Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
But...I was "in" AA long before I was a skeptic. I knew about it, from the inside, long before I knew about skepticism.

Doesn't that make me a special skeptic?

I want to be special! :mghissyfit
 
You just straw man everything I say, once even an invisible straw man which later turned out to be a complete misunderstanding.


Joey you're blaming the action of a few on the many (no matter how much you try to explain it away) it, there's a term for that, do you know what it is?


This is actually the problem, there are no "leaders" so when someone is giving anti-psychiatry advice, there is no one to stop them. And there effectively ARE leaders in AA. Just because you don't have some structure, doesn't mean people don't act like leaders. Ridiculous.

So there are no leaders, yet there are leaders or people that ACT like leaders? :confused:


It's literally the worst example that's out there but this happens on a spectrum I have posted like a hundred other stories of anti-psychiatry, 13th stepping, sponsers telling sponsees what to do, making the group your own complete community, it's just the far end, but it's the exact same problems!

100 stories, 2 million members, I'd say that's not a bad ratio, much better than many other organizations, like the LAPD sure as hell beats the Catholic church. :)

No you just don't understand the subtle concepts of memetics.

Now were progressing to ad homs are we? What does memetics have to do with that large brush you want to paint everyone with? Let me use the LAPD again but for a different purpose. Police officers are supposed to be trusted people, if an LA officer sexually assaulted a minor, should the NYPD be held responsible?


Does the structure of the UWFB lead to this happening a lot in their organization? Are there thousands of stories of this kind of stuff happening at the UWFB?

Oh goody now were up to thousands, evidences?

Your interpretations of what I'm saying are insulting and ridiculous
.

You can describe them however you want but they're apt and you continue to dodge them.


You have no ideas on how to change AA? You don't think that this could have been prevented. I should just stop here.

Umm I have lots of idea, but alas I'm only one person and I didn't join AA to reorganize it, just wanted some help getting sober, thankfully it was provided. But why don't you give us your suggestions and how you'd go about carrying that out. I've asked you similar questions, yet you don't give answers, maybe you will this time.

Then AA is a retarded organization because that's a recipe for disaster. My whole argument is that an organization to help victims of mental illness should be professional, the fact that AA allows people to use their name without careful monitoring, reporting systems and complete transparency of accounting and freedom of information is absolutely unconscionable
.

LMAO, sorry I just have to laugh, who is going to pay for all that Joey? Professional eh, really? I'm really glad you don't run AA Joey because I'd probably be divorced and/or dead right now.

I seem to know more about AA than you do. I argue that it not having a ridgid structure is part of the problem so what are you talking about.
Exactly..

That's strange because I'd bet most members feel exactly the opposite, I know I do and wouldn't have stayed if that was the case. I'll let you in on a little secret, most alcoholics don't like being told what to do. :)
 
You're great, keep it up.

I know. Thanks. I will

I said unfairly. Where's the context? You don't get to say that I'm a bad person because I'm honest.

Unfairly? I got you the first time and I stand by my response.
I would ask you... have you been fair? Screaming, yelling, and lying with half-baked ill conceived and evidence free assertions. insulting peiople, their intelligence and making things up. Is that fair? Is that skeptical? Is it balanced?
Hardly.

If you want to play rough, expect to get some back. It was you braniac, who set the tone for our discussions and now you are sooking because I throw your nonsense back in your face.

If you don't like what you get, stop dishing it up in the first place. You (like others) are mistaking me for some sort of Christian who will happliy turn the other cheek.

btw. I have never said you are "bad".
Another lie?

You do a great job of advertising for alternatives to A.A.

He he. Right back at you.

But...I was "in" AA long before I was a skeptic. I knew about it, from the inside, long before I knew about skepticism.

Doesn't that make me a special skeptic?

I want to be special! :mghissyfit

You are special, if you believe you are special.
But I must say, I'm a little skeptical. ;)
 
You should have mentioned to your fellow JREFers that that's a comment on the blog. It's not a very smart comment, why is this important to you? I was about to comment a rebuttal to that :rolleyes: Here, I'll link to it since you won't since it's a comment on the post about you.

The guy is wrong, and is making a common fallcious argument against "pseudoskeptics". I agree my fellow skeptics don't know a lot about AA but that isn't for his reasons, it's because they just haven't been introduced to it and AA has done a lot of work gaining itself respectability and is often benign. That's all there is to it, people will listen.

There's a great post and discussion on this very issue, skeptics not understanding AA, happening right now on Ed Brayton's blog at ScienceBlogs! Check it out!

:)

http://scienceblogs.com/dispatches/2011/06/skepticism_and_the_12_step_ind.php

It's not important to me at all, I figured some here would enjoy his ridiculous comments about the JREF. Maybe I can blame others there for his comments too, no that would be really silly now wouldn't it.

Please do tell about all this work AA has done gaining itself respectability. What genius beholds this super secret society, imagine fooling all these people for so very long.

AA is the new NWO.
 
That may depend on how you look at it. For my part, admitting to being powerless over alcohol amounted to admitting to myself that once I took a drink, it was going to be a long time before I stopped.

That is still not what "powerless" means.

If I step over a high cliff, I will fall until I hit the ground. Whilst falling, I will truly be powerless - but even that doesn't change anything about that first step I took over the edge of the cliff, does it?


Addiction? Compulsion? I don't know. I do know, however, that once I got going, I was out of control with regard to drinking. I was powerless to stop. It was not an easy thing to admit.

But that is not the same thing at all.

"I am powerless over alcohol" has no qualifiers. And it is - often - a sober person that admits this.

"Once I start drinking I am powerless to stop until I pass out" is a completely different claim. It allows you to realize that "maybe I shouldn't have that first drink, then". The claim of absolute powerlessness excludes that possibility.
 
Joey you're blaming the action of a few on the many
No I'm blaming the memetics of AA
So there are no leaders, yet there are leaders or people that ACT like leaders? :confused:
Exactly.
100 stories, 2 million members, I'd say that's not a bad ratio, much better than many other organizations, like the LAPD sure as hell beats the Catholic church. :)
It's not just a few bad apples, it's a consistent pattern.
Now were progressing to ad homs are we?
I'm stating a fact, you haven't understood my memetic arguments, so obviously you don't.
What does memetics have to do with that large brush you want to paint everyone with?
I don't paint everyone with a large brush, that's your straw man you made up.
Let me use the LAPD again but for a different purpose. Police officers are supposed to be trusted people, if an LA officer sexually assaulted a minor, should the NYPD be held responsible?
IF THEY DON'T FIRE HIM, YES!!!!!!!!! The G.S.O and the Intergroup were made aware of Midtown and did nothing. Get your facts straight! You're criticizing the wrong dude. Remember your invisible straw man? You tried to "move on" from that before I demanded you quote me. You had it backwards and admitted it, good thing I did that. It's getting worse. Slow down.
Oh goody now were up to thousands, evidences?
Thousands of what? testimonies of harm from AA? There are many times more than that on the internet, books have been written on the Horror stories of AA, documented cases are in news archives. I looked for them, you seem to not take the few I have given as reason to look into more. I find this dishonorable.
You can describe them however you want but they're apt and you continue to dodge them.
What am I dodging?
Umm I have lots of idea, but alas I'm only one person and I didn't join AA to reorganize it, just wanted some help getting sober, thankfully it was provided. But why don't you give us your suggestions and how you'd go about carrying that out.
Give me a break!!! I have made those suggestions like a dozen times! Make AA a professional organization with accountability and reporting systems and complete transparency and freedom of information! Like a professional organization!
I've asked you similar questions, yet you don't give answers
WHAT?!
maybe you will this time.
Go look at all the other times I've already said that.
LMAO, sorry I just have to laugh, who is going to pay for all that Joey? Professional eh, really?
Pay for what? It could all be volunteer! They found the cash to pay their assissant treasurer 220 dollars an hour but we can't stop the quacks from telling mental patients to get off their meds! That's laughable to you?
I'm really glad you don't run AA Joey because I'd probably be divorced and/or dead right now.
What? What kind of sick and twisted comment is this?
That's strange because I'd bet most members feel exactly the opposite, I know I do and wouldn't have stayed if that was the case. I'll let you in on a little secret, most alcoholics don't like being told what to do. :)
Most people don't being told what to do. AA's idea of what alcoholic psychology is is wrong and folk wisdom crap.
 
Last edited:
Most people don't being told what to do. AA's idea of what alcoholic psychology is is wrong and folk wisdom crap.

But, ... but, ...

You said AA was "anti-psychology", now you say it has its own version of "alcoholic psychology"? I wish you would make up your mind.

But I will bite... Just what is AA's idea of "alcoholic psychology", from where did it spring and can you prove it?
 
Unfairly? I got you the first time and I stand by my response.

I would ask you... have you been fair? Screaming, yelling
How is this possible for you to hear me through the computer?
and lying with half-baked ill conceived and evidence free assertions. insulting peiople, their intelligence and making things up. Is that fair? Is that skeptical? Is it balanced?
Hardly.
I don't do that, ever, you're just slandering me. Quote me from now on when you accuse me of this or don't comment at all you're wasting everyone's time.

If you want to play rough, expect to get some back. It was you braniac, who set the tone for our discussions and now you are sooking because I throw your nonsense back in your face.
:rolleyes:

If you don't like what you get, stop dishing it up in the first place. You (like others) are mistaking me for some sort of Christian who will happliy turn the other cheek.
I am definitely not mistaking you for that tough guy.

btw. I have never said you are "bad".
Another lie?
No another case of you nitpicking a word or the way I speak as a pseudoargument. Second quote up there in this post is you saying I'm a "bad" person.

He he. Right back at you.
I do a great job advertising for the alternatives to AA? THANKS ALFIE
 
Last edited:
Please do tell<snip>.
Why should I even reply to you? I'll probably kill some alcoholics and break up some marriages just by posting here. Really you need to explain yourself with that.

Besides all of my evidence is wrong or made up anyway.

Gee, I thought you had no time. You were supposed to quote what made you say that about stinkin' thinkin' and Orange Papers. But you've spent all this time arguing with me tonight. Somehow that makes me think that you're digging for something really good you can't find yet and you know I'll be able to throw it back in your face so you have to find something really worthwhile.

My apologies, I'll respond to this request for information, in spades, when you've done your due diligence.
 
But, ... but, ...

You said AA was "anti-psychology", now you say it has its own version of "alcoholic psychology"? I wish you would make up your mind.
Never did say that. You straw man full time. I said it was anti-psychiatry for one reason only, sponsers telling people to get off drugs or refusing to sponser people on meds or firing them when they find out is a common occurance. Bill W even admitted that they started out anti-psychiatry! HA! I noticed you didn't reply to those posts I made recently. Just search pamphlet and you should find them again.

But I will bite... Just what is AA's idea of "alcoholic psychology", from where did it spring and can you prove it?
The idea of alcoholics having a separate psychology all their own is the idea you get from the program. This is just made up ********, it's just part of "we're all one" cult thinking. Alcoholics this, alcoholics that, they just make it up as they go! As alcoholics we don't like to be told what to do, so if we're good healthy people, we'll allow ourselves to be told what to do! wtf? Now, I know that it doesn't have to be taken in that way, that there is a positive, good meaning to that meme. But in practice, sometimes it works the other way.

Or like, if you can go into a bar, have one drink, and stop, you're not an alcoholic. I heard that a lot. That's made up ********.
 
No I'm blaming the memetics of AA

Nah, you're committing a form of bigotry.


I said members, you screamed LEADERS, I think you're getting confused.


It's not just a few bad apples, it's a consistent pattern.
I'm stating a fact, you haven't understood my memetic arguments, so obviously you don't. I don't paint everyone with a large brush, that's your straw man you made up.

Thought I'd leave the above as one quote, just to revel at the giant contradiction in it.

IF THEY DON'T FIRE HIM, YES!!!!!!!!! The G.S.O and the Intergroup were made aware of Midtown and did nothing. Get your facts straight! You're criticizing the wrong dude. Remember your invisible straw man? You tried to "move on" from that before I demanded you quote me. You had it backwards and admitted it, good thing I did that. It's getting worse. Slow down.

The NYPD should be responsible for the LAPD not firing an officer? :confused:

Who needs to slow down again?


Thousands of what? testimonies of harm from AA? There are many times more than that on the internet, books have been written on the Horror stories of AA, documented cases are in news archives. I looked for them, you seem to not take the few I have given as reason to look into more. I find this dishonorable.

Sexual assualts Joey, maybe you should take a break from the thread.

What am I dodging?

My interpretations assertions that you're blaming AA for the untoward behavior of a small minority of it's members. This dance has grown tiresome, I'm done with it.

Give me a break!!! I have made those suggestions like a dozen times!

Make AA a professional organization with accountability and reporting systems and complete transparency and freedom of information! Like a professional organization!WHAT?!
Go look at all the other times I've already said that.
Pay for what? It could all be volunteer! They found the cash to pay their assissant treasurer 220 dollars an hour but we can't stop the quacks from telling mental patients to get off their meds! That's laughable to you?What? What kind of sick and twisted comment is this?

Who would set that up, how would it work, who would oversee it, lots of paperwork, many hours, who's filling these roles, doing these jobs?

Some groups in my area don't even have a GSR and /or an intergroup rep, most groups are lucky if a quarter of their members show up for a business meeting, yet you want to add all these duties, again no clue on how AA is structured.

Yep, still glad you're not in charge of AA.
 
Nah, you're committing a form of bigotry,
That's what every anti-cult critic is slandered with so go ahead, make that case, over and over, without providing a coherent case for it, it makes me look better.
I said members, you screamed LEADERS, I think you're getting confused.
Why are you denying the leaders of midtown were cult leaders?
Thought I'd leave the above as one quote, just to revel at the giant contradiction in it.
If you have a hereditary illness in your family, and a large number of people get the illness and a large number don't that's still a consistent pattern.
The NYPD should be responsible for the LAPD not firing an officer? :confused:

Who needs to slow down again?
You're right, my brain did not catch the two different acronyms. Big deal, your example makes no sense. YOU are the person who knows nothing about AA. Midtown was connected to the intergroup and the GSO and they did nothing! Read it and weep. A tragic scandal.
Sexual assualts Joey, maybe you should take a break from the thread.
Sexual assaults? 13th stepping is a not sexual assault, it's predatory but in a different way. Maybe you should go back and read the thread.
My interpretations assertions that you're blaming AA for the untoward behavior of a small minority of it's members. This dance has grown tiresome, I'm done with it.
Good, you've never done anything with it. The "few bad apples" argument is tired cult apology. The patterns are too common and the evidence too deep.
Who would set that up, how would it work, who would oversee it, lots of paperwork, many hours, who's filling these roles, doing these jobs?
Yeah it's too much work. Just let the idiots get away with it. You know, all I'm saying is that you have a disciplined style where if word gets out that a sponsor told someone to get off their meds, their name goes on a list and they aren't allowed to be a sponser, and everyone has to be on a list, and that could all be done on the internet for next to nothing. Accountability.
Some groups in my area don't even have a GSR and /or an intergroup rep, most groups are lucky if a quarter of their members show up for a business meeting, yet you want to add all these duties, again no clue on how AA is structured.
I have family members that run meetings just get a clue yourself bucko, I'm talking about midtown, it was connected to the GSO and the intergroup, they did nothing. Some people think the lack of structure is a mixed blessing, that's delusional. You could have all of the benefits of the group AND accountability. Whatever you're not listening to common sense. It would be too much work to be responsible Joey! WTF?
Yep, still glad you're not in charge of AA.
Yeah the first thing I'd do is dismantle it.
 
Last edited:
Why should I even reply to you? I'll probably kill some alcoholics and break up some marriages just by posting here. Really you need to explain yourself with that.

Besides all of my evidence is wrong or made up anyway.

Gee, I thought you had no time. You were supposed to quote what made you say that about stinkin' thinkin' and Orange Papers. But you've spent all this time arguing with me tonight. Somehow that makes me think that you're digging for something really good you can't find yet and you know I'll be able to throw it back in your face so you have to find something really worthwhile.

My apologies, I'll respond to this request for information, in spades, when you've done your due diligence.

Time for bed.

No really I don't have the time to wade through page upon page of assertions and formulate what I consider a thorough response.

I've been playing with some old family pictures my wife wants uploaded to her Facebook account and having a "conversation" with you while I doing it.

I'm done with the photos and this thread for the time being.

Have a good night. :)
 
Besides all of my evidence is wrong or made up anyway.

First thing you've said that makes sense.

Never did say that.

Sure you did. More than once and I've already proven it. You tell big fat porkies mate.

I said it was anti-psychiatry for one reason only, sponsers telling people to get off drugs or refusing to sponser people on meds or firing them when they find out is a common occurance.[/quote]

Maybe, but only when challenged a few times and you had to backpedal really really fast.

Bill W even admitted that they started out anti-psychiatry! HA! I noticed you didn't reply to those posts I made recently. Just search pamphlet and you should find them again.

He did not say any such thing. Another lie.

The idea of alcoholics having a separate psychology all their own is the idea you get from the program.

As is cbrt I guess?

Now, I know that it doesn't have to be taken in that way, that there is a positive, good meaning to that meme. But in practice, sometimes it works the other way.

This part is almost rational. Sometimes it might cause a problem. But then again so does medicine, psychiatry, psychology, the girl guides, hollywood etc etc ad nauseum.

You concede here that "sometimes" it goes the other way but most of the time it has a good meaning.

Is it possible you are finding some objectivity at last? ;)
 
Last edited:
No really I don't have the time to wade through page upon page of assertions and formulate what I consider a thorough response.
The question you were asked was essentially "What made you say that about Stinkin' Thinkin"? You should have been able to tell us right away! The fact you have to dig means you have nothing and never did! Gawd this is so mind-numbingly obvious to everyone the only recourse you have left is to admit it. That's really the best for everyone, even if you can only bring yourself to do so with with some fallacious caveats, that would still be something.

When you think you're already right, it's easy to make mistakes like that.

You keep saying I'm painting everyone with the same brush and I'm hating on everyone. Dude, I support my family attending meetings if that's what makes them happy, some of them actually run meetings and groups and have sponsees. I don't think they are cult leaders. I think some of it's cult-like, and I think AA as a memetic organism has always been a cult. And they actually agree with most of what I say! It's a nuanced position. It would have to be as it's a deeply complex monster.

I've been playing with some old family pictures my wife wants uploaded to her Facebook account and having a "conversation" with you while I doing it.

I'm done with the photos and this thread for the time being.

Have a good night. :)
That sounds lovely, I hope you had a pleasant evening.

Good night! :)
 
Last edited:
Sure you did. More than one and I've already proven it. You tell big fat porkies mate.
I have asked you to quote me and you never do.. Go back and find where I said "AA is anti-psychology" :rolleyes: They have a lot of pseudoscience and folk psychology and but being against accepted psychology is a separate thing. They often against medication that's my claim.

Maybe, but only when challenged a few times and you had to backpedal really really fast.
Correcting your misconceptions isn't you winning points, like you thought it was when I said it was "effectively". Delusional wishful thinking is all.
He did not say any such thing. Another lie.
I quoted it in this post and this post and here's the pamphlet for complete context. He's admitting they were anti-psy while trying to say they'll be good now, it's in the past, while still apologizing for their spiritual solution woo. My argument is that whatever they tried to do didn't work, the cult memetics worked on people's weaknesses too much, and we still have many meetings where pill takers are shamed into silence or coached off their meds, (as I show) Fail. No one can apologize for this. You tried by saying it was impossible to fix, but you never told me how, despite me asking you twice.
As is cbrt I guess?
c r b t? You mean CBT? If you do I don't understand, please explain.
This part is almost rational. Sometimes it might cause a problem. But then again so does medicine, psychiatry, psychology <snip>
Those people use science to learn from their mistakes and iatrogenic effects and teach their professional members how to avoid them in the future.
the girl guides, hollywood etc etc ad nauseum.
smh
You concede here that "sometimes" it goes the other way but most of the time it has a good meaning.

Is there any chance you are finding some objectivity at last? ;)
I never conceded "most of the time" I said sometimes and you weaseled in those words. Telling alcoholics "they don't like to be told what to do" is mostly stupid, no one likes being told what to do, it's mostly a technique to get you to do what your sponser says. No one has to be told crap like this in order to have an open mind and listen to education... Everyone wants to do things that are proven to be good for them. They showed up to the meeting for help already FFS

I've said this before, that the language and cult memes in AA can have positive meanings, but how often is it actually true? The first time was with "you're too smart for your own good" Yeah, was googling that, an ex-mormon remarked that he used to hear that in the mormon world all the time, funny hasn't heard it since he left. Not really something people genuinely tell each other unless they are trying to thought stop them.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom