Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The discussion has deviated from the AA program to whether alcoholism ca better be described as a matter of "personal responsibility" or a matter of "loss of control". The preponderance of recent research indicates that it is the latter.


Yes, I agree and have stated as such in this thread months and months ago. My point was not to challenge you on this issue but to use it as a useful contrast to the AA belief structure.
 
Do you really not understand the difference between "after the first drink" and "whether or not they drink"?

Of course I can. All you have to do is actually mention that this is what you were talking about, rather than remain opaque and try to appear clever.

In the former case, the subject has had at least one drink, whereas, in the latter case the, the subject has had no drinks at all. Yes, the "alcoholic" can control his or her drinking by choosing not to drink at all, but, once he or she has one drink, it is very difficult, if not impossible, for him or her to stop until he or she has become intoxicated.

I find it hard to believe that it becomes "impossible" to control your own voluntary muscles.

Such a "loss of control" has been observed in rats that have had prolonged exposure to ethanol and then been abstinent for some time:

Rats < People.

From controlled drug intake to loss of control: the irreversible development of drug addiction in the rat

This information is not hard to find given that there are free online journal databases, so I am surprised that those arguing against the disease model of alcoholism/addiction have not at least made an effort to address the vast amount of research support the disease model and phenomena such as "loss of control" that has been done.

And does this "loss of control" only apply to alcohol, or to other things as well ?
 
The discussion has deviated from the AA program to whether alcoholism ca better be described as a matter of "personal responsibility" or a matter of "loss of control". The preponderance of recent research indicates that it is the latter.

I can foresee drunk drivers using that excuse...
 
Reductio ad Absurdum.

Focusing on personal responsibility doesn't mean that's the sole focus.
But give some drunks an inch, and they'll take a length of rope and literally or metaphorically hang themselves with it.

I was lectured constantly for my enabling of my ex's alcoholism, and I was too young or naive to see what was meant. My merely loving him and staying with him was enabling to him. He was and is a past master of twisting anything to suit his needs.

He was "sick," AA said so.
He was powerless; AA said so.
The responsibility was that of his higher power, to remove his shortcomings, not his own.

He was twisting AA to enable his drinking. How many others do that? Can't AA do a better job at removing enabling strategies, as much as possible? I know they can't possibly remove them all, but some are glaring, in my experience.

Why would one want to be party to enabling someone who needs to get better?
What's the excuse? If removing some of those tools could be helpful, then why insist it isn't necessary?

Smells like denial.
 
Last edited:
Here's a fun quote from a stepper who commented over at the stinkin thinkin blog today:

You are all “right”
if you pray enough…properly….your cancer WILL GO AWAY

the people in AA who “don’t make it”….do it wrong

they don’t follow directions…they don’t find God
they don’t take it a day at a time etc

not drinking is the tip of theiceberg

why we drink…resntments,dis-honesty,selfishness and fear
thats the root cause
that what the “steps” are for

and
for every story you post someone else will post a story of a MIRACLE


This is the third most delusional stepper I've seen this week,

Edited by LashL: 
Edited breach of Rule 12 and Rule 0.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
"If it doesn't work as promised, it's because you did it wrong."

"God doesn't answer prayer at all. He's not a Cosmic gum machine. You shouldn't have asked."
"God only answers the prayers of the faithful. You're not faithful enough."
"God does answer prayer. Most of the time, he says 'no,' because you asked for the wrong thing."
"God can't answer prayer, because it negates your free will."
"You didn't pray properly."

Hmmm...I see a common thread between this and:

You are all “right”
if you pray enough…properly….your cancer WILL GO AWAY

the people in AA who “don’t make it”….do it wrong

they don’t follow directions…they don’t find God
they don’t take it a day at a time etc

not drinking is the tip of theiceberg

why we drink…resntments,dis-honesty,selfishness and fear
thats the root cause
that what the “steps” are for
 
"Once I start drinking I am powerless to stop until I pass out" is a completely different claim. It allows you to realize that "maybe I shouldn't have that first drink, then". The claim of absolute powerlessness excludes that possibility.

Which is precisely why I posted my perspective on the matter. There may be some who claim the absolute type of powerlessness you describe, but I don't number myself among them. Frankly, the notion strikes me as absurd.
 
Here's a fun quote from a stepper who commented over at the stinkin thinkin blog today:

and

This is the third most delusional stepper I've seen this week,
Edited by LashL: 
Edited breach of Rule 12 and Rule 0.

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/2011/06/23/the-looking-glass/

:eek:

Wowzers this lady is going freakin' bonkers in the comments over there!

"It’s a rare occurrence that we capture this kind of lunacy in the wild" We got a real live one 'ere mate!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Of course I can. All you have to do is actually mention that this is what you were talking about, rather than remain opaque and try to appear clever.

Uh...I wasn't not trying to be "clever". It was quite obvious that you were conflating having take a drink with not having taken a drink.

I find it hard to believe that it becomes "impossible" to control your own voluntary muscles.

Since when is an argument from personal incredulity valid.

Rats < People.

Are you saying that animal models provide little to no insight into human behavior?

What do you have to say about the human study I posted?

And does this "loss of control" only apply to alcohol, or to other things as well ?

It's a general model for addiction, but you would know that if you had done some cursory research instead of posting your ignorant opinions.

I can foresee drunk drivers using that excuse...

Since when is an argument from consequences valid?
 
Reductio ad Absurdum.

Focusing on personal responsibility doesn't mean that's the sole focus.
But give some drunks an inch, and they'll take a length of rope and literally or metaphorically hang themselves with it.

I was lectured constantly for my enabling of my ex's alcoholism, and I was too young or naive to see what was meant. My merely loving him and staying with him was enabling to him. He was and is a past master of twisting anything to suit his needs.

He was "sick," AA said so.
He was powerless; AA said so.
The responsibility was that of his higher power, to remove his shortcomings, not his own.

He was twisting AA to enable his drinking. How many others do that? Can't AA do a better job at removing enabling strategies, as much as possible? I know they can't possibly remove them all, but some are glaring, in my experience.

Why would one want to be party to enabling someone who needs to get better?
What's the excuse? If removing some of those tools could be helpful, then why insist it isn't necessary?

Smells like denial.
Smells like a truly crappy AA group or groups.
 
It has been demonstrated through research that there is such a thing as "loss of control", so I don't see the logic in insisting that alcoholism is merely an issue of "personal responsibility".

If that's true, then it follows that AA's program couldn't work, any more than faith healing can cure cancer... unless of course one believes there's a god or similar supernatural force actually interceding.

A person who has literally, biologically lost control isn't going to regain that control simply by interacting with other alcoholics and changing how he thinks about things, any more than someone whose body is producing cancer cells can get it to stop just by association with other cancer patients and thinking differently.
 
@slingblade: Guess I've been lucky in that I've been a member of several US groups but never had the misfortune of seeing horror stories that obviously do exist.

Do you know if your ex was ever a member of a Closed Discussion group?
 
If that's true, then it follows that AA's program couldn't work, any more than faith healing can cure cancer... unless of course one believes there's a god or similar supernatural force actually interceding.

A person who has literally, biologically lost control isn't going to regain that control simply by interacting with other alcoholics and changing how he thinks about things, any more than someone whose body is producing cancer cells can get it to stop just by association with other cancer patients and thinking differently.

:rolleyes:

Again, anyone can avoid taking that first drink. Alcoholics lack the ability to stop after taking the first drink.

AA provides a social network that encourages alcoholics not to take that first drink and give them the tools to cope with situations that induce the desire to drink.
 
:rolleyes:

Again, anyone can avoid taking that first drink. Alcoholics lack the ability to stop after taking the first drink.

AA provides a social network that encourages alcoholics not to take that first drink and give them the tools to cope with situations that induce the desire to drink.

If the first paragraph is true, then even alcoholics have power over alcohol. I agree with what Slingblade posted a few posts above:

If instead of "became powerless," why not something more like, "gave up our power to alcohol" in a sense of being willing to reclaim that power? Just as one example. It puts the responsibility squarely and unambiguously on ourselves, where it belongs in most cases. I don't see how this could hurt AA, and do see where it could help the people in it.
 
Good afternoon, all. May I have your attention, please?

Cut out the personalizations, stay on topic to this thread, and be civil to each other.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
Pup said:
:rolleyes:

Again, anyone can avoid taking that first drink. Alcoholics lack the ability to stop after taking the first drink.

AA provides a social network that encourages alcoholics not to take that first drink and give them the tools to cope with situations that induce the desire to drink.

If the first paragraph is true, then even alcoholics have power over alcohol. I agree with what Slingblade posted a few posts above:

If instead of "became powerless," why not something more like, "gave up our power to alcohol" in a sense of being willing to reclaim that power? Just as one example. It puts the responsibility squarely and unambiguously on ourselves, where it belongs in most cases. I don't see how this could hurt AA, and do see where it could help the people in it.

Because the evidence from actual scientific research does not suggest that alcoholics "gave up control"; it suggest that they "lost control".

This is not a really difficult concept to grasp, but it does require that people stop moralizing about excessive alcohol consumption.
 
@slingblade: Guess I've been lucky in that I've been a member of several US groups but never had the misfortune of seeing horror stories that obviously do exist.

Do you know if your ex was ever a member of a Closed Discussion group?

He attended Open Meetings, and those were the sort I attended with him several times, and Closed Meetings, which he said I couldn't go to, so I didn't. I went to the Al_Anon meeting in the same buildings instead, if they had one.
 
Yep

I see this all the time. Alcoholics lose their moral compass and the impact on partners and others is devastating.
I would believe these comments to be accurate and in line with the experience of others generally.

Correct, but not just vecause AA said so. The medical profession etc too.

They actually would have said he was "powerless over alcohol".

Incorrect. The responsibility was his and his alone. That said, AA would have suggested he needed help from elsewhere, but not that he was not responsible. If he heard only this, or repeated only this he is using it as a cop out as I have previously explained.
I believe he was maintaining his levels of manipulation and selective hearing.

Exactly

At the risk of sounding rude, and I'm certainly not trying to be. The problem of enabling lies with the enabler (i.e. you) not the alcoholic. Sure they helped you get there, but once you are there the responsiobility is yours to rectify. Help is available through counselling, support groups, other therapies etc.

Thank you. See, I do see the program with a not-totally jaundiced eye. I only think it could improve, and needs to. Everything needs an upgrade now and then...



How did you find alanon? Did it help?

Unfortunately no, it didn't. I didn't understand what they were trying to tell me, in any of the meetings I attended in Denver and the suburbs.

I'd say in a meeting that his behaviors hurt me, and they'd say, "but you're letting it hurt you." I could not wrap my 20-something head around that. I tried, but it just felt like they were blaming me. Like his alcoholism was my fault.

Letting it hurt me? Like I could choose? How could all the abuse I took not hurt? And because I was a die-hard Thumper Fundie back then, I couldn't just walk out on my marriage, as was often suggested to me. Many of the Al-Anon members urged me to divorce him, many times. I...don't think they should have, or if they were right to, then they didn't handle it right. Not for me. It built walls. He was already hurting me; I couldn't let these women hurt me, too.

I didn't realize that, as I said, my simply being his wife was a way of enabling him to drink. I see it now, but then again, I'm also no longer religious. A lot of things are clearer to me now.
 
Great (personal) post Slingblade! Am truly sorry you had to go though that crap with an active drinker - my assumption is things are much better now?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom