Hallo Alfie
Banned
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2009
- Messages
- 10,691
That isn't evidence, it's one person's opinion, one who isn't in any way an expert on cults.
Damn!
I was saving some of that to rip him apart again later on.
That isn't evidence, it's one person's opinion, one who isn't in any way an expert on cults.
If you are addicted to alcohol or anything else, you aren't a victim. You did it to yourself. It's your fault. Just as there's no sobriety god waiting for you to start going to meetings so he/she/it can remove your addiction, there's no boogie man lying in wait imposing addiction on you or anyone else. You did it to yourself.
And, yes, just quit. If you can't do it on your own, get some help. Real help, not AA religious faith healing. It's not my job to vet the programs or drug treatments for you.
<snip>
... how is it that they are able to recover in AA? The bottom line is either personal responsibility or God.
Actually they detail many experts thoughts the cult aspect of AA and that is the website of the word's foremost authority on cults who obviously endorses it so I have no idea what you're talking about. Did you read it?That isn't evidence, it's one person's opinion, one who isn't in any way an expert on cults.
I found this from a messageboard whose main focus is cult education:
http://forum.rickross.com/read.php?8,1016,page=34
AA Recruiting Mind GamesFrom time to time I will also hear someone compare cults to an organization like Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) or to some other group with a charismatic leader. Again, it is not the one feature - namely, a charismatic leader or adherence to a particular belief system - that cults may share with another group that is crucial; rather, it is the differences that are important. AA does not recruit deceptively
I completely disagree with this as an argument, as if every cult needs to be hiding what it entails to a severe degreeAA does not hide what membership eventually will entail
Huh? What? But you'll die. You'll end up in institutions. You'll ruin your life. Once you're an alkie always an alkie! And people who leave the meetings die. All sorts of crap.and members can leave at any point.
Yeah, there are no wealthy people in cults... people never get rich in cults....AA focuses on helping people grow, while cults use their members to promote the growth of the cult and increase the cult leader's power and wealth.
Ok whatever Margaret Singer. Unfortunately she dead so no one can challenge her on this.Cults are complex structures, and by taking any one point out of context, we can lose sight of the whole.
The social support group aspect is not to be overlooked, no matter how many times you guys want to ignore it.
Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) is the most commonly used program for substance abuse recovery and one of the few models to demonstrate positive abstinence outcomes. Although little is known regarding the underlying mechanisms that make this program effective, one frequently cited aspect is social support. In order to gain insight into the processes at work in AA, this paper reviewed 24 papers examining the relationship between AA and social network variables. Various types of social support were included in the review such as structural support, functional support, general support, alcohol-specific support, and recovery helping. Overall, this review found that AA involvement is related to a variety of positive qualitative and quantitative changes in social support networks. Although AA had the greatest impact on friend networks, it had less influence on networks consisting of family members or others. In addition, support from others in AA was found to be of great value to recovery, and individuals with harmful social networks supportive of drinking actually benefited the most from AA involvement. Furthermore, social support variables consistently mediated AA's impact on abstinence, suggesting that social support is a mechanism in the effectiveness of AA in promoting a sober lifestyle. Recommendations are made for future research and clinical practice.
False dichotomy. AA (and other such programs, possibly like the SMART one you mentioned to me earlier) offer other things as well. The social support group aspect is not to be overlooked, no matter how many times you guys want to ignore it.
It's still a choice to actually pick up a drink!
Addiction: New research suggests it’s a choice
Harvard interview with this Harvard Prof
"Addiction is a Choice" we have known this for a long time.
Remember you said
You can't blame someone for developing alcoholism through normal drinking, but you can blame them for not stopping. A genetic link is not enough to prove your free will has been removed from you.
Q: At the centre of your argument is that much of the research on addiction to date is based on people who wound up in treatment clinics. Why is that problematic?
A: It’s problematic because 60 to 70 per cent of the time, those people have additional psychiatric disorders. And those disorders interfere with their capacity to engage in activities that would compete with the drugs—jobs, family, other activities. So the people the clinicians see, and the people the researchers study, are those who keep using drugs and don’t stop right into their 40s. That’s maybe 15 to 20 per cent of [addicts], and they have greatly skewed our picture of the natural history of addiction. From the data I’ve seen, it looks like most people who meet the criteria for addiction actually stop using by age 30.
hud, I'm addressing the idea that alcoholism is a disease which renders people fundamentally incapable of controlling their behavior. I do not believe that this is so. What I'm saying is that supposing it is true, how on earth would AA work? Either one would have to believe it's divine intervention, or accept personal responsibility.
Sure, tell that to the people who say their first drinks or uses are involuntary.Yes, but most people may not know that they are alcoholics when they first pick up a drink. I certainly didn't.
But I have made I decision to never consume alcohol again, because I am pretty convinced from my past behavior around alcohol that, once I pick up that first drink, I will not stop until I am intoxicated. Thus, I am choosing not to have a first drink because I know it will turn into many more afterward.
100 pages of non-progress ! Fun for the whole family !
I can't tell you the number of times I've heard someone say "haha I remember filling those things out, they asked how many drinks I had a day, I just lied and put down X, I didn't want anyone to know how much I drank/used.
You're so welcome!Good read, thanks.
It's just amazing what goes on in the social sciences sometimes! That is truly bizarre.It's interesting to note the psychologist in your first link has a problem with the majority of studies done on alcoholism as I do.
I wish someone would conduct long term studies in detail where subjects are seen by a medical professional on a regular basis. Studying addiction by relying on questionnaires submitted by addicts is ridiculous. It's like studying a crime by using surveys filled out by convicted criminals.
I can't tell you the number of times I've heard someone say "haha I remember filling those things out, they asked how many drinks I had a day, I just lied and put down X, I didn't want anyone to know how much I drank/used.
Actually they detail many experts thoughts the cult aspect of AA and that is the website of the word's foremost authority on cults who obviously endorses it so I have no idea what you're talking about. Did you read it?
“potentially disturbing structural features of Alcoholics Anonymous.” Features that, in the opinion of some, might suggest a cult mentality.
Bufe concluded that AA is not a cult, “though it does have dangerous cult-like tendencies.”
Viewed as the Twelve Step Alcoholism Movement, rather than as a single isolated organization, the Program actually looks more cult-like and sinister. For example, AA per se does not seem to exploit its members financially, but AA-styled treatment facilities sometimes do.
Great, I'm glad you mentioned it. I kind of got excited when Margaret Sanger was mentioned earlier, but figured I'd wait to see if someone tried to bring her out firstShe only mentioned it once offhand in her book "Cults in Our Midst" She just didn't know a lot about what happens in the program.
AA Recruiting Mind Games
I completely disagree with this as an argument, as if every cult needs to be hiding what it entails to a severe degree
Huh? What? But you'll die. You'll end up in institutions. You'll ruin your life. Once you're an alkie always an alkie! And people who leave the meetings die. All sorts of crap.
All 8 of Robert Lifton's criteria are used.
Yeah, there are no wealthy people in cults... people never get rich in cults....
Ok whatever Margaret Singer. Unfortunately she dead so no one can challenge her on this.
What part of the actual cult experts arguments from that article did you disagree with.
You just tried to trump an argument from authority that I did not make with your own argument from authority.
Heaven?
Godsend?
Numerology.
LMFAO!
We have a true believer.
That is a total cop out on his behalf. I would be absolutely amazed if any person in or out of AA would condone abusive and violent behavior.
AA -in spite of what you and others think - teaches personal responsibility it does not advocate an abdication of it.
The blame lies with your abuser, no-one else.
Are you suggesting there is no genetic influence?
Are you also suggesting that alcoholism doesn't contain the necessary pathology for it to be described as a disease?
Well it's keeping them from drinking.![]()
LOL, you're beginning to sound like truthers who believe Larry Silverstein made billions on 9/11.
Who in AA is getting rich?
I think you've objected to more than that, but ok.
You may remember that on the religious parts we are in complete agreement, and that is mostly why I stopped going to meetings.
Sorry to hear of the abuse you went through. I'm curious how he used the 9th step against you, did he try to make it all out to be your fault or something? If so, he's an *******.
Damn!
I was saving some of that to rip him apart again later on.![]()
You have some facts to share on 'AA getting rich'?You're sounding like someone who doesn't have an argument.
So you were born an alcoholic?