So, it wasn't AA that popularized these things in AA it was those evil "other" people?
But then these OTHER people, these gurus, started out as and still are 12-step members themselves. They became popular by taking the 12-step message and morphing it into a popular form, suitable for things like PBS TV shows.
Their influence in meetings in general isn't that great, but when I heard people taking about "shame" and especially "toxic shame" in meetings, it was obvious they were quoting Bradshaw.
How do you distinguish a "true" stepper from a "false" stepper? (Are those the two categories of people in AA?)
That's simple, just ask 'em.
It's kinda like "true alcoholic" (a phrase actually used in the literature). A stepper is someone who (willingly) attends 12-step meetings. A "true stepper" is a (self-appointed) leader in 12-step meetings - someone who's even more holier-than-though than usual. Or maybe that should be "soberer-than-though."
And isn't this, in the end, just more pseudo-psycho-babble? It seems that AA'ers like their little adages and feel that whoever has the catchiest one wins the argument.
Most of these adages are directly from the literature, mostly the first 164 pages of the big book. There's a few taken from the stories, especially the one titled in the third edition "Doctor, Alcoholic, Addict" renamed for the 4th edition which contains the infamous "acceptance" parahraph, and there are several from the AA book "Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions" usually called the 12&12.
What exactly does this have to do with anything. Who uses a word isn't the issue.
Language and who controls it is exactly the issue. Read up on cults and you'll find out about loading the language. Sober in AA doesn't mean the dictionary meaning of not drunk (most people, unless they weigh less than 100 lbs, can drink one beer and not be drunk, thus they're still sober), it means abstinent from alcohol. It's often got more stuff loaded on that, such as "spiritually fit." I heard a man say "I haven't had a drink in years, but I'm not sober today."
People in AA don't tell you about these different meanings - they're not even aware of them themselves. They think the words always meant these things, and that they didn't know what the words truly meant until they were in AA a while. It's magical thinking, and it's amazing.
The issue is people projecting their mistaken beliefs onto others and then forcing, through peer pressure and indoctrination, those people to conform to a mistaken ideology.
Loading the language is a substantial part of that.
...
Which is what people here have been saying. AA'ers adhere to the original, official literature of the Big Book just like religious zealots adhere to their version of the original, official literature in their chosen religious text.
Yeah, that's why there are so many different denominations of Christianity who adhere strictly to what the KJV Holy Bible says. The Church of Christ doesn't have musical instruments and sings all their hymms without accompaniment. They've got a pamphlet that explains how that's based on some New Testament verse. Obviously either the Church of Christ or many other denominations are wrong about what the Bible says, but they ALL believe they're right.
But there's usually some fine point that someone finds that "oh my God, we're not doing it right," they bring it up to the group/congregation which then ignores them or treats them like the "feminist fruitbat" that goes up the AA organization who wants to change the steps to say "God as we understood Him or Her" ... and they end up starting a new meeting/church/denomination, all because they have the "correct" interpretation of the holy scriptures.
People BELIEVE they are strictly adhering, but of course they're making their own interpretations.