Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course they do. Salt, fat, etc. Chips contain substances that make my brain go "ooh, good !" And anything that makes you go "ooh, good !" can be addictive. There's a reason why I can't seem to stop.

Are chips listed as a drug by the AMA or FDA.

No?

Maybe you should reflect on why that is.
 
So alcohol is your higher power.

Strawman

I don't have a god. AA does.

Who/what is/are AA god(s)?

The Girl Guides of Canada have removed all reference to "god" and "higher power" in their literature and program. They are now a truly secular organization and guess what? . . . Their membership increased significantly.

They had changed their references, like AA, from "God" to "a higher power" and even "God as we know him" but that didn't change anything in the eyes of the public. So they removed the reference to god completely. They didn't just claim to be inclusive, they actually took action.

I think it's pretty good evidence that religion of the type AA pushes is a barrier to many people.

I tend to agree with you, I know it bothered me when I first joined.

I'd like to see god removed, but higher power remain, it helps remind us that we can't control certain things and/or situations

A simple, updated re-wording of some (not all, just some) of AA's verbiage would work wonders and hurt no one.

If instead of "became powerless," why not something more like, "gave up our power to alcohol" in a sense of being willing to reclaim that power? Just as one example. It puts the responsibility squarely and unambiguously on ourselves, where it belongs in most cases. I don't see how this could hurt AA, and do see where it could help the people in it.

We are powerless over alcohol after we have the first drink, at least that's the way I interpet it, but I agree some things could be changed. It's difficult process which is a curse and but also a blessing, it makes it hard for someone to replace higher power with "Our almighty lord Jesus Christ, savior of souls." :D
 
Uh...I wasn't not trying to be "clever". It was quite obvious that you were conflating having take a drink with not having taken a drink.



Since when is an argument from personal incredulity valid.



Are you saying that animal models provide little to no insight into human behavior?

What do you have to say about the human study I posted?



It's a general model for addiction, but you would know that if you had done some cursory research instead of posting your ignorant opinions.



Since when is an argument from consequences valid?

LOL nice.

Poor Belz
 
I read the story when you first posted it, how was "AA" supposed to stop them?

Did you want them to send the AA police?

Well, presumably the local intergroup could have de-listed them. And if it failed to act, the next level up could have directed it to do so.

In another story linked in this thread, two groups were de-listed by the Toronto intergroup (forgive me if I'm getting the terminology wrong). Their crime? Tweaking the 12 steps to make them secular.

So, it seems to me that:
1) AA's hierarchy can do "something" to discipline groups that step out of line, or at least make clear that those groups are not considered part of AA; and
2) AA's hierarchy is willing to take action when the word "god" is threatened (you know, that word that doesn't mean all that much, because it could be anything anyway and take what you want and leave the rest), but not when people are abusing their authority as sponsors to obtain free household labor and sexual services.
 
Oh yeah we actively recruit at the courts,we organize parties that go to the courts and hand out flyers. This guy the same as a 9/11 truther. Conspiracy theories galore.

I understand it's rigorously honest to deny this, by which I mean it's true if you want it to be true. But outside of the AA bubble, the truth is actually the truth. AA does indeed work with the courts and prisons to recruit membership. Two-thirds of new AAs are sent there by the courts. Here is brochure approved by, and produced by, AA's central office: AA Guidelines for Cooperating with the court. There are other AA pamphlets that they distribute with titles like "It sure beats sitting in a jail cell" and "AA in correctional facilities." AA is littered with felons who used AA attendance to mitigate their sentences, for anything from impaired driving to rape.

We highlight some of these (very few out of the literally thousands daily) not to imply that AA membership means a person is a sicko felon. We don't believe that for a second. Most AAs are regular people. Some good, some bad, but no different than the general population. The difference is that in any other area, any other group, there is accountability. In AA, there is none, and so the nutters are allowed run free. AAs worry about "keeping my side of the street clean," and are encouraged "not to take other people's inventory."

Are chips listed as a drug by the AMA or FDA.

No?

Maybe you should reflect on why that is.

Sex isn't listed as a drug, either. But both food and sex addiction are very real. I will concede that I've never seen anyone refer to a potato chip as "cunning, baffling and powerful."

"13th-Stepping:" Why Alcoholics Anonymous Is Not Always a Safe Place for Women

I wouldn't exactly place much faith in a 57 person study when AA has a few million members, especially when it was probably a targeted group.

Maybe I'll do a study at my group, if all the women there report zero incidents I guess there's no abuse. :rolleyes:

If you wish, I could give you a lesson on randomized sampling, but I don't think it would matter.

I think this is another case of rigorous honesty™. 13th stepping is definitely a problem throughout AA. Our problem at Stinkin Thinkin with AA and 13th steeping is not the acts themselves. We don't condone it, but we realize that you or AA GSO can't control individual members. Our problem is the lack of accountability and the turning a blind eye to it. Pretending it doesn't happen.

A few years ago, the GSO in New York actually sent out an internal memo to AA groups in the UK advising them of this problem. It was never intended for public consumption, but it was leaked. You can read about it here: Drink Advice Service Confronts Sex Abuse. This quote from an AA spokesman in the UK was interesting:

"It came as a bit of a shock to me and I have never picked up on these allegations before. AA [is] in a difficult position: we all put checks and balances in place, but it is very difficult to protect people entirely from abuse of position because the people involved are invariably clever."

Now, when this person said "we put checks and balances in place," he was displaying the patented AA rigorous honesty™ again. Because there are no checks and balances at all. And as far as "being shocked," I doubt that. It is very common.
 
Last edited:
Well, presumably the local intergroup could have de-listed them. And if it failed to act, the next level up could have directed it to do so.

In another story linked in this thread, two groups were de-listed by the Toronto intergroup (forgive me if I'm getting the terminology wrong). Their crime? Tweaking the 12 steps to make them secular.

So, it seems to me that:
1) AA's hierarchy can do "something" to discipline groups that step out of line, or at least make clear that those groups are not considered part of AA; and
2) AA's hierarchy is willing to take action when the word "god" is threatened (you know, that word that doesn't mean all that much, because it could be anything anyway and take what you want and leave the rest), but not when people are abusing their authority as sponsors to obtain free household labor and sexual services.

Yes, they could have, but according to that article the group had 400 members and isn't clear how many dirtbags were involved. Should a group be de-listed due to a few goofs? The article claims Mike Q was doing this from his house which seems to indicate the thirteen stepping wasn't being done at the group but after hours at his house. It'd be nice if we had a clearer picture of what happened.

We have compliants from "Kristen" and then we have this:

"We interviewed 15 to 20 people, and they all said he's doing it. But it was all, 'It wasn't me,' " said Montgomery police Sgt. Ron Collins of the department's pedophile section. "Nobody's come forward with anything we could charge him with
As for the two groups in Toronto, the changes they made (it was a little more than tweaking)to the 12 steps essentially makes them different than AA.

Saying that, I'm going to check out those groups, it sounds like somewhere I might like to go, too bad they aren't closer to me. :(
 
Yes, they could have, but according to that article the group had 400 members and isn't clear how many dirtbags were involved. Should a group be de-listed due to a few goofs? The article claims Mike Q was doing this from his house which seems to indicate the thirteen stepping wasn't being done at the group but after hours at his house. It'd be nice if we had a clearer picture of what happened.

If you want to argue that there wasn't enough evidence to de-list them, fine -- I don't really know enough to wade into that -- but I was responding to your snide remark about sending in the "AA police," implying that there's nothing that can be done about groups that are problematic.

We have compliants from "Kristen" and then we have this:

"We interviewed 15 to 20 people, and they all said he's doing it. But it was all, 'It wasn't me,' " said Montgomery police Sgt. Ron Collins of the department's pedophile section. "Nobody's come forward with anything we could charge him with

That's really a red herring, though. Whether someone can be criminally charged or not is not the issue. For example:

As for the two groups in Toronto, the changes they made (it was a little more than tweaking)to the 12 steps essentially makes them different than AA.

There's nothing illegal about that, is it?

But really, you're making my point for me. If the changes they made to the 12 steps -- and basically all they did was replace "God" and "higher power" with secular language -- makes it "different than AA," then all the talk about how none of these things are requirements for AA, take what you want, etc. is confirmed to be so much bovine excrement.
 
Let me get this straight, since AA print some pamphlets, this equates to "actively recruiting" in the courts? I mean, explain for all of us what AA actully does in the courts. Do we organize people and have them attend hearings. Do we talk to the judge or prosecutor, Do we hang around outside like Mormoms, give out pamphlets and evangelize.

First, you were the one mocking Joey and saying this: "Oh yeah we actively recruit at the courts,we organize parties that go to the courts and hand out flyers. This guy the same as a 9/11 truther. Conspiracy theories galore."

Like it was somehow crazy to think AA would do such thing. Obviously, they do. And to answer your questions:

-Yes, AAs actually do organize people and have them attend hearings.

-Yes, AAs do meet with both judges and prosecutors, as well as defense attorneys.

- I am unaware of any AAs who hang outside of courthouses like Mormons, but AA does hold "information sessions" with district attorneys offices. This happens across the United States. I'm not sure about how it works in Canada, but I know AA is used to mitigate sentences in parts of Canada.

- AAs go into jails and prisons on their "12-step calls" and set up groups there, where that attendance is used to argue for parole. As a condition of release, these prisoners must attend AA meetings. [As a fun side note, it isn't commonly known that in the U.S., AA is the exception to the rule that convicted felons may not fraternize with each other.]

Again, how would you police it? You admitted yourself the GSO can't control individual members.

The GSO cannot control the actions of individual members, but they can control the consequences and hold members accountable. Just as virtually every organization I can think of does (sans the Catholic Church). The difference between AA and the real world is, in the regular world, there are consequences. In AA, there is none. This is one reason there is so much crazy in AA. Normal people filter themselves out, and it's the crazies who found a niche in the world where they can do their thing, anonymously and without accountability, stick around.

Our problem with AA is with accountability, both at at the GSO level, intergroup and individual group level. AA is structured in a way to where there is no accountability, and individual members pretend the abuses don't happen, or sweep them under the rug. Like you are doing here, for example.
 
This google stuff is so much fun:

http://www.utexas.edu/research/asrec/recovery.pdf

Carlton Erickson, Ph.D.
• Distinguished Professor of Pharmacology
• Director, Addiction Science Research
and Education Center
• Associate Dean for Research
and Graduate Studies
College of Pharmacy
The University of Texas at Austin
www.utexas.edu/research/asrec

This guy seems to disagree with you too Joey, you'd better alert Stinkin Thinking, another quack's on the loose. :D

You do realize that an AA citing this guy is like a creationist citing Carl Sagan? Personally, I'm a big fan of him and what he is doing, and have read one of his books, which helped pry me from the 12-step hocus pocus.

Why would you advocate what he says, while at the same time promote AA as the solution? I'm guessing you didn't read much about him before you mined this out of google.
 
I've been to at least 20 different groups, guess what? NONE of them have leaders. What are the responsibilities of group leaders in AA Joey?

Again with the rigorous honesty™. AA definitely has leaders. There are some good ones, but there are lots and lots of nutbars, too. The only requirement to gain guru status, is time sober. Old-timers who can't pay their rent or keep a job, can hold court and spout the AA dogma, and have hordes of of groupies cling to their ever word. Here is good example, as told by an AA member of twenty years:

In an AA group that I belonged to there is a particularly pathetic old lizard (he’s still there) called Santa due to his vague bearded resemblance to the image of Saint Nicklaus. He is childish and attention seeking in the meetings that he dominates like an unruly child (talking, passing notes, telling jokes, pounding the table, #$%@&## around with his hearing devices ~ it’s pretty clear that he can’t actually HEAR anyone but himself and he doesn’t seem to care about that, interrupting, getting up and wandering around the room); then he launches into what could only be called sermons for his credulous faithful. Even with my eyes crossed and my face nearly to my knees at just days sober I could tell this ******* was full of @#$%.

His sponsees are called “elves” but are, of course, grown men. He keeps a little posse of these men (about 5 at any given time, many for years on end) and works them through their steps and such. That would be bad enough, but he runs these men’s lives like a nosy maiden auntie in antebellum Georgia might micromanage virgin maidens. He runs his sponsorship game like a fey teen aged girl with the constant threat of withdrawal of his affection and attention. Each sponsor contract is “renewed” every MONTH so the elf must toe the line or risk being “fired” as an AA slave/dog every four weeks.

He is in their #@$% every way that you can be in anyone’s @$#%. They begin every day calling him at an appointed hour and minute, variations of even five minutes are grounds for reprimand. They run endless errands for him (he is disabled and can not drive). They pick him up and drive him everywhere he wants to go. They are summoned for mind melting sessions with him “one on one” every Sunday. Particularly grotesque is the experience of seeing this obviously long post-sexual person dishing out dating advice to these sad lonely men (who are required to spend every Saturday night with him at his meeting and “meeting after the meeting” ~ it’s a 5 hour AA session all centered on him, he loves it). Not surprisingly these men are not major woman magnets, but they don’t seem to be allowed to even date for very long ~ there is always something wrong with the women and they return to spending their weekends with Santa. I detected that the vicarious experience of the elves recounting their sex lives to him has a sick appeal for this creep and that he was very invested in separating the men from their women or any woman who might conceivably love or even like them.

As I got to know him I came to see how staggeringly dysfunctional and disturbed his whole set-up actually is. Of course, he’s retired. So, he’s got nothing but time to manipulate and dominate these poor shaken men who have emerged from years of profound alcohol abuse, drug abuse and drink dependence and simply transferred control of their lives to him. He’s fond of talking about what a big mover and shaker he once was (a car salesman!) and tells a sad, small, bald and obvious lie about once having owned a Maserati car. Never in a million #$@%ing years did this sad loser who lives in a garage behind his wife’s mother’s house in a slum own that car, never. So much for rigorous honesty. Besides, he’s functionally illiterate. I’ve seen him try to write a simple sentence. The level is around late grammar school with learning disabled style errors (sorry, but that’s what I observed, I would feel sorry for him if he wasn’t running a sort of Heart of Darkness style End of Days cult around himself ~ obey Santa or die). the Big Book is the only thing this cretin has ever read, of that I am certain. Yet, having twenty years or so sober (or so he says) he is a king in AA. A God really, worshiped, admired, obeyed. It’s disgusting.

And holy hell, the Clancy Group is very mid-town like. They follow this guy Clancy, dress in suits like Louis Farrakhan's followers, and have their lives micro-managed by Clancy's underlings who lead groups under Clancy's umbrella. Here is a discussion about them at the Friend's of Bill, a pro-AA site: http://fobw.tribe.net/thread/8da36487-4d8a-4221-bb5d-cf478e564ee5
 
Interesting PowerPoint from Dr. Erickson:

Neurobiology of Addiction

Exposes some of the lack of subtlety in the arguments of both sides in this thread.

I happen to agree with you about the physiological component of addiction.

What is mind boggling to me, is why you advocate treating it as a character flaw and with faith healing, which is the AA approach. They are the ones moralizing it.
 
I happen to agree with you about the physiological component of addiction.

Well, not everybody posting in this thread does, and my post was directed at them, as much as it was directed the posters who are towing the AA line verbatim.

What is mind boggling to me, is why you advocate treating it as a character flaw and with faith healing, which is the AA approach.

I don't. As I have said before, I am only relating what has worked for me thus far. There are currently no SMART or SOS in-person meetings in my area, and there are no Rational Recovery meeting at all.

I am benefiting from being able to associate with people face-to-face on a daily basis. What works for me may not work for someone else, and it is not for me to judge someone else's recovery.

They are the ones moralizing it.

"I know you are but what am I?"
 
What is mind boggling to me, is why you advocate treating it as a character flaw and with faith healing, which is the AA approach. They are the ones moralizing it.

Unless I misunderstand you, this is just plain wrong. How or where does AA make addiction a moral issue?
 
"Character defect", "selfish", "self-centered", "self-seeking".

"Not bad people getting good, but sick people getting well".

The defects you mention are syptoms of alcoholism. The moral issues do not cause, nor are they the addiction; they are a result or byproduct of it.
 
Last edited:
"Not bad people getting good, but sick people getting well".

The defects you mention are syptoms of the malady. The moral issues do not cause nor are they the addiction, they are a byproduct of it.

Are there really any inherently "moral" issues in addiction?
 
"Not bad people getting good, but sick people getting well".

The defects you mention are syptoms of alcoholism. The moral issues do not cause, nor are they the addiction; they are a result or byproduct of it.

Where does it say this in the 'Big Book'?
 
Are there really any inherently "moral" issues in addiction?

I'm not trying to be too clever here, but are there any inherently moral issues in humanity? I think the results would be similar.

At any rate (unless I misunderstood) Jack Astor is suggesting AA makes alcoholism a moral issue. It seems to me the opposite is true: Society had/has alcoholism as a moral issue, and AA says it is a disease (and fwiw, i prefer "disorder").
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom