Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You certainly have opinions. Too bad any evidence to back them up is lacking.

From the "How it works" from every meeting

[FONT=Arial, Arial, Helvetica] Rarely have we seen a person fail who has thoroughly followed our path. Those who do not recover are people who cannot or will not completely give themselves to this simple program, usually men and women who are constitutionally incapable of being honest with themselves. There are such unfortunates. They are not at fault; they seem to have been born that way. They are naturally incapable of grasping and developing a manner of living which demands rigorous honesty. Their chances are less than average. There are those, too, who suffer from grave emotional and mental disorders, but many of them do recover if they have the capacity to be honest.[/FONT]


Really get someone desperate for help coping with addiction. Tell them it's not their fault that they have a disease, tell them they have to hit bottom before they can change and, then tell them that.
 
Yes, we can, but, since I clearly explained what I meant, I don't see why it is my fault that you are willfully misunderstanding me.

:rolleyes:

I'm sorry you feel that way, but, again, it is not my fault that you cannot see that the division of motions into "voluntary" and "involuntary" is simplistic, especially when the parts of the brain that the subject does not perceive and operating under conscious control can influence the subject's ability to make a conscious or voluntary decision.

I understand the distinction. But having my arm twitch uncontrollably and solving a complex mathematical equation are two complete different things, for instance. No matter of loss of control will make you do the latter.
 
*snip*
Where has anyone in this thread ever denied it exists. While I don't agree with it, it's not a crime. It's definitely not rampant.


How do you know?

That was 75 years ago. The big book is an historical document with some good ideas and many that have outgrown their usefulness. On top of that it was the writings of a man with a heavy religious bent.


Which hasn't been changed one iota in those 75 years. Deliberately not changed. Therefore, it can certainly be reasonably concluded that the program now is as it was when it was first set out. "Take what you want and leave the rest" is an unofficial statement that came about decades later, and is even being actively fought against by many AAs.
 
Completely untrue. The AA actively participates and encourages this.

Encouraging or discouraging. Meh
The truth is that AA has its traditions which have served them very well (for the most part) for a long time. That the legal system abdicates its responsibilities is not AAs fault.
That criminals in prison need some assistance with their addiction and AA is all on offer is not AAs fault either.

Your problem is with the legal system, not AA.

Indeed who, who came up with the idea, and why didn't the AA object or continue to object.

Who came up with it? Probably someone trying to help suffering alcoholics in prison. Go figure, someone seeing a problem and trying to fix it. :rolleyes:

Why no objection? Check the traditions.

AA tells them they have no choice they could leave and they will most likely die.


There is an inherent danger in ceasing any form of maintenance for an addict/alcoholic. No?
But I agree that a member saying that "AA is the only way" or similar is untrue. It may be true for them, but not for everyone.

Sorry no. Some of the people in AA are at their most vulnerable and low. And they should be aware that some of the other people in the room are using AA as part of a plea bargain to escape from prison.

It's a recipe for disaster.

Again I quite agree. But again, your beef is with the legal system, not AA whose doors are open to everyone.

Good. But people with these addictions can stop. And so can alcoholics. They have power over their lives, contrary to what the AA steps claim.

Of course people have control, but they lost control of their drinking along the way.
AA talks about "powerless over alcohol". Control is regained once the disease (if I can use that term) is arrested.
The rest of your post is a total misunderstanding and seems to have been taken straight out of that South Park episode. It is also wrong, just plain wrong.

This is most incredibly disingenuous

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q...&sig=AHIEtbSDDAk0N1ezKSiWCQiDE035hfYigg&pli=1


Or A.A. Guidelines Cooperating with Court, D.W.I. and Similar Programs.

AA have extensive guidelines for dealing with courts and DWI programs, and actively approach and recruit offer hope in prisons.

ftfy

And while I din't go through the whole document you have provided, I don't see your point. It actually confirms everything I have been saying.


Incidently Alfie I've read the thread on stinkin thinking, and your claims about ....

Reported.

Which hasn't been changed one iota in those 75 years. Deliberately not changed. Therefore, it can certainly be reasonably concluded that the program now is as it was when it was first set out. "Take what you want and leave the rest" is an unofficial statement that came about decades later, and is even being actively fought against by many AAs.

I'm not one for rewriting history, nor book burning for that matter.

There are some that treat the big book as "the one true source of enlightenment" or whatever. Within AA they are often referred to as "Big Book Nazis" and they are usually treated with patience and understanding (if not a smidgy bit of derision). They usually grow out of it, it is seems to be something like an adolescent phase. My personal foray into big book naziism only lasted a few weeks.
 
Last edited:
Encouraging or discouraging. Meh
The truth is that AA has its traditions which have served them very well (for the most part) for a long time. That the legal system abdicates its responsibilities is not AAs fault.
That criminals in prison need some assistance with their addiction and AA is all on offer is not AAs fault either.

Your problem is with the legal system, not AA.

Piffle AA actively encourages a process that you claim is forced upon them.


Who came up with it? Probably someone trying to help suffering alcoholics in prison. Go figure, someone seeing a problem and trying to fix it. :rolleyes:

Well someone's changed their tune.....



There is an inherent danger in ceasing any form of maintenance for an addict/alcoholic. No?
But I agree that a member saying that "AA is the only way" or similar is untrue. It may be true for them, but not for everyone.

AA offers or suggests no alternative, merely that those who fail AA are doomed to fail at life.

Again I quite agree. But again, your beef is with the legal system, not AA whose doors are open to everyone.

AA hold the door open for people. AA is full of criminals who used AA as a get out of jail free (or early) card and then continued on their criminal way.

It seems like you have a handy get out of jail free card here AA Alfie. Anything good AA does is because of AA, and any failures, or morally reprehensible act that happens around AA, happens in spite of AA.
ftfy

And while I din't go through the whole document you have provided, I don't see your point. It actually confirms everything I have been saying.

Wonderful, you didn't read it but none the less you know it confirms what you are saying. Gosh what tremendous psych powers you have at your disposal. Call Randi claim your million, you're psychic!

Lets remind the people what you said;

Actually your beef is really with the court system for accepting this a part of the plea bargain, parole conditions etc. It seems that both the court system and those criminals use AAs open minded approach to membership for their own purposes. It is more like AA is the victim here than the perpetrator wouldn't you say?

Now then you were shown how AA don't just passively accept the court system fostering them with criminals and early release types why they actively cooperate with them, and you're still claiming you're right!

Reported.

What's to report? You claimed the crowd at "stinkin thinkin" are "animals" and "dolts", and when I took a look at the thread I found you making patronising suggestions about the size of people's genital, and suggesting that they're obese. While gleefully crowing at the attention you were getting, and mocking them for their attitude towards AA.

A.A. Alfie you're supposed to be a mental health professional, working with addiction your behaviour on that thread wasn't just uncivilised it was downright unprofessional.

I really wouldn't have kept bringing up that forum for all to see here.

I'm not one for rewriting history, nor book burning for that matter.

There are some that treat the big book as "the one true source of enlightenment" or whatever. Within AA they are often referred to as "Big Book Nazis" and they are usually treated with patience and understanding (if not a smidgy bit of derision). They usually grow out of it, it is seems to be something like an adolescent phase. My personal foray into big book naziism only lasted a few weeks.

And yet funny enough there is one piece of literature every AA member is supposed to have and read from.
 
Personal attack noted.


No, if I called you a simpleton. that would've been a personal attack. I have faith you can do better, but's it's slowly fading.


Approval from whom? How? The GSO appears to just rake in the cash and doesn't seem answerable to anyone.


Conspiracy theories are that way ---------->


Now go reread my post and answer the questions, otherwise people here are going to believe the simpleton moniker is indeed apt.


No wait I did. It's simple. The kind of trial you suggest is exactly what the AA is capable of, and should do



Your feelings aren't evidence, put on your critical thinking cap and explain in detail how AA will finance, organize and conduct these studies. You're dodging my questions because you don't know the answers or you don't like them.



Wait no see this is you treating me like a idiot again.



More dodging, you're new at this debate stuff aren't you.



Really where?


Proof you don't understand what one is.


No you made the claim about the site. And then you announced it has "loads of links"

I'm asking you to share which specific parts of the orange papers



You've been a member since 2006, so I'm sure you're well aware it is against forum rules to post large excerpts from elsewhere.

Everything I've talked about can be found on this page:

http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-effectiveness.html




You've made this claim several days ago. And once again I notice you've failed to list a single fallacy or contradiction.
It's getting tiresome now.


Now you're just lying.

I'm going to ask you some questions. If you dodge these like you've done the others, it will be evident for all to see and I'll no longer engage your dishonesty.

Does Orange claim many times AA is a cult?

Does Orange claim, AA has a terrible retention rate?

Do these two claims contradict each other.

Also, does Orange claim AA has leaders?

Who are my leaders, who leads AA Alfie and AlBell. I want specific names of those ordering me around.




I've not used a single one.

I've simply asked you to show me a single fallacy or contradiction in the orange papers.



Ignorance is bliss. I've already pointed out two.

- Cult ≠ people freely leaving, no leader


- admits there's a scarcity of proper studies, but that doesn't matter let's use crappy, inconclusive, miniscule ones anyway in attempts to slander AA.



Really? Where?

I've looked through this thread and I cant see them.

Why don't you be a dear. And Link to the fallacies and contradictions, and explain in detail why they are wrong.


Liar


So either you're lazy or you can't.


Lie



He's not my hero, and I'm still waiting for the expose.

And yes claiming you've exposed him as a hypocrite is dishonest of you.



Not sure why you're waiting it's been posted for awhile and yep he's a hypocrite.





It's not a dodge, I'm trying to understand what a study about attitudes to homosexuality in the 1980s and ten years ago has to do with this.



Yep, no answer, just as I predicted. This seems to be a pattern for you.

Oh and you're guilty of another fallacy, red herring.

I'll ask again one last time:

A study was conducted in 1983 asserting 24% of it's respondents knew someone who is gay, the number increased to to 73% in 2001, why do think that is? Did someone put something in the water to create more homosexuals?


I'll await your first typo with glee then.


That wasn't a typo it was a made-up word.




No it was the point.

You were claiming that there was no scientific consensus as to what was a alcoholic, but now you claim that while we don't know what a alcoholic is we know a recovered alcoholic is more honest?

Another big fat strawman. You left out a word and context. Why?



Now you did not.



Did too. See I can use fourth grade arguments too.



I'm sorry? My what now?



Your. As in a third person pronoun. I should be getting paid for this.:rolleyes:






You do put the the aggressive in passive aggressive



You're dodging again, you should seek some help for that.
 
How do you know?

You got me, in the province of Ontario members trying to pick up other members for sex isn't rampant.

Or maybe it is and I've never heard of it. They might be having secret AA orgies late at night others aren't aware of. Anything's possible.
 
AA tells them they have no choice they could leave and they will most likely die.



There is an inherent danger in ceasing any form of maintenance for an addict/alcoholic. No?
But I agree that a member saying that "AA is the only way" or similar is untrue. It may be true for them, but not for everyone.







I bookmarked this a few months ago:

http://www.daily-reflections.com/2011/04/23/aa-is-not-a-cure-all-2-3/




In my early years of sobriety I was full of pride, thinking that A.A. was the only source of treatment for a good and happy life. It certainly was the basic ingredient for my sobriety and even today, with over twelve years in the program, I am very involved in meetings, sponsorship and service. During the first four years of my recovery, I found it necessary to seek professional help, since my emotional health was extremely poor. There are those folks too, who have found sobriety and happiness in other organizations. A.A. taught me that I had a choice: to go to any lengths to enhance my sobriety. A.A. may not be a cure-all for everything, but it is the center of my sober living.





Others comments in that link are similar to the above.



I guess 8Den is wrong again.
 
Piffle AA actively encourages a process that you claim is forced upon them.

Evidence please.

Well someone's changed their tune.....

How so?

AA offers or suggests no alternative,

You clearly missed the bit where I said those statements made by members are untrue. We agree on this, yet you still want to fight me on the point. :rolleyes:

You also missed this question, so I will ask it again:

There is an inherent danger in ceasing any form of maintenance for an addict/alcoholic. No?

AA hold the door open for people. AA is full of criminals who used AA as a get out of jail free (or early) card and then continued on their criminal way.

AA offers nothing to these so called criminals except experience strength and hope. It is the judiciary that offers a get out of jail free card, not AA.

I am totally amazed you can't see this.

Wonderful, you didn't read it but none the less you know it confirms what you are saying. Gosh what tremendous psych powers you have at your disposal. Call Randi claim your million, you're psychic!

He he. Nice try. Fail.

Which bits in there confirm your claims then matey?

Now then you were shown how AA don't just passively accept the court system fostering them with criminals and early release types why they actively cooperate with them, and you're still claiming you're right!

Where did you show me this? Where is that in your little document exactly?
Like I said, the judiciary offers the 'get out of jail card'. AA offers a possible solution to their alcohol problems.

What's to report?

Read you MA.

A.A. Alfie you're supposed to be a mental health professional, working with addiction your behaviour on that thread wasn't just uncivilised it was downright unprofessional.

Where should I send my invoice? I didn't realise you were paying me and that I was on the clock. :rolleyes:

Debate there about there, not here.

I really wouldn't have kept bringing up that forum for all to see here.

You would like that wouldn't you?
I imagine much more to protect the members there than to protect me. I stand by my fun and games there as just that, fun and games with kiddies.

I will give you one thing, at least you are prepared to discuss things here rather than the poo-fling-fest that is ST.

And yet funny enough there is one piece of literature every AA member is supposed to have and read from.

Being proof of what? That we enjoy history, That the big book is a good place for a newcomer to start? What?

Or maybe it is and I've never heard of it. They might be having secret AA orgies late at night others aren't aware of. Anything's possible.

Where does one sign up?
 
Last edited:
That article certainly is certainly on topic. The first three comments are god related, and most of the others as well. Why, indeed, do people claim AA is not religious...
 
That article certainly is certainly on topic. The first three comments are god related, and most of the others as well. Why, indeed, do people claim AA is not religious...

The answer really is very simple you know.

It is a spiritual program, not religious.
Religion equals spiritual. Sure
But Spirituality does not have to be religious.
 
Same difference. Made up supernatural forces.

And this is where your confusion lies.
Straight off wiki:

Religion implies a particular faith tradition that includes acceptance of a metaphysical or supernatural reality, whereas spirituality is not necessarily bound to any particular religious tradition

and

If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being. This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings.

So again, to the OP and you. The reason why someone can say that AA is not religious but spiritual is determined by how they ascribe usage to the words and how they define them. For mine, the differences are clear, for others not so much. That does not make my interpretation any less valid; just different.

This thread can now close. :D
 
Religion implies a particular faith tradition that includes acceptance of a metaphysical or supernatural reality, whereas spirituality is not necessarily bound to any particular religious tradition

AA insists on belief in a "god," "a god as we know him," and "a higher power, all of which qualify it as religious under your definition.

If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being. This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings.

Without all the god bothering AA does, this definition would fit. Unfortunately . . .

So again, to the OP and you. The reason why someone can say that AA is not religious but spiritual is determined by how they ascribe usage to the words and how they define them. For mine, the differences are clear, for others not so much. That does not make my interpretation any less valid; just different.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed personal comment
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Same difference. Made up supernatural forces.

Except that you don't have to believe in any supernatural entity or force to be spiritual, at least in the AA sense. All that you have to believe in is a power greater than yourself, and there are plenty of those that are completely natural.
 
I sent this a a PM to qayak, but I really meant to post it here:

qayak said:
Religion implies a particular faith tradition that includes acceptance of a metaphysical or supernatural reality, whereas spirituality is not necessarily bound to any particular religious tradition

AA insists on belief in a "god," "a god as we know him," and "a higher power, all of which qualify it as religious under your definition.

If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being. This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings.

Without all the god bothering AA does, this definition would fit. Unfortunately . . .

Just because the word "God" is used doesn't mean that "God" has to supernatural. In fact, "God" can be some aspect of one's psyche that one externalizes unconsciously.
 
I was referring to the link posted. Most comments were religious in nature. There is no evidence of the existence of a "spirit". The mind is in the brain. So "spiritual" is directly linked to the supernatural.
Also, they tell you you can use anything as a higher power, but what does that really mean? Nothing.
 
Last edited:
I was referring to the link posted. Most comments were religious in nature. There is no evidence of the existence of a "spirit". The mind is in the brain. So "spiritual" is directly linked to the supernatural.
Also, they tell you you can use anything as a higher power, but what does that really mean? Nothing.

So say you.

Don't you think it is a little arrogant for you to be deciding what the beliefs of AA members mean?
 
I sent this a a PM to qayak, but I really meant to post it here:



Just because the word "God" is used doesn't mean that "God" has to supernatural. In fact, "God" can be some aspect of one's psyche that one externalizes unconsciously.

We've been down this road before. I'd suggest you go read the entire thread, but I like you. :)

Dynamic explained it really well many pages ago.

For me, having a higher power reminds me I don't control everything. I can't control all the gravitational forces in the universe. I can't make barometric pressure go up and down. I don't control the inner workings of a combustable engine.

If I'm driving on the highway today and my car breaks down, oh well stuff happens.

Before when I was drinking I'd take that as a personal affront and complain about my lot in life.

The last 5 years of my drinking career I basically held the belief, my life was destined to suck and it would always be that way, so I'd better get used to it.

Thankfully I don't feel that way any longer and my life for the most part is great.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom