Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I just returned from a visit to 'Stinkin Thinking'. The views there have a lot in common with racists and bigots.

You know if you see a black guy smoking crack they all smoke crack or if a Jew ask for something to be discounted it's because all Jews are cheap.

Apparently if someone is raped by an AA member we are all rapists, if someone is convicted of robbery and goes to AA we're full of criminals.

When some 46 year-old jackass tries to pick up a young woman at a meeting, we're all horny drooling predators. I'll give them credit though, they aren't sexist, supposed there's a bunch of "cougars" in our midst too. Scary stuff.
 
I'm sorry but that just reveals how ignorant you are about addiction. Do you really believe people decide to make a bad choice and die?

A poor girl from a broken home is handed a crack pipe at the age of 16, a year later she's screwing 60 year old men to support her addiction, you don't think doing that takes willpower? Why would she do something awful like that (apologies to Hugh Hefner)? Why wouldn't she just quit?


I speak from experience. 2 uncles and my mother were alchoholics. My mother and 1 uncle were able to make the choice to turn their lives around, stop drinking and reclaim ther lives. They both fully admit that they made the choice to drink to excess- just as they made the decison to quit. I used to drink to excess, and made an ass of mysdelf- only after seeing the footage of what a drunken jerk i was at a siblings wedding, I made the choice never to drink to excess again. I made the choice to be a drunk, likewise i made the choice to stop drinking..

Obviously you see all addicts as victims iof outside forces who shouldn't bear any responsibility for their actions- i think it's you who is clueless about addiction. That is the kind of mindset that will keep a person stuck in ther addicton.

The first step a person must do to beat addiction is acknowldge they have a problem- then in order to make changes, they have to admit responsibility, and admit they put themselves in their current situtation.

Your example of 'the poor girl being handed a crack pipe at 16' suggests you think that peson dodesn't bear any responsibilty for taking that first smoke. In your world view, when does personal responsibility begin and end for the addict?

I wince when i hear alchoholics blame their drinking on 'a disease'.
 
Last edited:
False dichotomy.

I suggest you actually review some of the science behind the disease model of alcoholism/addiction before you ask questions that can easily be answered by a PubMed search.

Not good enough. Answer the question. Add whatever other options there are if need be.

Are you or are you not responsible for your actions ? What about people who are addicted to chocolate ? Is it their choice to eat one ?
 
I remember back 25 or 27 years ago, a certain number of folks in a certain AA group went to have themselves tested for allergies, and all of them turned out to be allergic to all the grains used to make alcohols: barley, wheat, rye, etc...except it never seemed to affect them in any other way except in the consumption of alcohol.
 
I'm sorry but that just reveals how ignorant you are about addiction. Do you really believe people decide to make a bad choice and die?

People make bad decisions are die, yes. All the time. Today I ate a 275g bag of chips in one sitting. I know I shouldn't. Why do I keep doing that ? Willpower.
 
The first step a person must do to beat addiction is acknowldge they have a problem- then in order to make changes, they have to admit responsibility, and admit they put themselves in their current situtation.

That's actually hilarious, though, isn't it ? The first step toward getting rid of an addiction is to realise that there's a problem and that you are wholly responsible for it.

AA's solution is to realise that there's a problem and that you can do squat diddly do about it.
 
People make bad decisions are die, yes. All the time. Today I ate a 275g bag of chips in one sitting. I know I shouldn't. Why do I keep doing that ? Willpower.

I ate a whole bag of M&Ms with peanuts last night...Such will no doubt wreck my teeth, and wreak havoc with my blood sugar. Seems to me I eat choclate all the time. Can I claim to be a victim? Who can i sue?

Very true, it's all about willpower...


I have a strong hunch that many of the programs designed to 'help' addicts are a bit like religions- they perpetuate the idea that the addicted person is powerless and weak, and could never help themselves, but could only be helped from an outside force, be it AA or a skygod
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry but that just reveals how ignorant you are about addiction. Do you really believe people decide to make a bad choice and die?

Do you really believe that's the argument?

A poor girl from a broken home is handed a crack pipe at the age of 16, a year later she's screwing 60 year old men to support her addiction, you don't think doing that takes willpower? Why would she do something awful like that (apologies to Hugh Hefner)? Why wouldn't she just quit?

The reasons why she doesn't "just quit" would be numerous, interconnected, and complicated.

That doesn't absolve her from personal responsibility. If she can't make the choice--however many times she needs to make it--to help herself, then she won't get better.

Or are you saying the famous 12-steps are worked upon you?

Odd...I've always heard you have to work your own program, not that the program works you.
 
Do you really believe that's the argument?



The reasons why she doesn't "just quit" would be numerous, interconnected, and complicated.

That doesn't absolve her from personal responsibility. If she can't make the choice--however many times she needs to make it--to help herself, then she won't get better.

Or are you saying the famous 12-steps are worked upon you?

Odd...I've always heard you have to work your own program, not that the program works you.


You wrote "That doesn't absolve her from personal responsibility", then you seem to contradict yourself.
When I see the alchoholic homeless person, or addict passed out under a tree, no doubt they've faced a lot of adversity in life, but the blame for their current states us squarley on their own shoulders.

In your view, should the addict (alchohol, drugs, food, gambling, etc) trying to turn their life around admit responsibility for their bad choices, or should they blame everying on other people, or on 'society'?

An addict cannot change and recover unless they accept responsibility for the self destructive decisions they've made.
 
Last edited:
In your view, should the addict (alchohol, drugs, food, gambling, etc) trying to turn their life around admit responsibility for their bad choices,

My previous posts should have made it quite clear that the above is my view. Perhaps you've not read them?




or should they blame everying on other people, or on 'society'?

An addict cannot change and recover unless they accept responsibility for the self destructive decisions they've made.

<--Choir. You're preaching to it. :cool:
 
You wrote "That doesn't absolve her from personal responsibility", then you seem to contradict yourself.

What? HOW?

It's her personal responsibility to make the choice to engage in behaviors, and it's her choice to try to stop.

Whose choice is it, if not hers?


When I see the alchoholic homeless person, or addict passed out under a tree, no doubt they've faced a lot of adversity in life, but the blame for their current states us squarley on their own shoulders.

They're the only ones who can decide they must get themselves out. No one can do it for them, or do it without their active cooperation.

In your view, should the addict (alchohol, drugs, food, gambling, etc) trying to turn their life around admit responsibility for their bad choices, or should they blame everying on other people, or on 'society'?

WTF, you really haven't read any of my posts.

An addict cannot change and recover unless they accept responsibility for the self destructive decisions they've made.

<--Choir. Now, you're flogging it. ;)
 
See Alfie's post with salaries from other organizations, I think it's high, but not outrageous. Certainly a topic to chat about with friends at the next meeting I get to.

You LOLed at the idea that anyone was getting rich off AA. Those figures show that some are. Anyway, I'm glad you were able to square that in your mind and move on.

Sure, I just think it's cowardly to do it without his knowledge. Why do you need to recruit people to "take him on" anyway? Having trouble refuting his arguments on your own? Time to call in the calvary.

Oh my gosh. Sorry, Alfie!!


Oh I don't know, maybe because right at the beginning of your FAQ, you address AA members.

Did you see the picture at the top of the FAQ? Are you seriously making the case that I'm trying to recruit AA members in that FAQ? I wrote that to address the AA scolds who land there wagging their fingers at us, saying exactly the same things. I got sick of responding to the same things over and over again. I think at one point in there I tell them to kiss my ass. I wouldn't exactly call that honey.


Maybe because the sites has links to places like this:

this:http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/EFTCoaa/

That's a community for people who have left AA. Again, I'm not sure how you're making the case that we exist to seduce AA members out of AA. So weird.

It could also be the myriad of AA related topics when you go here:

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/stinkin-thinkin-essential-reading/

Are you saying that because we write about AA, we're writing for AA members? This is such a disingenuous argument -- I'd be surprised if you even really stand behind yourself here.

I'm sure you evidence for this claim right? After all you're on a skeptic site now, bald assertions don't get a free pass here. Oh and once again Orange's rants don't count as evidence.

That's very funny. Is that how skeptics operate? Please bring evidence, but I won't look at it objectively if it comes from certain sources that freak me out.

Well, here. Do some reading: J.M. Brandsma, M.C. Maultsby, and R.J. Walsh, The Outpatient Treatment of Alcoholism: A Review and Comparative Study (University Park Press, 1980).

This is a controlled study of people randomly assigned to either AA or REBT or no treatment at all. AA's were significantly more likely to binge drink within the first three months of treatment than those in REBT (9 times) or in no treatment at all (5 times).

Several AA boogeymen, including Stanton Peele, Orange, Ken Ragge, Chaz Bufe, and Ken Anderson cite this study. I hope that their having their eyeballs all over it doesn't prevent you from looking at the study objectively.

Why all the hate for AA? Why don't you rail on the NIAAA? At least in AA we fund the program ourselves, it's better than wasting billions of taxpayer dollars with nothing to show for it. No?

It's our thing. Everyone has their thing. AA's are always telling us what our blog should be about, which I find really weird. But look, addiction is an enormous problem in the world, and progress has been in a holding pattern. People do not want to address the fact that we have turned over a whole branch of mental health to faith healing, and that a behemoth industry has grown up around it, with people churning through this relapse factory.

We focus on it because we find it important.

Saying that I've already encountered some pretty hilarious contradictions. On the one hand AA gets criticized for the anonymity of it's members, on the other it's being condemned for revealing a persons identity. :D

Anonymity has no place in a program where vulnerable people are looking for help while courts are sentencing domestic abusers and sexual predators to the same rooms. The lack of oversight and responsibility is appalling.

I don't know what you're referring to when you say "it's being condemned for revealing a person's identity." But there is a big difference between having a system of accountability built into the program and individual members randomly violating each other's trust.

So, I'm out of here for the day. I am supposed to be working.
 
Post #1910 in this thread, excerpt:

I can't wrap my head around the whole "admit we are powerless," or the "higher power" stuff.

Yes, yes, I know what they mean. I know what they at least attempt to do.

But you aren't powerless. Your power is pretty much the only power that matters. Sure, you can get support from others, and you should, but your power is still the power that's going to get you into the door of the first meeting, and keep you coming back.

Is my position more clear now?
 
I just returned from a visit to 'Stinkin Thinking'. The views there have a lot in common with racists and bigots.

You know if you see a black guy smoking crack they all smoke crack or if a Jew ask for something to be discounted it's because all Jews are cheap.

Apparently if someone is raped by an AA member we are all rapists, if someone is convicted of robbery and goes to AA we're full of criminals.

When some 46 year-old jackass tries to pick up a young woman at a meeting, we're all horny drooling predators. I'll give them credit though, they aren't sexist, supposed there's a bunch of "cougars" in our midst too. Scary stuff.

Hey, ProBonoShill, you just made our Quote of the Day.
 
What? HOW?

It's her personal responsibility to make the choice to engage in behaviors, and it's her choice to try to stop.

Whose choice is it, if not hers?




They're the only ones who can decide they must get themselves out. No one can do it for them, or do it without their active cooperation.



WTF, you really haven't read any of my posts.



<--Choir. Now, you're flogging it. ;)


Okay, my mistake, I apologize
 
I remember back 25 or 27 years ago, a certain number of folks in a certain AA group went to have themselves tested for allergies, and all of them turned out to be allergic to all the grains used to make alcohols: barley, wheat, rye, etc...except it never seemed to affect them in any other way except in the consumption of alcohol.

Whoa hold on, its going to take me a while to look up all those references and citations.... Oh never mind.

The reasons why she doesn't "just quit" would be numerous, interconnected, and complicated.

Not really. I'll show you:

It's her personal responsibility to make the choice to engage in behaviors, and it's her choice to try to stop.

Whose choice is it, if not hers?




They're the only ones who can decide they must get themselves out. No one can do it for them, or do it without their active cooperation.

See? Not numerous, interconnected, or complicated.
 
Yes, after years of heavy substance abuse the brain of the alchohilic/addict is altered- but it doesn't defer the fact that they got themselves into this situation. Part of being an adult is taking responsibility for your own actions- if you choose to drink to excess, shoot drugs into your arm, or binge eat (or starve yourself), it's your own fault.

It's not just heavy abuse, though. In college, I drank probably as much, if not slightly less, than the people I hung out with. That was definitely the case after college, yet I am the one with a substance abuse problem.
 
Not good enough. Answer the question. Add whatever other options there are if need be.

Are you or are you not responsible for your actions ? What about people who are addicted to chocolate ? Is it their choice to eat one ?

Perhaps you could enlighten us as to what you mean by "personal responsibility", because it has been established that people with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome are not personally responsible for their self-harm, yet the neurophysiology of addiction is dismissed as "not good enough".
 
It's not just heavy abuse, though. In college, I drank probably as much, if not slightly less, than the people I hung out with. That was definitely the case after college, yet I am the one with a substance abuse problem.

I quit heav drinking after the disaster of my brother's wedding- I threw up on the wedding cake
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom