Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
FWIW, I personally think that one of the main issues with AA is their loosie-goosie structure. They are proud of this non-structure.
They have a name, they have a movement, and they have paid staff, but they maintain this whole "no leadership" concept. Man up. An orgnisation ought to have integrity, leadership, and ACCOUNTABILITY.

I would have no issue with them if they weren't recommended in court rulings and if their reputation was genuine. It seems that no one dares taking them on.
-Studies don't show that their system is effective.
-Their system is not explicable in scientific terms.
-They don't update their tactics with new science.
-They are not accountable.
 
I'm not sure exactly how you've discounted each particular study or survey that consistently shows this 5% (sans the one that actually shows AA involvement makes one less likely to quit drinking than doing nothing). Let's go one at a time. Maybe we can start with Project MATCH, which was a huge study. Tell us why this study doesn't count.
If "This was a secondary analysis of data from a multisite clinical trial of alcohol dependent volunteers (N = 1726) who received outpatient psychosocial therapy. Analyses were confined to the primary outcome variables, percent days abstinent (PDA) and drinks per drinking day (DDD)." doesn't tell you why, from an AA standpoint the study misses every mark AA strives for, far be from me to educate you. PDA & DDD! (where's that laughing dog smiley?)

I'll also mention that sfaik the participants in "12 step" were given some bastardized version of same rather than actual AA Closed Discussion meetings.

The study was a joke rather than an analysis of AA success rates (which I agree, from personal observation, are low).

Here is a fun bit of background information on this study.
Blather from a blog. Wow! (need laughing dog again)
 
FWIW, I personally think that one of the main issues with AA is their loosie-goosie structure. They are proud of this non-structure.
They have a name, they have a movement, and they have paid staff, but they maintain this whole "no leadership" concept. Man up. An orgnisation ought to have integrity, leadership, and ACCOUNTABILITY.
Think you get "ACCOUNTABILITY" from, say, Betty Ford Clinic?

I would have no issue with them if they weren't recommended in court rulings and if their reputation was genuine. It seems that no one dares taking them on.
Certainly no one worth worrying about. But, yes, even atheists have been, and can be, accommodated in AA.

-Studies don't show that their system is effective.
Nor is any addiction treatment protocol if resultant PDA isn't 'forever' and DDD zero.

-Their system is not explicable in scientific terms.
Some BMT techniques are in play but any spritual aspect, agree, no.

-They don't update their tactics with new science.
Now if there just was some applicable "new science". What New Science do you recommend?

-They are not accountable.
Like every other treatment method and facility, you mean?
 
Think you get "ACCOUNTABILITY" from, say, Betty Ford Clinic?


Certainly no one worth worrying about. But, yes, even atheists have been, and can be, accommodated in AA.


Nor is any addiction treatment protocol if resultant PDA isn't 'forever' and DDD zero.


Some BMT techniques are in play but any spritual aspect, agree, no.


Now if there just was some applicable "new science". What New Science do you recommend?


Like every other treatment method and facility, you mean?

So, basically you're saying you agree with everything I said, except you'd like to apply it to all other forms of treatment?
Okay. We're good.

By the way, I never mentioned anything about any other treatment provider. I've always wanted to say this: Strawman.
 
Nanny, only read your first post. AA is questioned alot considering the relgious stuff it's based on. But so far there pretty much hasn't been an alternative. Not that most people know off yet.

The next part doesn't reply to what I'm suposed to reply about this topic, sorry for that

I fixed my alcohol addiction(and other addictions for that matter besides smoking) with a medication called Baclofen. First off Baclofen isn't patented anymore so please do not consider this as spam. Googeling Baclofen and indiffrence to alcohol I'd suggest first ;).

Baclofen is an old medication which was created for diffrent purposes. Until some time ago when A french doctor, also alcoholic. Fixed his addiction completely with Baclofen and wrote a book about his experiences and story with Baclofen named "The end of my addiction" by Olivier Ameisen.

Baclofen still lacks large scale experiments considering treatment against addiction. But for alcoholics, succesrate is a very high % average.

Maybe it is a solution for your friend? Even if he/she doesn't want to try it. Should be at least aware of such an option.

I've also created a Baclofenforum where people can discuss Baclofen, and their experiences or ask questions. If you or anyone else would like a link there, please ask me and I'll pm it to you.

For other questions/comments pm me too, as I don't want to mess up this topic. :)
 
I hope this dissuades people from using AA, and encourages them to seek support groups and treatment that does not rely on supernatural intervention from invisible spirits. Religion has no place in addiction treatment, and the brainwashing and other manipulation in the group makes it even worse . There is a reason it doesn't help people beyond the 5% who would quit anyway.

These other support groups that you mention. Do you have statistics on their efficacy?

I've also created a Baclofenforum where people can discuss Baclofen, and their experiences or ask questions. If you or anyone else would like a link there, please ask me and I'll pm it to you.

For other questions/comments pm me too, as I don't want to mess up this topic. :)

Please pm me with this. I have more than just a passing interest.
 
I doubt a decent longitudinal long-term study will ever be done. "5%" gets bandied about as though it were scientific fact which it isn't.

Yeah you'd think on a so called skeptics forum there would be more critical thinking going on.

According to the info from this link:

http://alcoholism.about.com/od/pro/a/blacer051013.htm

One's success in AA is related to the length of time spent as a member and their personal commitment to it.



"We know that self-help groups, such as AA, contribute to better alcohol-related and psychosocial outcomes," said Rudolf H. Moos, senior research career scientist

Well that can't be, AA has a 95% failure rate.

For example, patients with alcohol use-disorders who participate in AA, and those who attend more meetings and/or participate for a longer time, are more likely to be abstinent and to maintain remission up to five years after an episode of professional treatment than patients who are not involved or less involved in such groups.

NO WAY? So people who go to one meeting and leave don't get better? Who would of thought that.


individuals who obtain professional treatment and participate in AA in the first year after initiating help-seeking are more likely to achieve remission for up to 15 years later than are individuals who obtain professional treatment alone. Finally, individuals who have achieved remission but who discontinue participation in AA are at increased risk for relapse; individuals who have not stopped drinking and who discontinue participation in AA are more likely to continue drinking."

How can that be?

5% success rate remember.

Oh and remember about 10 pages ago when someone linked to a ranking of treatments for alcoholism where seeing your family doctor was deemed to have the highest success rate?

Yeah about that.

http://alcoholism.about.com/cs/heal/a/aa000513a.htm

Nine out of ten primary care physicians in the United States fail to correctly diagnose alcohol abuse even when their adult patients present classic early symptoms, according to a survey by the Center on Addiction and Drug Abuse (CASA) at Columbia University.

Even more startling perhaps, 41 percent of pediatricians fail to diagnose illegal drug abuse when presented with a classic description of a drug abusing teenage patient.

This is what the NIAAA has to say about studies done on alcoholism treatment:

http://alcoholism.about.com/od/pro/l/blnaa17.htm

Until the last decade, alcoholism treatment research lagged behind standard medical and behavioral treatment research. Randomized controlled trials, the most objective type of treatment research methodology, were rarely used by alcohol treatment researchers.

Instead, much of the early research suffered from lack of comparison groups, high rates of attrition, and reliance solely on self-reports of alcohol consumption, all of which may have biased, or skewed, the results.


Noooooo really? Alcoholics filling out questionnaires isn't a reliable way to determine the effectiveness of treatment? Gee well that sucks, someone better tell Agent Orange he has to rewrite 90% of his website.

Anyone still supporting the 5% success rate of AA canard is either dumb, dishonest or idiotic.
 
Last edited:
Succes rate of Baclofen is 88%. This number may drop/increase when more research is done. I know a lot of people now who use Baclofen or have used it. My personal experience is that that 88% is pretty accurate.
 
If "This was a secondary analysis of data from a multisite clinical trial of alcohol dependent volunteers (N = 1726) who received outpatient psychosocial therapy. Analyses were confined to the primary outcome variables, percent days abstinent (PDA) and drinks per drinking day (DDD)." doesn't tell you why, from an AA standpoint the study misses every mark AA strives for, far be from me to educate you. PDA & DDD! (where's that laughing dog smiley?)

I'll also mention that sfaik the participants in "12 step" were given some bastardized version of same rather than actual AA Closed Discussion meetings. (need laughing dog again)

I see. You're pulling the, "this isn't REALLY AA" excuse. Interesting you go for that one, since there were a couple of things you could have pulled from the ignore-the-data bag 'o tricks.
 
Yeah you'd think on a so called skeptics forum there would be more critical thinking going on.

So would I. But then again, you're your defending spiritual faith healing. So what are you gonna do?

As for the Moos studies you cite, I'm not going to spoon feed you how to interpret data, and I suspect even if you could, you'd massage it.

So let me just point out that that study you cited does indeed show a correlation with AA attendance and abstinence. So...yea AA!

What it doesn't do is show a cause for their sobriety in the first place, and what Moos did (who is a long-time AA shill) is lop off everyone who failed the program in the first year, which is the vast majority of participants. It correlates AA attendance with sobriety, but only for those who have been abstinent for a year already (well, not really abstinent, but those who meet Moos ridiculous definition of abstinence. really, someone with reduced drinking counts, too.). This is like implying basketball teams makes people tall, or hospitals make people sick. Of course they don't. This is where tall and sick people gather. Cause and correlation aren't the same.

So, to summarize. The study is good for AA, in that it correlates AA attendance with sobriety. Former drinkers who used a support group like going there. It just doesn't prove, nor was is it intended to prove, AA's effectiveness in getting people to quit.


Today's contradiction moment:

AlBell dismisses the Project MATCH study because it isn't really AA. It's that treatment centre stuff. Which means the study doesn't matter because it doesn't study what happens in the super secret closed meetings.

ProBonoShill points to a study to prove AA works. Well, he thought he was, but didn't understand what the study was about, but this was his intention. And this study was from treatment centre AA.

Nicely done.



It was a nice tag team on mind-bending contradiction.
 
I see. You're pulling the, "this isn't REALLY AA" excuse. Interesting you go for that one, since there were a couple of things you could have pulled from the ignore-the-data bag 'o tricks.
The pap you linked was such a joke, why would anyone bother to do anything but ignore it?

The problem is no data, to accept or reject, is available. Few "Reasearchers" appear to have a clue what alcoholism is, let alone measure it.
 
The problem is no data, to accept or reject, is available. Few "Reasearchers" appear to have a clue what alcoholism is, let alone measure it.

Only if you believe it's a spiritual deficiency, in which case you are right. Magical spirits are a tough thing to measure.

Maybe research lab should be done in Bill Wilson's oujia board and spook room, and some of those ghost traps from Ghostbusters.
 
"Spiritual Deficiency"! Alcoholism may cause some to become more pronounced, but no, not my understanding.
 
I'd go with "uninformed", and/or "clueless", as we discuss alcoholism per-se, modalities and success rates. :)
 
Succes rate of Baclofen is 88%. This number may drop/increase when more research is done. I know a lot of people now who use Baclofen or have used it. My personal experience is that that 88% is pretty accurate.

I've spent the last few hours reading about Baclofen, the potential for this drug to help alleviate alcoholism seems promising. Hopefully more studies will be done and correct dosages can be determined.

Dr. Ameisen’s book looks interesting maybe I'll get myself a copy.

It's amazing how many people that disagree with you are dumb, dishonest or idiotic.

It's amazing you ignored all the facts in my post and resorted to your usual boorish behavior of posting shallow one liners.


Actually it's not that amazing, it seems that's all you do here at JREF.
 
I've spent the last few hours reading about Baclofen, the potential for this drug to help alleviate alcoholism seems promising. Hopefully more studies will be done and correct dosages can be determined.

Dr. Ameisen’s book looks interesting maybe I'll get myself a copy.



It's amazing you ignored all the facts in my post and resorted to your usual boorish behavior of posting shallow one liners.


Actually it's not that amazing, it seems that's all you do here at JREF.

You've read all my posts? I'm flattered.
 
The educated skeptic?

So would I. But then again, you're your defending spiritual faith healing. So what are you gonna do?

As for the Moos studies you cite, I'm not going to spoon feed you how to interpret data, and I suspect even if you could, you'd massage it.

So let me just point out that that study you cited does indeed show a correlation with AA attendance and abstinence. So...yea AA!
What it doesn't do is show a cause for their sobriety in the first place, and what Moos did (who is a long-time AA shill) is lop off everyone who failed the program in the first year, which is the vast majority of participants.

The cause for their sobriety is their willingness to follow a simple design for a new life. Moos is a long time shill, Jack what would that make you (with your Blog) a short time shill for Anti-AA'ers.
Here we go again with "failed the program" in the first year. You are misleading the readers again Jack or you are just ignorant due to your lack of personal or professional experience with AA.
Jack you have not been able to clearly define what is a failure in the AA program.
Many folks come to AA saying they are a alcoholic only to find out they are not, this I would say constitutes (from my experience) at least 85 % of the new people coming to AA the very first time. The courts and the treatment centers are sending most of them. So I guess your saying Jack that because these folks who were never alcoholic to begin with (They were forced to come) are now considered failures because they left within the first year. Great, good to see you are finally clearing this up.
This is what is wrong with studies of this nature. There are to many IDK's.


It correlates AA attendance with sobriety, but only for those who have been abstinent for a year already (well, not really abstinent, but those who meet Moos ridiculous definition of abstinence. really, someone with reduced drinking counts, too.). This is like implying basketball teams makes people tall, or hospitals make people sick. Of course they don't. This is where tall and sick people gather. Cause and correlation aren't the same.

What are you talking about here, Jack. Is this as far as your cognitive mind can go. Attendance at a AA meeting means studying the text book, sharing your personal experinces and listening to others. There is a learning process going on while attending an AA meeting. To what degree each member wants to learn is up to them. Hence AA=Self Help Program.

So, to summarize. The study is good for AA, in that it correlates AA attendance with sobriety. Former drinkers who used a support group like going there. It just doesn't prove, nor was is it intended to prove, AA's effectiveness in getting people to quit.

Well.... like we have been trying to point out to you Jack, first you would have to have some experience with AA (more then owning a blog and listening to others) to understand the dynamics of learning going on in a AA meeting.
Since you don't and you can only draw on experiences from looking in through a very hazy portal which brings you to these weak conclusions that AA doesn't help people at all get sober.


Today's contradiction moment:

AlBell dismisses the Project MATCH study because it isn't really AA. It's that treatment centre stuff. Which means the study doesn't matter because it doesn't study what happens in the super secret closed meetings.

ProBonoShill points to a study to prove AA works. Well, he thought he was, but didn't understand what the study was about, but this was his intention. And this study was from treatment centre AA.

Nicely done. It was a nice tag team on mind-bending contradiction.



OH boy!!! Jack the only contradiction going on here is your attempt at acting like you really know what you are talking about.
There is a huge difference between Treatment Center AA (Straight Inc/Steven Slate, it is on your Blog, Jack) and Traditional AA. There is a big difference between being forced into AA by the Judicial system and walking in on your own. If we have to explain this to you then where are we really here. I mean this is just your basic information most people in this industry know about AA.
 
What does it matter; you'll dismiss it in either case.

No we won't, just make sure it can hold two opinions. Aye!!

Are you asking out of genuine interest, or as another way to dismiss critics by saying that if they're not going to AA, they don't really know what they're talking about?

Well, there is validity in saying such a statement. AA is not like anything else really, it is a dreadful personal experience one has to experience first hand.
Sorry if that leaves you out but It doesn't mean you can not learn a thing or two.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom