ProBonoShill a number of days ago you said
And were asked
Please now show us the fallacies and contradictions on the Orange Papers site[FONT=Calibri, Verdana, Helvetica, Arial][/FONT]
I'm hesitant to spend much time on this because I fear it will be deemed off topic and moved to AAH. Maybe a mod can comment and move it to the appropriate area.
Let's start anyway, the following is after spending less than 10 minutes there.
The site contains a gazillion links and even more words.
Orange freely admits this:
In spite of the scarcity of good, properly run randomized longitudinal controlled studies of the effectiveness of Alcoholics Anonymous
I agree with him.
But wait.
He then plasters studies that are missing the very characteristics I've highlighted above all over his site.
Studies with minuscule sample sizes, free of subject data.
Studies/Surveys done on people who may or may not even be alcoholics.
Studies/Surveys conducted by questionnaires filled out by people who are notorious liars, those people being alcohol abusers.
Maybe someone should conduct a study focusing on recovered alcoholics (who are demonstrably more honest), ask them if they've ever participated in a "drinking" study and if so were they ever untruthful. I know I certainly was.
What's an alcoholic 8Den? Even the medical community can't agree on that term should mean. Yet Orange cities studies that haven't even qualified their subjects.
He then throws around the 5% canard with glee over and over. That study never mentions how much time the focus group subjects spent in AA. Did they go to one meeting, 4 or 5, a thousand? Maybe some of those people left after a few meetings and didn't like AA. Were they counted as those treated by AA?
I also find it funny he cherry picks the 5%. ZOMG! 95% who went to AA (whatever that means) are out drinking again. Insinuating they are out getting plastered, yet fails to mention that 38% managed to quit OR are now drinking socially, a number at least 10 percentage points above the next best method.
He goes on and on and on about people leaving AA (gee people not ready to give up drinking who haven't invested a penny leaving a self help group, what a shocker, I wonder if anyone's ever quit Weight Watchers.

) but he never qualifies what he's talking about. Some people come to the rooms, don't like it and leave, does that qualify as AA treatment? How do all these people leaving jive with his AA is a cult stance? Another glaring contradiction.
AA is a mind controlling cult, yet people are leaving freely everyday.
As well as the cult references, here is another ad hom:
The moment he wittingly drinks so much as a drop of beer, wine, spirits, or any other alcoholic drink he automatically loses all status as a member of Alcoholics Anonymous.
He quotes a pamphlet from 1940 to make them look bad, knowing full well AA Traditions were developed a few years later with #3 stating the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.
I've said many times AA isn't perfect and some groups are better than others, but the conspiracy theory type hysteria found on these AA hate sites is ridiculous.