Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Since you already know the answer, why ask?

To recap, atheists are certain the program is religious, non-atheists don't necessarily find it so.
 
Last edited:
What is the topic of this thread? it seems to have gone badly astray.

Shall I ask outside the thread, or can someone here tell us the topic?

I believe so too.

When I submitted my post concerning the orange papers I also sent it to the moderation team for review and am awaiting an answer.

Maybe this thread should be split or a new one created where we can discuss the merits of AA treatment.

I'm not sure how in depth we'd get though because according to Orange (and I happen to agree with him) there is a:

scarcity of good, properly run randomized longitudinal controlled studies of the effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous
 
Jack, it is a simple question that you seem not to want to answer. Are you saying AA makes alcoholism a moral issue? That is far different to a spiritual malady.
And can you show me where "the big book is clear" on this question of it being a moral issue?



See edited/added apology.

Considering spirituality is total hokum it makes alcoholism a woo woo malady!

There is no soul, there is no spirit, 'spirituality' is an incoherent heterogenous rubric for superstition, religion and crack pottery!

:D:D:D:D:D

*********** alcoholism is a *********** behavioral disorder often driven and rooted in biological issues, but spirit is ********.

And I say that as a long time buddhist nihilist witch.
 
Last edited:
Since you already know the answer, why ask?

To recap, atheists are certain the program is religious, non-atheists don't necessarily find it so.

I as an atheist, who is not wearing my kilt, would like to say that I find the groups to vary a lot. There is some religions in some groups.
 
Since you already know the answer, why ask?

To get it back on topic. In case people have forgotten, off-topic posts and derails are not allowed.

My posts have gone right along to AAH with all the other off-topic, MA-breaking posts, at my behest, and because of my reporting, among others. So don't tell me I'm hypocritical. I know my wrongs, and I've tended to them.

To recap, atheists are certain the program is religious, non-atheists don't necessarily find it so.

That's the outcome.

I don't find it accurate.
 
Last edited:
I believe so too.

When I submitted my post concerning the orange papers I also sent it to the moderation team for review and am awaiting an answer.

Maybe this thread should be split or a new one created where we can discuss the merits of AA treatment.

I'm not sure how in depth we'd get though because according to Orange (and I happen to agree with him) there is a:

Indeed

scarcity of good, properly run randomized longitudinal controlled studies of the effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous

And I hasten to add, AA being a organisation with over 75 years existence, and is happy to allow drink drivers, child abusers, and people who have committed violent crimes, to as part of a plea bargain for a reduced sentence, or as part of parole agreement, yet aren't interested in helping run f good, properly run randomized longitudinal controlled studies of the effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous .

Such studies would help ratify AAs standing.
 
The site contains a gazillion links and even more words.

Links you don't want to share.


He then plasters studies that are missing the very characteristics I've highlighted above all over his site.

Studies with minuscule sample sizes, free of subject data.

Studies/Surveys done on people who may or may not even be alcoholics.
Studies/Surveys conducted by questionnaires filled out by people who are notorious liars, those people being alcohol abusers.

Maybe someone should conduct a study focusing on recovered alcoholics (who are demonstrably more honest), ask them if they've ever participated in a "drinking" study and if so were they ever untruthful. I know I certainly was.

What's an alcoholic 8Den? Even the medical community can't agree on that term should mean. Yet Orange cities studies that haven't even qualified their subjects.

He then throws around the 5% canard with glee over and over. That study never mentions how much time the focus group subjects spent in AA. Did they go to one meeting, 4 or 5, a thousand? Maybe some of those people left after a few meetings and didn't like AA. Were they counted as those treated by AA?

I also find it funny he cherry picks the 5%. ZOMG! 95% who went to AA (whatever that means) are out drinking again. Insinuating they are out getting plastered, yet fails to mention that 38% managed to quit OR are now drinking socially, a number at least 10 percentage points above the next best method.

This seems to be have your cake and eat it arguing PBS

You're arguing that Orange Papers quote statistics that are made up and unfair, and then you drop your 38% statistic like it's statement of fact.

Incidentally you claim that no one agrees what a "alcoholic" is, but you claim that "recovered alcoholics" are "demonstrableness more honest".

I've never met such a dishonest sceptic in my life.

He goes on and on and on about people leaving AA (gee people not ready to give up drinking who haven't invested a penny leaving a self help group, what a shocker, I wonder if anyone's ever quit Weight Watchers. :rolleyes: ) but he never qualifies what he's talking about. Some people come to the rooms, don't like it and leave, does that qualify as AA treatment? How do all these people leaving jive with his AA is a cult stance? Another glaring contradiction.

What about those people who are supposed to attend and are court appointed to be there?

AA is a mind controlling cult, yet people are leaving freely everyday. :confused:

AA keeps telling people to keep coming back, and informs people there that they are

Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those too who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.




I've said many times AA isn't perfect and some groups are better than others, but the conspiracy theory type hysteria found on these AA hate sites is ridiculous.

Yeah and why is the concept of 13th stepping not just a urban myth
 
Considering spirituality is total hokum it makes alcoholism a woo woo malady!

There is no soul, there is no spirit, 'spirituality' is an incoherent heterogenous rubric for superstition, religion and crack pottery!

The question was one of morality, not spirituality.

You surprise me DD, you are usually more on top of a subject than that.

And I hasten to add, AA being a organisation with over 75 years existence, and is happy to allow drink drivers, child abusers, and people who have committed violent crimes, to as part of a plea bargain for a reduced sentence, or as part of parole agreement, ...

Actually your beef is really with the court system for accepting this a part of the plea bargain, parole conditions etc. It seems that both the court system and those criminals use AAs open minded approach to membership for their own purposes. It is more like AA is the victim here than the perpetrator wouldn't you say?

What about those people who are supposed to attend and are court appointed to be there?

Who sends them there? But "what about" them?

AA keeps telling people to keep coming back, and informs people there that they are ...

You seem to be asserting that people have no choice, when the opposite is true.


Am I assume we have no deal?
 
Last edited:
Indeed

And I hasten to add, AA being a organisation with over 75 years existence, and is happy to allow drink drivers, child abusers, and people who have committed violent crimes, to as part of a plea bargain for a reduced sentence, or as part of parole agreement, yet aren't interested in helping run f good, properly run randomized longitudinal controlled studies of the effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous .

Such studies would help ratify AAs standing.

I'll be courteous and answer your two replies, but until I get an answer from the moderation team about what will be allowed in this thread, I won't waste any further time educating you, just to have it all end up in AAH.


Who is going to fund these randomized longitudinal controlled studies?

How will they be carried out? Are you going to ask AA members for ID and subject them to blood tests? Who is going to organize all of this? Who will validate and oversee the tests? Think randomized. Think longitudinal. Think controlled

Links you don't want to share.

Strawman.

Why would I care to share links that can be found with a simple google search, do you think I have the ability to hide information? There's this little thing called the internet, maybe you've heard of it?



This seems to be have your cake and eat it arguing PBS

You're arguing that Orange Papers quote statistics that are made up and unfair, and then you drop your 38% statistic like it's statement of fact.

Who said anything about made-up or unfair? Do you have a problem with English comprehension?
If you're going to debate me, at least try to be honest.

He's using studies based on faulty data. I'll explain it for you in the hope you'll learn something.

A study was conducted in 1983 asserting 24% of it's respondents knew someone who is gay, the number increased to to 73% in 2001, why do think that is? Did someone put something in the water to create more homosexuals?

Incidentally you claim that no one agrees what a "alcoholic" is, but you claim that "recovered alcoholics" are "demonstrableness more honest".

I've never met such a dishonest sceptic in my life.

demonstrableness? I don't usually bag on person's spelling, but that is atrocious.

Anyway, it's not my fault you can't tell the difference between a person using a word as a description and it being used as a catch all diagnosis in studies.

What about those people who are supposed to attend and are court appointed to be there?

What does this have to do with my post? I suggest you look up the definition of strawman and learn what it means.

Anyway. What about them? It's not my job to keep them sober, if they want help it's there.

I can't make anyone stay sober, they have to want it for themselves.

AA keeps telling people to keep coming back, and informs people there that they are

That they are what?

People who need to get honest with themselves?

People who should keep coming back because they've drank til the point of blackout for 28 years like myself and probably won't understand what the hell is going on for at least a few months. Ohhh the horror!








Yeah and why is the concept of 13th stepping not just a urban myth

Where has anyone in this thread ever denied it exists. While I don't agree with it, it's not a crime. It's definitely not rampant. In fact I've personally never seen it. What I usually see is two relatively new people hooking up even after it's been suggested they don't and quite often they don't return.

My apologies but I won't be addressing you again until we're given the all clear from the mods.
 
Last edited:
To get it back on topic. In case people have forgotten, off-topic posts and derails are not allowed.

I should have read the rules more carefully. This thread went off the rails last July, so I didn't think it mattered by the time I got here. My apologies.

So, to the actual topic of the thread: Why do people insist AA is not religious?

There are multiple answers to this, but to start with, what some people less familiar with AA is, the program is the book "Alcoholics Anonyous," aka 'The Big Book'. The groups and organization is named from this. Anything you need to understand about the program itself is in the book, including its recruiting practices, which are described in Chapter 7. It's short, and can be read HERE.

Chapter 7 is essentially a 'How To' manual. In this chapter, steppers are told to deceive a "prospect," by not being fully open about the religiosity of the program, because the prospect may have their own prejudices about religion. Basically, the AAs job is to get the prospect in the door with deception. It's akin to someone from Amway calling you for "business opportunity." They also call their recruits "prospects."

This is from that chapter:

"When dealing with such a person, you had better use everyday language to describe spiritual principles. There is no use arousing any prejudice he may have against certain theological terms and conceptions about which he may already be confused. Don't raise such issues, no matter what your own convictions are.
Your prospect may belong to a religious denomination. His religious education and training may be far superior to yours. In that case he is going to wonder how you can add anything to what he already knows. But he well be curious to learn why his own convictions have not worked and why yours seem to work so well. He may be an example of the truth that faith alone is insufficient. To be vital, faith must be accompanied by self sacrifice and unselfish, constructive action. Let him see that you are not there to instruct him in religion. Admit that he probably knows more about it than you do, but call to his attention the fact that however deep his faith and knowledge, he could not have applied it or he would not drink, Perhaps your story will help him see where he has failed to practice the very precepts he knows so well. We represent no particular faith or denomination. We are dealing only with general principles common to most denominations."

The idea is to get the person into the door. Once there, the conversion happens, which is described in Chapter 4, "We Agnostics." Don't let the title fool you, it isn't about acceptance of agnosticism as a part of AA, but about religious conversion. It is also a short text, and can be read HERE. [As a word of caution, don't drink milk as you read this chapter, as you may start laughing and spew it out your nose.] This is from this chapter:

"Yes, we of agnostic temperament have had these thoughts and experiences. Let us make haste to reassure you. We found that as soon as we were able to lay aside prejudice and express even a willingness to believe in a Power greater than ourselves, we commenced to get results, even though it was impossible for any of us to fully define or comprehend that Power, which is God."

This encapsulates the "open-mindedness" often referred to in AA. That which can't explained, God did it. Read the full text, and it's clear that the door-knobs, "Group of Drunks," etc.; are simply proxies to a specific god, who performs specific tasks, regardless of what you call it. It is important to understand that the program does not say you may have a "god of your understanding." Step 3 is simple, and is "God as you understand Him." You may understand Him as your chia pet, but He is the god of AA. Here is what the 'Big Book' says:

"We were now at Step Three. Many of us said to our Maker, AS WE UNDERSTOOD HIM: "God, I offer myself to Thee--to build with me and to do with me as Thou wilt. Relieve me of the bondage of self, that I may better do Thy will. Take away my difficulties, that victory over them may bear witness to those I would help of Thy Power, Thy Love, and Thy Way of life. May I do Thy will always!" We thought well before taking this step making sure we were ready; that we could at last abandon ourselves utterly to Him."

This God the third-step prayer is specific. It is "our Maker." The Big Kahuna. The Alpha and Omega.


Now, as has been pointed out here I am sure, is there are no requirements in AA, including working the steps. But if you aren't working the steps, you aren't doing the program. Besides, the "suggestions" aren't really presented as suggestions. Here is from "Getting Started in AA," a popular book published by Hazelden that serves a primer to using the 'Big Book' and the program:

"Within reason we are entitled to, 'take what we want and leave the rest' as we listen in AA meetings. Even the steps, of course, are only 'suggested' for those who want to get and stay sober. People who don't need to get sober don't need to work the steps."

So, no, you don't need to actually work the program. Only if you want to get sober. Of course, the only reason to go to AA in the first place is to get sober. There is no other reason to go, so this "choice" is presented as a false dilemma: "Do you want to work the steps, which includes accepting God, turning your will to God, praying to God, confessing to God; or do you not want to get sober?" That isn't a choice.

So to answer the question of why they won't admit it is religion, is because it helps bait others into the program. People are more likely to go if they believe it somehow isn't religious. Once are sucked in, they are brainswashed and convinced that turning your life over to the will of a supernatural being, praying to him, etc.; is not religious. They honest to god believe it themselves. They'll also do whatever they can to protect the group, which is their primary purpose, so they'll go through whatever mind-bending mental gymnastics they need to in order to convince themselves and others it's true.
 
Last edited:
That was 75 years ago. The big book is an historical document with some good ideas and many that have outgrown their usefulness. On top of that it was the writings of a man with a heavy religious bent.
This is not compelling evidence, what is is the hundreds of thousands of spiritual AAers across the globe. Those that have no religious affiliations, and those that do.

No doubt in the good ole' USA there is heavy Christian leaning, I could bet in Israel there is a heavy Jewish leaning. In Italy a heavy Roman Catholic leaning, etc etc, Where I live, no one gives a toss.
 
Last edited:
That was 75 years ago. The big book is an historical document with some good ideas and many that have outgrown their usefulness. On top of that it was the writings of a man with a heavy religious bent.
This is not compelling evidence, what is is the hundreds of thousands of spiritual AAers across the globe. Those that have no religious affiliations, and those that do.

No doubt in the good ole' USA there is heavy Christian leaning, I could bet in Israel there is a heavy Jewish leaning. In Italy a heavy Roman Catholic leaning, etc etc, Where I live, no one gives a toss.

You and I and the other people commenting here could walk into a Synagogue with a ouija board and a sacrificial goat; seance the dead or proclaim ourselves devout atheists; proclaim the Bible as three-thousand year old historical document that we don't worship. And that still would not make Christianity or Judaism non-Religions.

You may choose not practice the AA program, which is spelled out clearly in the How It Works section of the 'Big Book'. Which, by the way, is not a "historical document," but is the very foundation of the program. It is read from in every meeting, and is studied just like those who study the Bible (like this group in Alfie's neck of the woods). If you choose not to do it, fine; but that is not AA, and not the program. I can go to church merely to sleep and socialize, but that doesn't mean the tenets of the church are optional for those who choose to practice it.

I have never heard even the biggest AA apologist dismiss the 'Big Book' as a "historical document" before. What you are saying here has no basis in reality. It's stunning, actually. We've gone way deep into the Rabbit Hole here.
 
Last edited:
Uh...I wasn't not trying to be "clever". It was quite obvious that you were conflating having take a drink with not having taken a drink.

So I confused polar opposites ? What the hell are you talking about ?

Since when is an argument from personal incredulity valid.

So you think your voluntary muscles move involuntarily, pick up a drink, etc. ?

Are you saying that animal models provide little to no insight into human behavior?

No.

It's a general model for addiction, but you would know that if you had done some cursory research instead of posting your ignorant opinions.

If it applies to ALL addictions, then why does it not work when I mention other addictions ?
 
Is gambling listed as a drug ?

Is it not?!? :confused:
If not a drug, it can at least have a drug like effects on the brain, correct?
I would be amazed if it wasn't there.

Anyway, the point was do chips have that effect on the brain?
The answer is "not often, but possibly" there are people out there who identify as food addicts.
 
Who is going to fund these randomized longitudinal controlled studies?

The AA of course. They're hardly a impoverished organisation.

How will they be carried out? Are you going to ask AA members for ID and subject them to blood tests? Who is going to organize all of this? Who will validate and oversee the tests? Think randomized. Think longitudinal. Think controlled

Um within the AA of course. There is a code of rigorous honesty remember.

Strawman.

Why would I care to share links that can be found with a simple google search, do you think I have the ability to hide information? There's this little thing called the internet, maybe you've heard of it?

Okay. Seriously you keep using the term strawman

A straw man is a component of an argument and is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent's position.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man#cite_note-book-0

Thats a strawman.

You keep saying that there are

"fallacies" and "contradictions" on the Orange Papers site

You've made the claim the onus is on you to support it. Not to make the claim, then wave me in the direction of google while shouting "STRAWMAN STRAWMAN"

I'm going to presume you can't find fallacies and contradictions on the Orange papers site.


Who said anything about made-up or unfair? Do you have a problem with English comprehension?
If you're going to debate me, at least try to be honest.

I was paraphrasing. Consider your dishonesty about the orange papers this is more than a tad rich.

He's using studies based on faulty data. I'll explain it for you in the hope you'll learn something.

A study was conducted in 1983 asserting 24% of it's respondents knew someone who is gay, the number increased to to 73% in 2001, why do think that is? Did someone put something in the water to create more homosexuals?

And the point of this little non sequitur is?

demonstrableness? I don't usually bag on person's spelling, but that is atrocious.
Generally thats a sign of hubris.

Anyway, it's not my fault you can't tell the difference between a person using a word as a description and it being used as a catch all diagnosis in studies.

No, you questioned his use of the word alcoholics saying the term hadn't been defined and then in same breath suggested that recovered alcoholics were more honest.


That they are what?

Are your reading skills lacking as well, I followed on with

Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those too who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.

The speech from AA meetings.

You're just being obtuse.


People who need to get honest with themselves?

People who should keep coming back because they've drank til the point of blackout for 28 years like myself and probably won't understand what the hell is going on for at least a few months. Ohhh the horror!

Sounds like people who are the ideal candidates for cult.
 
"But, your honor, I couldn't possibly be held responsible for driving drunk ! See, I lost control."

You don't seem to understand the legal system very well. Even when someone loses control, they can still be held accountable for their actions. Committing a crime "in the heat passion" does not exonerate you, it just provides mitigating circumstances for a sentence reduction.

One is still responsible for that first drink.
 
Actually your beef is really with the court system for accepting this a part of the plea bargain, parole conditions etc. It seems that both the court system and those criminals use AAs open minded approach to membership for their own purposes. It is more like AA is the victim here than the perpetrator wouldn't you say?

Completely untrue. The AA actively participates and encourages this.


Who sends them there? But "what about" them?
Indeed who, who came up with the idea, and why didn't the AA object or continue to object.

You seem to be asserting that people have no choice, when the opposite is true.
AA tells them they have no choice they could leave and they will most likely die.


Am I assume we have no deal?
Sorry no. Some of the people in AA are at their most vulnerable and low. And they should be aware that some of the other people in the room are using AA as part of a plea bargain to escape from prison.

It's a recipe for disaster.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom