Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I should have read the rules more carefully. This thread went off the rails last July, so I didn't think it mattered by the time I got here. My apologies.

Nah, don't apologize. :) It did go off the rails, and it probably can't be led back, but it was worth a try. The question--or rather, the answer--still intrigues me.

I'm reading your answer now. It's quite intriguing. Thank you for it.
 
So I confused polar opposites ? What the hell are you talking about ?

I spelled it out as clearly as possible. If you can't understand, maybe you should review your English skills.

So you think your voluntary muscles move involuntarily, pick up a drink, etc. ?

The "choice" to move our "voluntary" muscles is not always under conscious control. This is not to say that addicts are spastic but that the neruocircuitry of addiction resides in the midbrain, which is not under conscious control, and can therefore influence our "voluntary" actions in ways that we are not consciously aware of.


Then why object to the rat study solely on the basis that the subject are rats.

If it applies to ALL addictions, then why does it not work when I mention other addictions ?

Who said it didn't?
 
You don't seem to understand the legal system very well. Even when someone loses control, they can still be held accountable for their actions. Committing a crime "in the heat passion" does not exonerate you, it just provides mitigating circumstances for a sentence reduction.

One is still responsible for that first drink.

Are there no alcoholics who _can_ have one drink ?
 
I spelled it out as clearly as possible. If you can't understand, maybe you should review your English skills.

If you were not understood, perhaps YOU should review your English skills. Or, alternatively, you can try again.

The "choice" to move our "voluntary" muscles is not always under conscious control. This is not to say that addicts are spastic but that the neruocircuitry of addiction resides in the midbrain, which is not under conscious control, and can therefore influence our "voluntary" actions in ways that we are not consciously aware of.

Granted. But having a drink is a bit more complex.

Then why object to the rat study solely on the basis that the subject are rats.

"I spelled it out as clearly as possible."
 
Is it not?!? :confused:
If not a drug, it can at least have a drug like effects on the brain, correct?
I would be amazed if it wasn't there.

Anyway, the point was do chips have that effect on the brain?
The answer is "not often, but possibly" there are people out there who identify as food addicts.

Good. But people with these addictions can stop. And so can alcoholics. They have power over their lives, contrary to what the AA steps claim.
 
If you were not understood, perhaps YOU should review your English skills. Or, alternatively, you can try again.

This assume that you actually want to understand what I said. When I provided an explanation, you merely answered my question about being able to understand the difference between "after the first drink" and "whether or not they drink". If you understand the aforementioned difference (and linked to), I don't need to explain myself further.

Granted. But having a drink is a bit more complex.

And it is this complexity that you apparently not taken the time to avail yourself of.

"I spelled it out as clearly as possible."

No, you didn't.

"Rats < humans" does not even approach the cursory level of explanation that I took when I explained difference between "after the first drink" and "whether or not they drink".
 
Are there no alcoholics who _can_ have one drink ?



Asking that, in my opinion, is much like asking:
Are there no heroin addicts who can shoot up just once?
Are there no smokers who can have just one cigarette?

If you've tried to stop an addictive behavior, it may be possible to re-engage with the substance occasionally and not become re-addicted. But it's more likely you'll eventually fall back into the destructive behaviors you've tried to halt, and become addicted once more.
 
You seem to know a lot about this sort of thing.
And that is a huge amount of straw in just two sentences. :rolleyes:

An analogy isn't a straw man.

Which leads to a serious question. What is it with labeling statements logical fallacies when they really aren't? Straw man is a big one (y'all seem to really like that for some reason), but yesterday I saw Shill label something "ad hominem" which it was not. It really looks bad to point out a fallacy when there is none.

So, what's up with this?
 
Last edited:
http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/straw-man.html

Description of Straw Man

The Straw Man fallacy is committed when a person simply ignores a person's actual position and substitutes a distorted, exaggerated or misrepresented version of that position. This sort of "reasoning" has the following pattern:

Person A has position X.
Person B presents position Y (which is a distorted version of X).
Person B attacks position Y.
Therefore X is false/incorrect/flawed.

This sort of "reasoning" is fallacious because attacking a distorted version of a position simply does not constitute an attack on the position itself. One might as well expect an attack on a poor drawing of a person to hurt the person.

Indications of an attempt to straw man an argument:

"So, you're saying..." This is sometimes an attempt only to clarify a poorly constructed point, but can also be an attempt to alter the presented argument into something it isn't, which is "straw manning."

"No, I never said..." Usually, though not always, the clearest sign of a straw man. The response indicates the initial argument has been altered, not in a clarifying way, but in an attempt to change the argument into something that is more easily attacked.

Many people on these boards are learning critical thought and logical argumentation, and don't always get it right. Some know exactly what they're doing, and don't care if they ever get it right. They just want to poke sharp sticks at bunnies, so they can gleefully watch the bunnies bleed. ;)
 
Asking that, in my opinion, is much like asking:
Are there no heroin addicts who can shoot up just once?
Are there no smokers who can have just one cigarette?

If you've tried to stop an addictive behavior, it may be possible to re-engage with the substance occasionally and not become re-addicted. But it's more likely you'll eventually fall back into the destructive behaviors you've tried to halt, and become addicted once more.

I'm sorry: This just doesn't fit the scientific evidence concerning the neurophysiology of addiction.
 
A.A. Alfie said:
Actually your beef is really with the court system for accepting this a part of the plea bargain, parole conditions etc. It seems that both the court system and those criminals use AAs open minded approach to membership for their own purposes. It is more like AA is the victim here than the perpetrator wouldn't you say?

This is most incredibly disingenuous

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q...&sig=AHIEtbSDDAk0N1ezKSiWCQiDE035hfYigg&pli=1


Or A.A. Guidelines Cooperating with Court, D.W.I. and Similar Programs.

AA have extensive guidelines for dealing with courts and DWI programs, and actively approach and recruit in prisons.

Edited by Tricky: 
Edited for Rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Asking that, in my opinion, is much like asking:
Are there no heroin addicts who can shoot up just once?
Are there no smokers who can have just one cigarette?

If you've tried to stop an addictive behavior, it may be possible to re-engage with the substance occasionally and not become re-addicted. But it's more likely you'll eventually fall back into the destructive behaviors you've tried to halt, and become addicted once more.

I'm honestly asking because I don't know.
 
It also assumed that you want to be understood. We can do this all year.

Yes, we can, but, since I clearly explained what I meant, I don't see why it is my fault that you are willfully misunderstanding me.

That's a non-answer.

I'm sorry you feel that way, but, again, it is not my fault that you cannot see that the division of motions into "voluntary" and "involuntary" is simplistic, especially when the parts of the brain that the subject does not perceive and operating under conscious control can influence the subject's ability to make a conscious or voluntary decision.

The complexity of the necessary motions is the same after the first drink.

As is the above mentioned influence of the mesolimbic system.
 
I don't find it accurate.
Recovering alcoholics are likely to. For recovering alcoholics (and hopefully for suffering alcoholics too) the rest is meaningless noise.

ps. I find your attempts to blame AA for problems involving an alcoholic spouse in-accurate.
 
Completely untrue. The AA actively participates and encourages this.


Indeed who, who came up with the idea, and why didn't the AA object or continue to object.

AA tells them they have no choice they could leave and they will most likely die.


Sorry no. Some of the people in AA are at their most vulnerable and low. And they should be aware that some of the other people in the room are using AA as part of a plea bargain to escape from prison.

It's a recipe for disaster.
You certainly have opinions. Too bad any evidence to back them up is lacking.
 
That's an answer I'd expect from a simpleton, you can do better.

Personal attack noted.

How much will these studies cost? AA currently has a surplus of around 6 million dollars, do you think that will be enough to cover the cost. Do you think it's prudent to run a surplus in case something unforeseen happens in the future? You're well aware the GSO would need approval for this expenditure right? What if the thousands of groups around the world said no? What happens then? Just admit you didn't really think this through and move on.

Approval from whom? How? The GSO appears to just rake in the cash and doesn't seem answerable to anyone.

No wait I did. It's simple. The kind of trial you suggest is exactly what the AA is capable of, and should do


Oh wait:




Yep didn't think it through.

Have you ever conducted a randomized longitudinal controlled study? Do you even know what the parameters are?

Wait no see this is you treating me like a idiot again.



Seriously you keep creating them.

Really where?

I claimed the site has many links, it does, you brought up the ridiculous strawman claiming I don't want to share them.

No you made the claim about the site. And then you announced it has "loads of links"

I'm asking you to share which specific parts of the orange papers

You said:
No, I'm dismissing him because his site has so many fallacies and contradictions I've grown tired of counting them.

You've made this claim several days ago. And once again I notice you've failed to list a single fallacy or contradiction.

It's getting tiresome now.

Stop using them and I'll stop calling you out for it.

I've not used a single one.

I've simply asked you to show me a single fallacy or contradiction in the orange papers.

I've already posted a few and you rudely ignored them.

Really? Where?

I've looked through this thread and I cant see them.

Why don't you be a dear. And Link to the fallacies and contradictions, and explain in detail why they are wrong.

Why would I waste my time? I'm not interested in holding your hand, but I'll give some key words to think about: good studies, scarcity, people leaving, not effective, cult.

So either you're lazy or you can't.

Now you're using ad homs. I'm not dishonest, you're just having trouble with reading comprehension and can't handle having your hero Orange exposed for being a giant hypocrite.

He's not my hero, and I'm still waiting for the expose.

And yes claiming you've exposed him as a hypocrite is dishonest of you.

Dodge noted. Answer the question. I know you can't

I'm predicting you'll dodge this again.

It's not a dodge, I'm trying to understand what a study about attitudes to homosexuality in the 1980s and ten years ago has to do with this.


No it's a valid criticism.

I'll await your first typo with glee then.



Recovered alcoholics ARE generally more honest, but that wasn't the point.

No it was the point.

You were claiming that there was no scientific consensus as to what was a alcoholic, but now you claim that while we don't know what a alcoholic is we know a recovered alcoholic is more honest?

Okay, NOW I have no choice but to hold your hand. There is a HUGE difference between some anonymous poster using the term to describe people with a drinking problem and it being used to label people in studies when medical professionals haven't even agreed on what it defines.



Answered already.

Now you did not.

What don't you understand about being honest and that helping in your recovery? Do you think recovery goes better by being dishonest?

I'm sorry? My what now?




Yep, that's me! Going to my cult with no leaders once or twice a week, when I feel like it. Able to leave at any time. In fact I'm taking holidays soon and will be MIA for a awhile, do you think my cult will come looking for me? Is Weight Watchers a cult, how about the Girl Guides? Salvation Army? SOS and SMART are they cults too.

LOL Is that you Orange?

You do put the the aggressive in passive aggressive
 
Recovering alcoholics are likely to. For recovering alcoholics (and hopefully for suffering alcoholics too) the rest is meaningless noise.

ps. I find your attempts to blame AA for problems involving an alcoholic spouse in-accurate.

Of course you would. At least, you'd feel compelled to say so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom