Joey McGee
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2011
- Messages
- 10,307
Why do you need an "expert on cults" You already have one, Steven Hassan endorses this article. Maybe not everything in it, but enough to warn people about it on his site. The other people mentioned are experts in their own right, but it is not the point, it's the arguments about what happens to people.Ummm it's a he not "they" and he is not an expert on cults, nor is anyone else from that article that I can see.
Well what's your definition of a cult then.Okay I reread it, still don't see how AA is a cult
Sorry what are you talking about.it seems the main focus of the article is to rail on 12 step programs and treatment centers.
It also has 50 year-old irrelevant quotes from people described as "alcohologists" whatever that means
Those are just quotes about the history from the start of the article.There's also this:
“potentially disturbing structural features of Alcoholics Anonymous.” Features that, in the opinion of some, might suggest a cult mentality.
12-step centers make a lot of money.and this
also this which contradicts assertions ITT that AA is getting rich.
Again, this is not really the point of calling A.A. a cult. I can't call it one because it's free? Please, as if money is an issue you can call this into question on.Viewed as the Twelve Step Alcoholism Movement, rather than as a single isolated organization, the Program actually looks more cult-like and sinister. For example, AA per se does not seem to exploit its members financially, but AA-styled treatment facilities sometimes do.
Why did you focus on the first less important part of the article? The best part is when they talk about Lifton's criteria.Admittedly the two non-alcoholic sociologists from California make some interesting points, but most of what they say can be attributed to groups like Weight-Watchers or the Boy Scouts too.
I have no idea what you're talking about, I am not using anyone as an argument from authority at all. I say what some groups and the general tendency of what AA does is cult-like to the degree I just call it a cult, it's a perjoritive word. Some groups aren't cults, I have said this countless times, good for them, go join them, woop dee doo. Wilfully ignoring the testimonies of countless people about what it was like deprogramming from AA is another story. It took me months to accept AA was a cult, I had to keep going back and looking at it, but now I've just seen too much and watch others apologize and ignore too much and I'm completely sick of it.Quoting a disgruntled ex member of AA isn't proof either. Orange is about as credible as you, I or Alfie. Maybe I can get Alfie to write an article and I can link to it too.![]()
Nothing to do with my arguments.Once again who is getting rich in A.A.?
Don't mock the abuse of people in AA with evolved memetic cult techniques. I'm happy for you that you're not in a destructive environment. Many are. And if people actually cared, they might spend a lot of time thinking and researching it like I did before making a decision.I told my sponsor I'd probably hook up with him at a meeting tonight, I decided to stay home, have coffee with my wife and hang out here.
Oh noes! My cult leaders won't be happy, they're gonna come looking for me. I better lock my doors!![]()
Mock me all you like, the evidence of the victims is everywhere. google AA deprogramming and read their stories, ask yourself if this is a bunch of delusional idiots.
And if you still need more, read Orange on why AA is a cult. Oh yes, the disgruntled ex-member routine, that's what scientology says about all of his critics too. I don't argue from authority. He is a smart man with motivation for helping people and should be respected for that, not attacked with the "disgruntled ex-member" routine, which should have grown tired long ago.
Last edited: