Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Where does it say this in the 'Big Book'?

I'm not sure it does say that exactly, and I apologise for not being totally clear (see that Joey? Another apology).

But my question to you is, are you or are you not saying that AA makes alcoholism a moral issue? If I read you right, I would like you to explain it or back it up. This isn't stinkin' thinkin' you know. :);)
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure it does say that exactly.
But my question to you is, are you or are you not saying that AA makes alcoholism a moral issue?

I am saying that, yes. The 'Big Book' is clear that that alcoholism a spiritual malady, and that alcoholism is a consequence.

If don't know the 'Big Book' says that, why are you stating it? You do realize the program is from the book.
 
I am saying that, yes. The 'Big Book' is clear that that alcoholism a spiritual malady, and that alcoholism is a consequence.

Jack, it is a simple question that you seem not to want to answer. Are you saying AA makes alcoholism a moral issue? That is far different to a spiritual malady.
And can you show me where "the big book is clear" on this question of it being a moral issue?

If don't know the 'Big Book' says that, why are you stating it? You do realize the program is from the book.

See edited/added apology.
 
First, you were the one mocking Joey and saying this: "Oh yeah we actively recruit at the courts,we organize parties that go to the courts and hand out flyers. This guy the same as a 9/11 truther. Conspiracy theories galore."

Like it was somehow crazy to think AA would do such thing. Obviously, they do. And to answer your questions:

-Yes, AAs actually do organize people and have them attend hearings.

-Yes, AAs do meet with both judges and prosecutors, as well as defense attorneys.

- I am unaware of any AAs who hang outside of courthouses like Mormons, but AA does hold "information sessions" with district attorneys offices. This happens across the United States. I'm not sure about how it works in Canada, but I know AA is used to mitigate sentences in parts of Canada.

I thought you weren't here to debate me? Yet you keep quoting my posts, how odd.


Anyway, sorry but I'm going to have to start treating you like I do 9/11 truthers.

You have evidence for the above right? Like proof AA has some sort of special department that goes around meeting with the Judiciary.

Besides what does the above have to do with the weasel words "actively recruiting" and "evangelizing?"

AAs go into jails and prisons on their "12-step calls" and set up groups there, where that attendance is used to argue for parole. As a condition of release, these prisoners must attend AA meetings. [As a fun side note, it isn't commonly known that in the U.S., AA is the exception to the rule that convicted felons may not fraternize with each other.]

I guess we should just lock them up and throw away key. You don't think we should help rehabilitate criminals? Especially those who commit crimes after drinking. Drunk drivers for example.

If AA members want to share their stories in jail, why shouldn't they be allowed?

The GSO cannot control the actions of individual members, but they can control the consequences and hold members accountable. Just as virtually every organization I can think of does (sans the Catholic Church). The difference between AA and the real world is, in the regular world, there are consequences. In AA, there is none. This is one reason there is so much crazy in AA. Normal people filter themselves out, and it's the crazies who found a niche in the world where they can do their thing, anonymously and without accountability, stick around.

Really? How would they do that? Please explain. are we going to kick out members who have slept with 40 year old newcomer? Who's conducting the investigation?

Oh and explain how SMART and SOS are any different. If I join next week and a woman seduces me can I have her kicked out?

Our problem with AA is with accountability, both at at the GSO level, intergroup and individual group level. AA is structured in a way to where there is no accountability, and individual members pretend the abuses don't happen, or sweep them under the rug. Like you are doing here, for example.

Quit the hyperbole, what type of abuse are you talking about? Are there crimes taking place? Are the authorities involved? If not why not? Evidence? Let me remind you where you are, anonymous internet anecdotes don't count as evidence here.

Also,I'd like to know how you would structure AA, maybe you'll have a better answer than Joey.

You do realize that an AA citing this guy is like a creationist citing Carl Sagan? Personally, I'm a big fan of him and what he is doing, and have read one of his books, which helped pry me from the 12-step hocus pocus.

Why would you advocate what he says, while at the same time promote AA as the solution? I'm guessing you didn't read much about him before you mined this out of google.

I read the entire thing, he separates dependency from abuse and believes they should be treated separately, one of those treatments is AA. Tell me does Dr. Erickson think AA is bad? Do you have a quote from him advising us to quit AA?


Really? Are you an officer in AA?

No, I don't even know an AA officer, what is that?

I live in the Greater Toronto area, I could attend a different group meeting everyday for the next three months (probably longer) if I was willing to drive an hour from my home.



Again with the rigorous honesty™. AA definitely has leaders. There are some good ones, but there are lots and lots of nutbars, too. The only requirement to gain guru status, is time sober. Old-timers who can't pay their rent or keep a job, can hold court and spout the AA dogma, and have hordes of of groupies cling to their ever word. Here is good example, as told by an AA member of twenty years:



And holy hell, the Clancy Group is very mid-town like. They follow this guy Clancy, dress in suits like Louis Farrakhan's followers, and have their lives micro-managed by Clancy's underlings who lead groups under Clancy's umbrella. Here is a discussion about them at the Friend's of Bill, a pro-AA site: http://fobw.tribe.net/thread/8da36487-4d8a-4221-bb5d-cf478e564ee5

Great tell me, who are my leaders? Alfie and AlBell want to know too. Who are their leaders.

I know for a fact every one of these cities has at least one group, some have several, who leads these groups? Give me names so I can check for myself.

http://www.citypopulation.de/Canada-Ontario.html#Stadt_alpha
 
Last edited:
Besides what does the above have to do with the weasel words "actively recruiting" and "evangelizing?"

I would like an answer to this "recruiting" claim too.

I guess we should just lock them up and throw away key. You don't think we should help rehabilitate criminals? Especially those who commit crimes after drinking. Drunk drivers for example.

If AA members want to share their stories in jail, why shouldn't they be allowed?

Actually I think Jack's real problkem here is with the judicial system, not AA. It is the courts that send them there, not AA that invites them (although they are always accepted, per tradition three).

Oh and explain how SMART and SOS are any different. If I join next week and a woman seduces me can I have her kicked out?

It would depend on a few things I reckon:
- were you drunk?
- and is she good looking? ;)

I know I'm being sexist, sue me.


No, I don't even know an AA officer, what is that?

Me either. Is it possible that he is (gasp) making things up?

Great tell me, who are my leaders? Alfie and AlBell want to know too. Who are their leaders.

Ahem.
That is "Iron man Alfie", if you don't mind.

I'm thinking about getting my name changed from AA Alfie to IM Alfie.
 
Last edited:
Thread reopened. For the last time, address the argument (not the arguer) and be civil and polite. Further bickering and incivility will lead to the thread being placed on moderated status, or possibly being closed outright.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jhunter1163
 
ProBonoShill and A.A. Alfie-

Do the local A.A. districts in your areas not have Corrections and Treatment Committees?

While they are not exactly the same as active recruitment, I can see how the actions delegated to these committees could be construed as "recruitment" by those who want to ascribe nefarious motives to AA.
 
ProBonoShill a number of days ago you said

ProBonoShill said:
No, I'm dismissing him because his site has so many fallacies and contradictions I've grown tired of counting them.

And were asked
Quote one directly from Orange's site and we'll see about that.

Please now show us the fallacies and contradictions on the Orange Papers site[FONT=Calibri, Verdana, Helvetica, Arial][/FONT]
 
Any alcoholic who can't blame his problems on something outside himself isn't trying.
 
ProBonoShill a number of days ago you said



And were asked


Please now show us the fallacies and contradictions on the Orange Papers site[FONT=Calibri, Verdana, Helvetica, Arial][/FONT]



I'm hesitant to spend much time on this because I fear it will be deemed off topic and moved to AAH. Maybe a mod can comment and move it to the appropriate area.

Let's start anyway, the following is after spending less than 10 minutes there.

The site contains a gazillion links and even more words.




Orange freely admits this:

In spite of the scarcity of good, properly run randomized longitudinal controlled studies of the effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous

I agree with him.

But wait.

He then plasters studies that are missing the very characteristics I've highlighted above all over his site.

Studies with minuscule sample sizes, free of subject data.

Studies/Surveys done on people who may or may not even be alcoholics.

Studies/Surveys conducted by questionnaires filled out by people who are notorious liars, those people being alcohol abusers.

Maybe someone should conduct a study focusing on recovered alcoholics (who are demonstrably more honest), ask them if they've ever participated in a "drinking" study and if so were they ever untruthful. I know I certainly was.

What's an alcoholic 8Den? Even the medical community can't agree on that term should mean. Yet Orange cities studies that haven't even qualified their subjects.

He then throws around the 5% canard with glee over and over. That study never mentions how much time the focus group subjects spent in AA. Did they go to one meeting, 4 or 5, a thousand? Maybe some of those people left after a few meetings and didn't like AA. Were they counted as those treated by AA?

I also find it funny he cherry picks the 5%. ZOMG! 95% who went to AA (whatever that means) are out drinking again. Insinuating they are out getting plastered, yet fails to mention that 38% managed to quit OR are now drinking socially, a number at least 10 percentage points above the next best method.



He goes on and on and on about people leaving AA (gee people not ready to give up drinking who haven't invested a penny leaving a self help group, what a shocker, I wonder if anyone's ever quit Weight Watchers. :rolleyes: ) but he never qualifies what he's talking about. Some people come to the rooms, don't like it and leave, does that qualify as AA treatment? How do all these people leaving jive with his AA is a cult stance? Another glaring contradiction.

AA is a mind controlling cult, yet people are leaving freely everyday. :confused:




As well as the cult references, here is another ad hom:


The moment he wittingly drinks so much as a drop of beer, wine, spirits, or any other alcoholic drink he automatically loses all status as a member of Alcoholics Anonymous.

He quotes a pamphlet from 1940 to make them look bad, knowing full well AA Traditions were developed a few years later with #3 stating the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.




I've said many times AA isn't perfect and some groups are better than others, but the conspiracy theory type hysteria found on these AA hate sites is ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
ProBonoShill and A.A. Alfie-

Do the local A.A. districts in your areas not have Corrections and Treatment Committees?

While they are not exactly the same as active recruitment, I can see how the actions delegated to these committees could be construed as "recruitment" by those who want to ascribe nefarious motives to AA.

Sorry I missed this.

I believe we have a 3 person district committee who coordinate the various meetings at correctional facilities in our area. The meetings are identical to the ones "outside", inmates take turns chairing, reading and speaking. The committee tries to provide speakers from outside to share their stories but not everyone is willing to do it. I've done it once and found some are interested but others, are just there to break up the monotony of their stay behind bars.

I find my friends in AA who found sobriety in prison or were former inmates are the ones most willing to speak in the jails. Recently I lost a friend to cancer, he spent 10+ years in Kingston Penitentiary. He helped me alot when I first quit drinking and used to speak in the jails quite a bit. If you were to call him a leader or say he was recruiting anyone, he would've laughed his ass off.
 
You continually ignore my posts and yet somehow think I'm going to address yours?

You're one funny guy Jack.

Welcome to ignore.

Actually, I was asking you to answer the question you didn't answer before, not my question. 8den asked you to point out the contradictions and fallacies that Orange has on his site, but you didn't do that. Well, you kind of did. You quoted from an old AA brochure that is quoted on the Orange site, and wrongly called it "ad hominem." I'm guessing you aren't aware of what ad hominem means. Still, you were on the right track.

So, if you won't answer my question, could you at least answer the original question from 8den? I haven't read that whole site, and I would like to see where he contradicted himself or put forth a logical fallacy.
 
What is the topic of this thread? it seems to have gone badly astray.

Shall I ask outside the thread, or can someone here tell us the topic?
 
That's what it's become. Not the same thing.

What's the topic of this thread, as set forth in the opening post, by the thread starter?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom