Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I respectfully suggest you didn't read far enough. The stories provide evidence that some members do indeed wrongly suggest that members not take medications.

First, they are just stories, second they are from 1984. I would respectfully suggest the "official" part is more important but that's just me.

You found nothing significant in the first 6 pages, the official (apparently) AA position?
 
First, they are just stories, second they are from 1984. I would respectfully suggest the "official" part is more important but that's just me.

You found nothing significant in the first 6 pages, the official (apparently) AA position?

Could anyone for just one minute please forget the OFFICIAL AA POSITION and please focus on the idea that the practice occurs within these groups, under the aegis of AA?

Could anyone manage to do that?
 
Could anyone for just one minute please forget the OFFICIAL AA POSITION and please focus on the idea that the practice occurs within these groups, under the aegis of AA?

Could anyone manage to do that?

Well, certainly I can do that :)

In my personal observation attending many thousands of meetings, I've heard anti-doctor, anti-prescribed medication statements more times than I can count. I wouldn't call it a majority of times, perhaps around 10% or thereabouts of the meetings I've attended have at least one person or speaker that makes such a statement, making the claim that it's AA's position.

Entirely anecdotal, of course :)
 
Could anyone for just one minute please forget the OFFICIAL AA POSITION and please focus on the idea that the practice occurs within these groups, under the aegis of AA?

Could anyone manage to do that?

My posts, if you read them, were the opposite. I did not see this happening in meetings. I didn't know the "Official Position" until you posted it.

So, how can I forget the "Official position" and focus on the practice? My (anecdotal) evidence is that it DOESN'T happen.

I don't know what else to say? :confused:
 
Well, it doesn't really matter, I guess. It's just dead or debilitated drunks, and who cares about them, eh? Good riddance.

Yes, that's nothing but pure snark. But honestly, it doesn't matter. Not to me. I'm not a drunk, and AA can't hurt me anymore.

Those poor people who are being hurt...oh well. Too bad, so sad.
 
It's simple. Your lack of experience can be explained by two facts.

1) This problem has gotten radically better in the last 15 years. (ask the old timers at your group)

2) The bigger and more modern the city the more likely to see less anti-psychiatry.

Your lack of anecdotes don't mean mine are imaginary. You obviously didn't go to the group where the 30-year veteran quit over this stuff. Why did that man quit? Because there was no other way for him to make change happen. You can't write an email to head office and report them and have them disciplined and prevent them from giving more advice. The cult protects it's own. Some places it's the opposite, the anti-psys are shouted down. Doesn't change a thing for my attack angle.

Every faith healing cult organization and belief system in the world has problems with anti-psy, it's just par for the course, it's as easy as 1, 2, 3 to figure out how and why it continues to happen.
 
Last edited:
Well, it doesn't really matter, I guess. It's just dead or debilitated drunks, and who cares about them, eh? Good riddance.

Yes, that's nothing but pure snark. But honestly, it doesn't matter. Not to me. I'm not a drunk, and AA can't hurt me anymore.

Those poor people who are being hurt...oh well. Too bad, so sad.
Yeah, the number of drunks who need help, and are dissuaded from AA by threads like this on forums like this are being hurt, will continue to be hurt, and far exceed the few here and elsewhere who weren't able to graciously accept what was offered, or find alternatives that suited them.
 
Yeah, the number of drunks who need help, and are dissuaded from AA by threads like this on forums like this are being hurt, will continue to be hurt
Yes, critics of AA have been accused of killing alcoholics since the cult began, shameful, unfounded, and typical of cult apologia.
and far exceed the few here and elsewhere who weren't able to graciously accept what was offered
This is what I keep telling everyone, as soon as you disagree with AA, it's because you have something wrong with you. You're egotistical. You have resentments. You're insane. :mad:
or find alternatives that suited them.
The National Institutes of Health would like to have a word with you.

SMART recovery uses cognitive methods to help people with alcoholism recover. LifeRing recovery and SOS are two other nonreligious programs. Women for Sobriety is a self-help group just for women -- many women with alcohol problems have different concerns than men. Moderation Management is a program for problem drinkers who want to moderate their drinking. It recommends abstinence for people who fail at moderation.
Those are all respectable organizations. Many have internet meetings available, so anyone can benefit from anywhere.

I would recommend every woman check out Women for Sobriety. Too many AA horror stories. Vulnerable women are traditionally preyed upon within AA. Cult leader and founder Bill W invented this practice, 13th stepping. People in the program constantly have to tell others to back off off the new women. It can be a very unhealthy environment.
 
Last edited:
It's a faith healing religious cult, all of those have problems with anti-psychiatry, that's the problem. This is why people deserve a secular alternative.

But there are secular alternatives and people are free to go there.

Belz, does it make some kind of significant difference to the people involved if it isn't "official policy," but it's still happening?

Indeed. And it is ignorant in the extreme, but despite what Joey says, it isn't AA policy.

I respectfully suggest you didn't read far enough. The stories provide evidence that some members do indeed wrongly suggest that members not take medications.

I haven't read it either - but will do so later when time allows. Are they talking about prescription meds, anti-depressants, mood stabilisers etc or are they talking about the misuse of barbituates (in the old) or benzodiazapines (in the new)?
 
Last edited:
But there are secular alternatives and people are free to go there.
I didn't say there wasn't, I said people deserve better, and they are getting better, and these organizations DO NOT tolerate ANY anti-psychiatry, so are therefore better, just on this one fact alone... You're gazillions of times more likely to be chastised by morons in AA than in SMART. That should be against the rules. But there is no discipline in AA, doesn't this disgust you?

Indeed. And it is ignorant in the extreme, but despite what Joey says, it isn't AA policy
Keep repeating this straw man all you want, I never claimed it was, and in fact said they have given official statements for pro, which doesn't change the fact that there is no discipline within the organization. If I go to AA and my sponser tells me to go off my meds, who do I report him to? How do I cause him to lose his influence in the organization? I can't, I have little recourse, like that 30 year vet (who is not alone) I would have to quit in protest. This is incalculably immoral and intolerable.
 
I would recommend every woman check out Women for Sobriety. Too many AA horror stories. Vulnerable women are traditionally preyed upon within AA. Cult leader and founder Bill W invented this practice, 13th stepping. People in the program constantly have to tell others to back off off the new women. It can be a very unhealthy environment.

Just a personal story, has no significance to this, really, but I remember the time my ex got himself a new sponsor. And she was gorgeous. I think their affair lasted 3 months or so.
 
I haven't read it either - but will do so later when time allows. Are they talking about prescription meds, anti-depressants, mood stabilisers etc or are they talking about the misuse of barbituates (in the old) or benzodiazapines (in the new)?

Its a short read, barely 6 pages before the personal sories from members start.

They are talking about the addidctive drugs and pills, like the ones you mention at the end of your post. What you would expect from something written in 1984 - valium, painkillers, speed.

There's no mention at all really in the "official" part about drugs like Prozac, for example. I don't really remember anything about anti-depressants and the like from my high school years either :D
 
Could anyone for just one minute please forget the OFFICIAL AA POSITION and please focus on the idea that the practice occurs within these groups, under the aegis of AA?

Could anyone manage to do that?
Slingblade, I totally have your back on this.

I have been trying to ignore this thread for a really long time, but today it came up on our blog (Stinkin' Thinkin': Muckraking the 12 Step Treatment Industry, where I write under the handle "friendthegirl") and so...

AA's official policies and pamphlets are disclaimers.

They are not official policy or anything that makes them accountable; these disclaimers are designed to absolve them of responsibility for what actually happens in "the rooms," what they teach, what they know happens in the rooms, what they condone, but what that they do not want to be held accountable for. They will not be responsible for the outcome of their program.

Every official policy and tradition that they own is designed to absolve them of responsibility from the actions of the people who represent them (you think "Anonymity" is in your best interest?). The people who represent AA (members) are always very careful to point out that they do not officially represent them. And AA is always very careful to point out that it does not speak for or condone anything at all, and are not responsible for anything that happens in its name.

It's a perpetual motion pass-the-buck business model machine. The great disappearing AA. Just try to pin it down at any level. Where does the buck stop? Can you justify the fact that no one is accountable?
 
Ilsita, I know we've only just met, but....can I hug you? :D

Thank you for your valuable contribution here, and thanks so much for mentioning the blog! I'm reading it now; it's amazing work.

Now, if we can just get Alfie to stop defending....
 
Yeah, the number of drunks who need help, and are dissuaded from AA by threads like this on forums like this are being hurt, will continue to be hurt, and far exceed the few here and elsewhere who weren't able to graciously accept what was offered, or find alternatives that suited them.

Evidence?

Hell, if it's required of us, Al, it's darn sure required of you.
 
It's a perpetual motion pass-the-buck business model machine. The great disappearing AA. Just try to pin it down at any level. Where does the buck stop? Can you justify the fact that no one is accountable?


The buck stops and starts with the individual. What a concept; self-responsibility. ;)

Drink? My choice.
Take drugs? My choice
Do meetings? My choice.
Listen to idiots? My choice.
What does my program look like? My choice.
What God/HP/PGTM? My choice.
Get sober? My choice.
And on and on we go.
 
Last edited:
The buck stops and starts with the individual. What a concept; self-responsibility. ;)
Ludicrous and unconscionable. We're talking about vulnerable victims of mental illness, addiction, traumatic events and abuse here. These people are highly suggestible and suffering. They are encouraged to allow their sponsors to take responsibility, and you have even said in this thread that not following a sponsors advice will kill you.

Some self-responsibility you are advocating for here. The memetic virus that is AA programming has evolved to be extra effective at brainwashing these victims in their suggestible state. Just like a real virus it gets you when your immune system is weak.

Listen to idiots? My choice.
Great, by this logic, people who practice quack medicine and give people poor medical advice can't be sued or thrown in jail! When you act as an authority you have to take responsibility for that. They aren't listening to idiots in their mind, they are listening to people who have the key to saving their lives! The people with the wisdom they need to get back to their family and get their lives back. Unbelievable apologetics going on around here.
 
Just a personal story, has no significance to this, really, but I remember the time my ex got himself a new sponsor. And she was gorgeous. I think their affair lasted 3 months or so.
Brutal. Co-ed sponsership? Yeah it's not supposed to happen but, people do look the other way!

Many years ago I introduced a woman to AA and she completely threw herself into the program head-first and she was engaged with a man she met there within months of joining. It did not end well, he was a twisted man, apparently with a history of problems with women in the group. Every time I think of how enthusiastic she was about it and how I was the one that sold her on it, I feel horrible. At least I could have warned her that this happens all the time and to be extremely careful, I just didn't know at the time.

To their credit I know for a fact that there are good men aware of this that will stop these things from progressing, telling people to back off etc. It's just an extremely important thing to be aware of. It's allowed to happen far too often just because of the non-professional, cult woo nature of the program.

Another side note of history, that swine Bill Wilson...

There is a chapter in the Big Book, titled "To Wives", which is ostensibly advice from the alcoholics' wives to other alcoholics' wives. But Bill Wilson did not let his wife Lois write the To Wives chapter of the Big Book. In spite of the fact that the chapter begins with the words:

"As wives of Alcoholics Anonymous, we would like you to feel that we understand as perhaps few can",

Mr. Wilson actually wrote the entire chapter himself while pretending to be his own wife, because, he said, he didn't trust Lois to get it right. He mumbled something about how she wouldn't get the style the same as the rest of the book. Lois felt hurt by the rejection, but that was the way it was going to be.

What a man.
 
Last edited:
Joey, you'll find that controlling aspect in a lot of alcoholics. It's easier to control someone else, someone gullible and naive and loving, as I once was, than it is to control yourself. It feeds your ego, gives you a false sense of power, and actually enables you to continue on your destructive path.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom