Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The spiritual disease is actually the foundation of the AA 12-step program, is found in the 'Big Book'. It permeates AA. I would love to see this separate AA universe described in this thread where the 'Big Book' is simply a historical document, and there is none the spiritual disease nonsense, and religiosity doesn't ooze from every pore.
Where in the Big Book are the words "spiritual disease" found?

My websearch for "spiritual disease" found no references to AA.
 
Where in the Big Book are the words "spiritual disease" found?

My websearch for "spiritual disease" found no references to AA.

It's on page 64:

"Resentment is the "number one" offender. It destroys more alcoholics than anything else. From it stem all forms of spiritual disease, for we have been not only mentally and physically ill, we have been spiritually sick. When the spiritual malady is overcome, we straighten out mentally and physically. In dealing with resentments, we set them on paper. We listed people, institutions or principles with whom we were angry. We asked ourselves why we were angry. In most cases it was found that our self-esteem, our pocketbooks, our ambitions, our personal relationships...."

Alcoholism, according to the AA, is a symptom of a spiritual disease. Fix that with the steps - admit powerlessness, turn you life over to the care God, confess your sins, have God remove your shortcomings, pray to God - and you're good to go. But only for one day at a time, for the rest of your life.

You can read more about it here.
 
Last edited:
Yes, you are saying that atheism and theism are the same.

Actually I'm not.

No, they don't. This is a crucial point that you fail to understand.

Sure they do

It all depends on what you are meaning by "neutral". But in all cases you are NOT believing in God, and are therefore an atheist agnostic.

ftfy in terms of my understanding of myself. If you don't agree, fine, but I really don't care. :p

What it seems is that you are a very poor mind-reader, troll.

Oh! Ouch. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
It's on page 64:

"Resentment is the "number one" offender. It destroys more alcoholics than anything else. From it stem all forms of spiritual disease, for we have been not only mentally and physically ill, we have been spiritually sick. When the spiritual malady is overcome, we straighten out mentally and physically. In dealing with resentments, we set them on paper. We listed people, institutions or principles with whom we were angry. We asked ourselves why we were angry. In most cases it was found that our self-esteem, our pocketbooks, our ambitions, our personal relationships...."

Alcoholism, according to the AA, is a symptom of a spiritual disease. Fix that with the steps - admit powerlessness, turn you life over to the care God, confess your sins, have God remove your shortcomings, pray to God - and you're good to go. But only for one day at a time, for the rest of your life.

You can read more about it here.
From your cite, these are spiritual maladies:

being restless, irritable, and discontented (page xxvi),
having trouble with personal relationships,
not being able to control our emotional natures,
being a prey to (or suffering from) misery and depression,
not being able to make a living (or a happy and successful life),
having feelings of uselessness,
being full of fear,
unhappiness,
inability to be of real help to other people (page 52),
being like "the actor who wants to run the whole show" (pages 60-61),
being "driven by a hundred forms of fear, self-delusion, self-seeking, and self-pity" (page 62),
self-will run riot (page 62),
leading a double life (page 73),
living like a tornado running through the lives of others (page 82), and
exhibiting selfish and inconsiderate habits

Note that alcoholism is not on the list. As I see it, symptoms of spritual maladies (like alcoholism or addictions) are not "spritual maladies" in and of themselves.
 
Last edited:
Studies about what, then, exactly?

Successful treatments in alcoholism/alcohol dependency

Alright, I hear you. Miles off the mark in what sense, then? Compared to results you've seen from other studies? From informal results seen at your treatment agency?

A bit of both, any studies I have seen have been somewhat lacking and certainly not comprehensive. It seems to me that people want to mix alcoholism up with heavy drinking.
What I would really like to see is something that does this:

Identifies and isolates those with the opiate receptor differences (that nebulous 10% of the population), looks at treatment options for them, recording successes and failures with treatments etc.

As I said earlier, people imply or even state outright that the "evidence based results on alcoholism treatments" are out there. Not from what I've seen.
 
Last edited:
Note that alcoholism is not on the list. As I see it, symptoms of spritual maladies (like alcoholism or addictions) are not "spritual maladies" in and of themselves.

That is exactly what AA teaches. Alcoholism is not the disease. Alcoholism is a symptom of the spiritual malady. AA is not about quitting drinking. That is just a consequence. AA is about religious conversion, one of the benefits of that is sobriety. It's a ridiculous notion that came about because those original members were simply the alcoholic wing of the Oxford Group who got booted for being drunks. They believed their moral failings and character flaws were the cause of their addiction. All AA is, is the Oxford Group steps with some extra hocus pocus tacked on.

Let me let you in on something. There are no "spiritual maladies." At least, nobody has yet discovered the spiritual gene. If you're addicted, you've got yourself a screwed up body chemistry.
 
I suspect I've been to as many AA groups & meetings as you have, and found no trace of the position that drunks fit into the category "addiction to be a spiritual problem requiring a spiritual solution".


Okay.



Successful treatments in alcoholism/alcohol dependency

A bit of both, any studies I have seen have been somewhat lacking and certainly not comprehensive. It seems to me that people want to mix alcoholism up with heavy drinking.
What I would really like to see is something that does this:

Identifies and isolates those with the opiate receptor differences (that nebulous 10% of the population), looks at treatment options for them, recording successes and failures with treatments etc.

As I said earlier, people imply or even state outright that the "evidence based results on alcoholism treatments" are out there. Not from what I've seen.


What did you think of my most recent link? Did it help in answering some of your questions?
 
ftfy in terms of my understanding of myself. If you don't agree, fine, but I really don't care.

Again you show your ignorance. Agnostic and atheist are not mutually exclusive.

But since you don't know the meaning of the words "skepticism", "atheist", "higher power", "faith", "program" and "neutral", it's not surprising you don't know the one that goes with "agnostic" either.
 
That is exactly what AA teaches. Alcoholism is not the disease. Alcoholism is a symptom of the spiritual malady. AA is not about quitting drinking. That is just a consequence. AA is about religious conversion, one of the benefits of that is sobriety. It's a ridiculous notion that came about because those original members were simply the alcoholic wing of the Oxford Group who got booted for being drunks. They believed their moral failings and character flaws were the cause of their addiction. All AA is, is the Oxford Group steps with some extra hocus pocus tacked on.
You are welcome to hold that, imo unsustainable, opinion.

Let me let you in on something. There are no "spiritual maladies." At least, nobody has yet discovered the spiritual gene. If you're addicted, you've got yourself a screwed up body chemistry.
Let me let you in on something. "Spiritual malady" may have made sense in the context of the US in the 1940's. Today we might better term them inappropriate mental constructs which lead to inappropriate behavors, one of which may be drinking alcoholically, that is, alcoholism.
 
Last edited:
Let me let you in on something. "Spiritual malady" may have made sense in the context of the US in the 1940's. Today we might better term them inappropriate mental constructs which lead to inappropriate behavors, one of which may be drinking alcoholically, that is, alcoholism.

What you are saying is that AA and its members have substituted modern pseudo-psycho- babble for 1940's pseudo-psycho-babble.
 
What you are saying is that AA and its members have substituted modern pseudo-psycho- babble for 1940's pseudo-psycho-babble.
And that's to some extent true, due to the influence of popular 12-step based self-help gurus such as John Bradshaw ("Mister Shame") and Melody Beattie ("Mizz Codepencency").

But many "true steppers" have resented this infiltration - Al-Anon pretty much outlawed the word co-dependent because it was deemed a word used by professionals and Al-Anon proclaims itself to be a non-professional organization. For the most part, 12-step members adhere as well as they know how to (the modern interpretations of) the Official Literature as originally published.
 
That is exactly what AA teaches. Alcoholism is not the disease. Alcoholism is a symptom of the spiritual malady.
That well may be how AA was when the literature was written, and that may be exactly how the literature describes it, but current belief in AA is that alcoholism is a disease. And members believe they are adhering perfectly with the literature as originally written when they say alcoholism is a disease.

I've rarely if ever seen such deep hermeneutics in meetings or on online 12-step forums as I've just seen in the last few post in this thread. What AA members REALLY believe is what's passed onto them from the old-timers, even if the book they're reading out of says something ever slightly so different. Hermeneutics requires deeper thought and more critical, logical reasoning than is available to AA members. When something appears to say something different from what they've been taught by other longer-term members, the only conclusion possible is the member must be misinterpreting what they're reading.

I once read part of the pamphlet "A Members Eye View of Alcoholics Anonymous" as discussion leader at a meeting, and I saw this reinterpretation happen right before my eyes.
 
Last edited:
That well may be how AA was when the literature was written, and that may be exactly how the literature describes it, but current belief in AA is that alcoholism is a disease. And members believe they are adhering perfectly with the literature as originally written when they say alcoholism is a disease.

I've rarely if ever seen such deep hermeneutics in meetings or on online 12-step forums as I've just seen in the last few post in this thread. What AA members REALLY believe is what's passed onto them from the old-timers, even if the book they're reading out of says something ever slightly so different.

True, although I know of plenty of the back to basics AA fundies who study it like scripture, believe it and interpret it literally. It depends on the group or person. My first post in this thread I compared asking what AA is to asking "how long is a string?" There are lots of denominations, each one crazy in its own way. This is why a discussion like this is like a never-ending whack-a-mole game, because some stepper will inevitably tell you how wrong you are.

Old-schoolers scoff at the idea of turning ones life over to chia pet, but the newfangled hippie-type steppers can actually promote this without snickering. Then there is everything in between, as steppers are simply retrofitting their belief system into the program with rationalizations and such. It's a giant grab bag of idolatry and pseudoscience.
 
Last edited:
And that's to some extent true, due to the influence of popular 12-step based self-help gurus such as John Bradshaw ("Mister Shame") and Melody Beattie ("Mizz Codepencency").

So, it wasn't AA that popularized these things in AA it was those evil "other" people? :rolleyes:

But many "true steppers" have resented this infiltration...

How do you distinguish a "true" stepper from a "false" stepper? (Are those the two categories of people in AA?)

And isn't this, in the end, just more pseudo-psycho-babble? It seems that AA'ers like their little adages and feel that whoever has the catchiest one wins the argument.

- Al-Anon pretty much outlawed the word co-dependent because it was deemed a word used by professionals and Al-Anon proclaims itself to be a non-professional organization.

What exactly does this have to do with anything. Who uses a word isn't the issue. The issue is people projecting their mistaken beliefs onto others and then forcing, through peer pressure and indoctrination, those people to conform to a mistaken ideology.

For instance, my brother-in-law comes back from his AA meeting on a 12 Step high and I get to hear how my life can be summed up with a few silly adages. I have listened for 12 years while he has told me that I am in denial about my mother's death. Why? Because when she died, most of my family cried a lot. I didn't. That, in his mind, is denial just like the new comer who stood up at his meeting and told the group how it was nothing more than preaching is in denial about his alcoholism. (Don't even ask me how the two are related.)

And don't get me wrong, my BIL is a good guy. He is also a fervent believer in AA. I like him better sober, but then again, I don't like anyone when they are drunk.

And don't think his sobriety is a benefit of AA. Very unlikely.

For the most part, 12-step members adhere as well as they know how to (the modern interpretations of) the Official Literature as originally published.

Which is what people here have been saying. AA'ers adhere to the original, official literature of the Big Book just like religious zealots adhere to their version of the original, official literature in their chosen religious text.
 
So, it wasn't AA that popularized these things in AA it was those evil "other" people? :rolleyes:
But then these OTHER people, these gurus, started out as and still are 12-step members themselves. They became popular by taking the 12-step message and morphing it into a popular form, suitable for things like PBS TV shows.

Their influence in meetings in general isn't that great, but when I heard people taking about "shame" and especially "toxic shame" in meetings, it was obvious they were quoting Bradshaw.
How do you distinguish a "true" stepper from a "false" stepper? (Are those the two categories of people in AA?)
That's simple, just ask 'em. :)

It's kinda like "true alcoholic" (a phrase actually used in the literature). A stepper is someone who (willingly) attends 12-step meetings. A "true stepper" is a (self-appointed) leader in 12-step meetings - someone who's even more holier-than-though than usual. Or maybe that should be "soberer-than-though."
And isn't this, in the end, just more pseudo-psycho-babble? It seems that AA'ers like their little adages and feel that whoever has the catchiest one wins the argument.
Most of these adages are directly from the literature, mostly the first 164 pages of the big book. There's a few taken from the stories, especially the one titled in the third edition "Doctor, Alcoholic, Addict" renamed for the 4th edition which contains the infamous "acceptance" parahraph, and there are several from the AA book "Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions" usually called the 12&12.
What exactly does this have to do with anything. Who uses a word isn't the issue.
Language and who controls it is exactly the issue. Read up on cults and you'll find out about loading the language. Sober in AA doesn't mean the dictionary meaning of not drunk (most people, unless they weigh less than 100 lbs, can drink one beer and not be drunk, thus they're still sober), it means abstinent from alcohol. It's often got more stuff loaded on that, such as "spiritually fit." I heard a man say "I haven't had a drink in years, but I'm not sober today."

People in AA don't tell you about these different meanings - they're not even aware of them themselves. They think the words always meant these things, and that they didn't know what the words truly meant until they were in AA a while. It's magical thinking, and it's amazing.
The issue is people projecting their mistaken beliefs onto others and then forcing, through peer pressure and indoctrination, those people to conform to a mistaken ideology.
Loading the language is a substantial part of that.


...
Which is what people here have been saying. AA'ers adhere to the original, official literature of the Big Book just like religious zealots adhere to their version of the original, official literature in their chosen religious text.
Yeah, that's why there are so many different denominations of Christianity who adhere strictly to what the KJV Holy Bible says. The Church of Christ doesn't have musical instruments and sings all their hymms without accompaniment. They've got a pamphlet that explains how that's based on some New Testament verse. Obviously either the Church of Christ or many other denominations are wrong about what the Bible says, but they ALL believe they're right.

But there's usually some fine point that someone finds that "oh my God, we're not doing it right," they bring it up to the group/congregation which then ignores them or treats them like the "feminist fruitbat" that goes up the AA organization who wants to change the steps to say "God as we understood Him or Her" ... and they end up starting a new meeting/church/denomination, all because they have the "correct" interpretation of the holy scriptures.

People BELIEVE they are strictly adhering, but of course they're making their own interpretations.
 
Last edited:
True, although I know of plenty of the back to basics AA fundies who study it like scripture, believe it and interpret it literally. It depends on the group or person. My first post in this thread I compared asking what AA is to asking "how long is a string?" There are lots of denominations, each one crazy in its own way. This is why a discussion like this is like a never-ending whack-a-mole game, because some stepper will inevitably tell you how wrong you are.

Old-schoolers scoff at the idea of turning ones life over to chia pet, but the newfangled hippie-type steppers can actually promote this without snickering. Then there is everything in between, as steppers are simply retrofitting their belief system into the program with rationalizations and such. It's a giant grab bag of idolatry and pseudoscience.
There's a lot of bait-and-switch in the literature, as well as in meeting themselves. The 12&12 on Step 3 says it's perfectly fine to have the AA group be your higher power. In step 11 it says someone who relies only on the group as their higher power is missing something, and true sobriety can only be achieved through having a spiritual higher power.

So there's self-contradictory stuff like that, and there are phrases such as "take what you like and leave the rest" and "if you can drink like a man, our hats are off to you" (adapted from the big book p.31) that turn out to be disingenuous.

Been there, done that, and I literally got a free t-shirt in AA.
 
Yeah, benbradley, did you have a personal spiritual epiphany and come down with a purity fetish?
 
That would be a completely different question; but I suspect you know that as well as I do.

Hmmm. If you are as clueless concerning AA (closed) Meetings and groups as the majority of posters in this thread are I suppose you wouldn't know that.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom