Norseman, you said in a earlier post that you had limited experience with AA, if yo had any at all.
My puzzlement is then how you could make this statement above. You don't have the intimate relationship with AA, studying and practicing the steps.
How do you know what is AA and what it isn't for any particular person, what they can take and what they can leave.
Norse I believe that in order to make your argument, you are making the same mistake (lack of intimate knowledge) that many of the novice readers of AA make. You take everything that was written in the Book literally and that is just not feasible.
This is not a "one shoe fits all" design for life philosophy.
Suggestions my friend, suggestions.
AA invites everyone and the Big Book allows all to interpret as they see fit. Crazy as it seems this works for many and has for 7 decades.
To be more precise, I've had experience with AA; I haven't been explicit in detailing my involvement further than what I've already said in this thread (which extends back to nearly when it began a year or so ago) mainly because I'm saying that one does not need to be in AA to have valid critiques of AA. If you'd like, I can PM you my entire history (in maybe three short paragraphs

) regarding drugs, alcohol, treatment, and work history as it relates to chemical dependency.
And I say, "it ain't AA" because nowhere is it written in the official literature and any of the sponsors I've ever dealt with and heard about, say that you can pick and choose whatever you feel like. It's written and spoken aloud at every meeting I've ever attended that,
"if you want what we have and are willing to go to any lengths to get it..." and all the other similar language, does in no way mean that you get to make up your own plan of sobriety.
What do AAs say? "Work the steps." "Get a sponsor." "Do ninety in ninety." "Keep comin' back, it works if you work it!" "Your best thinking got you here [meaning you haven't made rational decisions and your life is a mess]."
There are blogs and publications and letters and sayings which all fight against that notion that you just pick and choose. In fact, I read recently about a guy who made the statement that lent some clarification of the idea that you "take what you want and leave the rest." He felt that it applied not to the AA program, but to the people sharing in meetings; when a person shares his/her experience, strength and hope, you as a listener can take something insightful that the person said and leave the rest.
Anyway, that makes the most sense to me, considering the entirety of AA -- it's writings, it's founders, it's continued legacy.