Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually I asked you what treatments there are and what the efficacy of each was in treating alcoholics.
Yes, you did and I appreciate you honestly answering my questions even so.



I have a number of different treatment options to use including a number of detox centres (home based, in house), rehab options (short, medium and long term) some 12 step, some not. We are always in need of more of these types of facilities but there are quite a lot of them; there is always a shortage of beds especially for those without private health cover.
Where there is a dearth is in the maintenance programs. AA - obviously, SMART, ongoing counselling and therapy. There is little else.

So when people say "there are other evidence based teatment", I want to know what they are.

Well, there are medical/pharmacologically based treatments; there are different types of counseling and therapy depending on the school of thought (I mentioned RET as one example earlier and there is brief therapy -- which I understood it in the sense of meeting with a counselor once a week for two months and not this absurd notion of "treatment" consisting of meeting once with your primary care physician -- as well as CBT, AA's spiritual disease model, the more mainstream disease model, etc.), so lumping all this and more into saying 'ongoing counseling and therapy' is kinda missing the trees for the forest.

So, while some therapies (so-called) seem a bit silly, I wonder if they are truly more effective than AA or not.




Correct, and I was testing you. Sorry.

No worries, mate! As long as it's intended as good-natured, I'm willing to take it.




Just have a look through..

Come on!?
Do you seriously want to rest on this list as evidence for the treatment of alcohol dependence?

Sure. I do, mainly because there are 48 listed modalities; there are ample to choose from if the first dozen don't strike your fancy, or are too woo or are absurd on the face of it. Some of the categories I find to be odd, but if this website just collects the data and is making a meta-data report, then there still can be some value in it.



"Take what you want" is what might be said in an AA meeting in terms of that program. In practice a client will do this too with the potential list of solutions that might be discovered, tabled and explored. It is not the role of a counsellor to tell people what to do. I think #2 said it well about what a therapist/counsellor might do: "Objective feedback from the assessment that is provided in a low-key way that does not label you or push you into doing anything you don't want to do"


Yes, I agree. AA's program was never intended, however, to be taken as one wished and I would hazard to say that most AAs still feel the same way. One must admit that there is a certain amount of logic in thinking that an alcoholic has, up until then, made rather poor decisions regarding his life, yet bringing him into a program which encourages him to continue to "take what he wants and leave the rest" isn't a recipe for sure success.

As with a doctor's prescription, the doctor certainly won't force you to take the medicine as prescribed, yet the doctor will tell you that by following it as prescribed, you will gain the maximum efficacy of the medication (ignoring for this illustration the sometimes lethal side effects or severe complications that suddenly stopping taking a medication or taking a medication sporadically can do).

Same as I see it with a therapist. The therapist does not tell the client what to do, but says "follow these guidelines for the best success rate". AA was always intended to do the same thing. That is why I still can make the reasonable conclusion that AA is still religiously-based. "Taking what you want and leaving the rest" was never a part of it (and actively derided as bad decision-making), the AA World Organization has made no changes whatsoever to the core AA material, and has even gone so far as to remove official recognition to groups which do make more secular changes.

If 'spirituality' was all there really was to it, even today, then why doesn't the AA big book (next edition) make the changes so hundreds of thousands of people across the world can enjoy a new-found sense of acceptance and inclusiveness?

At this point, it'd be too late for me anyway. I will no longer go to AA meetings mainly because I no longer believe addiction to be a spiritual problem requiring a spiritual solution. Don't care to support that model any longer.
 
Well, there are medical/pharmacologically based treatments; there are different types of counseling and therapy depending on the school of thought (I mentioned RET as one example earlier and there is brief therapy -- which I understood it in the sense of meeting with a counselor once a week for two months and not this absurd notion of "treatment" consisting of meeting once with your primary care physician -- as well as CBT, AA's spiritual disease model, the more mainstream disease model, etc.), so lumping all this and more into saying 'ongoing counseling and therapy' is kinda missing the trees for the forest.

Indeed, I wasn't trying to be comprehensive.

So, while some therapies (so-called) seem a bit silly, I wonder if they are truly more effective than AA or not.

I have been searching for these answers for a long time. People keep making the assertions that there are studies, but I've never seen them.

No worries, mate! As long as it's intended as good-natured, I'm willing to take it.

Coll. No offense. :cool:

Sure. I do, mainly because there are 48 listed modalities; there are ample to choose from if the first dozen don't strike your fancy, or are too woo or are absurd on the face of it. Some of the categories I find to be odd, but if this website just collects the data and is making a meta-data report, then there still can be some value in it.

I think you must have missed my point. The problem isn't with the treatment options listed per se, but the rankings - the options themselves are fine but in terms of efficacy for treating alcoholism/dependence they are miles off the mark and the results dubious at best.

If 'spirituality' was all there really was to it, even today, then why doesn't the AA big book (next edition) make the changes so hundreds of thousands of people across the world can enjoy a new-found sense of acceptance and inclusiveness?

I don't think spirituality is all there is to it. Early Bill and Bob found they had best results for themselves just by talking to another alky. For mine that is still the best foundation for sobriety.

At this point, it'd be too late for me anyway. I will no longer go to AA meetings mainly because I no longer believe addiction to be a spiritual problem requiring a spiritual solution. Don't care to support that model any longer.

I sincerely wish you well.
 
Hang on.
Hard or soft never came into it and now that it has I will happily agree. The hard line atheist is the one I am talking about and would suggest that this is done on faith - a belief rather than evidence. Fair enough? I am not sure however that this hard atheist is "rare", but I will be happy for you to show otherwise.
The soft atheist very close to the agnostic, and by and large those two groups are on the same page save for some semantics.

This is red herring. The burden of proof is still on you, regardless of the atheist with whom you are arguing. A negative can't be proven. I suspect you understand this, as it is logic 101.

But to keep more focused here, what you and AA are asking is not just for a belief in God, but a specific hands-on god who fixates on the problems of alcoholics, but only if they go to meetings a perform specific tasks, who didn't give a rat's ass for your condition before and only works for one day at a time -- and for us to attribute this god's magic to a person's sobriety.

And based on what evidence?

The belladonna induced revelation of a failed stock promoter; who claims to have had a white-light encounter with God.

Treated with what type of approach?

Literally the six steps of a religious cult (Oxford Group), with six more added because Belladonna Bill wanted 12, to match the 12 biblical apostles.

So, let's keep focused on what you're asking, Alfie.
 
Who says atheism is the default position?
A skeptic would surely assume the neutral position until something was proven one way or the other.

No, that's not the way it works. I'm sure you've already heard that the burden of proof is on the claimant. That means that, until the claimant has made his case, what we previously held to be true remains. In this case, namely, that there is no god.

See it this way: if you had NEVER heard of god before, you wouldn't be "neutral" as to its existence. Once the claim is made, why would you suddenly adopt a "neutral" stance towards it without cause ?

As ridiculous as it sounds, you have no idea whether there is a "miniature magical elephant" under your bed, and you won't know until we actually prove it.

It IS ridiculous. I have A LOT of reasons to believe there is no such thing under my bed. First, there are no such creatures known to exist. Second, if it's invisible, how can the person make this claim ? Third, where's the evidence ?

I make the claim right now, Alfie, that there IS such an elephant under your bed. Are you "neutral" about this claim ? Be honest, now. Don't tell me you "don't know".

Sure it seems silly but a smart person dismisses nothing and checks everything before being certain, only a fool would be certain without checking.

Incorrect. A smart person is pragmatic. There's no reason to give equal weight to every claim, no matter how silly it sounds. There is every reason to dismiss a claim until it is shown to be true.

A person who is as certain there is no god, has the same amount of faith as the person who is certain there is.

That doesn't even make sense. How can lack of faith be a faith in and of itself ? Alfie, it sounds to me as though you are so entrenched at defending the ideas you've promoted in this thread that you are willing to go to any length to maintain that position. There is no shame in admitting that you are wrong.
 
What am I asking Jack?
For you to believe in a higher power?
For you to believe that AA is the only way to get sober?
The Bill W was a saint?
That atheism is the same as theism?
Just what am I asking Jack? :rolleyes:

You seem to be trying to set a worlds record for straw in a single post. :)
 
No, that's not the way it works. I'm sure you've already heard that the burden of proof is on the claimant. That means that, until the claimant has made his case, what we previously held to be true remains. In this case, namely, that there is no god.

And my point is simply that if someone makes the claim "there is no god. Period". They can no more prove it thatn the theist that says "there is a god".

Both come from a position if belief, not fact

See it this way: if you had NEVER heard of god before, you wouldn't be "neutral" as to its existence.

Sure you would. You would neither believe nor disbelieve, ergo neutral.

Once the claim is made, why would you suddenly adopt a "neutral" stance towards it without cause ?

So you are saying that as soon as someone tells you something, you either believe or disbelieve? On the spot? Without checking anything? You already know the answer? You are saying that you cannot take a neutral stance under these circumstances?
Wow, you are bright.

It IS ridiculous. I have A LOT of reasons to believe there is no such thing under my bed. First, there are no such creatures known to exist. Second, if it's invisible, how can the person make this claim ? Third, where's the evidence ?

He he.
Look, I know there is no elephant under your bed and you know it too. But I just wanted to play with your strawman a while to see where it goes. It seems to have made you a bit angry actually.

I make the claim right now, Alfie, that there IS such an elephant under your bed. Are you "neutral" about this claim ? Be honest, now. Don't tell me you "don't know".

Very angry. :)
 
No, in fact you are making sense to me, and for the most part I agree. I really didn't want to make this an issue about whether atheists have a type of faith or not. I have no beef with atheists and may actually be one myself going by some people's definition. For mine it is one of semantics; my point is in the absense of absolute proof, absolute certainty is unobtainable and a level of faith is required.

I think one obvious difference between the "belief" of religion and the "belief" of the vast majority of atheists, is that in religion, if you hold fast to your belief despite evidence to the contrary, it's considered being good, faithful, devoted, etc.

If the "belief" is arrived at through the scientific method, as many atheists would say their belief is, then holding fast to it despite evidence to the contrary is considered silly, close-minded, etc.

There are many religious people who would say (true or not) that nothing would shake their faith in god. There are few atheists who would say that no matter how much evidence they were shown for a god, they still wouldn't believe it existed.

(Edited to add: Including all possible hypothetical evidence, of course, not just what theists currently offer as evidence.)
 
Last edited:
Who says atheism is the default position?
A skeptic would surely assume the neutral position until something was proven one way or the other.

Really AA Alfie?

What a load of crap.

You have been on this forum since 2009 and you still have such messed up notions?

The burden of proof is on the positive claim, unless you want to believe in fairies and other twaddle.

Next up

"Homeopathy cures alcoholism!"
 
For mine it is one of semantics; my point is in the absense of absolute proof, absolute certainty is unobtainable and a level of faith is required.

Um, no.

Homeopathy has no shown effect, I do not have to assume that it must be shown to be false.

It is upon the proponent to show it does have an effect.

Next up

"Believe in fairies cures alcoholism!"
 
A.A. Alfie said:
Indeed, I wasn't trying to be comprehensive.

I have been searching for these answers for a long time. People keep making the assertions that there are studies, but I've never seen them.

Studies about what, then, exactly? Studies which show the efficacy of various treatment modalities regarding chemical dependency? No one has produced any of these? http://www.spectrum.niaaa.nih.gov/features/Alcoholism.aspx

Some excerpts include:
  • Many heavy drinkers do not have alcohol dependence. For example, even in people who have 5 or more drinks a day (the equivalent of a bottle of wine) the rate of developing dependence is less than 7 percent per year.
  • Most persons who develop alcohol dependence have mild to moderate disorder, in which they primarily experience impaired control. For example, they set limits and go over them or find it difficult to quit or cut down. In general, these people do not have severe alcohol-related relationship, health, vocational or legal problems.
  • About 70 percent of affected persons have a single episode of less than 4 years. The remainder experience an average of five episodes. Thus, it appears that there are two forms of alcohol dependence: time-limited, and recurrent or chronic.
  • Although 22 is the average age when alcohol dependence begins, the onset varies from the mid-teens to middle age.
  • Twenty years after onset of alcohol dependence, about three-fourths of individuals are in full recovery; more than half of those who have fully recovered drink at low-risk levels without symptoms of alcohol dependence.
  • About 75 percent of persons who recover from alcohol dependence do so without seeking any kind of help, including specialty alcohol (rehab) programs and AA. Only 13 percent of people with alcohol dependence ever receive specialty alcohol treatment.




I think you must have missed my point. The problem isn't with the treatment options listed per se, but the rankings - the options themselves are fine but in terms of efficacy for treating alcoholism/dependence they are miles off the mark and the results dubious at best.

Alright, I hear you. Miles off the mark in what sense, then? Compared to results you've seen from other studies? From informal results seen at your treatment agency?



I don't think spirituality is all there is to it. Early Bill and Bob found they had best results for themselves just by talking to another alky. For mine that is still the best foundation for sobriety.

And I'm glad as well that you've found something that has been effective and produced a lot more peace and happiness in your life. My only argument is that AA, even from it's foundation, is more than just simply sharing one's 'experience strength and hope'. Though again, for many, that's been all they've needed.



I sincerely wish you well.

Thank you again! :)
 
I will no longer go to AA meetings mainly because I no longer believe addiction to be a spiritual problem requiring a spiritual solution. Don't care to support that model any longer.
Thanks for sharing.

I suspect I've been to as many AA groups & meetings as you have, and found no trace of the position that drunks fit into the category "addiction to be a spiritual problem requiring a spiritual solution".

Next anecdote?
 
The spiritual disease is actually the foundation of the AA 12-step program, is found in the 'Big Book'. It permeates AA. I would love to see this separate AA universe described in this thread where the 'Big Book' is simply a historical document, and there is none the spiritual disease nonsense, and religiosity doesn't ooze from every pore.

Of course, then it wouldn't be AA.
 
I think one obvious difference between the "belief" of religion and the "belief" of the vast majority of atheists, is that in religion, if you hold fast to your belief despite evidence to the contrary, it's considered being good, faithful, devoted, etc.

If the "belief" is arrived at through the scientific method, as many atheists would say their belief is, then holding fast to it despite evidence to the contrary is considered silly, close-minded, etc.

There are many religious people who would say (true or not) that nothing would shake their faith in god. There are few atheists who would say that no matter how much evidence they were shown for a god, they still wouldn't believe it existed.

(Edited to add: Including all possible hypothetical evidence, of course, not just what theists currently offer as evidence.)

Thanks!! It was very well said.
 
What am I asking Jack?
For you to believe in a higher power?
For you to believe that AA is the only way to get sober?
The Bill W was a saint?
That atheism is the same as theism?Just what am I asking Jack? :rolleyes:

You seem to be trying to set a worlds record for straw in a single post. :)

And my point is simply that if someone makes the claim "there is no god. Period". They can no more prove it thatn the theist that says "there is a god".
Both come from a position if belief, not fact



Sure you would. You would neither believe nor disbelieve, ergo neutral.



So you are saying that as soon as someone tells you something, you either believe or disbelieve? On the spot? Without checking anything? You already know the answer? You are saying that you cannot take a neutral stance under these circumstances?
Wow, you are bright.



He he.
Look, I know there is no elephant under your bed and you know it too. But I just wanted to play with your strawman a while to see where it goes. It seems to have made you a bit angry actually.



Very angry. :)

Yes, you are saying that atheism and theism are the same.
 
And my point is simply that if someone makes the claim "there is no god. Period". They can no more prove it thatn the theist that says "there is a god".

Both come from a position if belief, not fact

No, they don't. This is a crucial point that you fail to understand.

So you are saying that as soon as someone tells you something, you either believe or disbelieve? On the spot? Without checking anything? You already know the answer? You are saying that you cannot take a neutral stance under these circumstances?

It all depends on what you are meaning by "neutral". But in all cases you are NOT believing in God, and are therefore an atheist.

But both in the case of god and in the case of the magical elephant, there is not only no reason to believe it is true, but also reason to believe it is not. The "not" position is much more reasonable.

Look, I know there is no elephant under your bed and you know it too.

According to your own reasoning, you DON'T know. How would you know that there is such a thing under my bed or not ? Have you checked ?

It seems to have made you a bit angry actually.

What it seems is that you are a very poor mind-reader, troll.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom