Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The buck stops and starts with the individual. What a concept; self-responsibility. ;)

Alfie, If the buck stops with the individual, then can I expect you to denounce these foundational AA principles: powerlessness over inert substances; self-will run riot; progressive, terminal disease of the mind,body, and spirit; turning over one's will and life to the will of a higher power; asking a higher power to remove your defects of character for you; let go and let god?
 
Alfie, If the buck stops with the individual, then can I expect you to denounce these foundational AA principles: powerlessness over inert substances; self-will run riot; progressive, terminal disease of the mind,body, and spirit; turning over one's will and life to the will of a higher power; asking a higher power to remove your defects of character for you; let go and let god?

I'm just curious, but you don't think these two have meaning?

powerlessness over inert substances; self-will run riot

I mean the wording is convoluted and awkward but they were (IMO) a decent description of what my personal problems were when I was drinking.
 
If you're powerless, and must turn your life over to a higher power, how do you end up with personal responsibility? After all, your personal responsibility is flawed, and enabled you to drink destructively, to the point where your lives had become unmanageable.

I'M the one that's been blowing the self-control, personal responsibility horn.

But hey, if you're powerless, we can't expect you to manage your own lives.

And I'm sure you won't see how those concepts simply can't mesh.
Sounds like one's higher power is sitting on its hands to me.
 
If you're powerless, and must turn your life over to a higher power, how do you end up with personal responsibility? After all, your personal responsibility is flawed, and enabled you to drink destructively, to the point where your lives had become unmanageable.

I'M the one that's been blowing the self-control, personal responsibility horn.

But hey, if you're powerless, we can't expect you to manage your own lives.

And I'm sure you won't see how those concepts simply can't mesh.
Sounds like one's higher power is sitting on its hands to me.

Ok, I'll take one more crack at this.

Admitting I was powerless over alcohol was a way for me to admit I had a problem and needed help.

Full stop, that's all, no God involved for me at all. The only higher power I used was a group of people with the same problem to talk to.

Is it really that hard for people to understand that even a flawed program may have useful parts in it?
 
I'm just curious, but you don't think these two have meaning?

Hud, I can't figure out what you're asking, but maybe this will answer your question: If AA is a program that courts both vulnerable and addicted people (while aggressively promoting itself to the courts, which funnels domestic abusers and sexual predators into the rooms) and teaches that you cannot trust your own best instincts for yourself, there should be a system of checks and balances, accountability, and standards in place to prevent abuse. Abuse is rampant.

If AA's actual policy is "buyer beware" then should say so up front. If they did, however, they'd never be able to convince people to become "teachable."

I mean the wording is convoluted and awkward but they were (IMO) a decent description of what my personal problems were when I was drinking.[/QUOTE]

I'd never argue with your experience. I'm not as concerned with AA's belief system as I am with how it (does not) accept responsibility for the consequences of this belief system.
 
Is it really that hard for people to understand that even a flawed program may have useful parts in it?

All the "useful parts" of AA have nothing to do with AA, and can be found outside of AA, without all the elements that make AA counterproductive for most people. All the elements that are fundamental to AA (12 Steps) have nothing to do with recovery, and everything to do with spiritual awakening.
 
Another side note of history, that swine Bill Wilson...
What a man.

This is the first I have ever heard of this. Do you have some proof of it; perhaps some confirmation from Lois denying she ever wrote it. I had a browse through your link, it looks like opnions only (again)

Still waiting on the proof that "AA is anti-psych" btw.

Ok, I'll take one more crack at this.

Admitting I was powerless over alcohol was a way for me to admit I had a problem and needed help.

Full stop, that's all, no God involved for me at all. The only higher power I used was a group of people with the same problem to talk to.

Is it really that hard for people to understand that even a flawed program may have useful parts in it?[/


Take what you need and leave the rest.

It's also interesting that the "powerlessness" pertains only to alcohol, and is quite specific in this regard; it is not everything, as some seem to be insisting. It is also in the past tense "we were powerless..." and that our lives had become ..."

That "turning our life and will over" does not mean we are not responsible for our actions. For me it means more that I am no more in control of my ultimate destiny than the next person, and that trying to control every outcome - while I do my best to manage them - is not in my control, etc etc.
 
Last edited:
All the "useful parts" of AA have nothing to do with AA, and can be found outside of AA, without all the elements that make AA counterproductive for most people. All the elements that are fundamental to AA (12 Steps) have nothing to do with recovery, and everything to do with spiritual awakening.

Could be. I don't have a wide range of experience with programs outside of AA.

I guess I'm simply one of the lucky ones who used AA to get better and ignored, sidestepped, or was blissfully unaware of the drawbacks. And I say that with no snark at all. I could have just been lucky.

I don't consider myself a member anymore, don't go to meetings, don't drink either, and I'm reasonably happy.

I would like to know what other program you are referencing that has the good parts of AA without the drawbacks, so that I could pass that info along to others.

Thanks.
 
This is the first I have ever heard of this. Do you have some proof of it; perhaps some confirmation from Lois denying she ever wrote it. I had a browse through your link, it looks like opnions only (again)
You know, I'm glad you tried to pull this with me (again) because it just exposes you for either intellectual dishonesty or wilfull ignorance. You should have used the find function of your browser to go right to the quote and you would have seen the reference. Yeah, Lois' memoir is my opinion?

In fact, Lois had hoped Bill would ask her to write not only "To Wives," but also the following chapter, "The Family Afterward." But when "she shyly suggested this, he said no; he thought the book, except for the stories, should all be written in the same style" (LR, 114).9

LR = Lois Remembers: Memoirs of the Co-Founder of Al-Anon and Wife of the Co-Founder of Alcoholics Anonymous, Lois Wilson. Al-Anon Family Group Headquarters, Inc. 1979.


Still waiting on the proof that "AA is anti-psych" btw.
You're acting like an agitator. This is a straw man. I have shown repeatedly that it is a rampant belief no one deals with that is caused by it's memetic faith healing structure. Instead of try and work up against that, you invent a strawman that it's not official policy. The internet is not fooled. Make a real argument, such as the gajillions of testimonies of people quitting aa over anti-psychiatry are made up, that's pretty much your only recourse, other than this now ridiculous straw man
 
Last edited:
All the "useful parts" of AA have nothing to do with AA, and can be found outside of AA, without all the elements that make AA counterproductive for most people. All the elements that are fundamental to AA (12 Steps) have nothing to do with recovery, and everything to do with spiritual awakening.

Maybe, but even Joey Ds references refer to alcoholism being a spiritual problem. If the experts agree on this then wouldn't the spiritual aspect need to be addressed.
btw, I mean spiriual, not religious.
 
Could be. I don't have a wide range of experience with programs outside of AA.

I guess I'm simply one of the lucky ones who used AA to get better and ignored, sidestepped, or was blissfully unaware of the drawbacks. And I say that with no snark at all. I could have just been lucky.

I don't consider myself a member anymore, don't go to meetings, don't drink either, and I'm reasonably happy.

I would like to know what other program you are referencing that has the good parts of AA without the drawbacks, so that I could pass that info along to others.

Thanks.

HUD, one group program I'd recommend without hesitation is SMART Recovery, which is based on cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). It's completely secular, doesn't require people to get into invasive, hierarchical relationships with each other (no sponsors, no giving everyone your phone number, no tough love, etc), allows for "graduation" (meaning that you aren't required to go to meetings for the rest of your life, you can move on). People who lead smart meetings are trained and must meet certain requirements. Google it :)
 
Maybe, but even Joey Ds references refer to alcoholism being a spiritual problem. If the experts agree on this then wouldn't the spiritual aspect need to be addressed.
btw, I mean spiriual, not religious.

If alcoholism is a spiritual problem, does that mean that atheists -- or anyone who doesn't believe it is or address it as such -- can never truly recover from it?
 
What's a spirit, and where can I find it on a chart of the human body or brain?
Can it be triggered during scans, imaging, or other medical examination, the way memory and emotions can be triggered, scanned, and seen?

I've never understood the distinction: "I'm not religious, I'm spiritual."

Oh! Oh, dear...this website claims to understand "spirituality," and claims it's scientific! Look, it's right there, in their name!

Spiritual Science Research Foundation.

Oooh, they do research!

http://www.spiritualresearchfoundat...tualscience/spirituallevel_saints/index.php#1

1. About spiritual level

The Spiritual Science Research Foundation (SSRF) uses the term ‘spiritual level’ to describe a person’s spiritual maturity or spiritual capacity. It acts as a scale to define spiritual growth and gives perspective on where we are in our spiritual journey. The higher one’s spiritual level the greater is the amount of God principle manifest in that individual.

Aw, crap! God? But, I thought spirituality wasn't religious? Is it theistic, do you suppose? I guess you could have a god-concept, without a religious concept, huh?

But surely, it's not woo or anything, right? This Foundation says it does science, after all.

2. The scale of spiritual level

The SSRF uses a scale between 1 and 100% to describe spiritual level. 1% would refer to the spiritual level of an inanimate object, while 100% would refer to the pinnacle of spiritual growth for a person, which is Self-Realisation or being one with God.

Uh..."being one with god?" Being one what? One person? One spirit? But...what does spirit even mean?

http://www.spiritualresearchfoundat...ce/spirituallevel_saints/images/Evolution.gif

THE SOUL?

My friends, we have just passed firmly into woo-woo territory, since as skeptics, most of us know well there is no evidence whatsoever for the existence of the soul.



Do we need to keep discussing this "spiritual" nonsense as if that word or that concept is actually meaningful?

Because it's not.
 
Last edited:
If alcoholism is a spiritual problem, does that mean that atheists -- or anyone who doesn't believe it is or address it as such -- can never truly recover from it?

Spirituality does not have to include a religious or supernatural bent. Spirituality and religion are completely separate. One can have spirituality without religion, but one cannot be religious without spirituality.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirituality

Secular spirituality emphasizes humanistic qualities such as love, compassion, patience, tolerance, forgiveness, contentment, responsibility, harmony, and a concern for others[8]:22, aspects of life and human experience which go beyond a purely materialist view of the world, without necessarily accepting belief in a supernatural reality or divine being.

And

If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being. This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings. If one has such a belief and feels that relationship to such beings is the foundation of happiness then spiritual practice will be pursued on that basis: if one has no such belief spiritual practice is still essential for the management and understanding of thoughts and emotions which otherwise prevent happiness.


So when the OP asks why do people insist that AA isn't religious, the answer is simple: It can be, but religion is not a prerequisite. In fact many simply say that it is a spiritual program (as in the above definitions), not religious.

Thread ends here; question answered. :)
 
Last edited:
So when the OP asks why do people insist that AA isn't religious, the answer is simple: It can be, but religion is not a prerequisite.
No, this the apologist version. Reality is that it started with The Oxford Group cult, became it's own weirdo religious cult, spread all over the world, then struggled deeply to make itself accessible to secularists. It mostly fails at that until this day as evidenced by it's low retention rate and general rejection by most skeptical people.

In fact many simply say that it is a spiritual program (as in the above definitions), not religious.
It's a disorder of the reward system which is in your brain. Just because doing and thinking nice things gives you a reward that helps you rewire to some kind of natural state, doesn't mean it's "a spiritual problem" a useless euphemism and platitude that excuses all of the bonkers stuff that is spiritual in the faith-healing dimension of it.

Thread ends here
:rolleyes:
 
:)

Another post that is high on emotion, high on opinion, contains much arm waving and lacks real evidence.

Fail and snore.
Fail and handwaving is you dismissing a Cochrane review by saying it had a small sample. Fail is you accusing me of making stuff up when you just can't find the reference on the page I gave you. You're projecting your fail onto me, obviously.

It's all been documented on "The Orange Papers" which despite your inability to find references on it, is near flawlessly referenced. If anyone just spends an hour of their time on it, that will all be clear to them. Unlike you, people who are interested in facts will probably click on my links, and see that I'm not exaggerating at all, and see your classic appeals to emotion and straw men for what they are.

I imagine you've never read that site, so you get to accuse me of opinions and handwaving, when anyone who knows anything about AA knows it's merely an accuarate description of the facts (that have been posted throughout this thread multiple times) I call AA a cult, you don't like this, and try to attack me for it. but this is my evidence, and you don't try and dispute it. :rolleyes: I know, it's behind a link, makes it somehow appropriate to say I make stuff up.

Pretty much every time I show some evidence, you whine about how it's not perfect enough, and then when I call you on it, you never acknowledge you were wrong and have no more arguments. You've resorted to more appeals to emotion.

ETA: Like when you said that the reason I'm saying the things I'm saying in this thread is because I'm mentally ill. Not funny. Disgusting. That's how you debate, it's my ego, it's my resentments, blah blah blah, now I'm mentally ill, good for you Alfie, you're really contributing here, great stuff.
 
Last edited:
Spirituality does not have to include a religious or supernatural bent. Spirituality and religion are completely separate. One can have spirituality without religion, but one cannot be religious without spirituality.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirituality

Secular spirituality emphasizes humanistic qualities such as love, compassion, patience, tolerance, forgiveness, contentment, responsibility, harmony, and a concern for others[8]:22, aspects of life and human experience which go beyond a purely materialist view of the world, without necessarily accepting belief in a supernatural reality or divine being.

In essence: being nice helps me feel good. I don't see why the obvious needs a special term that utilizes a synonym for soul.


If spirituality is understood as the search for or the development of inner peace or the foundations of happiness, then spiritual practice of some kind is essential for personal well being. This activity may or may not include belief in supernatural beings. If one has such a belief and feels that relationship to such beings is the foundation of happiness then spiritual practice will be pursued on that basis: if one has no such belief spiritual practice is still essential for the management and understanding of thoughts and emotions which otherwise prevent happiness.

"If feeling good is good for you, then it's good to work on feeling good."


So when the OP asks why do people insist that AA isn't religious, the answer is simple: It can be, but religion is not a prerequisite. In fact many simply say that it is a spiritual program (as in the above definitions), not religious.

Then the "god" references in AA need to be removed. They simply aren't needed to make AA work. As long as a god concept is included in AA, and it is, because the word's all over the place, in all the literature, in the headquarters, pinned up to a wall in GREAT BIG GOTHIC FONTS...the AA Program of Recovery is simply lousy with god...then the AA Program of Recovery does have a religious bent, influence, or overtone.

I get that you take what you need, but if spirituality is about nurturing and developing the positive human emotions and qualities, and AA is spiritual, then why promote a god concept at all?

Your definitions for spirituality say a god's not necessary to it. Can't alcoholics get their god-fix, if they need it, without AA even mentioning it?
Why not promote those things that are necessary, and accomplished by humans tending to their emotional well-being, and leave the totally optional woo out of it?

Thread ends here; question answered. :)

Oh, yes, it has been answered, but the answer isn't the one you insist it is.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom