Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The answer is that it is not the object that is literally performing the actions that keeps the person sober; it is what the person believes about the object that allows the person reconceptualize their relationship to the world in such a way that makes it possible for them to maintain their sobriety.

Sometimes it helps the person in question to externalize that reconceptualization and call it "God" (in the sense that is most familiar to us in our Abrahamic religion-influenced society), but such externalization is not necessary to benefit from AA. However, it is also interesting to note that at least one secular recovery program, Rational Recovery, depends on "otherizing" the urge to use and use a "therapy", AVRT (Addictive Voice Recognition Therapy) to suppress the "Addictive Voice" of the "The Beast". While AVRT is a firmly secular alternative to AA, it is far from rational, because it involves identifying a part of one's cognitive apparatus as being "not oneself" without offering any evidence that it is not part of the self. In fact, Rational Recovery founder, Jack Trimpey, bills his book on AVRT as "[c]leanly divorcing AVRT from science, clinical thought, and religion, the The Art of AVRT takes AVRT to the next phase, exposing the AV in the world around us".

In sum, the effectiveness of the power greater than oneself depends not on any quality inherent to the whatever one chooses as one's power greater than oneself but on one's belief about the chosen power greater than oneself. Moreover, secular alternatives to AA do not necessarily avoid making unwarranted assumptions about the nature of addiction.

Hmm, it has been a while since I read Trimpey, it sounds as though they have moved off the CBT path and into woo, the addicted self talk is always part of oneself, perhaps some people find help by decoupling it to such an extenet but that seems rather lunatic to me, it is usuallu changing teh behavior in response to the cogntions, and chnaging the cognitions in response to the behaviors, sounds very odd. Not CBt at all

Ooooog, how yucky!

The ANIMAL VOICE, what a load a hellenistic victorian duality and twaddle.

http://www.avrt.com/

has some sense, it looks like it started down the correct path and then got all crazy.

Trimppey was always a little over the top and in fact RR has had some factional warfare.
 
It wasn't Danny B, it was me. And it wasn't a parody. I am very serious. I know, it looks like a parody to actually see it, but that is exactly what you are advocating when you place some object in place of God. You're asking for special pleading, and to say one can use a tree as his or her higher power, and the AA program specifically has steps that entail praying to that power and asking it to perform specific tasks. I'm just asking to explain how that works.

So, how can the moon or a chia pet do these things? It's a very serious question.

The problem, as I see it, is that you neglected to include doorknobs and rocks. :cool:
 
Does this work for everyone probably not, AA (even though Bill W. might have wanted to believe) is not a "one size fits all". At least that is not how it has evolved. IMO!

Correct.


My version is something like this:

Step 2: Came to believe that abstinence, new life skills and positive people could restore us to sanity.

Step 3: Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of fate, where I have no control.

Step 5: Admitted to the wind (i.e. out loud), to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

Step 6: Were entirely ready to work consciously to remove all these defects of character.

Step 7: Humbly asked my better self to remove our shortcomings.

Step 11: Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with my higher self, praying only for knowledge of it's will for us and the power to carry that out.

Quite versatile the steps, aren't they?

Spirituality is usually nonsense.

Healthy living is another issue, one can have purpose and meaning without the drivel, one can also have a sense of interdependence without the drivel.

There is NO spirit, hence no spirituality, it is nonsense, take what is good, deconstract it and call it something else.

That does not make what I said incorrect does it? In fact, it seems to me you confirm it.
Spirituality by definition can be anything. You want to call your spirituality "healthy living". And that's great, judging by the very little I know of you, it seems that it works just fine.
 
Correct.


My version is something like this:



Quite versatile the steps, aren't they?



That does not make what I said incorrect does it? In fact, it seems to me you confirm it.
Spirituality by definition can be anything. You want to call your spirituality "healthy living". And that's great, judging by the very little I know of you, it seems that it works just fine.

There is no evidence for a "higher self". And if the higher power is yourself, then it gets occammed out, since you're supposed to be powerless...
 
There is no evidence for a "higher self". And if the higher power is yourself, then it gets occammed out, since you're supposed to be powerless...

Also the "fate, where I have no control."

No evidence for "fate," and saying you have no control simply means you will never get better, never recover, because you have failed to re-take the control you've lost.
 
Alfie, it looks you just piecemealed your own program together, and aren't really even doing the AA program. Kind of a secular program with an AA tag slapped on it. It's like replacing every part of a Ford with parts from a Volvo, but still calling it a Ford.

So, what are you doing that is essentially AA?
 
Spirituality is usually nonsense.

Healthy living is another issue, one can have purpose and meaning without the drivel, one can also have a sense of interdependence without the drivel.

There is NO spirit, hence no spirituality, it is nonsense, take what is good, deconstract it and call it something else.

My point exactly, Thanks. This is what agnostics and atheists are doing within AA. Folks whether you want to accept it or not people are going to AA that do not believe in God or spirituality. They are deliberately removing the Ecclesiastical covenants and replacing them with a scientific power of their understanding. Most of you (members of JREF) already do that in your lives. Why is it so far fetched to entertain AA'ers doing it. Oh!! I know because the Big Book doesn't say you can do it. Well it does just read carefully, Bill W. was hiding it.
AA's evolving.
 
I feel so angry that the majority of people don't question AA at all.:mad:

I have an athiest friend who is an alcoholic. Is it better to be an alcoholic than to be religious? He clearly credits his lack of faith to his alcoholism.

I consider athiesm a faith too.

But, regardless, is being religious the lesser of the two evils if your other choice is destroying your liver, your family, your life, and going into convulsions?
 
There is no evidence for a "higher self". And if the higher power is yourself, then it gets occammed out, since you're supposed to be powerless...

Really!?
So lets say someone is behaving in a way that is out of character, say immorally. But this is an aberration. You can't see that this person has a better self or higher self; one with more control etc?
That is what I might call "better self"; I'm not sure where you are coming from.

Alcoholics are those whose moral compass gets lost along the way; reinstilling better behaviours and seeking those answers from what our real values are is what I'm talking about.

Perhaps you could elaborate on why you think there is no "higher or better self"


Also the "fate, where I have no control."

No evidence for "fate," and saying you have no control simply means you will never get better, never recover, because you have failed to re-take the control you've lost.

So you know when you are going to die, how long your health will last, how long you will have your job, the questions in an exam? You have control over these things? Really? You must be God. :rolleyes:

Alfie, it looks you just piecemealed your own program together, and aren't really even doing the AA program. Kind of a secular program with an AA tag slapped on it. It's like replacing every part of a Ford with parts from a Volvo, but still calling it a Ford.

Free choice, go figure. :rolleyes:

So, what are you doing that is essentially AA?

The steps, meetings, sponsors, sponsoring, self improvement, service, lifestyle balance, loving well, improving self esteem, defining my own spiritual core, education, positive people, apologising, forgiving, smiling, family, hard work, goal setting, rewarding love/sex life, being honest, eating healthily, exercising, meditating, letting go of things I can't control, self love, holidays, time out, being patient and tolerant (trying anyway he he), listening, letting go of perfection, letting go of selfishness and self pity, reviewing my character defects, compassion, courage, gratitude and not drinking.

Whew!
That's quite a list. I'm sure there is more but you get the idea.

So what am I doing? Probably all the things you're not. :)
 
Last edited:
I have an athiest friend who is an alcoholic. Is it better to be an alcoholic than to be religious? He clearly credits his lack of faith to his alcoholism.

I consider athiesm a faith too.

But, regardless, is being religious the lesser of the two evils if your other choice is destroying your liver, your family, your life, and going into convulsions?

Only the individual can answer that question.

That said, if one is looking at AA with such a narrow view, i.e. religion or death, they are not seeing the other possibilities. There is healing outside AA, there is also a different way to go about AA without the religiosity that outsiders and fundies seem to think so necessary.

But I would ask - and I mean not to be inflammatory - is your friend just making excuses not to stop? An alcoholic will often go to their graves (or worse) saying "I would rather die than get religion" when what they really mean is "I just can't stop and I want an easier softer way".

Again, I mean not to be personal towards your friend.
 
I have an athiest friend who is an alcoholic. Is it better to be an alcoholic than to be religious? He clearly credits his lack of faith to his alcoholism.

I consider athiesm a faith too.

But, regardless, is being religious the lesser of the two evils if your other choice is destroying your liver, your family, your life, and going into convulsions?

Only if snowflakes are nuclear fallout....
 
Really!?
So lets say someone is behaving in a way that is out of character, say immorally. But this is an aberration. You can't see that this person has a better self or higher self; one with more control etc?
That is what I might call "better self"; I'm not sure where you are coming from.

People here have already proposed this. You're not saying anything new or novel there. But we've been told you can't be your own higher power.

Well, can you or can't you be your own higher power?


Alcoholics are those whose moral compass gets lost along the way; reinstilling better behaviours and seeking those answers from what our real values are is what I'm talking about.

Perhaps you could elaborate on why you think there is no "higher or better self"

Though you weren't asking me, I can answer.

I do think there is the capacity in most people, though not all, to do better or be better. If you call that capacity, and the will, and the effort to do better and be better a "higher self," then you're agreeing with my point that you're the only one who can access that capacity. You're agreeing with my point that you must access that "higher self" if you're to ever have sobriety.

You're agreeing with me that god is superfluous to AA.

Now all you have to do is agree that the religious "god" aspects of this "spiritual" recovery program are unnecessary, and sometimes even a hindrance, and AA should 86 'em. AA should update its 12 Steps.


So you know when you are going to die, how long your health will last, how long you will have your job,

Within a certain time-frame, sure I do. I just haven't reached that time-frame yet.

I don't have to know when I'm going to die, to know that I am going to die. I don't have to know how long my health will last me--it's already declining, thanks--to know that health doesn't last. I don't need to know how long I'm going to keep my job, to know that the only way I won't lose it is if I die while I'm doing it.

the questions in an exam?

Wait, what? Knowing the questions, or knowing the answers to the questions? Most of the time, you won't know the questions, but you will know what material they'll cover. And if you don't know the answers, it's because you didn't bother to study said material. That's not fate; that's stupidity.


You have control over these things? Really? You must be God.

Oh, you didn't ask me up there if I could control when I die, or losing my job; you asked me if I knew when these things would happen. Which one is fate, then? Not knowing, or not controlling?

But if you ask if " have control over these things?" and declare I must be God to have such control, then you must feel it is God who determines my fate. Um...okay...how do I put this...

<--Atheist.
 
Last edited:
Except that you don't have to believe in any supernatural entity or force to be spiritual, at least in the AA sense. All that you have to believe in is a power greater than yourself, and there are plenty of those that are completely natural.

So I can believe in thunderstorms?
 
Jack, obviously you don't want to take the steps seriously, figuratively or literally. Many folks who come to AA without a God (because they choose not to believe) but have a very self destructive alcohol problem struggle mightily with this roadblock. I have talked with many folks who visited HARM, SOS and the other viable options and they don't want them. They want to go to AA and not deal with the God thing, I am not sure how they do it but they do.
Jack they do it with out all the nonsense you wrote above.
I think they compensate because they are at their wits end. One atheist explained to me he just put his understanding of science in place of God/Spirituality.
Make sense to me.

How do you do that?
 
People here have already proposed this. You're not saying anything new or novel there. But we've been told you can't be your own higher power.

Well, can you or can't you be your own higher power?

You are getting a little mixed up. I did not say I was my own HP now did I? And before you respond, please re-read what I put in my version of the steps so you are clear.

Though you weren't asking me, I can answer.

Far be it from you to put your nose into someone elses business. ;)

I do think there is the capacity in most people, though not all, to do better or be better. If you call that capacity, and the will, and the effort to do better and be better a "higher self," then you're agreeing with my point that you're the only one who can access that capacity.

Not quite, sometimes one needs to be shown how. We cannot know the things we do not know. Or can we?

You're agreeing with my point that you must access that "higher self" if you're to ever have sobriety.

I believe so, yes.

You're agreeing with me that god is superfluous to AA.

You are conflating a few of the steps and tools that I outlined.
God is not superfluous, but optional, spirituality (imo) is necessary.

Now all you have to do is agree that the religious "god" aspects of this "spiritual" recovery program are unnecessary, and sometimes even a hindrance, and AA should 86 'em. AA should update its 12 Steps.

But that would then preclude the membership of those that do have religious convictions. The doors are open to one and all. Or have I misunderstood?

Within a certain time-frame, sure I do. I just haven't reached that time-frame yet.

Then you really need to apply for the $1m. You can tell the future. :rolleyes:

I don't have to know when I'm going to die, to know that I am going to die. I don't have to know how long my health will last me--it's already declining, thanks--to know that health doesn't last. I don't need to know how long I'm going to keep my job, to know that the only way I won't lose it is if I die while I'm doing it.

In other words you need to wait and see and let fate take its course with many things in life, dont you? While you would hope or expect for certain outcomes there are no guarantees, are there? While you would like to be able to control the future you simply cant, can you?

That is "fate", you can choose another word if you want, I happen to like fate. Fair enough?

Oh, you didn't ask me up there if I could control when I die, or losing my job; you asked me if I knew when these things would happen. Which one is fate, then? Not knowing, or not controlling?

Either, I don't mind. Which would you like to discuss? Maybe we can do both at the same time.

But if you ask if " have control over these things?" and declare I must be God to have such control, then you must feel it is God who determines my fate. Um...okay...how do I put this...

<--Atheist.


Nice try, fail. I didn't bring god into this, you did. I said fate.

If you cannot determine the future, is it fate (or whatever word you like)?
If it is fate, then you have no control (or limited) one cannot possibly be certain (know) the outcome.
If you can't control it, what does one do with it?
And the answer is hand over one's will to fate or a higher power or god if you like.
So fate is never mine to determine nor to manage beyond reasonable expectations.

A practicing alcoholic tries to manage everything and rails against the world when it doesn't fall in line with their will. That is what 'handing one's life and will over' is about. Understand now?
 
Last edited:
It's okay, Alfie, really. What you said was perfectly clear.

I know your argument wasn't meant to agree with mine, but that sometimes happens when one's arguments chase their own tails. ;)
 
It's okay, Alfie, really. What you said was perfectly clear.

lol
It certainly was, you just misunderstood it.

But seriously, is that the best you can do?

(speaks softly and with care)
Come on, I gave you plenty to work with. You could even concede you may have been mistaken once or twice, I would give you a huge tick for being honest of you did.

Come on, you can see my point now, I know you can.

You know you can't control your life, or those around you, all the wrongs in the world, fate, the future....

You do know it, don't you.
Come on,...
come on.... ;)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom