The Norseman
Meandering fecklessly
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2008
- Messages
- 8,494
Yes, you did and I appreciate you honestly answering my questions even so.Actually I asked you what treatments there are and what the efficacy of each was in treating alcoholics.
I have a number of different treatment options to use including a number of detox centres (home based, in house), rehab options (short, medium and long term) some 12 step, some not. We are always in need of more of these types of facilities but there are quite a lot of them; there is always a shortage of beds especially for those without private health cover.
Where there is a dearth is in the maintenance programs. AA - obviously, SMART, ongoing counselling and therapy. There is little else.
So when people say "there are other evidence based teatment", I want to know what they are.
Well, there are medical/pharmacologically based treatments; there are different types of counseling and therapy depending on the school of thought (I mentioned RET as one example earlier and there is brief therapy -- which I understood it in the sense of meeting with a counselor once a week for two months and not this absurd notion of "treatment" consisting of meeting once with your primary care physician -- as well as CBT, AA's spiritual disease model, the more mainstream disease model, etc.), so lumping all this and more into saying 'ongoing counseling and therapy' is kinda missing the trees for the forest.
So, while some therapies (so-called) seem a bit silly, I wonder if they are truly more effective than AA or not.
Correct, and I was testing you. Sorry.
No worries, mate! As long as it's intended as good-natured, I'm willing to take it.
Just have a look through..
Come on!?
Do you seriously want to rest on this list as evidence for the treatment of alcohol dependence?
Sure. I do, mainly because there are 48 listed modalities; there are ample to choose from if the first dozen don't strike your fancy, or are too woo or are absurd on the face of it. Some of the categories I find to be odd, but if this website just collects the data and is making a meta-data report, then there still can be some value in it.
"Take what you want" is what might be said in an AA meeting in terms of that program. In practice a client will do this too with the potential list of solutions that might be discovered, tabled and explored. It is not the role of a counsellor to tell people what to do. I think #2 said it well about what a therapist/counsellor might do: "Objective feedback from the assessment that is provided in a low-key way that does not label you or push you into doing anything you don't want to do"
Yes, I agree. AA's program was never intended, however, to be taken as one wished and I would hazard to say that most AAs still feel the same way. One must admit that there is a certain amount of logic in thinking that an alcoholic has, up until then, made rather poor decisions regarding his life, yet bringing him into a program which encourages him to continue to "take what he wants and leave the rest" isn't a recipe for sure success.
As with a doctor's prescription, the doctor certainly won't force you to take the medicine as prescribed, yet the doctor will tell you that by following it as prescribed, you will gain the maximum efficacy of the medication (ignoring for this illustration the sometimes lethal side effects or severe complications that suddenly stopping taking a medication or taking a medication sporadically can do).
Same as I see it with a therapist. The therapist does not tell the client what to do, but says "follow these guidelines for the best success rate". AA was always intended to do the same thing. That is why I still can make the reasonable conclusion that AA is still religiously-based. "Taking what you want and leaving the rest" was never a part of it (and actively derided as bad decision-making), the AA World Organization has made no changes whatsoever to the core AA material, and has even gone so far as to remove official recognition to groups which do make more secular changes.
If 'spirituality' was all there really was to it, even today, then why doesn't the AA big book (next edition) make the changes so hundreds of thousands of people across the world can enjoy a new-found sense of acceptance and inclusiveness?
At this point, it'd be too late for me anyway. I will no longer go to AA meetings mainly because I no longer believe addiction to be a spiritual problem requiring a spiritual solution. Don't care to support that model any longer.