Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually there is a central service office. They distribute literature, organise delegate meetings etc etc; they service the membership.

Here's some onfo that might be useful.

http://www.aa.org.au/members/structure.php

Alcoholics Anonymous is not organized in the formal or political sense. There are no governing officers, no rules or regulations, no fees or dues. The need for certain services to alcoholics has, however, been apparent from the beginning of the Fellowship. Inquiries have to be answered. Literature has to be written, printed, and distributed. Requests for help are followed up. We need to cooperate with health workers. We need a central body to provide guidance on the AA Traditions.

Oh really.

As Gary Persip points out in Recovery From Addiction Without God?:

The very A.A. Traditions that curtail members from presenting information or sharing with one another from a "professional" standpoint during meetings effectively act to keep A.A. groups ignorant of current findings in addiction studies; they are assumed to have no place in the program of recovery. This cry of "professionalism" was originally designed to ensure the equality of all participants in the program of recovery, A.A. traditionally being based upon one drunk sharing his or her experience, strength, and hope with another. The current fellowship of A.A., however, has diverged in so many regards from the original program that any information that sounds as if it were based upon professional opinion comes to be regarded as suspect and is, therefore, discouraged. Anything above the level of a drunkalog is met with a stern admonition to "keep it simple." Neither is any current information on addiction research presented in the Grapevine, the official publication of the organization. Dissident cries from members, when permitted to be published, are mild and fully supportive of maintaining the traditional focus.

Like I said, the cult is protecting it's own blueprint before rationally trying to help people.
 
I'd judge this thread to be over, really.

We've shown enough evidence, only partially anecdotal, that AA is a group with clear, undeniable aspects of religiosity.

The topic has long since derailed into topics of harm and efficacy, and should be split.
 
I'd judge this thread to be over, really.

We've shown enough evidence, only partially anecdotal, that AA is a group with clear, undeniable aspects of religiosity.

The topic has long since derailed into topics of harm and efficacy, and should be split.

Shoot, that's not even the original point of the thread, if you look at the title. The original question was,

Why (given that it is religious) do people insist AA is not religious?

Of course the part in parentheses is my addition but it was implied in the question.

That the thread drifted away from its origins is not unusual. Just my opinion, but I'm not sure the JREF really needs multiple AA threads. This has kind of served as a catch-all thread for everything AA related, in a good way I think.
 
Shoot, that's not even the original point of the thread, if you look at the title.

Sorry, Hud, if I didn't phrase it in the best way, but I think my point stands. No offense intended. :)


That the thread drifted away from its origins is not unusual. Just my opinion, but I'm not sure the JREF really needs multiple AA threads. This has kind of served as a catch-all thread for everything AA related, in a good way I think.

I don't think the drift was a bad thing, per se, but when thread drift becomes this obvious, it's often split off into a thread of its own. Several threads, addressing the various topics, might be better. Just IMO.
 
Sorry, Hud, if I didn't phrase it in the best way, but I think my point stands. No offense intended. :)




I don't think the drift was a bad thing, per se, but when thread drift becomes this obvious, it's often split off into a thread of its own. Several threads, addressing the various topics, might be better. Just IMO.

No offense taken, hope I didn't sound like I was offended.

To your point, a few pages back I mentioned that a separate thread should be started dealing with only the question of "does it work." I'd like to see links to all relevant studies collected in one thread, instead of what is going on in this thread where posters keep saying something like "but I already proved that X pages ago."

I didn't think anyone else liked the idea. There are too many folks on both sides of this who like the argument and the personalities, and are enjoying themselves I think. :p
 
Pretty much my experience here too. The "pills are for dills" lobby is very much in the minority.
So what? How long have you been in AA? What do you suggest to completely eradicate this phenomenon?

The ignore function is looking good. Some people are completey off tap at the moment; I think they should listen to their doctors and take their meds. :)
Disgusting insult. Ignore me like you ignored the Cochrane review, it's not nice to AA either.

Are you aware that people also die from not listening to their sponsor?
Evidence of this? I'm aware that sponsers hold an unhealthy power over their sponsees (What? You joined a coed soccer team? :rolleyes:) because of the threat of this. Very disgusting. People die from not following proper medical advice, which sponsers are not qualified to give.

But that's my point too. That the anti-psych is not "the program" either. AA does not advocate this despite the hollow and fact free claims of others.
Straw man, I never said AA advocated for this, I said it's a common problem that no one has the ability to solve, and it happens because of it's faith healing belief structure. It thrives there. I know the 30 yr old timer that quit because of the meds fights, that story I just told, it's worthless. There are more for you all to find in google, but they are worthless. :rolleyes:

It's denialism. Nothing but straw mans against me this entire time.
 
No offense taken, hope I didn't sound like I was offended.

No, no! Not at all. You've just been taking some undeserved flak, and I didn't want to appear as if i were somehow piling on. :)

To your point, a few pages back I mentioned that a separate thread should be started dealing with only the question of "does it work." I'd like to see links to all relevant studies collected in one thread, instead of what is going on in this thread where posters keep saying something like "but I already proved that X pages ago."

I didn't think anyone else liked the idea. There are too many folks on both sides of this who like the argument and the personalities, and are enjoying themselves I think. :p

I not only liked it, I agree with it and think it's overdue.
 
Actually there is a central service office. They distribute literature, organise delegate meetings etc etc; they service the membership.


So when was the huge membership meeting that withdrew official support from the AA World Organization for those two secular AA groups in Canada? I don't remember hearing about it. Did you vote? I'm presuming you would have voted to keep those groups as officially recognized groups, right? I mean, maybe I'm misunderstanding what a bottom-up organization means.



Well, then. I believed you at first, provisionally, while I was awaiting _some_ sort of evidence. I'll retract that belief, now.


You know what? What if it was written down in the Big Book that AA is officially anti-psychiatric? What would it matter because all the AA-apologists would point to a few sentences and/or words sprinkled here and there which says something slightly contradictory and call it good.

Bill W. had a personal revelation; many others of the original founding group had revelations. Alcoholics Anonymous was founded based on a the highly religious Oxford Group. AA's fundamental premise is that alcoholism is a spiritual problem which requires a spiritual solution. Time and again, his story and story upon story upon story illustrates that they "tried everything else" and it failed. The only solution is to accept God and turn your life and will over to Him. The advice given in the literature and by sponsors and others in the group is to STOP THINKING and do what you're told.

What's the advice given to newcomers? "Get a sponsor." "Read the Big Book (often followed by someone handing out a free copy)." "Go do 30 in 30 (thirty meetings within thirty days)." Heck, I knew lots of zealots who would do 60 in 60 or 90 in 90 even. "Keep comin' back -- it works!" "Work the steps."

There are webpages devoted to these sayings and quips, which I've even quoted from in posting in this thread months ago.

Anyway, I personally wouldn't go so far to say that AA is anti-psychiatry, but I certainly think that since AA views alcoholism as a spiritual problem which requires a spiritual solution, then the actual science on addiction isn't really their focus. And this is borne out by -- at minimum -- the fact that no changes have been made incorporating any new advances and discoveries in addictions treatment.
 
Last edited:
Whether or not AA is "officially" anti-psychiatry, whether the literature supports it (it supports faith healing which in turn is why this belief thrives there) has absolutely nothing to do with my claims. It happens there, a lot, and nothing is done. It's a side effect of being a faith-healing cult, all I need to do is show how often it happens. Some meetings are different, that doesn't change the fact that they are only different now after many years of battles!

I recently talked with yet another ex-member old-timer, who has been in and out of A.A. for 30 years, who quit in anger, and hates A.A., because other old-timer sponsors kept telling mental cases to quit taking their medications, and then those sad cases committed suicide. His parting words to those A.A. members, after another funeral, were:
"Well, before you guys got ahold of him, at least he could say his own name.
But when you were done with him, he couldn't even do that." source

But this is just an anecdotal report. How many similar stories do you need me to post in this thread before you admit there is a problem in AA that could be solved by axing it and making it a professionally run organization with accountability and responsibility mechanisms? It's just such an easy thing to see. I'm baffled by all of these red herrings being tossed my way.

Like I said, this battle really peaked about a decade ago and has been getting better. From 1998...

Thus Spicer was a progressive, putting Hazelden at odds with more conservative, fundamentalist, 12-Step facilities like the Betty Ford clinic. And it put Spicer at odds with some of his own staff — half a dozen counselors quit in protest when Spicer approved of the anti-depressants. For them, allowing both coffee and anti-depressants seems to have been just too much of a departure from a purely spiritual treatment program.
Good riddance!

The fact that some meetings and groups have changed isn't impressive. It only happened naturally, how could it happen any other way? There's no directive from AA that says "sponsers who give medical advice are not allowed to be sponsers" which would be the first rule I would make in such an organization. It's not being dealt with proactively, it's still happening, but it's tolerated the same way other religious are. Unbelievable.
 
Last edited:
What if it was written down in the Big Book that AA is officially anti-psychiatric?

That would be the most convincing piece of evidence I can imagine to prove Joey's claim.

What would it matter because all the AA-apologists would point to a few sentences and/or words sprinkled here and there which says something slightly contradictory and call it good.

I don't care about AA apologists. I asked Joey the question, not Alfie.
 
That would be the most convincing piece of evidence I can imagine to prove Joey's claim.

Belz, does it make some kind of significant difference to the people involved if it isn't "official policy," but it's still happening?
 
That would be the most convincing piece of evidence I can imagine to prove Joey's claim.
That's unnecessary to prove my claim. The big book is faith healing, the program is a faith healing cult. To some people it's not those things, but it is to others. And I can show how the faith healing is connected to the preponderance of old timers quitting in anger over anti-psychiatry.

And, sponsers are allowed to continue to influence vulnerable victims of mental illness and addiction with their ill-gotten authority without any accountability or responsibility. This is just a bloody outrage.

Alas, some of the old-timer faithful in his twelve-step recovery group, including his sponsor, are telling him to stop taking the pills that the doctor gives him, and just trust the Twelve Steps to heal him. That borders on criminal irresponsibility.

It is also practicing medicine without a license, because they are countermanding the orders of a real doctor.

It is also practicing medicine without any training — those fools have never gone to medical school. Attending A.A. meetings for a few years does not make someone a competent doctor or psychiatrist.

Fortunately, my friend is following his doctor's orders. (Although he worries me — those nuts are getting to him — he is saying things like, "Still, I wonder if I can make it without medications..." He never did before. He freaked out and relapsed every time.) source

This goes on every single day all over the world, it should be illegal.
 
Last edited:

The first 6 pages - I stopped before it got to the member "stories" - seems like what I remember. Doesn't seem too controversial to me.

The "No AA Member Plays Doctor" part definitely rings true. On the other hand, I was never given a copy of this, either. As I said before I didn't know there was anything written on the subject.
 
Belz, does it make some kind of significant difference to the people involved if it isn't "official policy," but it's still happening?

Of course not, but that's not the issue here.

If the question "is AA a religious organisation" does not depend on individual anecdotes, then why would the question "is AA anti-psychiatry" be ?
 
.
2. Remember that the best safeguard against drug-related relapse is an active participation in the AA program of recovery.
Poor advice! Citation? They don't offer one for some reason.

I have never denied and have even suggested that AA has made pro-psychiatry statements in the past. This pamphlet is from 1984 and all of the examples I have given are from the last decade or so. Whatever this pamphlet was supposed to achieve, it failed.

People have a right to go to a recovery group without being pressured to go off their meds. If AA was worth it's salt it would put a permanent end to this by disciplining anyone who gives this advice and an accountable reporting system. This would be easy, but it would go against the cult blueprint, so it still hasn't happened, and the abuse continues, and will continue, until someone takes responsibility for what goes on in the group.
 
Last edited:
The first 6 pages - I stopped before it got to the member "stories" - seems like what I remember. Doesn't seem too controversial to me.

The "No AA Member Plays Doctor" part definitely rings true. On the other hand, I was never given a copy of this, either. As I said before I didn't know there was anything written on the subject.

I respectfully suggest you didn't read far enough. The stories provide evidence that some members do indeed wrongly suggest that members not take medications.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom