Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Who do have you in mind, offering valid, non-derisive criticisms?


There are several.


Asserting that the criticism is valid doesn't, in fact make it valid.


Asserting that the criticism is invalid doesn't, in fact, make it invalid.




Correct.
My version is something like this:
Quite versatile the steps, aren't they?
That does not make what I said incorrect does it? In fact, it seems to me you confirm it.
Spirituality by definition can be anything. You want to call your spirituality "healthy living". And that's great, judging by the very little I know of you, it seems that it works just fine.


Again, you're doing something; it just ain't AA. Or maybe you can point out again in the official literature where it says that you can "take what you want and leave the rest"?

I find it rather confusing that the same group that says, "your best thinking got you here" also seems to think they have the capacity to know what's really good for them and "leave the rest."



My point exactly, Thanks. This is what agnostics and atheists are doing within AA. Folks whether you want to accept it or not people are going to AA that do not believe in God or spirituality. They are deliberately removing the Ecclesiastical covenants and replacing them with a scientific power of their understanding. Most of you (members of JREF) already do that in your lives. Why is it so far fetched to entertain AA'ers doing it. Oh!! I know because the Big Book doesn't say you can do it. Well it does just read carefully, Bill W. was hiding it.
AA's evolving.


LOL. Evidence? Or is this that pesky, "take what you want and leave the rest" make it up as you go and it's all good evolution?



Really!?
So lets say someone is behaving in a way that is out of character, say immorally. But this is an aberration. You can't see that this person has a better self or higher self; one with more control etc?
That is what I might call "better self"; I'm not sure where you are coming from.
Alcoholics are those whose moral compass gets lost along the way; reinstilling better behaviours and seeking those answers from what our real values are is what I'm talking about.
Perhaps you could elaborate on why you think there is no "higher or better self"


These are only how AA views alcoholism; there are other, more valid models to better define and treat addiction. You know, you may be a therapist, but you certainly don't seem to be a chemical dependency professional.
 
Last edited:
These are only how AA views alcoholism; there are other, more valid models to better define and treat addiction. You know, you may be a therapist, but you certainly don't seem to be a chemical dependency professional.

Please elaborate.

As a professional I am always looking for the fullest range of treatment options to offer clients. Please do not misconstrue my support for AA as a lack of support for other modalities; I have never said and never would say that "AA is the only way" (or similar). Your comment above was in response to a discussion on how I apply the steps in a personal way that works for me.

So I would be sincerely grateful if you would provide the names of these other models and (more importantly) their efficacy in treating alcoholics.

I have been asking for results like these for a year now and so far no one has been able to provide anything of value or accuracy.

Cheers
 
Last edited:
Is not collecting stamps a hobby ?

Yes we have no bananas.

Actually Bill T has a point of view that many agnostics hold. Simply put:

Given the lack of evidence to prove a higher power or god, a belief in one is a matter of faith.

Given the lack of evidence disproving a higher power or god, a disbelief in one is a matter of faith.

"Only fools can be certain, it takes wisdom to be confused"
anon
 
Last edited:
People here have already proposed this. You're not saying anything new or novel there. But we've been told you can't be your own higher power.

Well, can you or can't you be your own higher power?

That's the problem with trying to defend a position at all costs. At some point you are forced to defend contradictory propositions, and make up reasons why they can both be true.
 
I have an athiest friend who is an alcoholic. Is it better to be an alcoholic than to be religious? He clearly credits his lack of faith to his alcoholism.

I consider athiesm a faith too.

So you dissagree with your friend on the cause of his alcoholism, right?

But, regardless, is being religious the lesser of the two evils if your other choice is destroying your liver, your family, your life, and going into convulsions?

false dichotomy.
 
Yes we have no bananas.

Actually Bill T has a point of view that many agnostics hold. Simply put:

Given the lack of evidence to prove a higher power or god, a belief in one is a matter of faith.

Given the lack of evidence disproving a higher power or god, a disbelief in one is a matter of faith.

"Only fools can be certain, it takes wisdom to be confused"
anon

But the problem with AA or any other religion, is they ask us to pre-suppose that God is the answer to what can't be explained. I'm guessing this video may been posted here before, but it hits close to home in looking at the open-mindedness AAs ask: Open-mindedness
 
Yes we have no bananas.

Actually Bill T has a point of view that many agnostics hold. Simply put:

Given the lack of evidence to prove a higher power or god, a belief in one is a matter of faith.

Given the lack of evidence disproving a higher power or god, a disbelief in one is a matter of faith.

"Only fools can be certain, it takes wisdom to be confused"
anon

Anon has based this statement on a series of logical fallacies in an attempt to make the two statements:

1- Given the lack of evidence to prove a higher power or god,

2- Given the lack of evidence disproving a higher power or god,

appear equally likely. They aren't.
 
These are only how AA views alcoholism; there are other, more valid models to better define and treat addiction. You know, you may be a therapist, but you certainly don't seem to be a chemical dependency professional.

This goes back to AA's disease model of alcoholism. It just isn't true but people buy into it because it makes them, and their alcoholism, a badge of honour. And they wear that badge loud and proud.

What is the cure rate of cancer 12 step programs? How about MS 12 step programs?

AA does what many religions do. It makes people "lay" ministers for the cause and makes them feel their work is very important. As we know from studies on motivation and drive, this is far more powerful than offering people money to do the job.
 
What is the cure rate of cancer 12 step programs? How about MS 12 step programs?

docexam.jpeg
 
Given the lack of evidence to prove a higher power or god, a belief in one is a matter of faith.

Given the lack of evidence disproving a higher power or god, a disbelief in one is a matter of faith.

False equivocation, actually. Not to derail this thread further, but in the absence of evidence for a claim, one can reasonably provisionably assume that the claim is false. This is not a matter of faith but one of pragmatism.
 
But that would then preclude the membership of those that do have religious convictions. The doors are open to one and all. Or have I misunderstood?

You either misunderstood or were pretending to.

How does dropping the references to God "preclude the membership of those that do have religious convictions?"

Secular <> anti-religion

I have a hard time believing you're not aware of this.

Nobody has proposed adding something like "because there is no god." Are the Girl Guides of Canada precluding the membership of religious people because they dropped the religious bits from their motto?

Incidentally, though, I note your implication that something in the steps could "preclude the membership" of someone who takes issue with it. Up until now, you've been insisting over and over again that it doesn't matter because the steps aren't mandatory, "take what you want and leave the rest," and if there's no bouncer at the door excluding non-religious people then the organization can't possibly be religious. Your concession is appreciated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom