Hallo Alfie
Banned
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2009
- Messages
- 10,691
It doesn't matter if AA sanctions this kind of behavior or not; if the members are doing it, then it is part of AA; a rogue part that shouldn't be there.
It's a double edged sword though isn't it?
The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.
Who else would we kick out? Atheists and agnostics? The steps, history?
Now, if the AA organization is working on it, great. More power to them. But if they're not practicing due diligence, they're being neglectful, and causing people to be hurt.
I agree, "Do what your doctor tells you" should be a saying too.
I guess the official stance that AA would take is that it is an outside issue, therefore AA has no opinion. See tradition 10
Ten—Alcoholics Anonymous has no opinion on outside issues; hence the A.A. name ought never be drawn into public controversy.
That you and Tinyal are working to change such things is good. Keep up that good work.
Thanks.
Sometimes we can only do that one person, one meeting or one share at a time.
As I mentioned above somewhere, this was done at the meetings around here. There was no directive from AA, so I guess it was more of a grass roots kind of thing.
At every meeting I was at where someone tried the anti-psychiatry or anti-meds thing, they were basically shouted down by multiple members. "AA does not play doctor" is what I learned, and of course just assumed it was like that everywhere. I didn't know there was a larger problem out there somewhere like you are describing. My sponsor approved of any and all treatments that might be effective.
Pretty much my experience here too. The "pills are for dills" lobby is very much in the minority.
So when some people in AA say not to take your pills that is not AA but when you tell him to take his pills that is AA.
Your argument is a No True Scotchman fallacy.
Actually what I really say is when it comes to medicine is "listen to your doctor".
I see you're not interested in proving your claim and you're even insulting people who are on your side. I'll let you calm down on your own.
The ignore function is looking good. Some people are completey off tap at the moment; I think they should listen to their doctors and take their meds.
Last edited: