Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
It doesn't matter if AA sanctions this kind of behavior or not; if the members are doing it, then it is part of AA; a rogue part that shouldn't be there.

It's a double edged sword though isn't it?
The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.

Who else would we kick out? Atheists and agnostics? The steps, history?

Now, if the AA organization is working on it, great. More power to them. But if they're not practicing due diligence, they're being neglectful, and causing people to be hurt.

I agree, "Do what your doctor tells you" should be a saying too.

I guess the official stance that AA would take is that it is an outside issue, therefore AA has no opinion. See tradition 10

Ten—Alcoholics Anonymous has no opinion on outside issues; hence the A.A. name ought never be drawn into public controversy.

That you and Tinyal are working to change such things is good. Keep up that good work.

Thanks.
Sometimes we can only do that one person, one meeting or one share at a time.

As I mentioned above somewhere, this was done at the meetings around here. There was no directive from AA, so I guess it was more of a grass roots kind of thing.

At every meeting I was at where someone tried the anti-psychiatry or anti-meds thing, they were basically shouted down by multiple members. "AA does not play doctor" is what I learned, and of course just assumed it was like that everywhere. I didn't know there was a larger problem out there somewhere like you are describing. My sponsor approved of any and all treatments that might be effective.

Pretty much my experience here too. The "pills are for dills" lobby is very much in the minority.

So when some people in AA say not to take your pills that is not AA but when you tell him to take his pills that is AA.

Your argument is a No True Scotchman fallacy.

Actually what I really say is when it comes to medicine is "listen to your doctor".

I see you're not interested in proving your claim and you're even insulting people who are on your side. I'll let you calm down on your own.

The ignore function is looking good. Some people are completey off tap at the moment; I think they should listen to their doctors and take their meds. :)
 
Last edited:
It's a double edged sword though isn't it?
The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking.

Who else would we kick out? Atheists and agnostics? The steps, history?

Whoa, slow down there, pardner! Who said anyone gets kicked out?

What do you do if a member brings a flask of booze to a meeting and puts it in his coffee? Do you kick him or her out?

Don't AA meetings have any rules of behavior? How do you enforce those, if there are any? Why can't you enforce this the same way?

PEOPLE DIE because of some members telling others they can't have their meds. Don't take this lightly, as it appears you're doing by making crap up wholesale about my position which I do think is called a strawman in some circles, eh?



I agree, "Do what your doctor tells you" should be a saying too.

Me, too.



Thanks.
Sometimes we can only do that one person, one meeting or one share at a time.

True, and I get that. One day at a time, one person at a time. K.I.S.S. :D

I'm saying the organization, from the top down, should be practicing due diligence, doing its best to make sure no one gets hurt by what they're told at a meeting. That's all.
 
Last edited:
Whoa, slow down there, pardner! Who said anyone gets kicked out?

My bad. I ran to the extreme end of the word sanction.

What do you do if a member brings a flask of booze to a meeting and puts it in his coffee? Do you kick him or her out?

No. I have seen dozens of drunk people inside meetings, I have never seen anyone asked to leave. In fact, at one meeting we had three men in the back row opening their stubbies in the meeting; they brought their own.

Don't AA meetings have any rules of behavior? How do you enforce those, if there are any? Why can't you enforce this the same way?

All are welcome, no-one is excluded.
I would be interested to hear how/if others have rules within their particular groups. If something was to be done I would imagine that it would only be if it was illegal (eg assault).

At my home group a few years back we had an AA member dealing drugs (to non members) from time-to-time. I was the secretary of the group and discussed it with the other home group members. We had healthy arguments both for and against doing anything about this. In the end, I simply had a quiet word to him that "some people were aware" what was occuring and that I (as an individual) would like him to stop. He did so on that basis; no threats, no exclusions, no sanctions. He is still a member and (after a stint inprison - through nothing to do with AA) has stopped dealing.

PEOPLE DIE because of some members telling others they can't have their meds. Don't take this lightly, as it appears you're doing by making crap up wholesale about my position which I do think is called a strawman in some circles, eh?

Huh? Now I could easily respond emotionally here ;). I most certainly do not take this lightly. I have not made crap up and I am not throwing straw. I think you are reading things here that are not there.

I'm saying the organization, from the top down, should be practicing due diligence, doing its best to make sure no one gets hurt by what they're told at a meeting. That's all.

And I have said that our traditions cover that and we have a double edged sword.

Are you aware that people also die from not listening to their sponsor?

At the end of the day, the individual is responsible for their own actions. The opinions expressed are those of individuals and people are free to share their personal journey; how they got sober and what worked for them. Frankly I don't like anyone using the meetings to articulate their personal soapbox topics. These topics include:

- religion
- atheism
- God
- pills
- internal politics
 
Are you aware that people also die from not listening to their sponsor?

Sure. But I wouldn't hold AA in any way responsible for that. That's on the alcoholic, not the program, isn't it?

You can't make alcoholics listen to their sponsors. You can't force alcoholics to work their program. But AA can be responsible about how its members present the program to other alcoholics. And it should.

It's either an "organization," with a charter, bylaws, mission statement, rules, guidelines, and accountability, or it's just a bunch of people doing whatever they want.
 
Sure. But I wouldn't hold AA in any way responsible for that. That's on the alcoholic, not the program, isn't it?

But that's my point too. That the anti-psych is not "the program" either. AA does not advocate this despite the hollow and fact free claims of others.

You can't make alcoholics listen to their sponsors. You can't force alcoholics to work their program. But AA can be responsible about how its members present the program to other alcoholics. And it should.

Who should make these rules? Under what powers? While I may agree with this sentiment of yours, facilitating change will not occur without a complete dismantling of the organisation and this will not happen.

It's either an "organization," with a charter, bylaws, mission statement, rules, guidelines, and accountability, or it's just a bunch of people doing whatever they want.

Tradition 9:
9. A.A., as such, ought never be organized; but we may create service boards
or committees directly responsible to those they serve.


I respectfully submit the "charter, bylaws, mission statements, rules" etc for your consideration, they are called the 12 traditions.

http://www.prismnet.com/aamen/trad.html

The reality is - despite Tinyal's earlier unsupported claims to the contrary - that unlike just about any other organisation, AA truly works from bottom up, not top down. His comments about the dizzying heights of power just meant he did had greater obligation to those he served, no-one served him. The more power he thought he had, the less he had in reality; this is why he gets so frustrated I think.
 
Last edited:
I see you're not interested in proving your claim and you're even insulting people who are on your side. I'll let you calm down on your own.
Look, it's the fourth time I've asked for sometime to tell me what additional evidence there would be or you would need if my claim is true. If you're going to just let that slide, I win.

I don't "take sides'. I'm not nicer or meaner to people because they are on or off my side. I said this was "concern trollery" because you obviously have no legitimate grievance with me, you just didn't like how I told Alfie what he could do with his request for that evidence, when it's already proven beyond a shadow of a doubt. So attack my honor all you want.
 
Last edited:
Look, it's the fourth time I've asked for sometime to tell me what additional evidence there would be or you would need if my claim is true. If you're going to just let that slide, I win.

picture.php
 
alfie whats actually funny is how you said my study had a small sample. You also refuse to answer that question, why? Because trying to answer it will result in me winning the debate.
 
What evidence do you need to prove that AA is anti-psychiatry?

Oh I don't know. Perhaps something that proves that AA (not some members) are anti-psychiatry. :rolleyes:
Maybe:
- letters from central office.
- official correspondence.
- even big book references (in context) might even nudge it.
- grapevine articles might do it.
- website statements.
- offical policy documents - maybe you should ask Tinyal to get them from the secret archives (lol).
- surely it's in the suggested steps and traditions? What's that? It isn't!? Well I'll be ....!

As I say, anything that shows AA is not anti-psych.

You see, I can show anecdotally too that AA is pro-psych and pro-meds simply by usung the same level standards that you do. Anecdotes are evidence, but they are very very weak.

It's your claim mate, the onus of proof is on you.
 
Oh I don't know. Perhaps something that proves that AA (not some members) are anti-psychiatry. :rolleyes:
Maybe:
- letters from central office.
- official correspondence.
- even big book references (in context) might even nudge it.
- grapevine articles might do it.
- website statements.
- offical policy documents - maybe you should ask Tinyal to get them from the secret archives (lol).
- surely it's in the suggested steps and traditions?

I hate to suggest you are lying, again, but the facts speak for themselves. You didn't accept any of that evidence in the past so it is highly unlikely you will accept it now.

You're a regular little AA fanatic. :rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
Impossible. AA isn't organized, so there is no central office.

:rolleyes:

Actually there is a central service office. They distribute literature, organise delegate meetings etc etc; they service the membership.

Here's some onfo that might be useful.

http://www.aa.org.au/members/structure.php

Alcoholics Anonymous is not organized in the formal or political sense. There are no governing officers, no rules or regulations, no fees or dues. The need for certain services to alcoholics has, however, been apparent from the beginning of the Fellowship. Inquiries have to be answered. Literature has to be written, printed, and distributed. Requests for help are followed up. We need to cooperate with health workers. We need a central body to provide guidance on the AA Traditions.
 
Look, it's the fourth time I've asked for sometime to tell me what additional evidence there would be or you would need if my claim is true.

I've already answered.

I said this was "concern trollery" because you obviously have no legitimate grievance with me, you just didn't like how I told Alfie what he could do with his request for that evidence, when it's already proven beyond a shadow of a doubt.

As I've already indicated, I don't give weight to anecdotal evidence from Alfie, and I won't from you, either. Either show that it's an official AA policy, or retract your statement.
 
As I've already indicated, I don't give weight to anecdotal evidence from Alfie, and I won't from you, either. Either show that it's an official AA policy, or retract your statement.

For the record, I don't give my stories with a view to them being accepted as compelling evidence per se, I am usually just telling stories of my experiences.

Cheers.
 
As I've already indicated, I don't give weight to anecdotal evidence from Alfie, and I won't from you, either. Either show that it's an official AA policy, or retract your statement.
Show me where I said it's official AA policy. I've said that the fact it's a faith healing cult leads to this belief, and that it's rampant because it gets spread memeticly through the sponsor system. This is a straw man against me. Ask any veteran of AA this has been a serious problem that no one has the power to prevent or fix, because of the sponsor system. Anyone who says that to a sponsee should not allowed to be a sponser. But who has the authority to do that in this bizarre cult?

I recently talked with yet another ex-member old-timer, who has been in and out of A.A. for 30 years, who quit in anger, and hates A.A., because other old-timer sponsors kept telling mental cases to quit taking their medications, and then those sad cases committed suicide. His parting words to those A.A. members, after another funeral, were:
"Well, before you guys got ahold of him, at least he could say his own name.
But when you were done with him, he couldn't even do that." source

It's not my job to figure stuff out for people, that's impossible.
 
Last edited:
Oh I don't know. Perhaps something that proves that AA (not some members) are anti-psychiatry. :rolleyes:
Maybe:
- letters from central office.
- official correspondence.
- even big book references (in context) might even nudge it.
- grapevine articles might do it.
- website statements.
- offical policy documents - maybe you should ask Tinyal to get them from the secret archives (lol).
- surely it's in the suggested steps and traditions? What's that? It isn't!? Well I'll be ....!

As I say, anything that shows AA is not anti-psych.

You see, I can show anecdotally too that AA is pro-psych and pro-meds simply by usung the same level standards that you do. Anecdotes are evidence, but they are very very weak.

It's your claim mate, the onus of proof is on you.
No. This is your straw man against me, that it has to be official policy before it exists. I show it exists, that no one does anything about it, that it's allowed to happen in many places. It's a battle, sometimes the anti-psychiatry factions win and people quit, like that worthless anecdote I just shared.

People quit in anger and hate AA over this after 30 years of service, that it happens so badly a lot of deaths are blamed on it. I can pull up stories like that all day long. I know that AA probaly made official pro-psychiatry statements, but that doesn't change what actually happens in the program.

It's a faith healing religious cult, all of those have problems with anti-psychiatry, that's the problem. This is why people deserve a secular alternative. This problem is deathly serious, and still your best is "It's not on their website". No, everyone knows about it, you even deprogram people from that belief as part of your job, it happens because of AA, now what is there to honestly dispute about this...

You just don't want AA to look bad, while I want people to look at the facts of what happens in the rooms to people. Do you support making a rule that anyone with an anti-psychiatry belief should not be allowed to be a sponser?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom