizing that studying the efficacy of AA and discussing the merits of AA is independent of whether or not a person who seeks excuses not to do something would find an excuse not to do something.



Take what you like, leave the rest: as always.

Which ain't AA.


The pap you linked was such a joke, why would anyone bother to do anything but ignore it?

More ad hominem dismissal of points raised.


The problem is no data, to accept or reject, is available. Few "Reasearchers" appear to have a clue what alcoholism is, let alone measure it.

The problem is that there is data available, although not perfect data.



I'd go with "uninformed", and/or "clueless", as we discuss alcoholism per-se, modalities and success rates. :)

And you're informed and cluefull about alcoholism modalities and success rates? How did you become more informed and cluefull about it than the researchers who are studying it?
 
I believe I have made every effort to explain here I am not disagreeing with this assessment of yours, that AA is religious as it is written in the Text Book and by the actions used by Dr. Bob and Lois in the initial years. They used the Bible when hosting meetings, so we get it. This is not my/our argument. I don't care how religious AA is or was for someone else, that is really none of my business. All I know is AA gave me enough room to move around being agnostic, I did not have to believe in a God nor use one to overcome my problems. I did not have to say, "OH I am spiritual not religious" either. I told people that I do not believe in this and I hold to my own higher principles and they were just fine with this. Please understand I was not looking for their approval or validation either. If people would just read the Big Book they would understand this topic was covered by Bill W. I am not delusional thinking Bill did not want to convert everyone towards "Gods" light, he did. But also know this there were a great many who did not fall in line with his thinking. Hence the chapter "We Agnostics".

The chapter "We Agnostics" was written to try and convince an atheist that Bill's way is the right way, not that it was really acceptable to be atheist and in recovery.
 
Oh and remember about 10 pages ago when someone linked to a ranking of treatments for alcoholism where seeing your family doctor was deemed to have the highest success rate?

You don't like that meta-study? That's cool. So what about the actual studies that were used in that meta-study? I would rather read your critique on those studies rather than dismissing those studies based on the fact you are contemptuous of the meta-study.



Noooooo really? Alcoholics filling out questionnaires isn't a reliable way to determine the effectiveness of treatment? Gee well that sucks, someone better tell Agent Orange he has to rewrite 90% of his website.

Anyone still supporting the 5% success rate of AA canard is either dumb, dishonest or idiotic.

The irony is that Agent Orange was using AA's own cited numbers and doing the math based on that.

You disagree? Feel free to use AA's own published success numbers and do the math and see if he's right or not. If he's not right, I'd be interested in knowing it.
 
Luckily no one said that, huh?

Of course you and others have, both explicitly and by implication. Alphie agreed with you a few posts above. The idea that someone needs to attend a closed meeting to know what AA really is, is simply wrong. Of course, a closed meeting is just more of the religious crazy found the AA's website. I would actually encourage others to go to a closed meeting, but I don't hate anyone here.
 
Last edited:
AlBell sez:
Take what you like, leave the rest: as always.

Noreseman sez:
Which ain't AA.

Norseman, you said in a earlier post that you had limited experience with AA, if yo had any at all.
My puzzlement is then how you could make this statement above. You don't have the intimate relationship with AA, studying and practicing the steps.
How do you know what is AA and what it isn't for any particular person, what they can take and what they can leave.
Norse I believe that in order to make your argument, you are making the same mistake (lack of intimate knowledge) that many of the novice readers of AA make. You take everything that was written in the Book literally and that is just not feasible.
This is not a "one shoe fits all" design for life philosophy.
Suggestions my friend, suggestions.
AA invites everyone and the Big Book allows all to interpret as they see fit. Crazy as it seems this works for many and has for 7 decades.
 
Of course you and others have, both explicitly and by implication. Alphie agreed with you a few posts above. The idea that someone needs to attend a closed meeting to know what AA really is, is simply wrong. Of course, a closed meeting is just more of the religious crazy found the AA's website. I would actually encourage others to go to a closed meeting, but I don't hate anyone here.

You are absolutely right, Jack but I don't believe you really knows this from experience. Well, you and I both know this is true.
Open meeting were originally formed so teachers, professors, probation officers, lawyers, nurses, husbands and wifes (of alcoholics, before Alanon) could come listen and ask questions.
Closed meeting stayed closed (Alcoholics only) for anonymity and so alcoholics felt comfortable sharing.
I am sure their are plenty of other reasons for both open and closed meeting but that was a few I could remember right now.
 
You don't like that meta-study? That's cool. So what about the actual studies that were used in that meta-study? I would rather read your critique on those studies rather than dismissing those studies based on the fact you are contemptuous of the meta-study.





The irony is that Agent Orange was using AA's own cited numbers and doing the math based on that.

You disagree? Feel free to use AA's own published success numbers and do the math and see if he's right or not. If he's not right, I'd be interested in knowing it.
You give every indication of being an expert now studying alcoholics, who, like many, in, for example, the medical and educational communities, appear to have no clue what alcoholism actually means to an alcoholic who ends up in AA closed discussion meetings looking for help.

Id'say for any here who think think the statement -- "Analyses were confined to the primary outcome variables, percent days abstinent (PDA) and drinks per drinking day (DDD)." has some applicability to most longer-term participants in AA closed discussion meetings, it doesn't, but that belief puts such a believer in the "clueless" category.

As to the fact that most AAers quit within a year, most likely. IMO, the great majority of those forced by courts to attend are in that group, as are other folks still trying to determine if they actually are alcoholics. In my own case I 'graduated' from AA twice to the PDA & DDD stage, before returning for a third successful-to-date effort.
 
Of course you and others have, both explicitly and by implication. Alphie agreed with you a few posts above.
Of course those who make such an interpretation of what I posted would be wrong.

The idea that someone needs to attend a closed meeting to know what AA really is, is simply wrong.
Well, yes, the only people who should attend closed meetings are people who think they are, or may be, alcoholics and want help.

Of course, a closed meeting is just more of the religious crazy found the AA's website.
Of course, that's a determination closed meeting attendees need to make for themselves, rather than taking advice from those who never have attended one.


I would actually encourage others to go to a closed meeting,
I would encourage people attend closed meetings if they think they are, or may be, alcoholics and want help.


but I don't hate anyone here.
Thanks for sharing.
 
Norseman, you said in a earlier post that you had limited experience with AA, if yo had any at all.
My puzzlement is then how you could make this statement above. You don't have the intimate relationship with AA, studying and practicing the steps.
How do you know what is AA and what it isn't for any particular person, what they can take and what they can leave.
Norse I believe that in order to make your argument, you are making the same mistake (lack of intimate knowledge) that many of the novice readers of AA make. You take everything that was written in the Book literally and that is just not feasible.
This is not a "one shoe fits all" design for life philosophy.
Suggestions my friend, suggestions.
AA invites everyone and the Big Book allows all to interpret as they see fit. Crazy as it seems this works for many and has for 7 decades.

To be more precise, I've had experience with AA; I haven't been explicit in detailing my involvement further than what I've already said in this thread (which extends back to nearly when it began a year or so ago) mainly because I'm saying that one does not need to be in AA to have valid critiques of AA. If you'd like, I can PM you my entire history (in maybe three short paragraphs :) ) regarding drugs, alcohol, treatment, and work history as it relates to chemical dependency.

And I say, "it ain't AA" because nowhere is it written in the official literature and any of the sponsors I've ever dealt with and heard about, say that you can pick and choose whatever you feel like. It's written and spoken aloud at every meeting I've ever attended that, "if you want what we have and are willing to go to any lengths to get it..." and all the other similar language, does in no way mean that you get to make up your own plan of sobriety.

What do AAs say? "Work the steps." "Get a sponsor." "Do ninety in ninety." "Keep comin' back, it works if you work it!" "Your best thinking got you here [meaning you haven't made rational decisions and your life is a mess]."

There are blogs and publications and letters and sayings which all fight against that notion that you just pick and choose. In fact, I read recently about a guy who made the statement that lent some clarification of the idea that you "take what you want and leave the rest." He felt that it applied not to the AA program, but to the people sharing in meetings; when a person shares his/her experience, strength and hope, you as a listener can take something insightful that the person said and leave the rest.

Anyway, that makes the most sense to me, considering the entirety of AA -- it's writings, it's founders, it's continued legacy.
 
