Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think I'll use it for:

Fat people - Just stop eating. You did this to yourself.

Sometimes, that's true. Most overweight people don't have a medical condition that influences weight gain. Some do, sure. But for the most part, it's due to poor behaviors. If you can watch your diet, and you don't, it isn't someone else's behavior that's the problem, is it?

Poor people - Just get a job! You did this to yourself.

There are all kinds of extenuating circumstances, but there's a variable level of personal responsibility to it, of course.

Homeless people - Get a House! And a job! You did this to yourself.

I am personally acquainted with a homeless women and her husband who are homeless by choice. She works whatever work she can get--we worked the Census together and she was, by far, one of the hardest workers we had--and so does he. But they like not being tied down to more than their tent, and they pay their way, and get permission to live wherever they camp...just saying that "homeless" covers more than "the bum who won't work." Sometimes, the homeless are the mentally ill, who can't work, who have fallen through the cracks. But yes, again, there's a level of personal responsibility for many in that situation, but it varies.

(I had to throw in a few things you could yell strawman about :D)

Why was it more important to be a wise-acre than to progress the discussion?
 
Blaming people who have substance abuse issues for their substance abuse is like blaming people with type II diabetes for their diabetes: while there may be life-style circumstances that they can change to alleviate their symptoms, there is generally very little they can do to change the genetic and biological factors that predispose them to developing whatever conditions they have.
 
Sometimes, that's true. Most overweight people don't have a medical condition that influences weight gain. Some do, sure. But for the most part, it's due to poor behaviors. If you can watch your diet, and you don't, it isn't someone else's behavior that's the problem, is it?



There are all kinds of extenuating circumstances, but there's a variable level of personal responsibility to it, of course.



I am personally acquainted with a homeless women and her husband who are homeless by choice. She works whatever work she can get--we worked the Census together and she was, by far, one of the hardest workers we had--and so does he. But they like not being tied down to more than their tent, and they pay their way, and get permission to live wherever they camp...just saying that "homeless" covers more than "the bum who won't work." Sometimes, the homeless are the mentally ill, who can't work, who have fallen through the cracks. But yes, again, there's a level of personal responsibility for many in that situation, but it varies.



Why was it more important to be a wise-acre than to progress the discussion?

Thanks. At least I know where you stand. I disagree, but that's cool.

As to your last comment, have you read this thread? I was trying to fit in. Also, its possible to do both at once. False dichotomy on your part. :D
 
Thanks. At least I know where you stand. I disagree, but that's cool.

You disagree with personal responsibility? In general? Wow.

As to your last comment, have you read this thread? I was trying to fit in. Also, its possible to do both at once. False dichotomy on your part. :D

Yeah, I'm so glad I'm working so hard to be civil and polite. It's so appreciated.
 
You disagree with personal responsibility? In general? Wow.

No, with the idea that substance abuse is purely a matter of "personal responsibility".

Do you think that preventing self-harm associated with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome is purely a matter of "personal responsibility"?
 
You disagree with personal responsibility? In general? Wow..

No, and I didn't say that. Wow, you got that from me saying I didn't agree with you? Wow.

Sure, personal responsibility plays a part in daily life. But a lot of people still have problems and just telling them it is their fault is not a good way to affect change. In my opinion.

Yeah, I'm so glad I'm working so hard to be civil and polite. It's so appreciated.

I've been civil and polite. If I haven't been, show me where and I'll own up to it. I think you may have me confused with a whole lot of other people in this thread. A small attempt at humor is not uncivil behavior, nor impolite. No need for the clutching of pearls.

ETA: I did use one of those smiley things to try to show I was kidding around as well.
 
No, with the idea that substance abuse is purely a matter of "personal responsibility".

Do you think that preventing self-harm associated with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome is purely a matter of "personal responsibility"?

Oh my gosh... Addiction has never been proven to be a disease, let alone a genetic disorder that damages the nervous system to such an extent that sufferers injure themselves uncontrollably from the time they are toddlers. Are you kidding?

People may argue about the nuances of whether or not alcoholism should be called a disease, but there is no way the two can be compared. Can people who suffer with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome cure themselves through spiritual awakening?

Unreal.
 
Oh my gosh... Addiction has never been proven to be a disease, let alone a genetic disorder that damages the nervous system to such an extent that sufferers injure themselves uncontrollably from the time they are toddlers. Are you kidding?

People may argue about the nuances of whether or not alcoholism should be called a disease, but there is no way the two can be compared. Can people who suffer with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome cure themselves through spiritual awakening?

Unreal.

I think obesity is a much better example. Some people do simply eat too much. But not all of them. Some people need help, and these are the people we're talking about. I think.

I also vaguely remember that science was looking into a genetic disposition towards substance abuse and that there was at least a possible link. I need to look that up, when I have time...

The interesting thing about the "personal responsibility" angle is that it is part of AA as well. Steps 8 & 9. As I have said before, there are good parts to the program, no matter what you think of the overall picture.
 
Oh my gosh... Addiction has never been proven to be a disease, let alone a genetic disorder that damages the nervous system to such an extent that sufferers injure themselves uncontrollably from the time they are toddlers. Are you kidding?

People may argue about the nuances of whether or not alcoholism should be called a disease, but there is no way the two can be compared. Can people who suffer with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome cure themselves through spiritual awakening?

Unreal.

Uh...what's unreal is that those arguing that alcoholism and addiction are a matter of "personal responsibility" seem to be completely ignorant of the vast amount of research that connects alcoholism to genetics.
 
I think obesity is a much better example. Some people do simply eat too much. But not all of them. Some people need help, and these are the people we're talking about. I think.

I already made the analogy between alcoholism and type II diabetes. I was strengthening it (perhaps too much) with the analogy to Lesch-Nyhan syndrome, because LNS is an examples of a condition where it is clear that sufferers don't have control over their behavior.
 
Uh...what's unreal is that those arguing that alcoholism and addiction are a matter of "personal responsibility" seem to be completely ignorant of the vast amount of research that connects alcoholism to genetics.
It's still a choice to actually pick up a drink!


Addiction: New research suggests it’s a choice

Q: How has genetic theory—the idea that behaviours like drug dependence are determined by biology—influenced this debate?

A: There was an initial dark period. The initial impulse was to say that nothing that is disordered in our behaviour is voluntary—that everything is a disease. But we’re gradually discovering that things which are clearly voluntary, like religious beliefs, have a heritability. So people are going to say, aha, it’s not that voluntary behaviours are non-biological and involuntary ones are biological. It’s just that they have a different wiring, and the wiring for voluntary ones are more complicated. The neurons are influenced by consequences as well as by preceding biological conditions. Genetics plays a big role in voluntary behaviour, but our brains are wired so that certain activities can be influenced by rewards and punishments.

Harvard interview with this Harvard Prof

"Addiction is a Choice" we have known this for a long time.

Remember you said

Blaming people who have substance abuse issues for their substance abuse is like blaming people with type II diabetes for their diabetes
You can't blame someone for developing alcoholism through normal drinking, but you can blame them for not stopping. A genetic link is not enough to prove your free will has been removed from you.
 
No, and I didn't say that. Wow, you got that from me saying I didn't agree with you? Wow.

I was talking about taking personal responsibility for your choices, our decisions, and our life. You disagree. I took it from what you said, no more, no less.

if that's not what you disagree with, then spell it out. I'll see if I actually said it, for you to even be able to disagree with me on!

Sure, personal responsibility plays a part in daily life. But a lot of people still have problems and just telling them it is their fault is not a good way to affect change. In my opinion.

That's the strawman. Taking personal responsibility doesn't consist of someone else "just tell[ing] them it's their fault." But you've got to accept your fault in it, whatever it amounts to, or you can't move on, or get better.

That only some nebulous higher power that's actually god can restore you to sanity, or can remove your shortcomings, isn't you taking personal responsibility at all. Only you can restore you to sanity. No one else can do it for you.
 
I was talking about taking personal responsibility for your choices, our decisions, and our life. You disagree. I took it from what you said, no more, no less.

if that's not what you disagree with, then spell it out. I'll see if I actually said it, for you to even be able to disagree with me on!
I didn't want to get into a big point by point argument about it. I was trying to say, we can just agree to disagree on it without being snarky, or uncivil. I was trying to let it go.


That's the strawman. Taking personal responsibility doesn't consist of someone else "just tell[ing] them it's their fault." But you've got to accept your fault in it, whatever it amounts to, or you can't move on, or get better.

That only some nebulous higher power that's actually god can restore you to sanity, or can remove your shortcomings, isn't you taking personal responsibility at all. Only you can restore you to sanity. No one else can do it for you.

I never said personal responsibility consists of someone else just telling them its their fault. So that's a strawman on your part. (sigh, I get so tired of that its not funny) In that whole thing though you still don't seem to see a need for some sort of outside help. The more this position keeps being repeated, the more it sounds like "just quit." So its not a strawman. It is what you're actually saying. Repeated emphasis on personal resposibilty ONLY is not the solution. But that's what I keep reading. Go back and look at that post from Jack Astor that you "applauded." You'll see what I mean.

How hard is it to say something like "By taking personal responsibilty and combining that with some quality outside help, you can quit." :confused:

Also, as I mentioned above, you are in part endorsing the 8th and 9th steps of AA. :D
 
It's still a choice to actually pick up a drink!


Addiction: New research suggests it’s a choice

Yes, but most people may not know that they are alcoholics when they first pick up a drink. I certainly didn't.

But I have made I decision to never consume alcohol again, because I am pretty convinced from my past behavior around alcohol that, once I pick up that first drink, I will not stop until I am intoxicated. Thus, I am choosing not to have a first drink because I know it will turn into many more afterward.
 
Thank you :)

You're so right, I apologize for my personal battle infringing on the public good.

slingblade I think you must be from heaven. your post number three sevens (#3777) was awesomely helpful and now number #3977 is also a Godsend so what can I say? Maybe numerology is true :p

Heaven?
Godsend?
Numerology.

LMFAO!

We have a true believer. :D

I blame AA for its religious aspects that helped enable my abuser to keep on abusing. God is not accountable to anyone! As long as my abuser could fall back on such notions as, "My higher power isn't helping me yet; that's not my fault" or "you can't blame me for hitting you until you bleed, I'm powerless over alcohol," then he was being enabled by AA to continue.

That is a total cop out on his behalf. I would be absolutely amazed if any person in or out of AA would condone abusive and violent behavior.
AA -in spite of what you and others think - teaches personal responsibility it does not advocate an abdication of it.

The blame lies with your abuser, no-one else.

Oh my gosh... Addiction has never been proven to be a disease, let alone a genetic disorder that damages the nervous system to such an extent that sufferers injure themselves uncontrollably from the time they are toddlers. Are you kidding?

Are you suggesting there is no genetic influence?
Are you also suggesting that alcoholism doesn't contain the necessary pathology for it to be described as a disease?
 
Last edited:
Also, as I mentioned above, you are in part endorsing the 8th and 9th steps of AA. :D

So what? I've said all along my objection is with the religious parts.

Also, being 9th stepped was pretty painful. He wasn't supposed to do me more harm, but damned if he didn't do as much harm with it as he could, and gleefully. No one monitored him for proper application of the step, so he used it like a knife.


Your mileage will vary, of course. It has to. It just has to.
 
Joey, I think what's also significant about that is that Wilson was agreeing that these institutions are useless for alcoholics, but that they can and should be co-opted. He is not saying that psychiatry or medical science should be respected for any reason, and validates his member's rejection... He just finds it short sighted for people not to recognize the opportunity that these institutions present for furthering the AA message, as they can provide the resources, legitimization, and big piles of cash. It's incredibly cynical and opportunistic.

LOL, you're beginning to sound like truthers who believe Larry Silverstein made billions on 9/11.

Who in AA is getting rich?
 
What do you want? Me to invent you a time machine so you can go back and see it first hand? Did you read that pamphlet? Bill apologizes for it himself.



Wow. Still saying the same apologies over 50 years later... Whatever they tried to do to prevent anti-psychiatry, it failed, because the faith healing nature and their belief was too strong. It took on a life of it's own. They believed in the program too much to "neuter" it by making it a responsible and accountable to science. Like Bill W said "we have little time for biochemists"

What's wrong with my evidence for the XXth time?

That isn't evidence, it's one person's opinion, one who isn't in any way an expert on cults.

I found this from a messageboard whose main focus is cult education:

http://forum.rickross.com/read.php?8,1016,page=34


What Vince's recent links demonstrate is that AA has both critics that think it is too religious and those that seem to feel it is not religious enough.

Interesting.

Please understand vince that Margaret Singer would not agree with your application of her work concerning AA. Dr. Singer did not consider AA a "cult" and never opined otherwise, nor did she apply thought reform techniques to AA.

Robert Jay Lifton, the author of "Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism" likewise has not stated that AA uses thought reform, that I am aware of.

So you may offer your opinions, but they have no basis agreed upon by the authors you quote.

You offered a link to L. Allen Ragels paper "Is Alcoholics Anonymous a Cult?"

Ragels like others quoted by anti-AA critics on the Internet, is not a recognized cult expert and has no meaningful standing in that area of study.
 
So what? I've said all along my objection is with the religious parts.

<snip>

I think you've objected to more than that, but ok.

You may remember that on the religious parts we are in complete agreement, and that is mostly why I stopped going to meetings.

Sorry to hear of the abuse you went through. I'm curious how he used the 9th step against you, did he try to make it all out to be your fault or something? If so, he's an *******.
 
Uh...what's unreal is that those arguing that alcoholism and addiction are a matter of "personal responsibility" seem to be completely ignorant of the vast amount of research that connects alcoholism to genetics.

I'm aware of the research, but none of it has been able to draw the conclusion that alcoholism is a disease, nor has it led to any effective therapies based on the genetic findings. Furthermore, saying that one might be predisposed to alcohol abuse is not the same thing as saying that one has no control.

Supposing alcoholism is a genetic disease which renders people incapable of controlling their behavior, how is it that they are able to recover in AA? The bottom line is either personal responsibility or God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom