Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was going to comment on this rationalization earlier. It's a nice spin on the "spiritual not religious" thing. It's also ridiculous. The same thing can be said of Catholicism, Islam, Hinduism, Judaism or any other religion.

Just because you choose not to follow all of the tenets, or you choose to put your own crazy spin on it, doesn't mean it's not a religion. It's like saying, "I don't do all of the commandments of Christianity, or follow all of its other teachings, so this means Christianity can either be spiritual or religious."

Yes we know, by your definition Weight Watchers, Girl Guides and Jenny's weekly aerobics class are all religious too. :rolleyes:

You're a little late to the party Jack, this has been discussed ad nauseam, I'm not willing to ride that Merry-Go-Round again, maybe you can find another sadist who will, I doubt it though.
 
Okay. I'll bring out the simple words, and I'll type really slowly.

You cannot quit any behavior until you first realize you must quit.
This is not easy. It is hard.
Until you realize it, though, you won't quit.
No one else can realize this for you.
You must realize it yourself.

Then, you have to want to quit.
This is not easy. It is hard.
Until you want to, you won't quit.
No one else can want it for you.
You must want it for yourself.

Then, you have to try to quit.
This is not easy. It is very hard.
Until you try, you can't quit.
No one else can make you try,
Though they can help you.
You have to try, yourself.


One day, after a lot of struggle,
and after a lot of starting over,
and after wanting, then trying,
then failing, then not wanting,
then not trying, then wanting,
then trying...one day, you might
realize you no longer have to try.
You have quit. It is over.

Or you might realize that you
have to try every day, and maybe
you always, always have to try
every day. Maybe you will never have
a day that you won't have to try.
But every day you don't perform
that behavior, is a day in which you
are quit of it.


Not one single step of this is easy.
Not for most people.

That is why there really isn't such a thing as "just quitting."

No one else can do this for you.
You have to choose it.
If you never choose it, you can't start.
If you never choose it, you can't quit.

It is your choice, and only yours. The responsibility is yours. It isn't anyone else's but yours. But it isn't easy. There is no "just" about it.

Love this! Think I'll print it out and save it.

Do you mind if I share this SB?
 
If AA doesn't have a problem with groups turning into cults with all of the problems I mentioned, how do you explain midtown group? Washington Post








Mock me all you like, AA is dangerous.

Some members from one group out of thousands is bad and now AA is dangerous?????

And you had a problem with what I said about Stinkin Thinking?

Wow

Hypocrite much?
 
Some members from one group out of thousands is bad and now AA is dangerous?????
Some members? You didn't read the article. It was the leadership, and no one else in AA would shut it down when the parents went looking for help. That's a mark against all of AA. They're an organization but they won't shut down cults using their name? What the hell is that?

What I'm saying is that the nature of AA leads to these problems a lot of the time. This is just a really bad example of the spectrum of problems. It's like a hereditary genetic disease, it pops up and creates problems a lot, but not all the time, but it's still part of it's nature. They are the same problems that happen on a wide spectrum in many groups it's an example. It doesn't mean that all groups are like that, it means that this kind of program is dangerous in it's structure.

You could have a group or meeting that is not dangerous, I've never denied that. This seems to be how you argue against everything.

And you had a problem with what I said about Stinkin Thinking?
It was absolutely disgusting.

Wow

Hypocrite much?
:( This is a depressing thread.

What is your plan to change AA so midtown can never happen again under the name of AA?
 
Mock me all you like,

I didn't realise I needed permission, but thanks.

It was explained to me that religion is for those who fear hell, but spirituality is for those who have been there. Is that right?

No, try again.

It was absolutely disgusting.

How does your own medicine taste? :)
I might just revisit that idiotic site for some more entertainment. There are masses of stoopid in there ripe for my amusement. I will admit in advance, trolling that site looks like fun.

:( This is a depressing thread.

You could always leave; you have a choice you know and like me at my former pubs, you wont be missed.

It's possibly and addictive trait that keeps you here. Is it possible you are powerless to either admit defeat that it is a problem and/or accept it does you harm?

Where is the line in the sand that you crossed from fun to damage? From elation to depression?

If you are depressed about it, why don't you just stop? :boggled:

It is only when you are finally in enough pain, you might be compelled to do something about it.

Self sabotage, addiction etc can be very complex things until we get to a point that we take action to change things. When will you?

It seems you are powerless, yet you have the power to change it.
 
Last edited:
I didn't realise I needed permission, but thanks.
The point is that people are trying to mock me but are ending up mocking the people who are hurt by what happens in AA by denying and disrespecting what I'm talking about.
Hopw does your medicine taste? :)
I have not been unfairly mean to anyone in this thread. Quote me.
Leave, you wont be missed.
By you, thanks everyone who has let me know I'm appreciated.
It's possibly and addictive trait that keeps you here. Is it possible you are powerless to either admit defeat that it is a problem and/or accept it does you harm?

Where is the line in the sand that you crossed from fun to damage. From elation to depression? If you are depressed about it, why don't you just stop? :boggled:

When you are finally in enough pain, you might be compelled to do something about it.

Self sabotage, addiction etc can be very complex things until we get to a point that we take action to change things. When will you?
You don't seem like a very helpful counsellor. You seem to have taken my statement too seriously and tried to use it as an attack on me.

This thread is depressing because it's a depressing issue and when you try to talk about serious things, people resort to mockery, attacks and straw men more often than other threads. Also, when people say something nice to each other, someone usually ***** on it. When you see two people sharing kind words and another person mocks them, that's depressing. Who does that? You do.
 
Last edited:
Some members? You didn't read the article. It was the leadership, and no one else in AA would shut it down when the parents went looking for help. That's a mark against all of AA. They're an organization but they won't shut down cults using their name? What the hell is that?

What I'm saying is that the nature of AA leads to these problems a lot of the time. This is just a really bad example of the spectrum of problems. It's like a hereditary genetic disease, it pops up and creates problems a lot, but not all the time, but it's still part of it's nature. They are the same problems that happen on a wide spectrum in many groups it's an example. It doesn't mean that all groups are like that, it means that this kind of program is dangerous in it's structure.

You could have a group or meeting that is not dangerous, I've never denied that. This seems to be how you argue against everything.

It was absolutely disgusting.

:( This is a depressing thread.

What is your plan to change AA so midtown can never happen again under the name of AA?

You see Joey, this is what happens when people who have no clue what they are talking about.

I've been to at least 20 different groups, guess what? NONE of them have leaders. What are the responsibilities of group leaders in AA Joey?

What happened there is deplorable and Mike Q sounds like a douchebag, but the article even says:

the unusual adaptation of AA that Michael Quinones created from his home

Some wing-nut runs a group from his home basically breaking every AA tradition and this somehow makes AA as a whole dangerous? Nice critical thinking you have going on there.

So if organizers of a United Way Food Bank in Toledo were caught having sex with some of the young female volunteers, working at food banks is dangerous?

C'mon Joey, that argument is ridiculous.

As for changing Midtown, it has about as much relevance to me as the Food Banks in Toledo has to the ones where I live.

Do you even know how groups are for formed? No?

Well then I'll tell you, some dumbass like me decides he wants to form a group, a few of my like minded friends say "cool" and voilà a group is formed.

You non AA people seem to think there is some kind of rigid structure to AA groups. Some groups in my area are about as organized as my buddy's poker league.


Oh and haven't forgotten about the blog or Orange, I'll try to get to them this weekend.
 
You see Joey, this is what happens when people who have no clue what they are talking about.
You just straw man everything I say, once even an invisible straw man which later turned out to be a complete misunderstanding.
I've been to at least 20 different groups, guess what? NONE of them have leaders. What are the responsibilities of group leaders in AA Joey?
This is actually the problem, there are no "leaders" so when someone is giving anti-psychiatry advice, there is no one to stop them. And there effectively ARE leaders in AA. Just because you don't have some structure, doesn't mean people don't act like leaders. Ridiculous.
What happened there is deplorable and Mike Q sounds like a douchebag, but the article even says:
It's literally the worst example that's out there but this happens on a spectrum I have posted like a hundred other stories of anti-psychiatry, 13th stepping, sponsers telling sponsees what to do, making the group your own complete community, it's just the far end, but it's the exact same problems!
Some wing-nut runs a group from his home basically breaking every AA tradition and this somehow makes AA as a whole dangerous? Nice critical thinking you have going on there.
No you just don't understand the subtle concepts of memetics.
So if organizers of a United Way Food Bank in Toledo were caught having sex with some of the young female volunteers, working at food banks is dangerous?
Does the structure of the UWFB lead to this happening a lot in their organization? Are there thousands of stories of this kind of stuff happening at the UWFB?
C'mon Joey, that argument is ridiculous.
Your interpretations of what I'm saying are insulting and ridiculous.
As for changing Midtown, it has about as much relevance to me as the Food Banks in Toledo has to the ones where I live.
You have no ideas on how to change AA? You don't think that this could have been prevented. I should just stop here.
Do you even know how groups are for formed? No?

Well then I'll tell you, some dumbass like me decides he wants to form a group, a few of my like minded friends say "cool" and voilà a group is formed.
Then AA is a retarded organization because that's a recipe for disaster. My whole argument is that an organization to help victims of mental illness should be professional, the fact that AA allows people to use their name without careful monitoring, reporting systems and complete transparency of accounting and freedom of information is absolutely unconscionable.
You non AA people seem to think there is some kind of rigid structure to AA groups.
I seem to know more about AA than you do. I argue that it not having a ridgid structure is part of the problem so what are you talking about.
Some groups in my area are about as organized as my buddy's poker league
Exactly..
Oh and haven't forgotten about the blog or Orange, I'll try to get to them this weekend.
That's right, I can't wait to see what you quote as offensive and incorrect from those sites.
 
Last edited:
Why don't you tell us what the medical profession, psychology, psychiatry etc have to say rather than make incredibly simplistic deductions from "what my mum did".

I stand by my assertion, your net knowlede is close to zero and you continue to show that by sticking to your one and only set of personal examples.



!


If you haven't been through addiction yourself, then you are utterly clueless. The addict makes their choices, and the responsibility at getting better- or worse is in their hands of the addict.

AA, like all religious based cults brainwashes people to think they do not have the power to succeed on their own- that somehow they need a skygod, or some exterior force (like AA) to absolve them of adversity.

I have lived through addiction i have seen others battle it-some overcame addiction, and some lose their lives to it. Dismiss first person narratives all you want, but you have no idea what you are talking about.
Every alchoholic/drug addict who is where they are today made choices that led to their downfall, for whatever reason.

The only way they can rebound is take responsibility for their actions, and not give in to a lazy cop out and bame an imaginary 'disease'.


Dismissing personal examples, are we? You remind me of No planers who dismiss the accounts of witnesses who saw planes hitting the WTC. What would they know, right? After all, they were only there...
Likewise, what would my family and I know about beating addiction? Aftr all, some of us were addicts and beat addiction. So what would we know?


.
 
Last edited:
I just made a quick visit to Stinkin Thinkin and came across this, thought I would share with my fellow JREFers. :)

self described ‘skeptics’ of the james randi / michael shermer sort arent skeptics at all, theyre normalists. their issue isnt logical fallacies or bad science, their issue is that they cant stand anyone who dares to believe in, or even be curious about that which they analyze as contrary to what normal people believe. notice that these types love to attack UFO believers or truthers much more than they like attacking evangelical christians: their issue is not to stand for reason, but to stand for ‘the reasonable’ (as decided by what normal ‘respectable’ people find reasonable), against ‘wierdos’ who believe ‘ridiculous things’. and thus, they will defend AA as long as professionals defend AA, because they believe in believing what youre supposed to believe rather than any actual devotion to debunking such as they claim. if ‘skeptics’ were truly about fighting bad science, AA would be a far higher priorty than making fun of people who believe in UFOs. but their choice of targets reveals their true motives. and one result ironically, of these obvious true motives, normalcy and bullying rather than actual academic rigour, is that so called, self proclaimed ‘skeptics’ and 12steppers have more in common than either group realizes…. in the worst possible ways. both groups believe in ostracizing anyone who has an idea not pre approved by ‘your betters’.
 
I just made a quick visit to Stinkin Thinkin and came across this, thought I would share with my fellow JREFers. :)

I haven't checked it out, yet. I have to check with "my betters" to see if it's contrary to what normal JREFers are supposed to do.
 
The point is that people are trying to mock me but are ending up mocking the people who are hurt by what happens in AA by denying and disrespecting what I'm talking about.

Appeal to emotion noted.

I have not been unfairly mean to anyone in this thread. Quote me.

Cult!
Retarded!
Nuff said, there's plenty more.

You don't seem like a very helpful counsellor.

My qheque is in the mail.
What's that I'm not your counsellor? Well I'll be...

This thread is depressing because it's a depressing issue and when you try to talk about serious things, people resort to mockery, attacks and straw men more often than other threads. Also, when people say something nice to each other, someone usually ***** on it. When you see two people sharing kind words and another person mocks them, that's depressing. Who does that? You do.

Is anyone else getting teary?

I like it too.

Me three. :)

If you haven't been through addiction yourself, then you are utterly clueless.

You obviously have no idea what or who I am, where I have come from or how I got here. Read the thread brother and get a clue.

The addict makes their choices, and the responsibility at getting better- or worse is in their hands of the addict.

Yep

AA, (1) like all religious based cults brainwashes people (2) to think they do not have the power to succeed on their own- (3) that somehow they need a skygod, (3a) or some exterior force (like AA) (4)to absolve them of adversity.

(1)No, (2) no, (3) no, (3a) maybe and (4) no.
(My numerals)

I have lived through addiction i have seen others battle it-some overcame addiction, and some lose their lives to it.

Me too.

Dismiss first person narratives all you want, but you have no idea what you are talking about.

Incorrect. I have a great deal of knowledge in this area. Read the thread and discover what it is.

Every alchoholic/drug addict who is where they are today made choices that led to their downfall, for whatever reason.

Yep

The only way they can rebound is take responsibility for their actions, and not give in to a lazy cop out and bame an imaginary 'disease'.

Part right. They must take responsibility, if someone is using the word "disease" as a cop out, they are doing just that. AA says it is a disease and the alcoholic is responsible for taking action to arrest it.

Dismissing personal examples, are we? You remind me of No planers who dismiss the accounts of witnesses who saw planes hitting the WTC. What would they know, right? After all, they were only there...
Likewise, what would my family and I know about beating addiction? Aftr all, some of us were addicts and beat addiction. So what would we know?

You have your own experiences, sure. I am not dismissing them as irrelevant per se. I am however dismissing them as a source of authority when it comes to describing and treating addiction.
Correct me if I am wrong but you are basically sayiing that addiction is not a disease and people should just stop. If it were that simple we would not be having these discussions. What may have been simple for you, is not so for others, your example isn't theirs.
And your medical diagnosis and opinion is not supported by others who are actually experts in the field.

But again, read the thread, look at something external of the opinions of your stinkin' thinkin' kiddies merry-go-round.
 
I just made a quick visit to Stinkin Thinkin and came across this, thought I would share with my fellow JREFers. :)

You should have mentioned to your fellow JREFers that that's a comment on the blog. It's not a very smart comment, why is this important to you? I was about to comment a rebuttal to that :rolleyes: Here, I'll link to it since you won't since it's a comment on the post about you.

The guy is wrong, and is making a common fallcious argument against "pseudoskeptics". I agree my fellow skeptics don't know a lot about AA but that isn't for his reasons, it's because they just haven't been introduced to it and AA has done a lot of work gaining itself respectability and is often benign. That's all there is to it, people will listen.

There's a great post and discussion on this very issue, skeptics not understanding AA, happening right now on Ed Brayton's blog at ScienceBlogs! Check it out!

:)

http://scienceblogs.com/dispatches/2011/06/skepticism_and_the_12_step_ind.php
 
Appeal to emotion noted.
Appeal to emotion? No, I keep posting facts about people being abused in AA and people respond by mocking me instead of addressing the truth of what happens? That's not an argument from emotion, that's pointing out someone else's fallacy! You're great, keep it up. If you leave, I'll miss you. :p
Cult!
Retarded!
Nuff said, there's plenty more.
I said unfairly. Where's the context? You don't get to say that I'm a bad person because I'm honest. Oh right AA likes to attack people for being angry or having resentments, a favored thought stopper.
My qheque is in the mail.
What's that I'm not your counsellor? Well I'll be...

Is anyone else getting teary?
You do a great job of advertising for alternatives to A.A.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom