Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Any alcoholic who can't blame his problems on something outside himself isn't trying.

Which is why alchoholics who blamie their drinking on an imaginary disease are not taking responsibility for their actions. Drinking is a choice, so only when alchoholics choose not to drink, and accept responsibility for their poor (and positive) decisions, will they overcome an addiction. Their success or failure will due to their own action or inaction.

Imaginary skygods if anything hinder a person's ability to improve themselves (as religions promote self loathing)
 
Asserting that the criticism is invalid doesn't, in fact, make it invalid.

And I never said that his parody was invalid; I just said that your asserting that I was dismissing a valid criticism was an assertion without evidence.

I also explained previously why the power greater than oneself can be anything and why placing a belief in a power greater than oneself may be helpful, while the belief that the power greater than oneself may not be literally effective in maintaining sobriety. All I got in response was a not-so-clever parody of the Steps the seemed not to take into account anything I said.
 
Please elaborate.

As a professional I am always looking for the fullest range of treatment options to offer clients. Please do not misconstrue my support for AA as a lack of support for other modalities; I have never said and never would say that "AA is the only way" (or similar). Your comment above was in response to a discussion on how I apply the steps in a personal way that works for me.


What other treatment options do you offer your clients? I'd be grateful to know how similar ChemDep treatment is in Australia versus what I know of in the states. I can tell you that here, it depends on the treatment agency whether or not they are focused on RET, for example. But it's nearly universal that AA is offered and in many places, preached on as the only solution. It's sad, really, IMO.

At any rate, there's AA's spiritual disease model, there's a more AMA disease model (which I personally subscribed to, but am now having doubts about), there's a model of genetic predisposition, and there's a purely behaviorist model of addiction. I'm thinking you're really aware of all of these and perhaps more, but are trying to call me out.





So I would be sincerely grateful if you would provide the names of these other models and (more importantly) their efficacy in treating alcoholics.

I have been asking for results like these for a year now and so far no one has been able to provide anything of value or accuracy.

Cheers



It has been pointed out time and again, by myself and others, that this site has a ranking system they've created that links to definitions and studies that the data has been drawn from. Disagree with the ranking system, I don't really care. But there have been studies done -- and meta-studies done as well -- to find out the efficacy of various treatment modalities, including AA. They list 48 of them, in fact; all of which you may feel free to dispute. I have been following this thread and have also been reading links provided by "your side" such as the Green Papers; I don't consider myself anti-AA per se. I do think there are better methods that people would be better able to make informed decisions if they only knew these alternates existed, just like what I think happened to me, in this very thread no less.

Of course, we still have AA zealots who rail on about how AA is FREE and is the only thing FREE and is the BEST thing because it's FREE, even though time and again, it's been pointed out that there are other alternatives which are FREE as well; even more successful than AA as shown in the link above and FREE.





But I'm curious Alfie: do you counsel your clients who come to you for family issues, say, to do whatever they want? If so, what role do you play in that dynamic? If you don't counsel them to do whatever they want, why not? Do you hand them a book (like John Bradshaw's Bradshaw On: the Family) and tell them to read it and "take what they want and leave the rest"? What I'm trying to understand is that if "take what you want...etc." is an effective means of coming to some sort of solution for addiction, then can it successfully be applied to other areas of mental health problems.
 
And I never said that his parody was invalid; I just said that your asserting that I was dismissing a valid criticism was an assertion without evidence.

I also explained previously why the power greater than oneself can be anything and why placing a belief in a power greater than oneself may be helpful, while the belief that the power greater than oneself may not be literally effective in maintaining sobriety. All I got in response was a not-so-clever parody of the Steps the seemed not to take into account anything I said.


I was personally not limiting myself to the parody; I was making a more general comment that you have come across to me as dismissing any criticism, valid or not, as invalid and I found that to be a shame.

I, as always, could be wrong or I may have misunderstood you at some point or another.
 
You either misunderstood or were pretending to.

How does dropping the references to God "preclude the membership of those that do have religious convictions?"

Secular <> anti-religion

I have a hard time believing you're not aware of this.

If he were it would be particularily hypocritical as well, since Alfie keeps claiming that the references to god do NOT preclude _atheist_ membership...
 
If he were it would be particularily hypocritical as well, since Alfie keeps claiming that the references to god do NOT preclude _atheist_ membership...

They don't. There are people who identify as atheists and are members of AA.
 
They don't. There are people who identify as atheists and are members of AA.

I don't think anyone here is disputing that.

There are really two separate questions here:
1. Is AA religious?
2. If AA is religious, is that a bad thing (because it discourages atheists, or because of church/state issues, or otherwise)?

As to (1), the "precluding membership" thing is a bit of a red herring to begin with. Alfie seems to think that, if there isn't some AA authority at the door saying "no atheists allowed," then AA is not religious. It's been pointed out repeatedly that plenty of indisputably religious organizations allow atheists to visit their churches, attend their meetings, etc. The Catholic church is a religious organization even though I could sit in the pews any time if I so chose, without any lying or pretense required.

As to (2), if one believes that AA is religious, there is a sense in which one can argue that the religious nature "precludes" at least some atheists -- the ones who aren't comfortable with turning their life over to some "higher power," etc. But I think "discourages" or "deters" is a better word than "precludes," because the latter is open to the bouncer-at-the-door interpretation. And no, not all atheists would be discouraged, just as many atheists regularly attend church services because they like the music, want to please a family member, or otherwise feel they are getting something out of it. And some atheists probably believe that AA really isn't religious.
 
False equivocation, actually. Not to derail this thread further, but in the absence of evidence for a claim, one can reasonably provisionably assume that the claim is false. This is not a matter of faith but one of pragmatism.

I assume you are an atheist. How do you know there is no god?
The fact is you cannot know, therefore you are taking it in faith.

You either misunderstood or were pretending to.

Your concession is appreciated.

I did misunderstand , my apologies it was unintentional.
Would you mind rephrasing the question? I have an awful flu at the moment and my powers (so to speak) are somewhat reduced.

Only if one states, "I believe there is no god.", that is faith.

If one states "I have seen no evidence to lead me to beleive there is agod.", that is not faith.

Yep.

Nope the burden of proof is on the positive claim, every time.

If one says "there is no god", that sounds pretty positive to me.

Which is why alchoholics who blamie their drinking on an imaginary disease are not taking responsibility for their actions.

And those that do that are copping out. AA does not teach this, you have been watching too much South Park.

Drinking is a choice, so only when alchoholics choose not to drink, and accept responsibility for their poor (and positive) decisions, will they overcome an addiction. Their success or failure will due to their own action or inaction.

Correct.

What other treatment options do you offer your clients?

Actually I asked you what treatments there are and what the efficacy of each was in treating alcoholics.

I have a number of different treatment options to use including a number of detox centres (home based, in house), rehab options (short, medium and long term) some 12 step, some not. We are always in need of more of these types of facilities but there are quite a lot of them; there is always a shortage of beds especially for those without private health cover.
Where there is a dearth is in the maintenance programs. AA - obviously, SMART, ongoing counselling and therapy. There is little else.

So when people say "there are other evidence based teatment", I want to know what they are.

This comment is seen time and again, yet with nothing to support it.

At any rate, there's AA's spiritual disease model, there's a more AMA disease model (which I personally subscribed to, but am now having doubts about), there's a model of genetic predisposition, and there's a purely behaviorist model of addiction. I'm thinking you're really aware of all of these and perhaps more, but are trying to call me out.

Correct, and I was testing you. Sorry.

It has been pointed out time and again, by myself and others, that RL="http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm"]this site [/URL]has a ranking system they've created that links to definitions and studies that the data has been drawn from. Disagree with the ranking system, I don't really care. But there have been studies done -- and meta-studies done as well -- to find out the efficacy of various treatment modalities, including AA. They list 48 of them, in fact; all of which you may feel free to dispute. I have been following this thread and have also been reading links provided by "your side" such as the Green Papers; I don't consider myself anti-AA per se. I do think there are better methods that people would be better able to make informed decisions if they only knew these alternates existed, just like what I think happened to me, in this very thread no less.

Just have a look through..

#1 treatment
Brief Interventions
Brief interventions are usually given by healthcare providers. If you have a good working relationship with your personal physician, this is a good starting point. He or she can screen you for possible alcohol problems and assess whether your drinking or drug use is putting your health at risk or causing problems of which you might not be aware. Your physician may also suggest a more comprehensive assessment of your drinking and/or drug use and suggest other resources in your community.

If you don't have a good working relationship with a physician, consider one of the Motivational enhancement options in the next section.


So Brief Interventions are supposed to be the best form of treatment for alcohol dependence? Really? It is merely a screening or assessment at best.

It then says to do the Motivational enhancement options which is

#2
Motivational enhancement
Motivational enhancement is similar to brief intervention but it is often done by a psychologist, counselor, or therapist with some expertise in alcohol and drug problems. It's also known as a brief motivational intervention. The intervention is usually brief (1-4 sessions) and includes

- A thorough assessment of your drinking, drug use, risk factors, family history, alcohol and/or drug related problems, level of dependence, and motivation
- Objective feedback from the assessment that is provided in a low-key way that does not label you or push you into doing anything you don't want to do
- Motivational enhancement that helps you consider the good things and not-so-good things about your drinking and drug use. This aspect is designed to help you resolve your ambivalence about your drinking and/or drug use.


This too is little more more than an assessment too and it is supposed to be the second most effective treatment?

Come on!?
Do you seriously want to rest on this list as evidence for the treatment of alcohol dependence?

But I'm curious Alfie: do you counsel your clients who come to you for family issues, say, to do whatever they want? If so, what role do you play in that dynamic? If you don't counsel them to do whatever they want, why not? Do you hand them a book (like John Bradshaw's Bradshaw On: the Family) and tell them to read it and "take what they want and leave the rest"? What I'm trying to understand is that if "take what you want...etc." is an effective means of coming to some sort of solution for addiction, then can it successfully be applied to other areas of mental health problems.

"Take what you want" is what might be said in an AA meeting in terms of that program. In practice a client will do this too with the potential list of solutions that might be discovered, tabled and explored. It is not the role of a counsellor to tell people what to do. I think #2 said it well about what a therapist/counsellor might do: "Objective feedback from the assessment that is provided in a low-key way that does not label you or push you into doing anything you don't want to do"


I hope that answers your leading questions.
 
Last edited:
I assume you are an atheist. How do you know there is no god?
The fact is you cannot know, therefore you are taking it in faith.

Your premise is false, therefore your conclusion is not sound.

I have already explained, in the very post you were quoting, that atheism is the default position; a provisional conclusion based on a complete lack of evidence. It is not a faith, but a total absence of it.

If someone says "there is an invisible miniature magical elephant under my bed" I don't need to prove that it isn't there in order to reach the very reasonable conclusion that it isn't. The absence of any demonstration that it's there is enough, until such a time as new evidence is introduced.

Do you think that my conclusion that there ISN'T such a creature under my bed is due to faith ?
 
Last edited:
Your premise is false, therefore your conclusion is not sound.

I have already explained, in the very post you were quoting, that atheism is the default position; a provisional conclusion based on a complete lack of evidence. It is not a faith, but a total absence of it.

If someone says "there is an invisible miniature magical elephant under my bed" I don't need to prove that it isn't there in order to reach the very reasonable conclusion that it isn't. The absence of any demonstration that it's there is enough, until such a time as new evidence is introduced.

Do you think that my conclusion that there ISN'T such a creature under my bed is due to faith ?

Who says atheism is the default position?
A skeptic would surely assume the neutral position until something was proven one way or the other.
As ridiculous as it sounds, you have no idea whether there is a "miniature magical elephant" under your bed, and you won't know until we actually prove it.

Sure it seems silly but a smart person dismisses nothing and checks everything before being certain, only a fool would be certain without checking.

A person who is as certain there is no god, has the same amount of faith as the person who is certain there is.

Are you an atheist?
 
Last edited:
Who says atheism is the default position?
A skeptic would surely assume the neutral position until something was proven one way or the other.
As ridiculous as it sounds, you have no idea whether there is a "miniature magical elephant" under your bed, and you won't know until we actually prove it.

Sure it seems silly but a smart person dismisses nothing and checks everything before being certain, only a fool would be certain without checking.

A person who is as certain there is no god, has the same amount of faith as the person who is certain there is.

Are you an atheist?

The reason the skeptical position assumes there is no monster under the bed is the fact that every time we look under the bed, there is nothing there. The monster and no monster propositions are not of equal value. There is no reason to think a skeptic should always take the neutral position.

Most atheists don't say "there is no god". We say "what is this god you speak of?". Then we find it's made up and is backed by absolutely no evidence. You clearly need to try really hard to understand what the atheist position means and what skepticism really is.

What you're saying is a lot like saying you have a fifty fifty chance of winning the lottery. I win or I don't.
 
Last edited:
No wonder AAAlfie has such a problem admitting AA is a religious program - after all this time, he doesn't even understand the difference between Strong Atheism (Rare, such a person claims there is no god) and Weak Atheism (Nearly all athiests, such a person says 'without evidence - extraordinary evidence - there is no reason to believe any god(s) exist').

This means he also doesn't understand the burden of proof as a logical concept. Nor is he likely to, from the way he's posting.

I still can't wrap my head around the fact that he actually thinks atheism is a faith-based belief....such a claim is not only unfounded, but insulting and stupid.

A lost cause, if you ask me (not that anyone has) :)
 
Hang on.
Hard or soft never came into it and now that it has I will happily agree. The hard line atheist is the one I am talking about and would suggest that this is done on faith - a belief rather than evidence. Fair enough? I am not sure however that this hard atheist is "rare", but I will be happy for you to show otherwise.
The soft atheist very close to the agnostic, and by and large those two groups are on the same page save for some semantics.

Which higher power did you use in AA again Tinyal?
 
Last edited:
Even the hardest atheist stance is not based on any sort of faith.
Perhaps absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, but absence of evidence for claims for which evidence should clearly have been found by now is enough for some to take a conditional strong position against the claim.

If that position is then deemed to be based on faith, so what? That doesn't make it in any way similar to actual faith as we understand it.

How many ghosts stories do you have to debunk before you can say there's no such thing as a ghost?
The technical answer is: all of them. But after debunking every story for years, a strong "aghostist" position can make a lot of sense.

[I'm not sure how clear all this is, but I feel better now.]
 
Last edited:
No, in fact you are making sense to me, and for the most part I agree. I really didn't want to make this an issue about whether atheists have a type of faith or not. I have no beef with atheists and may actually be one myself going by some people's definition. For mine it is one of semantics; my point is in the absense of absolute proof, absolute certainty is unobtainable and a level of faith is required.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom