Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The buck stops and starts with the individual. What a concept; self-responsibility. ;)

Drink? My choice.
Take drugs? My choice
Do meetings? My choice.
Listen to idiots? My choice.
What does my program look like? My choice.
What God/HP/PGTM? My choice.
Get sober? My choice.
And on and on we go.


So how does that square with being powerless over alcohol and [one's] life became unmanageable?



If you're powerless, and must turn your life over to a higher power, how do you end up with personal responsibility? After all, your personal responsibility is flawed, and enabled you to drink destructively, to the point where your lives had become unmanageable.

I'M the one that's been blowing the self-control, personal responsibility horn.

But hey, if you're powerless, we can't expect you to manage your own lives.

And I'm sure you won't see how those concepts simply can't mesh.
Sounds like one's higher power is sitting on its hands to me.


I've made the same point several times. Maybe you'll get an answer where I did not. :)



With a budget responsibilities, personel, strategy, etc etc. A CEO (or similar) can be worth every penny, or not. The market dictates the salary and quality people are worth every cent.

While some might see this as a waste, I think it fairly commensurate with market expectations. If the job was $60k pa, you would attract rubbish.

The labourer is worthy of his hire.


LOL and how does this square with the bottom-up organization which has no direct leadership you've been claiming in this entire thread? And how does the AA World Organization make it's money to pay these grand salaries which you find to be perfectly reasonable?




See Alfie's post with salaries from other organizations, I think it's high, but not outrageous. Certainly a topic to chat about with friends at the next meeting I get to.

Sure, I just think it's cowardly to do it without his knowledge. Why do you need to recruit people to "take him on" anyway? Having trouble refuting his arguments on your own? Time to call in the calvary.

Oh I don't know, maybe because right at the beginning of your FAQ, you address AA members.


What's Alfie's argument again, exactly? If it's not written in the AA big book or other official literature, then it doesn't count but he can "take what he wants and leave the rest" which is a saying which... doesn't exist in the AA big book or literature. In fact, it's stated over and over again to explicitly NOT do that and there are many AAers who rail against that kind of thinking. What else is Alfie's argument? His anecdotes are equal to everyone else's anecdotes and because he doesn't see the strife and problems with religiosity in his groups then it doesn't really exist. He lives in a largely athiest country with a population of only 22 million and yet expects to understand what it's like to live in a country of 320 million that still has many, many pockets of religious zealots which in turn, has a tremendous impact on AA.



I'm sure you evidence for this claim right? After all you're on a skeptic site now, bald assertions don't get a free pass here. Oh and once again Orange's rants don't count as evidence.


Oh, really? Just because you say so? Just like AlBell, you're just laughingly dismissing a critique of AA by ad hominem (The guy's an idiot, therefore what he says is wrong.)
 
So how does that square with being powerless over alcohol and [one's] life became unmanageable?

Admitting you're powerless = admitting you have a problem, the first step to recovery no matter if you're doing it by yourself or joining a group such as AA.


I've made the same point several times. Maybe you'll get an answer where I did not. :)

I've answered that several times. I think what you mean is, the people you would most like to argue with in this thread have not answered you to your complete satisfaction.


Oh, really? Just because you say so? Just like AlBell, you're just laughingly dismissing a critique of AA by ad hominem (The guy's an idiot, therefore what he says is wrong.)

Odd how many people on a sceptical site are blind to fallacies like ad hom from people who they agree with, yet are quick to point it out in those on the "other side." Or maybe not so odd, at all. Its human nature I guess.
 
Odd how many people on a sceptical site are blind to fallacies like ad hom from people who they agree with, yet are quick to point it out in those on the "other side." Or maybe not so odd, at all. Its human nature I guess.

I do believe that it is called a bias blind spot. Everyone (including you and me) has one, so I wouldn't get too uptight when you notice other people's.
 
Or as I called it, human nature. :p

Sure, you and I have it too. I'm not too proud to admit it, either. :)

But "human nature", like "personal responsibility", is a poorly defined term, and I hate poorly defined terms.:p
 
Admitting you're powerless = admitting you have a problem, the first step to recovery no matter if you're doing it by yourself or joining a group such as AA.


Ah, okay. I don't generally equate the two, but thank you for responding. :)




I've answered that several times. I think what you mean is, the people you would most like to argue with in this thread have not answered you to your complete satisfaction.


No, not really. If you've responded to me personally about that, I missed it and I'm sorry. If you've responded to that point (or responded to a similar point made by another poster) then I also missed it. Would you be willing to paraphrase or quote what you've said?

I'm trying not to go round and round in this thread, though I suppose maybe I am; I'm really trying to continue to find more evidence about the various points people are making and trying to understand their point of view.



Odd how many people on a sceptical site are blind to fallacies like ad hom from people who they agree with, yet are quick to point it out in those on the "other side." Or maybe not so odd, at all. Its human nature I guess.



Well, let's talk specifics: in the case I'm bringing up, the Orange Papers quotes extensively from AA literature, talks, letters and other private correspondence, newspaper articles, journals, and books written about (and some not written about but mention) AA. Some of the Orange Papers commentary is inflammatory, but the majority is not.

Nonetheless, no one has yet to successfully (IMO) refute the religious origins of AA and the fact that, for 75 years, no changes have been made to the AA program. Meaning, it's still a religious organization. The best anyone has come up with is "take what you want and leave the rest" which is a non-official, non-sanctioned saying.
 
Perhaps you could enlighten us as to what you mean by "personal responsibility", because it has been established that people with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome are not personally responsible for their self-harm, yet the neurophysiology of addiction is dismissed as "not good enough".

What _I_ mean by personal responsibility ? I didn't mention this term. You must have me confused with someone else.

So now you're contending that an alcoholic CANNOT have any control over whether or not they drink ?
 
No, not really. If you've responded to me personally about that, I missed it and I'm sorry. If you've responded to that point (or responded to a similar point made by another poster) then I also missed it. Would you be willing to paraphrase or quote what you've said?

I actually responded to the particular post of Slingblade's you were quoting, you should be able to find it.

But to paraphrase, admitting I had been powerless over alcohol, was to me admitting I had a problem. Steps 8 and 9 as I have repeatedly mentioned bring personal responsibility right back in. When I mentioned this to SB, it was met with a "So what?" (paraphrase again.)


Well, let's talk specifics: in the case I'm bringing up, the Orange Papers...

If you want to talk specifics, lets talk about the specifics of this thread, which is what I was referencing in my post. I don't think I mentioned the famous "Orange papers." Why do you need to go to an outside, non-scientific source to back up what you were saying to begin with. The post of yours I responded to and my post which you are quoting had nothing to do with the "Orange Papers." It's like a republican quoting Fox News when asked a question, or a democrat quoting MSNBC to cover both sides.

In like 2 seconds of Googling I just found out there's a "Green Papers" too, some dude with more time than I who claims to rebut those other dude's claims. Can I just answer your Orange Papers with these other Green Papers? :rolleyes: Let's have an argument from authority face off next week at Tuesday Noon....
 
Last edited:
So, the best course is not admitting to the problem?

The contradiction lies in the claim that "admitting to being powerless" would be a first step to anything. If someone was actually powerless they couldn't do anything - by definition. Being unable to do something is what being powerless means.

If the problem you are admitting to is or entails being powerless, then you will not be part of the solution. Also, whether you'd admit to the problem or not wouldn't make a difference, either.
 
So, the best course is not admitting to the problem?

Did you understand what I meant, or are you just being obtuse ?

On the odd chance that it's the former: the contradiction is in the "powerless" vs "you can solve this problem." You're either powerless or you aren't. If you're not, and you can solve this, then you shouldn't say you're powerless. If you are, then you can't solve it.

It has _nothing_ to do with realising that there's a problem or not. I'm surprised you didn't get that. Unless, of course...
 
What _I_ mean by personal responsibility?

Yes, you are contending that an alcoholic has a choice to continue drinking after the first drink.

I didn't mention this term. You must have me confused with someone else.

Irrelevant, see above.

Dodge not, though.

So now you're contending that an alcoholic CANNOT have any control over whether or not they drink ?

Not what I said, but it is not surprising that your recapitulation of my argument would lack any subtlety.
 
So, the best course is not admitting to the problem?

The contradiction lies in the claim that "admitting to being powerless" would be a first step to anything. If someone was actually powerless they couldn't do anything - by definition. Being unable to do something is what being powerless means.

If the problem you are admitting to is or entails being powerless, then you will not be part of the solution. Also, whether you'd admit to the problem or not wouldn't make a difference, either.

That may depend on how you look at it. For my part, admitting to being powerless over alcohol amounted to admitting to myself that once I took a drink, it was going to be a long time before I stopped. Addiction? Compulsion? I don't know. I do know, however, that once I got going, I was out of control with regard to drinking. I was powerless to stop. It was not an easy thing to admit.
 
alchoholism is like overeating/obesity- it's a lifestyle choice that has very bad health consequences. in the end, the fault rests on the shoulders of the addict, be it the booze or food addict.
Blaming society or constant temptation is a copout.
 
I can't seem to find the salaries from last year, the figures from 2003 say he made 64k, so he's almost doubled his salary it seems. Interesting.

I also stumbled upon "Stinkin Thinkin" and think it's pretty cowardly of you ilsita to be attacking Alfie behind his back and trying to recruit people to come here to "take him on"

I really don't get the venomous hate of AA. Do you really believe you will get members to "see the light" by attacking people? Do you think we sit around at meetings devising schemes to get additional unsuspecting members? I mean the hysteria is laughable.

The people I know only want to help those suffering, there is no evil hidden agenda.

If a someone new came up to me and explained he didn't think this was the place for him, he was going to try SOS instead, I'd say cool, good luck.

In fact if there was an alternative to AA in my area I'd definitely go and maybe even stay who knows. I'd keep my AA friends though and certainly wouldn't make fun of them.

I'll always be grateful to AA, even if I stop being a member.


My best friend came into AA 18 months before I did. He finally found sobriety when the Paxil prescribed by his family physician was an abysmal failure. I continued to drink and he never once suggested I should stop or invite me to a meeting. Only after I tired of the ******** did I ask for his help and he was there for me. I asked him later why he never intervened and he asked me what I would've said if he did, I told him something along the lines of "go **** yourself" and he laughed and said there ya go.


AA isn't perfect by any means and admittedly I don't have much knowledge of what happens outside of the city I live in, but I can tell you around here no one has tried to brainwash me, there is no one pushing god on me and I am free to go to meetings when and where I like or not at all. I think you're WAY more obsessed with AA than I'll ever be.

??

Saying AA is religious is venomous hate?
 
alchoholism is like overeating/obesity- it's a lifestyle choice that has very bad health consequences. in the end, the fault rests on the shoulders of the addict, be it the booze or food addict.
Blaming society or constant temptation is a copout.

And not realizing that there are aspects of our biology, psychology, and sociality that we are not fully in control of is blaming the victim.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by tsig View Post
So you were born an alcoholic?
I believe I was born with the gene.
I also believe that I was taught through my culture, upbrininging etc to lean towards heavy drinking.
Throw in some PTSD and related problems and we have the perfect storm.

So it wasn't your will that picked up that first drink it was your gene?
 
With a budget responsibilities, personel, strategy, etc etc. A CEO (or similar) can be worth every penny, or not. The market dictates the salary and quality people are worth every cent.

While some might see this as a waste, I think it fairly commensurate with market expectations. If the job was $60k pa, you would attract rubbish.

The labourer is worthy of his hire.

It seems high for an organization that you clam doesn't exist.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom