Dancing David
Penultimate Amazing
The answer is that it is not the object that is literally performing the actions that keeps the person sober; it is what the person believes about the object that allows the person reconceptualize their relationship to the world in such a way that makes it possible for them to maintain their sobriety.
Sometimes it helps the person in question to externalize that reconceptualization and call it "God" (in the sense that is most familiar to us in our Abrahamic religion-influenced society), but such externalization is not necessary to benefit from AA. However, it is also interesting to note that at least one secular recovery program, Rational Recovery, depends on "otherizing" the urge to use and use a "therapy", AVRT (Addictive Voice Recognition Therapy) to suppress the "Addictive Voice" of the "The Beast". While AVRT is a firmly secular alternative to AA, it is far from rational, because it involves identifying a part of one's cognitive apparatus as being "not oneself" without offering any evidence that it is not part of the self. In fact, Rational Recovery founder, Jack Trimpey, bills his book on AVRT as "[c]leanly divorcing AVRT from science, clinical thought, and religion, the The Art of AVRT takes AVRT to the next phase, exposing the AV in the world around us".
In sum, the effectiveness of the power greater than oneself depends not on any quality inherent to the whatever one chooses as one's power greater than oneself but on one's belief about the chosen power greater than oneself. Moreover, secular alternatives to AA do not necessarily avoid making unwarranted assumptions about the nature of addiction.
Hmm, it has been a while since I read Trimpey, it sounds as though they have moved off the CBT path and into woo, the addicted self talk is always part of oneself, perhaps some people find help by decoupling it to such an extenet but that seems rather lunatic to me, it is usuallu changing teh behavior in response to the cogntions, and chnaging the cognitions in response to the behaviors, sounds very odd. Not CBt at all
Ooooog, how yucky!
The ANIMAL VOICE, what a load a hellenistic victorian duality and twaddle.
http://www.avrt.com/
has some sense, it looks like it started down the correct path and then got all crazy.
Trimppey was always a little over the top and in fact RR has had some factional warfare.