Just a personal story, has no significance to this, really, but I remember the time my ex got himself a new sponsor. And she was gorgeous. I think their affair lasted 3 months or so.
Slingblade, I've got your back in this thread for the most part, but I have to say that any program that relies on people making intense emotional connections is going to lead to a certain amount of infidelity. That doesn't excuse anyone who cheats; I just mean it's separate from the (alleged) religious aspects of AA.
Alfie, If the buck stops with the individual, then can I expect you to denounce these foundational AA principles: powerlessness over inert substances; self-will run riot; progressive, terminal disease of the mind,body, and spirit; turning over one's will and life to the will of a higher power; asking a higher power to remove your defects of character for you; let go and let god?
By the way, I love you.
But basically, I would ask Alfie to ponder and respond to the following questions:
1) What would you accept as evidence of "what AA does/believes/advocates"?
2) Under that definition, what do you think you can claim AA does/believer/advocates?
My gripe is that you want to claim that AA saves lives, kept person X sober, etc., but in response to critics you insist that anecdotes don't count, nothing short of official statements from an entity that apparently doesn't issue statements counts, etc.
Alfie, you need to come up with a consistent definition for when you credit AA with "success" and when you're willing to say "yeah, that's AA, but..."
Ok, I'll take one more crack at this.
Admitting I was powerless over alcohol was a way for me to admit I had a problem and needed help.
Full stop, that's all, no God involved for me at all. The only higher power I used was a group of people with the same problem to talk to.
Is it really that hard for people to understand that even a flawed program may have useful parts in it?
Not at all. I hang out here even though I don't agree with everything that's said. I think the JREF does good work even if I don't agree with every position that it takes. And I've said all along that AA may well do some good even if it is religious, given that a majority of the population in many of the areas in which it operates are religious (and many of the non-religious people can find a way to deal with it).
In other words, I'm waiting for someone to say, "yeah, AA is religious, but so what? We help a lot of religious people, some non-religious people, and the other non-religious people are free to seek out other sources of help." I might still have some criticisms, wondering if the religious aspects were really that important, but I'd accept it as an honest answer.