You give every indication of being an expert now studying alcoholics, who, like many, in, for example, the medical and educational communities, appear to have no clue what alcoholism actually means to an alcoholic who ends up in AA closed discussion meetings looking for help.

I am in no way an expert, nor do I intend to imply such. I'm trying to get the hard facts as best as possible and interpret them in the most accurate manner to get the best results for the most number of people.


Id'say for any here who think think the statement -- "Analyses were confined to the primary outcome variables, percent days abstinent (PDA) and drinks per drinking day (DDD)." has some applicability to most longer-term participants in AA closed discussion meetings, it doesn't, but that belief puts such a believer in the "clueless" category.

What I'm trying to figure out is why you are thinking this way. This has been a long thread and perhaps I've missed it; that study defines what it considers to be success and have measured by it. What's wrong with that? And secondly, how do those terms of success not apply to people going to AA?




As to the fact that most AAers quit within a year, most likely. IMO, the great majority of those forced by courts to attend are in that group, as are other folks still trying to determine if they actually are alcoholics. In my own case I 'graduated' from AA twice to the PDA & DDD stage, before returning for a third successful-to-date effort.

If you're trying to say that the courts' involvement in AA is unfortunate, then I agree with you. It definitely can skew the numbers because, at minimum, it's forced attendance.

Also, congratulations on your sobriety! :)
 
Of course, that's a determination closed meeting attendees need to make for themselves, rather than taking advice from those who never have attended one.

Why are are saying I've never been to a closed meeting? How could you possibly know this? I've actually been to many, and I assure you the only difference between them is in the degree of crazy and religious delusion.

Not that it matters, anyway. One doesn't need to attend a closed-door Opus Dei meeting to know it's part of a religion.
 
Of course you and others have, both explicitly and by implication. Alphie agreed with you a few posts above.

I did no such thing. Not to the remote inference you seem to be making.

Of course those who make such an interpretation of what I posted would be wrong.

It seemed quite a leap didn't it?

And I say, "it ain't AA" because nowhere is it written in the official literature and any of the sponsors I've ever dealt with and heard about, say that you can pick and choose whatever you feel like.

Which is contrary to my experience. Some are AA nazi's, some aren't.

It's written and spoken aloud at every meeting I've ever attended that, "if you want what we have and are willing to go to any lengths to get it..." and all the other similar language, does in no way mean that you get to make up your own plan of sobriety.

You didn't finish that saying that I hear in the rooms, which goes:

"If you want what we have, do what we did"

Now the question is "what did they do"? Where I come from, we took what we needed and left the rest.
 
Originally Posted by AlBell
Of course, that's a determination closed meeting attendees need to make for themselves, rather than taking advice from those who never have attended one.

Jack Astor says:
Why are you saying I've never been to a closed meeting? How could you possibly know this? I've actually been to many, and I assure you the only difference between them is in the degree of crazy and religious delusion.
Not that it matters, anyway. One doesn't need to attend a closed-door Opus Dei meeting to know it's part of a religion.

Oh, but you have mentioned you have never really been to AA meeting and that you have never been alcoholic/abusive in your drinking. You just haven't said it here, yet.
Why you are pretending to be someone else here, with this expert insight into the studies and actions a struggling alcoholic goes through is just mystifying.
You really think it just comes down to this inner fight individuals have about religion covenants. I can tell you most alcoholics like most Americans don't really make decisions concerning there life based entirely or proportionally upon their religious beliefs today. It is a after thought if at all for most alcoholics upon coming to AA. Then once in for any length of time the person begins to sort out whether and how (if at all) religion/spirituality will play a part in their recovery.
But ya see, Jack, you don't know this tiny bit of intimacy because you have never really been there, in the trenches. Working on yourself and helping others in their addiction. So it is easy for you to bandy about clever one liners and derogatory remarks towards alcoholics struggling to get sober. It is easy for you to make up the problem that AA should be in total anarchy because it was based upon religion. It is not, AA works quite well for the folks that want it and they are able to compensate for the religious overtones.
People don't insist AA is not religion, they insist upon determining if religion, spirituality or the lack of will play a part in their lives while learning the 12 steps ect....
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom