Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
So it wasn't your will that picked up that first drink it was your gene?

You know, this is a strange twist. I could swear most of the people who are arguing that alcoholism is a matter of will are the same people that argue that homosexuality is not a choice. Yet, like alcoholism, homosexuality does not have a firm biosociological or psychobiological explanation. Nonetheless, when the behavior is non-harmful, as is the case with homosexuality itself, the behavior is deemed "not a choice", whereas when the behavior is harmful, as is the case with alcoholism, the behavior is deemed "a choice".

Why would anyone rationally decided to harm themselves?
 
Not what I said, but it is not surprising that your recapitulation of my argument would lack any subtlety.

Wait...wait. Here:

You said:
Yes, you are contending that an alcoholic has a choice to continue drinking after the first drink.

And then to:

Me said:
So now you're contending that an alcoholic CANNOT have any control over whether or not they drink ?

You say:

You said:
Not what I said

Then what the hell ARE you saying ?
 
Belz... said:
Not what I said, but it is not surprising that your recapitulation of my argument would lack any subtlety.

Wait...wait. Here:

You said:
Yes, you are contending that an alcoholic has a choice to continue drinking after the first drink.

And then to:

Me said:
So now you're contending that an alcoholic CANNOT have any control over whether or not they drink ?

You say:

You said:
Not what I said

Then what the hell ARE you saying ?


Perhaps that you can't count.

1!=0.
 
Last edited:
I speak from experience. 2 uncles and my mother were alchoholics. My mother and 1 uncle were able to make the choice to turn their lives around, stop drinking and reclaim ther lives. They both fully admit that they made the choice to drink to excess- just as they made the decison to quit. I used to drink to excess, and made an ass of mysdelf- only after seeing the footage of what a drunken jerk i was at a siblings wedding, I made the choice never to drink to excess again. I made the choice to be a drunk, likewise i made the choice to stop drinking..


So your mother and and an uncle while being heavily inebriated had the mental faculties to say to themselves "I know I've drank too much tonight but **** it let's keep going"? I 'm not sure if you're aware of this but I'll let you in on a little secret, when people are intoxicated they're not very good at making decisions.


Obviously you see all addicts as victims iof outside forces who shouldn't bear any responsibility for their actions- i think it's you who is clueless about addiction. That is the kind of mindset that will keep a person stuck in ther addicton.


That's one big fat strawman you've built there.





The first step a person must do to beat addiction is acknowldge they have a problem- then in order to make changes, they have to admit responsibility, and admit they put themselves in their current situtation.



I agree wholeheartedly, but what if the person isn't aware of the extent of the problem or doesn't think they have a problem? What if they believe all they need to do is control it better?



Your example of 'the poor girl being handed a crack pipe at 16' suggests you think that peson dodesn't bear any responsibilty for taking that first smoke. In your world view, when does personal responsibility begin and end for the addict?



So if two people consume a substance, one can stop after having a small quantity and the other can't. You want me to believe it's because one has more willpower and self discipline than the other? If one is blessed with strong willpower, is that trait able to be applied for everything in ones life. I know many people who smoke who would like to quit, yet have no problem with alcohol, why is that? If a person's "willpower" isn't as strong as another's are they supposed to feel more responsible?



I wince when i hear alchoholics blame their drinking on 'a disease'.



Yeah those poor fools I know who have died from alcoholism, if only the had your self discipline they'd still be alive. :rolleyes:






People make bad decisions are die, yes. All the time. Today I ate a 275g bag of chips in one sitting. I know I shouldn't. Why do I keep doing that ? Willpower.



Do chips contain a mind altering addictive substance?

That comparison wasn't very good, but you know that.






Do you really believe that's the argument?



The reasons why she doesn't "just quit" would be numerous, interconnected, and complicated.

That doesn't absolve her from personal responsibility. If she can't make the choice--however many times she needs to make it--to help herself, then she won't get better.

Or are you saying the famous 12-steps are worked upon you?

Odd...I've always heard you have to work your own program, not that the program works you.




Another strawman, what's with you guys putting words in my mouth anyway?

People become addicted to substances, they might not see the danger at first, I know as sure as hell didn't, but once you're addicted it's not a simple matter of just stopping, that's ridiculous.







You LOLed at the idea that anyone was getting rich off AA. Those figures show that some are. Anyway, I'm glad you were able to square that in your mind and move on.[ /QUOTE]



LOL again, it seems AA executives make comparable salaries to those in other similar organizations, no conspiracy there! I wouldn't exactly describe those people as rich either, nor would Obama. :D


Oh my gosh. Sorry, Alfie!!



Dodge noted.




Did you see the picture at the top of the FAQ? Are you seriously making the case that I'm trying to recruit AA members in that FAQ? I wrote that to address the AA scolds who land there wagging their fingers at us, saying exactly the same things. I got sick of responding to the same things over and over again. I think at one point in there I tell them to kiss my ass. I wouldn't exactly call that honey.




That's a community for people who have left AA. Again, I'm not sure how you're making the case that we exist to seduce AA members out of AA. So weird.



Are you saying that because we write about AA, we're writing for AA members? This is such a disingenuous argument -- I'd be surprised if you even really stand behind yourself here.



Ahhh I get, if you're an AA member you suck, but once you leave you're allowed in the little club and get a pat on the back.

You're such a kind, open-minded and understanding group.




That's very funny. Is that how skeptics operate? Please bring evidence, but I won't look at it objectively if it comes from certain sources that freak me out.

Well, here. Do some reading: J.M. Brandsma, M.C. Maultsby, and R.J. Walsh, The Outpatient Treatment of Alcoholism: A Review and Comparative Study (University Park Press, 1980).

This is a controlled study of people randomly assigned to either AA or REBT or no treatment at all. AA's were significantly more likely to binge drink within the first three months of treatment than those in REBT (9 times) or in no treatment at all (5 times).

Several AA boogeymen, including Stanton Peele, Orange, Ken Ragge, Chaz Bufe, and Ken Anderson cite this study. I hope that their having their eyeballs all over it doesn't prevent you from looking at the study objectively.




Is Orange an expert on alcoholism? What are his credentials? What's that you say? He doesn't have any? Gee that's too bad. There goes your argument from authority.



BTW-Do you have a link to that study?



It's our thing. Everyone has their thing. AA's are always telling us what our blog should be about, which I find really weird. But look, addiction is an enormous problem in the world, and progress has been in a holding pattern. People do not want to address the fact that we have turned over a whole branch of mental health to faith healing, and that a behemoth industry has grown up around it, with people churning through this relapse factory.



We focus on it because we find it important.



You don't think AA has any effect on a person's mentality?

I'm guessing you don't approve of addiction counselling either?

How about group therapy?



Anonymity has no place in a program where vulnerable people are looking for help while courts are sentencing domestic abusers and sexual predators to the same rooms. The lack of oversight and responsibility is appalling.

I don't know what you're referring to when you say "it's being condemned for revealing a person's identity." But there is a big difference between having a system of accountability built into the program and individual members randomly violating each other's trust.

So, I'm out of here for the day. I am supposed to be working.



So you don't think judges know what they're doing? Where should these offenders go? Who will pay for it? While we're at, why don't you explain to me how AA is supposed to police it's members. This should be good.

Ares SMART and SOS privy to the background and tendencies of all their members? Have you taken them to task too? Nah, you haven't have you.







Hey, ProBonoShill, you just made our Quote of the Day.

Excellent! Glad I could be of help! :D






What's Alfie's argument again, exactly? If it's not written in the AA big book or other official literature, then it doesn't count but he can "take what he wants and leave the rest" which is a saying which... doesn't exist in the AA big book or literature. In fact, it's stated over and over again to explicitly NOT do that and there are many AAers who rail against that kind of thinking. What else is Alfie's argument? His anecdotes are equal to everyone else's anecdotes and because he doesn't see the strife and problems with religiosity in his groups then it doesn't really exist. He lives in a largely athiest country with a population of only 22 million and yet expects to understand what it's like to live in a country of 320 million that still has many, many pockets of religious zealots which in turn, has a tremendous impact on AA.



I could be mistaken but Alfie's argument as it pertains to the OP is that AA can be religious for some, but not others. I tend to agree.

That's weird because I hear that phrase all the time and don't remember anyone ever objecting to it.

My experience in AA has been very similar to Alfie's, maybe I just got lucky and landed in AA utopia, though I've met quite a few people from out of town and they seem to be normal. :boggled:




Oh, really? Just because you say so? Just like AlBell, you're just laughingly dismissing a critique of AA by ad hominem (The guy's an idiot, therefore what he says is wrong.)




No, I'm dismissing him because his site has so many fallacies and contradictions I've grown tired of counting them.






Odd how many people on a sceptical site are blind to fallacies like ad hom from people who they agree with, yet are quick to point it out in those on the "other side." Or maybe not so odd, at all. Its human nature I guess.



Yeah it's amazing isn't? The level of hypocrisy is stunning too.
 
Perhaps people are confused on the powerless bit.

Alcoholics become 'powerless' after taking a drink. Unfortunately they choose to take the first one anyway.
 
Did you understand what I meant, or are you just being obtuse ?

On the odd chance that it's the former: the contradiction is in the "powerless" vs "you can solve this problem." You're either powerless or you aren't. If you're not, and you can solve this, then you shouldn't say you're powerless. If you are, then you can't solve it.

It has _nothing_ to do with realising that there's a problem or not. I'm surprised you didn't get that. Unless, of course...

Speaking of obtuse, what about "powerless over alcohol" do you not understand?

Nevermind, you compared the ingestion of potato of chips to the consumption of alcohol so I see where the problem is.
 
That may depend on how you look at it. For my part, admitting to being powerless over alcohol amounted to admitting to myself that once I took a drink, it was going to be a long time before I stopped. Addiction? Compulsion? I don't know. I do know, however, that once I got going, I was out of control with regard to drinking. I was powerless to stop. It was not an easy thing to admit.

Ditto.
 
You know, this is a strange twist. I could swear most of the people who are arguing that alcoholism is a matter of will are the same people that argue that homosexuality is not a choice.

I seriously doubt that.

I think most of them would say that a desire to have sex with the same gender is a matter of birth; actually having the sex (or not) is a matter of will.

This seems to be made more complicated than it needs to be.

If someone can go from consuming too much alcohol to not doing so, through AA or any other program that doesn't use physical force or medication, then they have power over their alcohol use.

They may still have a genetic predisposition to alcoholism, but if they're not drinking, then they've controlled the problem by controlling their actions, even if what they do is choose not to take the first drink.
 
Excellent! Glad I could be of help! :D
The post of yours that they quoted was extremely ugly. A commenter there...
Please ask him to cite the source of this spurious charge. ” The views on ST have a lot in common with racists and bigots”?? Again,, show me where he came up with this “conclusion”.
I suggest you do that.
No, I'm dismissing him because his site has so many fallacies and contradictions I've grown tired of counting them.
Quote one directly from Orange's site and we'll see about that.
 
Last edited:
yes and yes.

Some people lack the inner resolve or self disipline to make healthy choices- if a person is severly obese, a drug addict or an alchoholic, they got that way because of bad choices they made- and if they remain in that state, it's because they are not doing what needs to be done to change.

It's convenioent to blame substance abuse on others, but the fact is the adult abuser (of food, booze, drugs) controls their own choices.And they have only themselves to blame if they morph into an addict.

If they find health and fitness, they are justly give credit, but if they make bad choices, are you suggesting they don't bear any responsibility for their own choieces?

As other have correctly pointed out, your knowledge and understanding of complex human chemistry, mentailty, psychology, addiction etc is bordering on zero.

That's actually hilarious, though, isn't it ? The first step toward getting rid of an addiction is to realise that there's a problem and that you are wholly responsible for it.

Correct.

AA's solution is to realise that there's a problem and that you can do squat diddly do about it.

Incorrect.


Do you really believe that's the argument?

The reasons why she doesn't "just quit" would be numerous, interconnected, and complicated.

That doesn't absolve her from personal responsibility. If she can't make the choice--however many times she needs to make it--to help herself, then she won't get better.

Or are you saying the famous 12-steps are worked upon you?

Odd...I've always heard you have to work your own program, not that the program works you.

This is why I like you SB, you try and remain objective.

You are pretty close to my thoughts here too btw.

Please don't vomit. :)

I quit heav drinking after the disaster of my brother's wedding- I threw up on the wedding cake

Did you eat it too? That would have been true unmanageability and powerlessness fatty. :p

But it's still a contradiction.

Actually it's not.
While I can see how the word powerlessness might cause some confusion, once one moves into the steps they will realise that this powerlessness is simply admitting total defeat.
For too long the alcoholic fought to control their (dare I say it) disease. They tries many time to control it, tried toi stop, made gazzillions of promises etc only to pick itup again.

It's a bit like the average punter taking on a prizefighter; they will never win, they will never beat him. Yet time and again they get back in the ring thinking they can try again. They are powerless to do anything but admit defeat and walk away.

That is the meaning of powerlessness. Rather than read the one sentence on the wall of a meeting, I would recommend p[eople have a look at the step in it's entirety to understand what the line actually means.

The contradiction lies in the claim that "admitting to being powerless" would be a first step to anything. If someone was actually powerless they couldn't do anything - by definition. Being unable to do something is what being powerless means.

Correct, we were powerless to beat it. So we admit defeat and regain power and sanity. Well done, you are starting to see I think.

alchoholism is like overeating/obesity- it's a lifestyle choice that has very bad health consequences. in the end, the fault rests on the shoulders of the addict, be it the booze or food addict.
Blaming society or constant temptation is a copout.

See above. Net kniowledge, close to zero.

So it wasn't your will that picked up that first drink it was your gene?

I don't remember saying that? Is that what I said?

It seems high for an organization that you clam doesn't exist.

I don't remember saying that either.
Can you show me where you are plucking these from?

On seconds thought, don't show me where they come from, as do not wish you to break any forum rules on decency, show me where I said them.

Speaking of obtuse, what about "powerless over alcohol" do you not understand?

Nevermind, you compared the ingestion of potato of chips to the consumption of alcohol so I see where the problem is.

Me too. ;)
 
I could be mistaken but Alfie's argument as it pertains to the OP is that AA can be religious for some, but not others. I tend to agree.

I was going to comment on this rationalization earlier. It's a nice spin on the "spiritual not religious" thing. It's also ridiculous. The same thing can be said of Catholicism, Islam, Hinduism, Judaism or any other religion.

Just because you choose not to follow all of the tenets, or you choose to put your own crazy spin on it, doesn't mean it's not a religion. It's like saying, "I don't do all of the commandments of Christianity, or follow all of its other teachings, so this means Christianity can either be spiritual or religious."
 
Last edited:
And not realizing that there are aspects of our biology, psychology, and sociality that we are not fully in control of is blaming the victim.

I see. So people who are obese ,don't exercise and eat nothing but junk food are not to blame....People who chose to drink are not to blame...people who chose to shoot up are victims...

Sorry, people who choose to abuse or neglect their health make that choice.
They will never beat the addiction if they can't (A) admit there is an addiction and (B) accept responsibility for bad choices
 
I seriously doubt that.

Me too, but the comparison wasn't bad.

I think most of them would say that a desire to have sex with the same gender is a matter of birth; actually having the sex (or not) is a matter of will.

I like this.


If someone can go from consuming too much alcohol to not doing so, through AA or any other program that doesn't use physical force or medication, then they have power over their alcohol use.

They may still have a genetic predisposition to alcoholism, but if they're not drinking, then they've controlled the problem by controlling their actions, even if what they do is choose not to take the first drink.

Correct and the powerlessness is in controlling their drinking. They are powerless in managing the drink, recovery is a matter of choice as is (finally) admitting defeat.

It is only when we throw up on the wedding cake or our own morality that we finally make the choice to change. Some people call this rock bottom - I refer to it as the four-L's of pain.

Quote one directly from Orange's site and we'll see about that.

Sigh.....

Lots and lots of posts, but I all I hear are screams of:

ORANGE!
CULT!
and arguments from (non) authority.
 
I was going to comment on this rationalization earlier. It's a nice spin on the "spiritual not religious" thing. It's also ridiculous. The same thing can be said of Catholicism, Islam, Hinduism, Judaism or any other religion.

Personally I wouldn't know.
But spirituality and religion are different. Do you understand the difference?

Sorry, people who choose to abuse or neglect their health make that choice.
They will never beat the addiction if they can't (A) admit there is an addiction and (B) accept responsibility for bad choices

Well said: I think you are starting to understand. This is exactly what AA shows people through the suggested steps, examples of others etc.

Wow, I think we might have a convert. ;)
 
Whoa hold on, its going to take me a while to look up all those references and citations.... Oh never mind.

Not really. I'll show you:

See? Not numerous, interconnected, or complicated.

Okay. I'll bring out the simple words, and I'll type really slowly.

You cannot quit any behavior until you first realize you must quit.
This is not easy. It is hard.
Until you realize it, though, you won't quit.
No one else can realize this for you.
You must realize it yourself.

Then, you have to want to quit.
This is not easy. It is hard.
Until you want to, you won't quit.
No one else can want it for you.
You must want it for yourself.

Then, you have to try to quit.
This is not easy. It is very hard.
Until you try, you can't quit.
No one else can make you try,
Though they can help you.
You have to try, yourself.


One day, after a lot of struggle,
and after a lot of starting over,
and after wanting, then trying,
then failing, then not wanting,
then not trying, then wanting,
then trying...one day, you might
realize you no longer have to try.
You have quit. It is over.

Or you might realize that you
have to try every day, and maybe
you always, always have to try
every day. Maybe you will never have
a day that you won't have to try.
But every day you don't perform
that behavior, is a day in which you
are quit of it.


Not one single step of this is easy.
Not for most people.

That is why there really isn't such a thing as "just quitting."

No one else can do this for you.
You have to choose it.
If you never choose it, you can't start.
If you never choose it, you can't quit.

It is your choice, and only yours. The responsibility is yours. It isn't anyone else's but yours. But it isn't easy. There is no "just" about it.
 
As other have correctly pointed out, your knowledge and understanding of complex human chemistry, mentailty, psychology, addiction etc is bordering on zero.


)



Try again. There has been substance abuse amongst friends and in my family which has been overcome by taking responsibility for bad choices, and making different decisions, so bad choices and self destructive lifestyles would not be perpetuated.

Given that I personally overcame a drinking problem by recognizing the addiction, accepting responsibity for my bad choces and making the effort to change my actions, such is evidenceto me that I know what I'm talking about..


The problem with your approach is that you seem to imply that outside forces are responsible for addiction - That takes accountability away from the addict.
 
Last edited:
Sigh.....

Lots and lots of posts, but I all I hear are screams of:

ORANGE!
CULT!
and arguments from (non) authority.
Pull the cotton out of your ears and stick it in your mouth then. ;)

Why don't you quote an argument from authority someone has used. You won't. Another straw man
 
Try again. There has been substance abuse amongst friends and in my family which has been overcome by taking responsibility for bad choices, and making different decisions, so bad choices and self destructive lifestyles would not be perpetuated.

Given that I personally overcame a drinking problem by recognizing the addiction, accepting responsibity for my bad choces and making the effort to change my actions, such is evidenceto me that I know what I'm talking about..


The problem with your approach is that you seem to imply that outside forces are responsible for addiction - That takes accountability away from the addict.

Why don't you tell us what the medical profession, psychology, psychiatry etc have to say rather than make incredibly simplistic deductions from "what my mum did".

I stand by my assertion, your net knowlede is close to zero and you continue to show that by sticking to your one and only set of personal examples.

Pull the cotton out of your ears and stick it in your mouth then. ;)

Why don't you quote an argument from authority someone has used. You won't. Another straw man

Actually I have used a few of your own citations to prove your assumptions totally wrong - in other words, they didn't say anything like what you thought. You have back pedalled and refused to stand by many assertions made. The Orange papers and your cult expert have been proven to be unreliable in the extreme due to their highly subjective authors. You use these as an authority. I have also shown you to be an unmitigated liar.

And you've still got nothing.

FAIL!
 
Actually I have used a few of your own citations to prove your assumptions totally wrong - in other words, they didn't say anything like what you thought. You have back pedalled and refused to stand by many assertions made. The Orange papers and your cult expert have been proven to be unreliable in the extreme due to their highly subjective authors. You use these as an authority. I have also shown you to be an unmitigated liar.

And you've still got nothing.

FAIL!
These are just your words and opinions. In my opinion and others, I've rebuked all of that.

Quote one thing that Orange got wrong. You won't.

I never used the cult experts argument from authority, I used their arguments and research.

I asked you to quote someone. Quote me making an argument from authority. Like I said you won't.
 
Last edited:
If AA doesn't have a problem with groups turning into cults with all of the problems I mentioned, how do you explain midtown group? Washington Post

They described a rigidly insular world of group homes and socializing, in which older men had sex with teenage girls, ties to family and friends were severed or strained, and the most vulnerable of alcoholics, some suffering from emotional problems, were encouraged to stop taking prescribed medications.

Kristen, now 26, said that for eight years, she was "passed along" from one middle-aged male leader of Midtown to another. She said her sponsor urged her to have sex with Quinones -- widely known as Mike Q. -- as a way to solidify her sobriety and spiritual revival. Kristen, who spoke on the condition that her last name not be used in keeping with AA traditions, also recalled helping to persuade other teenage girls to sleep with older men in the group.

"I pimped my sponsees out to sponsors," she said, referring to the AA members who agree to watch over a fellow member's sobriety. "I encouraged them to sleep with their sponsors because I really believed that this would help with their sobriety."
Kristen described being pressed to pay $1,200 for a summer house share in which she slept on the floor.
One young woman said she was assigned a boyfriend and encouraged to go off her antidepressants and cut off contact with Dye, the psychologist said.

Without her medication, the woman became acutely suicidal and was hospitalized, Dye said. When Midtown members learned that the woman was back on medication, she was ostracized and "was considered to have relapsed," Dye said.
They described being told by Midtown's leaders to stop taking medication prescribed by a psychiatrist, being permitted to visit family only in the company of other Midtown members and regularly cleaning Mike Q.'s house, mowing his lawn and doing his laundry. Her daughter had a male sponsor.
McCleskey (mother of daughter who ended up in the hospital suicidal) said she tried to get AA's local coordinating body to look into allegations against Midtown but was told that each group governs itself.
Midtown leaders told pastors they were being criticized unfairly by "disgruntled people who couldn't keep their act together," Goff recalled.
When Kristen left Midtown, she was utterly alone. "Everyone in my cellphone was Midtown," she said. "I was 24, and I knew literally nobody. I had cut off my ties with my family at the direction of my sponsor."

"Eight years of my life was wasted," Kristen said.

Mock me all you like, AA is dangerous.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom