Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Old Today, 04:51 PM #4437
benbradley
New Blood

Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 12

Originally Posted by Jack Astor View Post
True, although I know of plenty of the back to basics AA fundies who study it like scripture, believe it and interpret it literally. It depends on the group or person. My first post in this thread I compared asking what AA is to asking "how long is a string?" There are lots of denominations, each one crazy in its own way. This is why a discussion like this is like a never-ending whack-a-mole game, because some stepper will inevitably tell you how wrong you are.

Old-schoolers scoff at the idea of turning ones life over to chia pet, but the newfangled hippie-type steppers can actually promote this without snickering. Then there is everything in between, as steppers are simply retrofitting their belief system into the program with rationalizations and such. It's a giant grab bag of idolatry and pseudoscience.
There's a lot of bait-and-switch in the literature, as well as in meeting themselves. The 12&12 on Step 3 says it's perfectly fine to have the AA group be your higher power. In step 11 it says someone who relies only on the group as their higher power is missing something, and true sobriety can only be achieved through having a spiritual higher power.

So there's self-contradictory stuff like that, and there are phrases such as "take what you like and leave the rest" and "if you can drink like a man, our hats are off to you" (adapted from the big book p.31) that turn out to be disingenuous.

Been there, done that, and I literally got a free t-shirt in AA.


Jack Astor sez:
True, although I know of plenty of the back to basics AA fundies who study it like scripture, believe it and interpret it literally. It depends on the group or person. My first post in this thread I compared asking what AA is to asking "how long is a string?" There are lots of denominations, each one crazy in its own way. This is why a discussion like this is like a never-ending whack-a-mole game, because some stepper will inevitably tell you how wrong you are.

DannyB II sez:

OK, let me get this straight, in your comments above you show a definite arrogance and condescension. Categorizing people in AA into denominations "each one crazy in its own way", comparing the conversations with "Steppers" (your word) like "Whack a mole" because a person going to AA might disagree with you, so you whack them with words of sarcasm.
Can you be real Jack, I mean come on. You can't have a rational conversation without belittling the person on the opposite side.
It is not "how wrong you are", Jack. I don't think anyone is interested in proving you are wrong in your beliefs but I think from your post here and one other I read you are interested in proving AA is wrong for individuals.
The year is 2011 it is not 1934, many folks in AA are agnostic and atheist today, some like to call themselves spiritual most refuse to be aligned with religion and then some enjoy the religious aspect of AA. We compensate, many of us take the word "suggestive" literally.

Jack Astor sez:
Old-schoolers scoff at the idea of turning ones life over to chia pet, but the newfangled hippie-type steppers can actually promote this without snickering. Then there is everything in between, as steppers are simply retrofitting their belief system into the program with rationalizations and such. It's a giant grab bag of idolatry and pseudoscience.

DannyB II sez:
Where do you get this information from because you are not citing anything, you aren't even saying you were ever even in AA. Can we have citations please or at least some personal experiences testimony.


benbradley sez:
There's a lot of bait-and-switch in the literature, as well as in meeting themselves. The 12&12 on Step 3 says it's perfectly fine to have the AA group be your higher power. In step 11 it says someone who relies only on the group as their higher power is missing something, and true sobriety can only be achieved through having a spiritual higher power.

DannyB II sez:
Ben at the point of step three usually the person is rather new so leaning on the group of people you have made friends with is not a bad idea. Most of these new friends will probably be in your "Home Group".

By step eleven if you have been reading all along at this point you are looking for interdependence not just a dependence. Now this is my view and I don't go to AA anymore just like you Ben. I am not that happy about the AA of today but that doesn't mean I have to misquote the Big Book in a effort to tear it down.

No Bait and Switch, what is with all this paranoia.

benbradley sez:

So there's self-contradictory stuff like that, and there are phrases such as "take what you like and leave the rest" and "if you can drink like a man, our hats are off to you" (adapted from the big book p.31) that turn out to be disingenuous.

DannyB II:
No where in any of the AA literature is there a quote that says "take what you like and leave the rest". "If you can drink like a man, our hats are off to you" why is this disingenuous. It means exactly what it says. I have used the term, you have probably used it also.

benbradley sez:
Been there, done that, and I literally got a free t-shirt in AA.

DannyB II:

I have a few T-Shirts myself.
 
Last edited:
Did you bother to get sober? ;)

So when you say "sober," do you mean regular sober, or AA sober?

It's a tricky question. Most people think sobriety is not drinking or not getting drunk. Wrong.

You've got those who haven't drank in twenty years who were convinced they weren't really sober, because they didn't have the spiritual transformation. You've got those who thought they weren't sober even before they took a drink for the same reason.

AAer refer to it as a "dry drunk." But, hey! They've got a solution!:

CORRECTIVE MEASURES: Those undergoing a dry drunk lead impoverished lives. They experience severe limitations to grow, to mature, and benefit from the possibilities that life offers. They lack the freshness and spontaneity that genuinely sober alcoholics manifest. Their life is a closed system, attitudes and behaviors are stereotyped, repetitive, and consequently predictable.

Alcoholics learn early that humility and a power greater than them- selves are the bedrock for a genuine and productive sobriety. An unusual measure of self-discipline must accompany the ego deflation process. Needed is self-discipline in honesty, patience and responsibility towards the recovery process [and acceptance of their disease]. [To improve long term goals of sobriety be aware of mental stressors, get more involved in the recovery program, get active in the 12 steps, get and use a sponsor, talk things out.] Hopefully. they will begin to appreciate the ironic folly of those alcoholics who think life has suddenly become manageable again; whose sanity is beyond question; who see no need of turning their lives over to a power greater then them- selves; who find personal inventories unnecessary since they are seldom in the wrong and are no longer subject to the embarrassing need of repairing the wrongs they have done.
 
So when you say "sober," do you mean regular sober, or AA sober?

It's a tricky question. Most people think sobriety is not drinking or not getting drunk. Wrong.

You've got those who haven't drank in twenty years who were convinced they weren't really sober, because they didn't have the spiritual transformation. You've got those who thought they weren't sober even before they took a drink for the same reason.

AAer refer to it as a "dry drunk." But, hey! They've got a solution!:
Is that cite AA literature? But yes I'm aware of the 'dry drunk' concept.

Did you get sober in AA? I did, and continue to; sfaik, each individual (and those around him or her) judges what 'sober' means and what 'spiritual transformation', if any, might have occurred.
 
Last edited:
Is that cite AA literature? But yes I'm aware of the 'dry drunk' concept.

It actually is taken verbatim from AA literature. If you subscribe to AA Grapevine, the official AA magazine, you can find it doing an archive search. The article is simply titled "Dry Drunk."
Did you get sober in AA?

No. I'm not big on religion or faith healing.
 
Last edited:
Is that cite AA literature?

What does it matter; you'll dismiss it in either case.



Did you get sober in AA? I did, and continue to; sfaik, each individual (and those around him or her) judges what 'sober' means and what 'spiritual transformation', if any, might have occurred.

Are you asking out of genuine interest, or as another way to dismiss critics by saying that if they're not going to AA, they don't really know what they're talking about?
 
What does it matter; you'll dismiss it in either case.
Either way it's 'take what you want, leave the rest', yes.

I don't recall if Grapevine makes the disclaimer that authors' opinions are just that, not AA Policy.

BTW, even "AA Policy" is a joke given my comment above. Closed Discussion meetings (where only actual drunks trying to get better should be) don't stand much on Policy.


Are you asking out of genuine interest, or as another way to dismiss critics by saying that if they're not going to AA, they don't really know what they're talking about?
Interest in the sense too many AA bashers here have stated they don't have any 'drinking problem'.

And interest if another previously suffering drunk got the needed help from somewhere. I don't seem to get many answers 'yes, I'm sober, now and Thanks to ____________'.
 
So when you say "sober," do you mean regular sober, or AA sober?

I think the word sober is used in AA exactly they way it is defined in Websters Dictionary. There is no need for hyperbole here.

It's a tricky question. Most people think sobriety is not drinking or not getting drunk. Wrong.

No, we can stick to this definition. Since I went to AA for over 20 years Jack, I think that when I say no one is confused nor feels tricked when asked about there sobriety, it is actually a very serious admission with alcoholics.

You've got those who haven't drank in twenty years who were convinced they weren't really sober, because they didn't have the spiritual transformation. You've got those who thought they weren't sober even before they took a drink for the same reason.

Once again can we have a citation on this or at least some verifiable proof that you speak from a place of experience.
These comment sound just like what you can here at my uncle's bar, folks who didn't want what AA has to offer just telling everyone how it doesn't work. Sorry I have no citation either to back up what I just said.
 
The GrapeVine is not considered AA Text literature, it is a magazine with personal articles either quoted or written by AA members. That's it.
 
And interest if another previously suffering drunk got the needed help from somewhere. I don't seem to get many answers 'yes, I'm sober, now and Thanks to ____________'.

Yes, I'm sober thanks to myself.


The "this isn't AA literature" is an interesting "that's not AA!!" denial technique. Particularly from someone advocating things like "take what you want and leave the rest" (not in AA literature) and "god of your understanding" (not in AA literature), among other things. It's a neat trick steppers pull in denying what happens in AA doesn't happen, or is some sort of rogue idea. This the ugly cousin to the oft used "true Scotsman" fallacy so often heard.

Corky the 12-Step Monkey, who has a disease that tells him he doesn't have a disease, explains better than I what is and what is not AA here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lo-Qc_EuIJs
 
Yes, I'm sober thanks to myself.
Indeed. Same for all reformed drinkers. :)

The "this isn't AA literature" is an interesting "that's not AA!!" denial technique. Particularly from someone advocating things like "take what you want and leave the rest" (not in AA literature) and "god of your understanding" (not in AA literature), among other things. It's a neat trick steppers pull in denying what happens in AA doesn't happen, or is some sort of rogue idea. This the ugly cousin to the oft used "true Scotsman" fallacy so often heard.
Not as ugly as people here attacking something they neither need nor understand, to the potential detriment to someone reading this who is dis-suaded from seeking needed help. Few alcoholics need extra reasons to avoid facing their problem, and offering another cop-out is not particularly useful imo.

Corky the 12-Step Monkey, who has a disease that tells him he doesn't have a disease, explains better than I what is and what is not AA here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lo-Qc_EuIJs
Is argument by a juvenile youtube from luvdrunk.org the best you can muster?
 
Not as ugly as people here attacking something they neither need nor understand, to the potential detriment to someone reading this who is dis-suaded from seeking needed help. Few alcoholics need extra reasons to avoid facing their problem, and offering another cop-out is not particularly useful imo.

I hope this dissuades people from using AA, and encourages them to seek support groups and treatment that does not rely on supernatural intervention from invisible spirits. Religion has no place in addiction treatment, and the brainwashing and other manipulation in the group makes it even worse . There is a reason it doesn't help people beyond the 5% who would quit anyway.


And don't knock Corky. Remember rule 62.
 
Yes, I'm sober thanks to myself.

Well this isn't a actual truth is it Jack about you. You would have had to be a alcoholic first or at least have been abusive with alcohol to use the statement you made above in the context of this conversation.
You are purposely misleading the commentators here.


The "this isn't AA literature" is an interesting "that's not AA!!" denial technique. Particularly from someone advocating things like "take what you want and leave the rest" (not in AA literature) and "god of your understanding" (not in AA literature), among other things. It's a neat trick steppers pull in denying what happens in AA doesn't happen, or is some sort of rogue idea. This the ugly cousin to the oft used "true Scotsman" fallacy so often heard.

No, Jack, that is not true at all, I am not in denial about what is AA literature. I happen to know what is AA literature and what is parking lot (outside a meeting) fellowship cliches. Just because you need to hang your hat on some detriment concerning AA it seems you tend to want to use the gimmicky slogans the meeting halls pick up from Treatment Centers.
Come on AA is so much more then this.



Corky the 12-Step Monkey, who has a disease that tells him he doesn't have a disease, explains better than I what is and what is not AA here:

So now because you can't come up with any mature responsible citations you have to digress to silliest. This site is not Stinkin Thinkin.
 
Indeed. Same for all reformed drinkers. :)

Not as ugly as people here attacking something they neither need nor understand, to the potential detriment to someone reading this who is dis-suaded from seeking needed help. Few alcoholics need extra reasons to avoid facing their problem, and offering another cop-out is not particularly useful imo.


People who see all sides of AA are more well informed as to what kinds of treatment they might find most effective. They should know what are the positives and the drawbacks to it.


No, Jack, that is not true at all, I am not in denial about what is AA literature. I happen to know what is AA literature and what is parking lot (outside a meeting) fellowship cliches. Just because you need to hang your hat on some detriment concerning AA it seems you tend to want to use the gimmicky slogans the meeting halls pick up from Treatment Centers.
Come on AA is so much more then this.


If I may, I don't believe he was talking to you specifically. If you've read this thread, however, you will find many pro-AA people trotting out those very trite AA slogans as evidence that AA is not religious; is not a specific program of spiritual recovery; and AA is whatever program you feel like.

It was to those people, I'm thinking, that he's aiming his specific comments of what's official AA literature and what is not. At least, in the context of the entire thread, that's how I interpreted his comments; as always, I could be wrong.

The point being made is that AA is, by it's very nature expressed through the official literature, a religious organization. This has carried down, unchanged, for 75 years and is still being held to by the official AA World Organization, all official AA literature, and all AA spokespersons.
 
Q. Why do people insist AA is not religious?
A. I think we can really only answer this question one post at a time.

j.r.
 
I hope this dissuades people from using AA, and encourages them to seek support groups and treatment that does not rely on supernatural intervention from invisible spirits.
That might be the position of someone with a large equity interest in a for-profit addiction treatment facility targeting atheists. I'm not sure if the (US) 90%+- theists of some form or another would find that a sales point.

Religion has no place in addiction treatment, and the brainwashing and other manipulation in the group makes it even worse .
Certainly not true for all 'addicts' although where alcoholism exactly fits on the 'addiction scale' is uncertain.

I doubt most theists see it as a problem, and most groups I've seen are mostly theists of one form or another.

There is a reason it doesn't help people beyond the 5% who would quit anyway.
I doubt a decent longitudinal long-term study will ever be done. "5%" gets bandied about as though it were scientific fact which it isn't.

And don't knock Corky. Remember rule 62.
I leave further comment on Corky to you and other AA bashers.

People who see all sides of AA are more well informed as to what kinds of treatment they might find most effective. They should know what are the positives and the drawbacks to it.
Ya think? I think few still-drinking drunks look for anything more than 'the facts' that allow them not to seek help.



If I may, I don't believe he was talking to you specifically. If you've read this thread, however, you will find many pro-AA people trotting out those very trite AA slogans as evidence that AA is not religious; is not a specific program of spiritual recovery; and AA is whatever program you feel like.
That is basically my continuing position.

The point being made is that AA is, by it's very nature expressed through the official literature, a religious organization. This has carried down, unchanged, for 75 years and is still being held to by the official AA World Organization, all official AA literature, and all AA spokespersons.
Which ignores the point that many Closed Discussion groups do not pressure anyone to accept religion as a requirement for membership or to stop drinking.

Take what you like, leave the rest: as always.
 
People who see all sides of AA are more well informed as to what kinds of treatment they might find most effective. They should know what are the positives and the drawbacks to it.





If I may, I don't believe he was talking to you specifically. If you've read this thread, however, you will find many pro-AA people trotting out those very trite AA slogans as evidence that AA is not religious; is not a specific program of spiritual recovery; and AA is whatever program you feel like.

Norseman, AA "IS" a program of your choosing. AA gives a outline (a foundation) then suggests how you should build your structure. It does not direct nor make it mandatory you follow a certain blueprint.
The only time I hear this argument is from folks who usually have very little experience or maybe none at all with AA. There is the occasions where a disgruntled ex-AA'er will argue this point. They felt overwhelmed by the people they initially met at a meeting.
AA does have its hard line obsessive members. (IDK) why either, because it doesn't teach you to be this way in the Text Book AA, actually it asks for you to watch out for this behavior.


It was to those people, I'm thinking, that he's aiming his specific comments of what's official AA literature and what is not. At least, in the context of the entire thread, that's how I interpreted his comments; as always, I could be wrong.

No I don't think you are wrong. I may have been to direct with my comments.


The point being made is that AA is, by it's very nature expressed through the official literature, a religious organization. This has carried down, unchanged, for 75 years and is still being held to by the official AA World Organization, all official AA literature, and all AA spokespersons.

I believe I have made every effort to explain here I am not disagreeing with this assessment of yours, that AA is religious as it is written in the Text Book and by the actions used by Dr. Bob and Lois in the initial years. They used the Bible when hosting meetings, so we get it. This is not my/our argument. I don't care how religious AA is or was for someone else, that is really none of my business. All I know is AA gave me enough room to move around being agnostic, I did not have to believe in a God nor use one to overcome my problems. I did not have to say, "OH I am spiritual not religious" either. I told people that I do not believe in this and I hold to my own higher principles and they were just fine with this. Please understand I was not looking for their approval or validation either. If people would just read the Big Book they would understand this topic was covered by Bill W. I am not delusional thinking Bill did not want to convert everyone towards "Gods" light, he did. But also know this there were a great many who did not fall in line with his thinking. Hence the chapter "We Agnostics".
 
Last edited:
I doubt a decent longitudinal long-term study will ever be done. "5%" gets bandied about as though it were scientific fact which it isn't.

I'm not sure exactly how you've discounted each particular study or survey that consistently shows this 5% (sans the one that actually shows AA involvement makes one less likely to quit drinking than doing nothing). Let's go one at a time. Maybe we can start with Project MATCH, which was a huge study. Tell us why this study doesn't count.

Here is a fun bit of background information on this study.
 
Denialism is a disease. Thank Bill Wilson there is a spiritual solution!

Al-alon is also a dangerous cult to be wary of.

Alcoholics Anonymous killed my marriage
An acclaimed war reporter, JANINE DI GIOVANNI fell head over heels for a hard-drinking rival. Their love survived many battles, except one


Angie the Anti-theist recounts her time in Al-anon: My time in Al-Anon pt. 1

And another memoir Z's story.

Also check out these pages, one, two, three, and hit ctrl f and search al-anon to find more documented problems and the origins of the cult. Yes, they invented al-anon as a way help more people into the cult. It is a feel-good nightmare. Obviously a lot of good happens in al-anon, I also have family members in that program, but it's effects on the mind are, well, cult-like.

There are infinite kinds of AA and al-anon which make this conversation difficult. But if you look at the originals, where it came from, there is no mistaking it.

Still looking for more evidence that AA is a cult started by the insane man Bill Wilson? Look here. If you're looking for the truly bizarre. Ask google who Boniface is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom