Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why do people insist that AA is not religious?
Because they want non-religious people to be able to join as well. But it is indeed religious. End thread/
 
I've spent the last few hours reading about Baclofen, the potential for this drug to help alleviate alcoholism seems promising. Hopefully more studies will be done and correct dosages can be determined.

Dr. Ameisen’s book looks interesting maybe I'll get myself a copy.

I hope people(mods) don't mind me responding to a subject which this topic wasnt actually posted for. Else let me know.

Yeah the book by Ameisen is a must have. It's his lifestory how/why he got addicted to Alcohol and what other possible options/treatment he also tried.

The problem of Baclofen not being patented anymore is the main reason why the pharmaceutical industry has no interest researching it further. But currently one big research is being setup for Baclofen in Amsterdam as a millionair donated halve a million euro after being helped by Baclofen himself.

Other promising news is that currently a better version of Baclofen is researched and might be put on the market in 2013 if nothing goes wrong.
It is called 'stx 209' at the moment.
 
AA is religious, of course. People who say it is not are simply lying to themselves and others, either out of embarrassment or out of a desire to Lie For Jesus.
 
Did you form that opinion based on your attendance at AA meetings?


@gentlehorse: Oh dear! [insert laughing dog here]

Son of an alcoholic, widower of an alcoholic, friends of several alcoholics, all of whom went through AA. My mother and a good friend sobered up but were infected with a particularly nasty fundie form of xianity that was instilled in them through AA. I'm glad they are alive, but miss the people they were before the alcohol and religion got them.
 
Thank you. You have reason for your opinion.

My experience in AA allows me to continue of the opinion AA meetings are as religious, or not-religious, as any individual wants or allows.
 
Did you form that opinion based on your attendance at AA meetings?


@gentlehorse: Oh dear!

picture.php


There you go.

:D
Son of an alcoholic, widower of an alcoholic, friends of several alcoholics, all of whom went through AA. My mother and a good friend sobered up but were infected with a particularly nasty fundie form of xianity that was instilled in them through AA. I'm glad they are alive, but miss the people they were before the alcohol and religion got them.

It isn't about you though is it?
The problem is that the alcohol/alcoholism did get them. The only valid question here is whether they are happy or not.

Are they?
 
There you go.

:D


It isn't about you though is it?
The problem is that the alcohol/alcoholism did get them. The only valid question here is whether they are happy or not.

Are they?


They seem to be sometimes.

I think that they are better off religious than dead.

There is one other valid question, however: Why do people claim that AA is not religious when it is? I find it to be a well-founded question, in that I accept its supposition that AA is religious. I gave my answer.

I really dislike people taking advantage of damaged people and using their time of greatest desperation as an opportunity to proselytize.

You may claim that this doesn't happen in all cases. I would agree - not everyone comes out religious. The requirement that a 'higher power' be acknowledged is an invitation to superstition, is not necessary, and is insulting and injurious. I have done my best to steer others to some secular alternatives that treat people with dignity and without the need to abase themselves or lie to themselves and others.

Religious belief is wrong, injurious to humanity, and AA is tainted by it.
 
There you go.

:D


It isn't about you though is it?
The problem is that the alcohol/alcoholism did get them. The only valid question here is whether they are happy or not.

Are they?


Wasn't the question "Is AA religious"?

Not "Does AA make people happy"?

Many cult members are perfectly happy inside their cult.
 
Last edited:
Thank you. You have reason for your opinion.

My experience in AA allows me to continue of the opinion AA meetings are as religious, or not-religious, as any individual wants or allows.

How convenient. So AA is not innately religious, but it depends on your interpretation. Are F1s inherently fast ? Maybe not compared to a rocket, but they still are.
 
Religious belief is wrong, injurious to humanity, and AA is tainted by it.

Here here. And AA will tell people that they are diseased and they are powerless to overcome their disease.

Often that's the worst advise you can give to someone seeking help with addiction.
 
They seem to be sometimes.

I think that they are better off religious than dead.
They would likely agree.

There is one other valid question, however: Why do people claim that AA is not religious when it is? I find it to be a well-founded question, in that I accept its supposition that AA is religious. I gave my answer.

I really dislike people taking advantage of damaged people and using their time of greatest desperation as an opportunity to proselytize.
I'm glad I haven't run into that problem, but I agree it obviously exists in some groups.

You may claim that this doesn't happen in all cases. I would agree - not everyone comes out religious. The requirement that a 'higher power' be acknowledged is an invitation to superstition, is not necessary, and is insulting and injurious. I have done my best to steer others to some secular alternatives that treat people with dignity and without the need to abase themselves or lie to themselves and others.

Religious belief is wrong, injurious to humanity, and AA is tainted by it.
Agreed to the extent the general population of the US is also, in your words "tainted"; right or wrong, most US residents do not consider religion a "taint".
 
Funny how it says "this isn't about you", when he was specifically asked for a reason for his position!
In context that pointed out the author was sharing third-person rather than first-person experience. Why other people choose what they choose usually remains a mystery. I hazard a guess that conversion to fundamentalism usually happens to people who have a pre-existing, reasonably strong religious upbringing.

I posit that on this atheist-dominated forum it would be unexpected for anyone to share his own religious conversion courtesy of attending AA meetings.
 
Agreed to the extent the general population of the US is also, in your words "tainted"; right or wrong, most US residents do not consider religion a "taint".


It appears that the a large portion of the US population is religious and even more are superstitious in other ways. That makes me sad. What a waste of minds and lives.
 
It actually is taken verbatim from AA literature. If you subscribe to AA Grapevine, the official AA magazine, you can find it doing an archive search. The article is simply titled "Dry Drunk."
You can read my letter in the letters section (named "PO Box 1980") of the April 1990 AA Grapevine. I actually wrote it and sent it in April 1989. Yes, I was a "true believer" back then.
Wasn't the question "Is AA religious"?

Not "Does AA make people happy"?

Many cult members are perfectly happy inside their cult.
Some may be happy in AA, others might not. I knew about a dozen people in AA who committed suicide. I suppose they weren't happy.
 
They would likely agree.


I'm glad I haven't run into that problem, but I agree it obviously exists in some groups.


Agreed to the extent the general population of the US is also, in your words "tainted"; right or wrong, most US residents do not consider religion a "taint".

So you're agreeing that AA is religious just that it's OK because so"s the USA?
 
I think that they are better off religious than dead.

Thank you for your honesty here. Others would seem to disagree and seem to infer that death is preferable to religion. And they talk about doing harm! I find this incredible and (frankly) disgusting.

I really dislike people taking advantage of damaged people and using their time of greatest desperation as an opportunity to proselytize.

Advantage how?

Religious belief is wrong, injurious to humanity, and AA is tainted by it.

With specific reference to AA, how is religious belief injurious?

Wasn't the question "Is AA religious"?

Not "Does AA make people happy"?

It was germaine to the point made. Moreover that point was acknowledged by that poster and responded to in an honest fashion.

Irrelevant to this thread. But nice try.

But relevant to the point being made.
Some people here seem a little upset that AA might actually make people happy.

Some may be happy in AA, others might not. I knew about a dozen people in AA who committed suicide. I suppose they weren't happy.

I know many more than that. AA did not kill them, they killed themselves.

I have had a few final-type conversations with clients and members prior to their demise by their own hand. In all instances they said they could not get recovery, and had lost all hope of living anormal life. Many (if not all) suffered from comorbidity issues of varyng degrees, some had other psychological issues around abuse, PTSD or similar.

I have also seen many clients suicide who have AOD issues but have never been to AA.

Alcohol(ism) kills alcoholics, AA does not.
 
Last edited:
You can read my letter in the letters section (named "PO Box 1980") of the April 1990 AA Grapevine. I actually wrote it and sent it in April 1989. Yes, I was a "true believer" back then.

I find this so funny because I truly don't understand what this comment "I was a "true believer" back then", means. AA is a design for living for the horribly addicted and abusive alcoholic. A way for him to crawl out of the hellhole he created for himself. Why is it so impossible for you to believe this.

Some may be happy in AA, others might not. I knew about a dozen people in AA who committed suicide. I suppose they weren't happy.

My friend in my almost 25 years of being affiliated with AA in one aspect or another I have known much more then a dozen that have committed suicide. Some had come to AA a time or two most had not. Alcohol is a drug, the effects in combination with mental and/or emotional factors can trigger a deadly slide towards death.


Complexity wrote:
benbradley - that sucks. puts this bickering in its place.

I disagree wholeheartedly, it doesn't even come close. I do agree suicide "sucks" but the fact it is a big part of addiction can not be stated enough.
It is not a discussion blocker.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom