Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
That does seem high. That said it doesn't seem excessive when compared to other NFP organisations and I would suggest are commensurate with experience, duties and industry standards.

http://urbanlegends.about.com/library/bl_charities_salaries.htm

As of 2005, these were the most up-to-date and trustworthy figures I could find for the executives originally listed:

•Marsha J. Evans, President and CEO of the American Red Cross, was paid $468,599 in salary and benefits in fiscal 2003. (Source: BBB Wise Giving Alliance)

•Brian Gallagher, President and CEO of United Way, was paid $432,709 in salary and benefits in fiscal 2003. (Source: Charity Navigator)

•W. Todd Bassett, National Commander of the Salvation Army, was paid (along with his wife, who also works for the organization) an estimated $94,091 in salary and benefits in 2003 (including house and car). (Source: Fayetteville Observer)


Fast-forward to 2010
•As of 2010, Marsha J. Evans, was no longer employed by the American Red Cross. According to United Press International, Gail McGovern took over as CEO of the American Red Cross in 2008 at an annual salary of $500,000 plus a signing bonus of $65,000.

•Brian Gallagher is still President and CEO of United Way, and currently earns $1,037,140 a year, according to a December 2010 report from the American Institute of Philanthropy.

•W. Todd Bassett is no longer National Commander of the Salvation Army. The current National Commander, Israel L. Gaither, is paid somewhere between $79,389 and $243,248 annually for his services. (Since the Salvation Army, as a religious organization, doesn't report its expenses to the IRS, the only available figures for executive salaries are estimates, which vary greatly from source to source.)

•UNICEF's Executive Director, Anthony Lake, earns $201,351 a year, according to a 2010 communique from the organization — dramatically less than the $1,200,000 per year claimed in the message above.
 
Last edited:
That's all so pathetic. Okay, end derail before I start to cry over the sheer waste...

With a budget responsibilities, personel, strategy, etc etc. A CEO (or similar) can be worth every penny, or not. The market dictates the salary and quality people are worth every cent.

While some might see this as a waste, I think it fairly commensurate with market expectations. If the job was $60k pa, you would attract rubbish.

The labourer is worthy of his hire.
 
AA (and other such programs, possibly like the SMART one you mentioned to me earlier) offer other things as well. The social support group aspect is not to be overlooked, no matter how many times you guys want to ignore it.

You make a good point. I certainly don't want to overlook the social support of the group. So, what can one find in terms of a support structure?

Well, once you make through the smoke-filled haze of the front door (steppers smoke more than Ryan Dunn's Porche, because for some reason AA God™ doesn't fix nicotine addiction), you'll find an eclectic mix of curious characters:

> You've got the guy who can't keep a job or make his child support payments, but he's managed to gain status as an old-timer by not drinking and going to meetings six days a week for fourteen years.

> You've got "Paulie the Pervert," who got his sentence reduced and had his get-out-of-jail free card stamped with the help of AA. His real problem was sexual perversion, but his problem of choice became alcoholism when he learned he could meet like minded people in the rooms who were content with keeping their own side of the street clean.

> You've got "Fresh Meat Larry" - who found AA to be an excellent place for picking up poontang off of the new pigeons (AA term for newcomers).

> You've got "Dr Bob" -- Not THAT Dr Bob, Silly! This Dr Bob is really a used car salesman, but doles medical advice to newcomers, telling them to stop taking their prescription medications, or they aren't REALLY sober.

> There's Lucy, or "Loosey" as her cohorts call her. She's the female equivalent to Fresh Meat Larry. She's a standard AA cougar, who sounds like she gargles with kerosene and has skin as leathery as cowboy boot (again, the smoking thing).

> You've got "Socrates Sam," the patriarch of the bunch. He's the wise old guy whose outlasted everyone else. He retired a few years ago after pulling the "I have an alcohol addiction, and therefore a disability" scam. It doesn't pay much, but he stretches his budget getting his crop of sponsees to loan him money which he won't pay back, and having them do his yardwork and other odd chores around the house.

> Then there's the wide-eyed optimists who represent about 2/3 of the group. They have a few days to a few months of sobriety, which is attributed to statistical regression, but for which they credit AA. They'll drop off like flies once they start drinking again, or when they see the rest of the group is flat-out crazy, whichever comes first.

> Then you've got your "Asinine Alfies." They know everything, have an opinion about everything, and annoy the hell out everyone else. There's one in every group, and if you don't know who it is, it's you.

> There's the Stuart Smallies, who carry a dog-eared copy of the 'Big Book' in their back pocket, which they use to answer any of life's questions. They have three separate home groups, and leave one meeting to go to another. They've traded their addiction to alcohol, for an addiction to AA.


This is just a sampling. There are, of course, sub-groups and cross-personalities. There's even normal people who stick around a while, who are nothing more than outliers on the AA bell curve of sanity. It's not exactly the Rotary Club.
 
Last edited:
You make a good point. I certainly don't want to overlook the social support of the group. So, what can one find in terms of a support structure?

..snip of content free information..

.

That sounds more like the Stinkin' thinkin' forum of people filled with CTer mentality, success aversion tendencies and hate complexes. :p

How sad. ;)

I just visited there folks. Very enlightening. Only the bravest of the brave are coming here to take up the challenge that has been laid out for their entire forum. Here's the challenge laid out for them - it seems the author wont bother themself which says a lot imho:

I double-dog dare anyone to take this guy on. The first person to get him to concede a point gets a “One Day At A Time” serenity calendar, and my ever-lasting admiration.

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/2011/06/...olics-anonymous/comment-page-1/#comment-64009


He he. A double dare yet. Impressive. :D

At least one guy got it right:

I read a few of alfie’s latest posts and will concede that he is respectful and bright. This is in sharp contrast to the tony j and mcgowdog brand of true believer I’m more accustomed to.

I love it, I am famous!

A whole thread dedicated to me. Wow!
Be still ego - what is it they say about parody being the highest form of praise?

:D
 
Last edited:
And what about all the other drinks ? Didn't you pick them up by choice ? Or did some external force take command of your hand ?

It's much more like the frog in the pot; one doesn't realise they are in trouble until they they have crossed the line into problematic drinking and/or alcoholism.
 
And what about all the other drinks ? Didn't you pick them up by choice ? Or did some external force take command of your hand ?

False dichotomy.

I suggest you actually review some of the science behind the disease model of alcoholism/addiction before you ask questions that can easily be answered by a PubMed search.
 
Definitely interesting.

See Alfie's post with salaries from other organizations, I think it's high, but not outrageous. Certainly a topic to chat about with friends at the next meeting I get to.

Is this a private forum? We are perfectly within bounds and definitely not sneaky to publicly announce on the front page of a public blog, whose readership will be interested to hear that there is a public conversation happening with an anonymous person who has made his position public for several months on on public forum.

Sure, I just think it's cowardly to do it without his knowledge. Why do you need to recruit people to "take him on" anyway? Having trouble refuting his arguments on your own? Time to call in the calvary.

How did you get the impression that we were speaking to or trying to convert AA members? (Also, I answered this in the FAQ).

Oh I don't know, maybe because right at the beginning of your FAQ, you address AA members.

Maybe because the sites has links to places like this:

this:http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/EFTCoaa/

It could also be the myriad of AA related topics when you go here:

http://stinkin-thinkin.com/stinkin-thinkin-essential-reading/

I mean really, you're not trying save these people:

We want to stop the practice of sending children to AA meetings. Aside from the fact that children should not be mingling with predators, the evidence is clear that most people outgrow addictive behavior. There is nothing healthy about teaching children that they have a lifelong spiritual disease that they’re forever powerless over. This practice is unconscionable, and we suspect that it creates addicts more addicts than it saves.

There's much more, if I have time I'll wade through it later.

Of course, AA members have others' best interests at heart. AA members believe; they're generally good-hearted, and have no idea that AA members have an alarmingly higher rate of binge relapse than do people who try to quit using no treatment whatsoever. Who's going to tell them? You?

I'm sure you evidence for this claim right? After all you're on a skeptic site now, bald assertions don't get a free pass here. Oh and once again Orange's rants don't count as evidence.

Why all the hate for AA? Why don't you rail on the NIAAA? At least in AA we fund the program ourselves, it's better than wasting billions of taxpayer dollars with nothing to show for it. No?

That's nice. Would you be against AA's implementing standards to ensure that your experience is as close to the norm as possible, and providing information and recourse for those who do not have such a perfect experience?

No not at all to the first part, though I believe one's experience is directly related to the group they join and people they gravitate toward. For me it's mostly a bunch of people with severe alcohol problems getting together to help each other. One alcoholic talking to another.

As for the last part, AA isn't a professional organization, it's a bunch of drunks helping each other stay sober, if someone doesn't think it works for them they are free to find help elsewhere, if something criminal occurred than the appropriate authorities should be alerted. I mean what do you really expect from a free program run by volunteers?

What's next, are you going to denounce food banks because they don't follow a nutritional guide?

Oh no!! Oh, wait... So?[/QUOTE]

So I guess AA isn't a cult then? I'm not obsessed with it and yet you are. Who is the one with the problem again?


I spent a few minutes over there and will probably visit more, I like reading opposing viewpoints.

Saying that I've already encountered some pretty hilarious contradictions. On the one hand AA gets criticized for the anonymity of it's members, on the other it's being condemned for revealing a persons identity. :D
 
You make a good point. I certainly don't want to overlook the social support of the group. So, what can one find in terms of a support structure?

Well, once you make through the smoke-filled haze of the front door (steppers smoke more than Ryan Dunn's Porche, because for some reason AA God™ doesn't fix nicotine addiction), you'll find an eclectic mix of curious characters:

> You've got the guy who can't keep a job or make his child support payments, but he's managed to gain status as an old-timer by not drinking and going to meetings six days a week for fourteen years.

> You've got "Paulie the Pervert," who got his sentence reduced and had his get-out-of-jail free card stamped with the help of AA. His real problem was sexual perversion, but his problem of choice became alcoholism when he learned he could meet like minded people in the rooms who were content with keeping their own side of the street clean.

> You've got "Fresh Meat Larry" - who found AA to be an excellent place for picking up poontang off of the new pigeons (AA term for newcomers).

> You've got "Dr Bob" -- Not THAT Dr Bob, Silly! This Dr Bob is really a used car salesman, but doles medical advice to newcomers, telling them to stop taking their prescription medications, or they aren't REALLY sober.

> There's Lucy, or "Loosey" as her cohorts call her. She's the female equivalent to Fresh Meat Larry. She's a standard AA cougar, who sounds like she gargles with kerosene and has skin as leathery as cowboy boot (again, the smoking thing).

> You've got "Socrates Sam," the patriarch of the bunch. He's the wise old guy whose outlasted everyone else. He retired a few years ago after pulling the "I have an alcohol addiction, and therefore a disability" scam. It doesn't pay much, but he stretches his budget getting his crop of sponsees to loan him money which he won't pay back, and having them do his yardwork and other odd chores around the house.

> Then there's the wide-eyed optimists who represent about 2/3 of the group. They have a few days to a few months of sobriety, which is attributed to statistical regression, but for which they credit AA. They'll drop off like flies once they start drinking again, or when they see the rest of the group is flat-out crazy, whichever comes first.

> Then you've got your "Asinine Alfies." They know everything, have an opinion about everything, and annoy the hell out everyone else. There's one in every group, and if you don't know who it is, it's you.

> There's the Stuart Smallies, who carry a dog-eared copy of the 'Big Book' in their back pocket, which they use to answer any of life's questions. They have three separate home groups, and leave one meeting to go to another. They've traded their addiction to alcohol, for an addiction to AA.


This is just a sampling. There are, of course, sub-groups and cross-personalities. There's even normal people who stick around a while, who are nothing more than outliers on the AA bell curve of sanity. It's not exactly the Rotary Club.

Wow, that's quite a list of characters there, too bad I've never met anyone with those behaviors. Maybe you could use them to create a comic book and we could hand it out at meetings.

Never, ever been to a meeting that had two thirds as newcomers, not even ones designed specifically for them, you must be special.
 
Alchoholism is rife in my family- luckily my mother and uncles all stopped drinking- on theri own, years ago...

The relgious nuttery of AA is what kept my mother away from AA, she went cold turky on her own. The problem with AA is that there is no individual accountability. if you are an alchoholic, they say it's not your fault- rather, you have a disease. If you are able to quit drinking, you didn't do it, god helped you through it. BS


Alcholohism is like any drug addiction- the abuser has themself to blame for their bad choices- not a 'disease'- Saying alchoholism is a disease is a copout, and defers resposnibility of ones own actions to an outside force.



If a person can find the strengh within themselves to quit booze/drugs, they deserve full praise.
 
Last edited:
Why do you need to recruit people to "take him on" anyway? Having trouble refuting his arguments on your own? Time to call in the calvary.

We actually highlighted him because he (and you) is a poster boy the points we are trying to make on the blog. We've admired your work for a while now. You wouldn't recognize it, as the Dunning-Kruger effect is alive and well with team AA in this thread.

Carry on.
 
Alcholohism is like any drug addiction- the abuser has themself to blame for their bad choices- not a 'disease'- Saying alchoholism is a disease is a copout, and defers resposnibility of ones own actions to an outside force.



If a person can find the strengh within themselves to quit booze/drugs, they deserve full praise.

And if they don't, they are just weak people with no willpower right?
 
We actually highlighted him because he (and you) is a poster boy the points we are trying to make on the blog. We've admired your work for a while now. You wouldn't recognize it, as the Dunning-Kruger effect is alive and well with team AA in this thread.

Carry on.

LOL. Pot meet kettle.

That entire blog is comprised of the opinions of a few disgruntled AA members with no evidence to back up most of what they claim.
 
And if they don't, they are just weak people with no willpower right?

yes and yes.

Some people lack the inner resolve or self disipline to make healthy choices- if a person is severly obese, a drug addict or an alchoholic, they got that way because of bad choices they made- and if they remain in that state, it's because they are not doing what needs to be done to change.

It's convenioent to blame substance abuse on others, but the fact is the adult abuser (of food, booze, drugs) controls their own choices.And they have only themselves to blame if they morph into an addict.

If they find health and fitness, they are justly give credit, but if they make bad choices, are you suggesting they don't bear any responsibility for their own choieces?
 
Alcholohism is like any drug addiction- the abuser has themself to blame for their bad choices- not a 'disease'- Saying alchoholism is a disease is a copout, and defers resposnibility of ones own actions to an outside force.

Except that there is good evidence (that is readily available to anyone who can use a search engine) that, in the brains of people who have a history of alcohol use or alcohol dependence, prolonged heavy use of alcohol shifted the control of alcohol consumption from the areas that we perceive as being voluntarily controlled (e.g. the prefrontal cortex and the ventral striatum) to the areas of the brain that we perceive as being under autonomic control (e.g. the dorsal striatum). Thus, while "non-alcholoics" may be able to emerge from a period in their life when they were in a social milieu where heavy consumption of alcohol was perceived to be the normative behavior, "alcoholics" are not.
 
Except that there is good evidence (that is readily available to anyone who can use a search engine) that, in the brains of people who have a history of alcohol use or alcohol dependence, prolonged heavy use of alcohol shifted the control of alcohol consumption from the areas that we perceive as being voluntarily controlled (e.g. the prefrontal cortex and the ventral striatum) to the areas of the brain that we perceive as being under autonomic control (e.g. the dorsal striatum). Thus, while "non-alcholoics" may be able to emerge from a period in their life when they were in a social milieu where heavy consumption of alcohol was perceived to be the normative behavior, "alcoholics" are not.


Yes, after years of heavy substance abuse the brain of the alchohilic/addict is altered- but it doesn't defer the fact that they got themselves into this situation. Part of being an adult is taking responsibility for your own actions- if you choose to drink to excess, shoot drugs into your arm, or binge eat (or starve yourself), it's your own fault.
 
yes and yes.

Some people lack the inner resolve or self disipline to make healthy choices- if a person is severly obese, a drug addict or an alchoholic, they got that way because of bad choices they made- and if they remain in that state, it's because they are not doing what needs to be done to change.

It's convenioent to blame substance abuse on others, but the fact is the adult abuser (of food, booze, drugs) controls their own choices.And they have only themselves to blame if they morph into an addict.

If they find health and fitness, they are justly give credit, but if they make bad choices, are you suggesting they don't bear any responsibility for their own choieces?

I'm sorry but that just reveals how ignorant you are about addiction. Do you really believe people decide to make a bad choice and die?

A poor girl from a broken home is handed a crack pipe at the age of 16, a year later she's screwing 60 year old men to support her addiction, you don't think doing that takes willpower? Why would she do something awful like that (apologies to Hugh Hefner)? Why wouldn't she just quit?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom