You just straw man everything I say, once even an invisible straw man which later turned out to be a complete misunderstanding.
Joey you're blaming the action of a few on the many (no matter how much you try to explain it away) it, there's a term for that, do you know what it is?
This is actually the problem, there are no "leaders" so when someone is giving anti-psychiatry advice, there is no one to stop them. And there effectively ARE leaders in AA. Just because you don't have some structure, doesn't mean people don't act like leaders. Ridiculous.
So there are no leaders, yet there are leaders or people that ACT like leaders?
It's literally the worst example that's out there but this happens on a spectrum I have posted like a hundred other stories of anti-psychiatry, 13th stepping, sponsers telling sponsees what to do, making the group your own complete community, it's just the far end, but it's the exact same problems!
100 stories, 2 million members, I'd say that's not a bad ratio, much better than many other organizations, like the
LAPD sure as hell beats the Catholic church.
No you just don't understand the subtle concepts of memetics.
Now were progressing to ad homs are we? What does memetics have to do with that large brush you want to paint everyone with? Let me use the LAPD again but for a different purpose. Police officers are supposed to be trusted people, if an LA officer sexually assaulted a minor, should the NYPD be held responsible?
Does the structure of the UWFB lead to this happening a lot in their organization? Are there thousands of stories of this kind of stuff happening at the UWFB?
Oh goody now were up to thousands, evidences?
Your interpretations of what I'm saying are insulting and ridiculous
.
You can describe them however you want but they're apt and you continue to dodge them.
You have no ideas on how to change AA? You don't think that this could have been prevented. I should just stop here.
Umm I have lots of idea, but alas I'm only one person and I didn't join AA to reorganize it, just wanted some help getting sober, thankfully it was provided. But why don't you give us your suggestions and how you'd go about carrying that out. I've asked you similar questions, yet you don't give answers, maybe you will this time.
Then AA is a retarded organization because that's a recipe for disaster. My whole argument is that an organization to help victims of mental illness should be professional, the fact that AA allows people to use their name without careful monitoring, reporting systems and complete transparency of accounting and freedom of information is absolutely unconscionable
.
LMAO, sorry I just have to laugh, who is going to pay for all that Joey? Professional eh, really? I'm really glad you don't run AA Joey because I'd probably be divorced and/or dead right now.
I seem to know more about AA than you do. I argue that it not having a ridgid structure is part of the problem so what are you talking about.
Exactly..
That's strange because I'd bet most members feel exactly the opposite, I know I do and wouldn't have stayed if that was the case. I'll let you in on a little secret, most alcoholics don't like being told what to do.
