Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ummm it's a he not "they" and he is not an expert on cults, nor is anyone else from that article that I can see.
Why do you need an "expert on cults" You already have one, Steven Hassan endorses this article. Maybe not everything in it, but enough to warn people about it on his site. The other people mentioned are experts in their own right, but it is not the point, it's the arguments about what happens to people.

Okay I reread it, still don't see how AA is a cult
Well what's your definition of a cult then.
it seems the main focus of the article is to rail on 12 step programs and treatment centers.
Sorry what are you talking about.

It also has 50 year-old irrelevant quotes from people described as "alcohologists" whatever that means
:rolleyes:

There's also this:

“potentially disturbing structural features of Alcoholics Anonymous.” Features that, in the opinion of some, might suggest a cult mentality.
Those are just quotes about the history from the start of the article.

and this



also this which contradicts assertions ITT that AA is getting rich.
12-step centers make a lot of money.



Viewed as the Twelve Step Alcoholism Movement, rather than as a single isolated organization, the Program actually looks more cult-like and sinister. For example, AA per se does not seem to exploit its members financially, but AA-styled treatment facilities sometimes do.
Again, this is not really the point of calling A.A. a cult. I can't call it one because it's free? Please, as if money is an issue you can call this into question on.

Admittedly the two non-alcoholic sociologists from California make some interesting points, but most of what they say can be attributed to groups like Weight-Watchers or the Boy Scouts too.
Why did you focus on the first less important part of the article? The best part is when they talk about Lifton's criteria.


Quoting a disgruntled ex member of AA isn't proof either. Orange is about as credible as you, I or Alfie. Maybe I can get Alfie to write an article and I can link to it too. :rolleyes:
I have no idea what you're talking about, I am not using anyone as an argument from authority at all. I say what some groups and the general tendency of what AA does is cult-like to the degree I just call it a cult, it's a perjoritive word. Some groups aren't cults, I have said this countless times, good for them, go join them, woop dee doo. Wilfully ignoring the testimonies of countless people about what it was like deprogramming from AA is another story. It took me months to accept AA was a cult, I had to keep going back and looking at it, but now I've just seen too much and watch others apologize and ignore too much and I'm completely sick of it.

Once again who is getting rich in A.A.?
Nothing to do with my arguments.

I told my sponsor I'd probably hook up with him at a meeting tonight, I decided to stay home, have coffee with my wife and hang out here.

Oh noes! My cult leaders won't be happy, they're gonna come looking for me. I better lock my doors! :rolleyes:
Don't mock the abuse of people in AA with evolved memetic cult techniques. I'm happy for you that you're not in a destructive environment. Many are. And if people actually cared, they might spend a lot of time thinking and researching it like I did before making a decision.

Mock me all you like, the evidence of the victims is everywhere. google AA deprogramming and read their stories, ask yourself if this is a bunch of delusional idiots.

And if you still need more, read Orange on why AA is a cult. Oh yes, the disgruntled ex-member routine, that's what scientology says about all of his critics too. I don't argue from authority. He is a smart man with motivation for helping people and should be respected for that, not attacked with the "disgruntled ex-member" routine, which should have grown tired long ago.
 
Last edited:
Good work Joey! Unfortunately, I don't think you'll ever convince the several AA apologists & supporters here - over the years I've come to the conclusion that the same type of blindness to actual facts, new theory's, new information of any kind that religious believers seem to have is found to one degree or another in a large percentage of AA cult members (yes, I just called it a cult - which I'm convinced it is).
The orange papers is an excellent resource - much of his information & conclusions are well researched & documented ; I've communicated with him several times, and each time I've congratulated him on one point or another and offered my support.
Have a great day!
 
Why do you need an "expert on cults" You already have one, Steven Hassan endorses this article. Maybe not everything in it, but enough to warn people about it on his site. The other people mentioned are experts in their own right, but it is not the point, it's the arguments about what happens to people.

Well what's your definition of a cult then.
Sorry what are you talking about.

:rolleyes:

Those are just quotes about the history from the start of the article.

12-step centers make a lot of money.



Again, this is not really the point of calling A.A. a cult. I can't call it one because it's free? Please, as if money is an issue you can call this into question on.

Why did you focus on the first less important part of the article? The best part is when they talk about Lifton's criteria.


I have no idea what you're talking about, I am not using anyone as an argument from authority at all. I say what some groups and the general tendency of what AA does is cult-like to the degree I just call it a cult, it's a perjoritive word. Some groups aren't cults, I have said this countless times, good for them, go join them, woop dee doo. Wilfully ignoring the testimonies of countless people about what it was like deprogramming from AA is another story. It took me months to accept AA was a cult, I had to keep going back and looking at it, but now I've just seen too much and watch others apologize and ignore too much and I'm completely sick of it.

Nothing to do with my arguments.

Don't mock the abuse of people in AA with evolved memetic cult techniques. I'm happy for you that you're not in a destructive environment. Many aren. And if people actually cared, they might spend a lot of time thinking and researching it like I did before making a decision.

Mock me all you like, the evidence of the victims if everywhere. google AA deprogramming and read their stories, ask yourself if this is a bunch of delusional idiots.

Joey you've made claims concerning money and AA a couple of times in this thread, but I'll just drop the subject and move on.

My apologies to you and those who have suffered, my experience isn't very cult like, if there are groups or members taking advantage of vulnerable people that is shameful.
I only know of one person in my area of AA containing some of the traits mentioned in that article, he is a vulture and I despise him.I make it a point to talk to any newcomer after he comes into contact with them, others do the same.

No organization is perfect, even police departments have their bad apples. :)
 
Joey you've made claims concerning money and AA a couple of times in this thread, but I'll just drop the subject and move on.
Quote me. What's this, the invisible straw man? ;)

My apologies to you and those who have suffered, my experience isn't very cult like, if there are groups or members taking advantage of vulnerable people that is shameful.
I appreciate this. Personally I have mostly been personally affected by watching people I love change for the worse after entering the program. It wore me down over time and I have much better relationships with them now after basically talking them out of a lot of their old crap, they seem happier too! But this is just my bias possibly, it's my personal experience.
I only know of one person in my area of AA containing some of the traits mentioned in that article, he is a vulture and I despise him.I make it a point to talk to any newcomer after he comes into contact with them, others do the same.
Just imagine how horrible it would be if you were outnumbered by these types! Stories of old timers quitting abound.

No organization is perfect, even police departments have their bad apples. :)
The documented history of police departments is nothing like the documented history of AA meetings!

I think my local group is cult-like, there are lots of cranks and true believers, but also a lot of decent folk, and I'd never dream of telling my family to consider quitting now that they are happy there. I tell them this. It's not a serious cult like Midtown was. Why does crap like Midtown even happen? Because there are memetic weaknesses in the program. I really just want people to know about them.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
I see, when it goes wrong it's the individuals problem when it goes right it's an AA success.

Yikes, I didn't say anything like that. Were you responding to someone else?

If someone did say that, I would disagree with it too, so I think I'm on your side there.
 
Who is actually claiming this? Treatment centers make a lot of money.

I'm sure they do, even the ones who don't use the twelve steps. :)

Not sure what this has to do with AA though.

As for the claims see below, you claim AA is a cult and then make a sarcastic comment about people getting rich in cults, seems to me you're linking the two.
ilsita also thinks someone's getting rich:


Joey, I think what's also significant about that is that Wilson was agreeing that these institutions are useless for alcoholics, but that they can and should be co-opted. He is not saying that psychiatry or medical science should be respected for any reason, and validates his member's rejection... He just finds it short sighted for people not to recognize the opportunity that these institutions present for furthering the AA message, as they can provide the resources, legitimization, and big piles of cash. It's incredibly cynical and opportunistic.

All 8 of Robert Lifton's criteria are used.

Yeah, there are no wealthy people in cults... people never get rich in cults.... :rolleyes:

Ok whatever Margaret Singer. Unfortunately she dead so no one can challenge her on this.
 
It has to do with cult-like nature of 12-steps leading to deceptive or cult-like recruiting into 12-step facilities and that type of thing. This is a huge theme in the anti-AA movement and a lot has been written about it...

'Yeah, there are no wealthy people in cults... people never get rich in cults...."

Just a misunderstanding, here I am saying that just because AA is free, doesn't mean it's not a cult. Also, just because people are doing well financially and aren't getting financially abused by a group doesn't mean it's not a cult.
 
Once again who is getting rich in A.A.?

ProBonoShill, Please forgive me for dodging this... I'm not really (I and others have written on the subject extensively, I am working under a deadline at the moment. I have to bow out of the debate until I get my work done. I can point you to some links on the blog, if you're interested.)

But, let me concede that no one is making money in AA. Around and because of AA, and with AA's blessing, sure, but no, AA members are not raking in big bucks because they're AA members.

Hey, here's something you might find interesting: The assistant treasurer for AA's corporate office works 17.5 hours a week. Guess how much he made in 2009 for this part time job.

Really, take a guess (No peeking, or Rigorous Honesty, please). I will concede that you are right about everything you have ever thought or said in your whole life if you can come within $5,000 of this figure.
 
Last edited:
It has to do with cult-like nature of 12-steps leading to deceptive or cult-like recruiting into 12-step facilities and that type of thing. This is a huge theme in the anti-AA movement and a lot has been written about it...

'Yeah, there are no wealthy people in cults... people never get rich in cults...."

Just a misunderstanding, here I am saying that just because AA is free, doesn't mean it's not a cult. Also, just because people are doing well financially and aren't getting financially abused by a group doesn't mean it's not a cult.

Ok thanks for the clarification.

ProBonoShill, Please forgive me for dodging this... I'm not really (I and others have written on the subject extensively, I am working under a deadline at the moment. I have to bow out of the debate until I get my work done. I can point you to some links on the blog, if you're interested.)

But, let me concede that no one is making money in AA. Around and because of AA, and with AA's blessing, sure, but no, AA members are not raking in big bucks because they're AA members.

Hey, here's something you might find interesting: The assistant treasurer for AA's corporate office works 17.5 hours a week. Guess how much he made in 2009 for this part time job.

Really, take a guess (No peeking, or Rigorous Honesty, please). I will concede that you are right about everything you have ever thought or said in your whole life if you can come within $5,000 of this figure.

Didn't peek. :)

I'd say 50k seems like a reasonable figure.

Off to google I go........
 
Good work Joey! Unfortunately, I don't think you'll ever convince the several AA apologists & supporters here - over the years I've come to the conclusion that the same type of blindness to actual facts, new theory's, new information of any kind that religious believers seem to have is found to one degree or another in a large percentage of AA cult members (yes, I just called it a cult - which I'm convinced it is).
The orange papers is an excellent resource - much of his information & conclusions are well researched & documented ; I've communicated with him several times, and each time I've congratulated him on one point or another and offered my support.
Have a great day!

Thanks tinyal!

Yes Orange is just a guy with talent who feels the same way as a lot of people. I really don't understand what else he does but play with ducks and work on the site but really his references are as good as humanly possible and his writing is humorous, always buoyant so I can't see how you can hate on Orange Papers. Some people do, and he hilariously writes them back and puts it on his website. AFAIC it's almost the best part of the site.

I don't know about anyone here, but we are all naturally believers and deniers :p We all have to overcome to reach the facts, and sometimes evolutionary tendencies win out on some of our attempts at rationalism or skepticism. Sometimes you have to be emotionally detached or tramautized to overcome some of those kinds of things. I've been a believer/denier/apologist for lots of crazy things :D I try not to think of things as win-lose, in the end it's more the process that makes changes anyway.

That's my word

Cheers my friend!
 
Last edited:
I can't seem to find the salaries from last year, the figures from 2003 say he made 64k, so he's almost doubled his salary it seems. Interesting.

I also stumbled upon "Stinkin Thinkin" and think it's pretty cowardly of you ilsita to be attacking Alfie behind his back and trying to recruit people to come here to "take him on"

I really don't get the venomous hate of AA. Do you really believe you will get members to "see the light" by attacking people? Do you think we sit around at meetings devising schemes to get additional unsuspecting members? I mean the hysteria is laughable.

The people I know only want to help those suffering, there is no evil hidden agenda.

If a someone new came up to me and explained he didn't think this was the place for him, he was going to try SOS instead, I'd say cool, good luck.

In fact if there was an alternative to AA in my area I'd definitely go and maybe even stay who knows. I'd keep my AA friends though and certainly wouldn't make fun of them.

I'll always be grateful to AA, even if I stop being a member.


My best friend came into AA 18 months before I did. He finally found sobriety when the Paxil prescribed by his family physician was an abysmal failure. I continued to drink and he never once suggested I should stop or invite me to a meeting. Only after I tired of the ******** did I ask for his help and he was there for me. I asked him later why he never intervened and he asked me what I would've said if he did, I told him something along the lines of "go **** yourself" and he laughed and said there ya go.


AA isn't perfect by any means and admittedly I don't have much knowledge of what happens outside of the city I live in, but I can tell you around here no one has tried to brainwash me, there is no one pushing god on me and I am free to go to meetings when and where I like or not at all. I think you're WAY more obsessed with AA than I'll ever be.
 
I can't seem to find the salaries from last year, the figures from 2003 say he made 64k, so he's almost doubled his salary it seems. Interesting.

$200k for a 17.5 hour week as an assistant treasurer...I don't care which organization that is, that's criminal to me.

I also stumbled upon "Stinkin Thinkin" and think it's pretty cowardly of you ilsita to be attacking Alfie behind his back and trying to recruit people to come here to "take him on"

Um. None of us were born on JREF. We all came here from other places, for different reasons. A certain number of our members joined in just this way: someone passed along a thread here, folks wanted to talk about that, so they joined.

This isn't some Sooper Seekrit Club of Rilly Cool Skeptics. JREF educates. If you don't like people's arguments, you can try to counter them.

I really don't get the venomous hate of AA. Do you really believe you will get members to "see the light" by attacking people? Do you think we sit around at meetings devising schemes to get additional unsuspecting members? I mean the hysteria is laughable.

What's laughable, hon, is that blatant appeal to emotion, and ad hominem. Hating AA, or loving it, doesn't change the truth value of the points made about it. You know better than that.

The people I know only want to help those suffering, there is no evil hidden agenda.

Until you know everyone in AA, world-wide, all you've got there is a small-sample bias.

If a someone new came up to me and explained he didn't think this was the place for him, he was going to try SOS instead, I'd say cool, good luck.

Cool story, bro. But nothing to do with the points being made.

In fact if there was an alternative to AA in my area I'd definitely go and maybe even stay who knows. I'd keep my AA friends though and certainly wouldn't make fun of them.

I'll always be grateful to AA, even if I stop being a member.

It's nice you can say that. Not everyone can. You had a good experience, so they're full of crap?



AA isn't perfect by any means and admittedly I don't have much knowledge of what happens outside of the city I live in, but I can tell you around here no one has tried to brainwash me, there is no one pushing god on me and I am free to go to meetings when and where I like or not at all. I think you're WAY more obsessed with AA than I'll ever be.

ProBonoShill...does that name have anything to do with the CT forum? Suppose I can go there and find a topic about which you're passionate? Would it be accurate for me to call you obsessed?

Don't you see how fallaciously constructed your whole post is?
"I got something out of AA, so you're just being mean and saying bad things"?

Really?
 
Last edited:
$200k for a 17.5 hour week as an assistant treasurer...I don't care which organization that is, that's criminal to me.

It seems out of line, I'd like to see the salaries of others too.

Um. None of us were born on JREF. We all came here from other places, for different reasons. A certain number of our members joined in just this way: someone passed along a thread here, folks wanted to talk about that, so they joined.

This isn't some Sooper Seekrit Club of Rilly Cool Skeptics. JREF educates. If you don't like people's arguments, you can try to counter them.

Gee thanks for that insight, but that's not really what concerns me. More bothersome are the personal attacks taking place on that blog, here's a sample:

Whatever Alfie is, he is not respectful. He probably came to this blog and realized his audience expanded and smartened up. Alfie, you’re a jerk, apologize to slingblade in the thread or just go away, you’re a disgrace. Actually, stick around, you make the program look absolutely horrible. You and your buddy all Albell who thinks the thread will stop alcoholics from getting help!

The person referring to members as the AA Taliban is a nice touch too.

What's laughable, hon, is that blatant appeal to emotion, and ad hominem. Hating AA, or loving it, doesn't change the truth value of the points made about it. You know better than that.

I never said it did. I'm calling attention to the irrational hysteria of some AA haters.

Until you know everyone in AA, world-wide, all you've got there is a small-sample bias.

As do you, but it seems one side is allowed to use anecdotes as proof AA is evil, but the other is forbidden from doing the same thing to show it has value to some.

Cool story, bro. But nothing to do with the points being made.

What points are those? :confused: I'm hearing AA is a cult and brainwashes people, does my behavior in that sentence indicate I promote those things?

It's nice you can say that. Not everyone can. You had a good experience, so they're full of crap?

No not all, actually it pisses me off that a certain number of people have had negative experiences in AA. Doesn't change the fact it helps lots of people.


ProBonoShill...does that have anything to do with the CT forum? Suppose I can go there and find a topic about which you're passionate? Would it be accurate for me to call you obsessed?



Don't you see how fallaciously constructed your whole post is?
"I got something out of AA, so you're just being mean and saying bad things"?

Really?

Passionate is one thing, hateful is another.

Thanks for trying to put words in my mouth, but they are inaccurate.

That blog portrays AA members as helpless, brainwashed, dumb zombies in need of rescue from a cult who won't let us leave.

I was just pointing out how absurd that construct is.
 
I can't seem to find the salaries from last year, the figures from 2003 say he made 64k, so he's almost doubled his salary it seems. Interesting.

Definitely interesting.

I also stumbled upon "Stinkin Thinkin" and think it's pretty cowardly of you ilsita to be attacking Alfie behind his back and trying to recruit people to come here to "take him on"

Is this a private forum? We are perfectly within bounds and definitely not sneaky to publicly announce on the front page of a public blog, whose readership will be interested to hear that there is a public conversation happening with an anonymous person who has made his position public for several months on on public forum.

I really don't get the venomous hate of AA. Do you really believe you will get members to "see the light" by attacking people? Do you think we sit around at meetings devising schemes to get additional unsuspecting members? I mean the hysteria is laughable.

How did you get the impression that we were speaking to or trying to convert AA members? (Also, I answered this in the FAQ).

The people I know only want to help those suffering, there is no evil hidden agenda.'

Of course, AA members have others' best interests at heart. AA members believe; they're generally good-hearted, and have no idea that AA members have an alarmingly higher rate of binge relapse than do people who try to quit using no treatment whatsoever. Who's going to tell them? You?

My best friend came into AA 18 months before I did. He finally found sobriety when the Paxil prescribed by his family physician was an abysmal failure. I continued to drink and he never once suggested I should stop or invite me to a meeting. Only after I tired of the ******** did I ask for his help and he was there for me. I asked him later why he never intervened and he asked me what I would've said if he did, I told him something along the lines of "go **** yourself" and he laughed and said there ya go.


AA isn't perfect by any means and admittedly I don't have much knowledge of what happens outside of the city I live in, but I can tell you around here no one has tried to brainwash me, there is no one pushing god on me and I am free to go to meetings when and where I like or not at all.

That's nice. Would you be against AA's implementing standards to ensure that your experience is as close to the norm as possible, and providing information and recourse for those who do not have such a perfect experience?

I think you're WAY more obsessed with AA than I'll ever be.


Oh no!! Oh, wait... So?
 
hud, I'm addressing the idea that alcoholism is a disease which renders people fundamentally incapable of controlling their behavior. I do not believe that this is so. What I'm saying is that supposing it is true, how on earth would AA work? Either one would have to believe it's divine intervention, or accept personal responsibility.

Some do one, some do the other and some do both.
Free choice! Imagine?

Quoting a disgruntled ex member of AA isn't proof either. Orange is about as credible as you, I or Alfie. Maybe I can get Alfie to write an article and I can link to it too. :rolleyes:

Yeah! No credibility at all.

Oh.... wait....

Seriously it's as though some think that because there is a website, someone has a blog, or someone has created something, then posted it on the internet they are suddenly some sort of expert, and the fact they are on the internet gives them credibility.

I told my sponsor I'd probably hook up with him at a meeting tonight, I decided to stay home, have coffee with my wife and hang out here.

Oh noes! My cult leaders won't be happy, they're gonna come looking for me. I better lock my doors! :rolleyes:

He he. Good one.

So you were born an alcoholic?

I believe I was born with the gene.
I also believe that I was taught through my culture, upbrininging etc to lean towards heavy drinking.
Throw in some PTSD and related problems and we have the perfect storm.

But how about you answering my question.

Do you believe there is no genetic link?

Is that your goal, to rip people apart?

Some people, very few, but some.

I can't seem to find the salaries from last year, the figures from 2003 say he made 64k, so he's almost doubled his salary it seems. Interesting.

Was the $200k just from his/her AA work or was it total income?
Is the work and pay commensurate with the duties?

Just wondering

I also stumbled upon "Stinkin Thinkin" and think it's pretty cowardly of you ilsita to be attacking Alfie behind his back and trying to recruit people to come here to "take him on"

Ooh goody! clap clap My own fan club.

I just hope I can respond to them all. I don't like leaving my fan mail to others.

AA isn't perfect by any means and admittedly I don't have much knowledge of what happens outside of the city I live in, but I can tell you around here no one has tried to brainwash me, there is no one pushing god on me and I am free to go to meetings when and where I like or not at all. I think you're WAY more obsessed with AA than I'll ever be.

Nicely said

Um. None of us were born on JREF. We all came here from other places, for different reasons. A certain number of our members joined in just this way: someone passed along a thread here, folks wanted to talk about that, so they joined.

Great! Fresh meatThe more the merrier, I hope they are all as fanatical as some I have seen so far (not you SB, I kinda like you).
 
Last edited:
It seems out of line, I'd like to see the salaries of others too.

I'll post the link as soon as I have it (i put in a request with our resident AA encyclopedia), but here are the other salaries:

Corporate Employee Total Compensation for 2009:

Assistant Treasurer – Donald Meurer – $201,474 for 17.5 hours/week – $221.40/hour
Assistant Secretary – Doug Richardson – $135,124 for 35 hours/week – $74.24/hour
General Manager – Phyllis A. Halliday – $251,110 for 17.5 hours/week – $275.95/hour
Staff – Adrienne Brown – $121,583 -for 35 hours/week – $66.80/hour
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom