Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just a personal story, has no significance to this, really, but I remember the time my ex got himself a new sponsor. And she was gorgeous. I think their affair lasted 3 months or so.

Slingblade, I've got your back in this thread for the most part, but I have to say that any program that relies on people making intense emotional connections is going to lead to a certain amount of infidelity. That doesn't excuse anyone who cheats; I just mean it's separate from the (alleged) religious aspects of AA.


Alfie, If the buck stops with the individual, then can I expect you to denounce these foundational AA principles: powerlessness over inert substances; self-will run riot; progressive, terminal disease of the mind,body, and spirit; turning over one's will and life to the will of a higher power; asking a higher power to remove your defects of character for you; let go and let god?

By the way, I love you.

But basically, I would ask Alfie to ponder and respond to the following questions:

1) What would you accept as evidence of "what AA does/believes/advocates"?
2) Under that definition, what do you think you can claim AA does/believer/advocates?

My gripe is that you want to claim that AA saves lives, kept person X sober, etc., but in response to critics you insist that anecdotes don't count, nothing short of official statements from an entity that apparently doesn't issue statements counts, etc.

Alfie, you need to come up with a consistent definition for when you credit AA with "success" and when you're willing to say "yeah, that's AA, but..."



Ok, I'll take one more crack at this.

Admitting I was powerless over alcohol was a way for me to admit I had a problem and needed help.

Full stop, that's all, no God involved for me at all. The only higher power I used was a group of people with the same problem to talk to.

Is it really that hard for people to understand that even a flawed program may have useful parts in it?

Not at all. I hang out here even though I don't agree with everything that's said. I think the JREF does good work even if I don't agree with every position that it takes. And I've said all along that AA may well do some good even if it is religious, given that a majority of the population in many of the areas in which it operates are religious (and many of the non-religious people can find a way to deal with it).

In other words, I'm waiting for someone to say, "yeah, AA is religious, but so what? We help a lot of religious people, some non-religious people, and the other non-religious people are free to seek out other sources of help." I might still have some criticisms, wondering if the religious aspects were really that important, but I'd accept it as an honest answer.
 
Slingblade, I've got your back in this thread for the most part, but I have to say that any program that relies on people making intense emotional connections is going to lead to a certain amount of infidelity. That doesn't excuse anyone who cheats; I just mean it's separate from the (alleged) religious aspects of AA.

That's true, Dunstan, and I said it wasn't part of this matter, not really. But Joey's post made it pop into my head. Quite honestly, there was harm in every aspect of my first worst marriage, but I was young enough and christian enough and naive enough to be disappointed he found yet more avenues for harm through AA. Mostly my fault, for poor perceptions.

I do remember his original sponsor coming to our home, with him, to "counsel" me; basically denial from them both that it was bad to have an oppsite-sex sponsor, and noooo, no affair was going on. I only learned the truth some 6 or 7 years later when he "Ninth Stepped" me, and admitted it.

C'est la vie.

(but...maybe if they hadn't handed him that "powerless over alcohol," and "only a higher power could restore me," and "god as I understand him" stuff...maybe...)


In other words, I'm waiting for someone to say, "yeah, AA is religious, but so what? We help a lot of religious people, some non-religious people, and the other non-religious people are free to seek out other sources of help." I might still have some criticisms, wondering if the religious aspects were really that important, but I'd accept it as an honest answer.

I'm really hoping we won't have to wait much longer. It shouldn't be all that difficult to admit the patently obvious.
 
Last edited:
(but...maybe if they hadn't handed him that "powerless over alcohol," and "only a higher power could restore me," and "god as I understand him" stuff...maybe...)

Maybe. But it seems pretty clear to me from what you've said that this husband was a jerk and would have seized on any rationale, religious, sobriety-based, or otherwise, to do whatever suited his needs.

Sorry.
 
"If feeling good is good for you, then it's good to work on feeling good."

That's my take. But when drinking we work on feeling bad.

Then the "god" references in AA need to be removed. They simply aren't needed to make AA work. As long as a god concept is included in AA, and it is, because the word's all over the place, in all the literature, in the headquarters, pinned up to a wall in GREAT BIG GOTHIC FONTS...the AA Program of Recovery is simply lousy with god...then the AA Program of Recovery does have a religious bent, influence, or overtone.

I used to have a problem with that too. But I accept it now as the language of the day, Bill's language etc. The religious bent is certainly there and I have never claimed otherwise. It does get in people's way, but for others it gives freedom.

I get that you take what you need, but if spirituality is about nurturing and developing the positive human emotions and qualities, and AA is spiritual, then why promote a god concept at all?

Because we need to find out what our spirituality is about. Unless we know or start to explore it, how will we find out?

But basically, I would ask Alfie to ponder and respond to the following questions:

1) What would you accept as evidence of "what AA does/believes/advocates"?
2) Under that definition, what do you think you can claim AA does/believer/advocates?

Great questions. Just off the top...

I think for question one, the 12 traditions covers most of it. More can be found in the actions of the central office (as a representation of the membership) and general literature.

That said, I can concede that a lot of the 12 traditions are open to some personal interpretation.

For question 2 I think that tradition five covers it:

"Each group has but one primary purpose - to carry it's message to the alcoholic who still suffers."

The message being Hope.

My gripe is that you want to claim that AA saves lives, kept person X sober, etc., but in response to critics you insist that anecdotes don't count, nothing short of official statements from an entity that apparently doesn't issue statements counts, etc.

I'm not sure I have made too many direct claims here except perhaps to counter what is being said by my "opposition" by throwing in opposite claims.
But I agree and have conceded same before; it's just that I do that anecdote-for-anecdote and like to tell a few stories.

However, I do tend to rely on statistics of the world movement that is AA. How many groups and members are there across the globe?
Tinyal and I both believe AA had/has a lot to do with our respective sobrieties. I am 12 years clean and sober this year, he is 20 odd I think.

The tens of thousands of active groups and members are not just a figment of ones imagination. And the doors do not remain open due to some extensive conspiracy. The membership (filled with deists, agnostics and atheists) suggests something good is going on.

Alfie, you need to come up with a consistent definition for when you credit AA with "success" and when you're willing to say "yeah, that's AA, but..."

I think you will find any claims I make are made with a (or previously stated) disclaimer that I only have anecdotes. But I have seen and met thousands upon thousand of people all in AA/NA and elsewhere getting and staying sober through a spiritual program.

In other words, I'm waiting for someone to say, "yeah, AA is religious, but so what? We help a lot of religious people, some non-religious people, and the other non-religious people are free to seek out other sources of help." I might still have some criticisms, wondering if the religious aspects were really that important, but I'd accept it as an honest answer.

Haven't you heard me say - since the start of this thread that:

AA has many roots in religion, and can be religious if you want it to be, but in practice it doesn't have to be (or similar)

Were you paying attention when I said those things? Is this the honesty you were after?

I do not believe I have ever strayed from this position or stated otherwise.
 
Maybe. But it seems pretty clear to me from what you've said that this husband was a jerk and would have seized on any rationale, religious, sobriety-based, or otherwise, to do whatever suited his needs.

Sorry.

Another anecdote.

My ex wife still blames AA for our marriage breakdown. Frankly I find this to be a major copout on her behalf. While it is absolutely true that my drinking and drugging dramatically undermined the relationship, I sopent six or seven years trying to put things right.

Sadly, the marriage never came good despite my best efforts. I was clean and sober, I wasn't cheating, I had a good job (income wise - I hated the work in the end) and she didn't have to work, two kids, a beautiful house, investments, nice cars, nice things etc. In other words, all the trimmings of a normal middle class suburban life.

She blamed me and AA, however (and I'm not being sexist or demanding when I say this):
- she never cooked for me (remember she wasn't working and I was doing up to 12 hours per day).
- she did my washing, never my ironing.
- we rarely slept together (in a sexual sense)
- we had different bedrooms.
- she didn't enjoy my company.

It was a loveless marriage. I went to her and expressed my dismay that I felt our marriage was failing a number of times in the final three three years. I took her to marriage guidance counselling; she went once. I pleased - she denied the problem, I begged, she ignored me. And on and on.

I finally took a dramatic course of action and left and she said she didn't understand why?!? Incredible.

AA was not the reason for our marriage breaking down, it was my drinking that ruined it, and her lack of action in my recovery to try and jointly right the boat that sank it.

Is AA to blame?

Any way, I 13th stepped a girl in AA.

I'M KIDDING.

I did meet someone in AA after we split, we are married today, have four kids between us, two dogs, two snakes, a nice home, new jobs and careers.

My life is wonderful and I thank AA for an awful lot of it. My ex wife is still miserable and does nothing to try and find spiritual contentment (i.e. happiness).
 
Last edited:
I think for question one, the 12 traditions covers most of it. More can be found in the actions of the central office (as a representation of the membership) and general literature.

That said, I can concede that a lot of the 12 traditions are open to some personal interpretation.

Thanks for answering that.

For question 2 I think that tradition five covers it:

"Each group has but one primary purpose - to carry it's message to the alcoholic who still suffers."

The message being Hope.

Forgive me if I say that's a bit of a dodge. "Hope"? That's it? Not to sound like an American conservative politician, but "hope" is not a solution, program, policy, etc.

Saying "hope" or "things can get better" doesn't really get you anywhere. Unless alcoholics are really stupid, I would think the next question would be "how?" And if you're offering AA as the solution, I think it behooves you to explain how AA provides that hope.

Haven't you heard me say - since the start of this thread that:

AA has many roots in religion, and can be religious if you want it to be, but in practice it doesn't have to be (or similar)

Were you paying attention when I said those things? Is this the honesty you were after?

I do not believe I have ever strayed from this position or stated otherwise.

Alfie, the problem I have with those statements is that they're so contentless.

First, there's the issue that one can't say anything about AA without you insisting that it doesn't count unless it's in an official tradition, and when it's pointed out that Tradition Two mentions God, you brush it off.

Second, as I've pointed out to you earlier in this thread, by your definition of "religious," most church services aren't religious, either. They don't impose an entrance exam or require you to swear an oath. Atheists are allowed in to admire the architecture or music, or simply to keep their significant other happy. You can "take what you like" (the architecture, music, and sense of community) and "leave the rest" (the actual believing in God stuff).

You may very well have been "consistent" in the sense that you've never deviated from these positions. But that's easy to do when the positions don't mean anything.

And if the traditions of AA are so flexible as to be meaningless, how they can offer "hope" to anyone?
 
Another anecdote.

(Lots of stuff snipped)

Thanks for sharing that, and I mean that honestly.

I'm not sure that it tells us anything, though. Getting sober should change a person, and sometimes that is going to mean that a relationship stops working. Whether that's because AA destroyed the relationship (as you claim your ex claims) or because this was a copout (as you claim), or because you had a dysfunctional relationship to begin with that was bound to fail (which seems more likely to me as an admittedly ill-informed outsider).

She blamed me and AA, however (and I'm not being sexist or demanding when I say this):
- she never cooked for me (remember she wasn't working and I was doing up to 12 hours per day).
- she did my washing, never my ironing.
- we rarely slept together (in a sexual sense)
- we had different bedrooms.
- she didn't enjoy my company.

Other than the last item, it's really hard not to see that as a sexist complaint. Sorry, I'm trying not to be judgemental, but if you're going to share your history with people....

I did meet someone in AA after we split, we are married today, have four kids between us, two dogs, two snakes, a nice home, new jobs and careers.

My life is wonderful and I thank AA for an awful lot of it.

Well, as I said to slingblade, I think it's entirely reasonable for people to connect in AA or similar environments. I'm happy you're happy. But....

My ex wife is still miserable and does nothing to try and find spiritual contentment (i.e. happiness).

Without knowing your ex, and more about what you mean by this, this is very open to interpretation. Somehow I suspect that your ex is less religious than you, and that this is what you're referring to by "spiritual contentment" despite the disclaimer.

That said, I wouldn't be surprised if she's unhappy. I trust you'll forgive me for saying that anyone who marries and/or stays with an (unreformed) alcoholic probably has problems, too.

Of course, that begs the question of whether Al-alon is religious, which I hope won't require a 100-page thread....
 
Saying "hope" or "things can get better" doesn't really get you anywhere. Unless alcoholics are really stupid, I would think the next question would be "how?" And if you're offering AA as the solution, I think it behooves you to explain how AA provides that hope.

Practcing alcoholics aren't stupid; they are however insane.

You asked what AA advocates, I responded that step five covers it. Hope was the message. I will concede I could have been more complete in my response and could have said that the message was that abstinence will see your life improve. Isn't that what is being advocated? If you want to extend the question to How?", go right aheadHowever we are leading back to the 12 steps and spirituality pathway again.


Alfie, the problem I have with those statements is that they're so contentless.

You said you were after honesty, I am giving you nearly the exact response you want and you move the goalposts. Whatsthatabout?

First, there's the issue that one can't say anything about AA without you insisting that it doesn't count unless it's in an official tradition, and when it's pointed out that Tradition Two mentions God, you brush it off.

And so it does. God as we understand him. Bill in his own religious-speak way is saying group consensus or democracy. If you take the time to actually read step two (long version) you will see what is actually being said.

Linky

http://www.prismnet.com/aamen/trad.html

And if the traditions of AA are so flexible as to be meaningless, how they can offer "hope" to anyone?

Simple: Hope is offered by the clean and sober member who has come from the depths of despair to a fulfilling life. The new member can hear where they came from and be given hope that their life too can change for the better.
 
Other than the last item, it's really hard not to see that as a sexist complaint. Sorry, I'm trying not to be judgemental, but if you're going to share your history with people....

Well, the first two I think can be fair complaints. If he did work 12 hours per day in a paid job then it is not sexist or outright unfair to expect that the other person does the housework, is it?

(Did she cook for herself and do her own ironing, though?)

The next two just seem to be an extension of the final point. Again, I see no outright sexism here - I am not suggesting that either side should be blamed here, but it seems to describe a number of symptoms of a non-working relationship.
 
Practcing alcoholics aren't stupid; they are however insane.

You asked what AA advocates, I responded that step five covers it. Hope was the message. I will concede I could have been more complete in my response and could have said that the message was that abstinence will see your life improve. Isn't that what is being advocated? If you want to extend the question to How?", go right aheadHowever we are leading back to the 12 steps and spirituality pathway again.

Well, that's kind of my point.

We say "AA is the steps," you say "no, no, take what you want and leave the rest," we say, "well, what is AA then," you say "hope," I say "how," and you say, "look at the steps."

You said you were after honesty, I am giving you nearly the exact response you want and you move the goalposts. Whatsthatabout?

A contentless response, that can be changed when it suits your purposes, is not an honest one. When you spend most of a thread insisting that AA is not "religious," only to redefine "religious" when pressed in a way that renders it meaningless, is not very honest. Or, in case you're truly being sincere about this, let's just say that it's not conducive to meaningful dialogue.

And so it does. God as we understand him. Bill in his own religious-speak way is saying group consensus or democracy. If you take the time to actually read step two (long version) you will see what is actually being said.

Your link leads to a massive wall of text. Before I bother to read it, will you agree that it is an authoritative explanation of AA? Or will you disclaim anything I find on that site that disagrees with your claims?

Simple: Hope is offered by the clean and sober member who has come from the depths of despair to a fulfilling life. The new member can hear where they came from and be given hope that their life too can change for the better.

Well, that's a message I can endorse and I hope it works.
 
Well, the first two I think can be fair complaints. If he did work 12 hours per day in a paid job then it is not sexist or outright unfair to expect that the other person does the housework, is it?

(Did she cook for herself and do her own ironing, though?)

Sure, they could be fair complaints. But we're missing some information, like your stated assumption that he was working 12 hours per day in a paid job, and your unstated assumption that she wasn't.
 
Sure, they could be fair complaints. But we're missing some information, like your stated assumption that he was working 12 hours per day in a paid job, and your unstated assumption that she wasn't.

He said so, didn't he?

(remember she wasn't working and I was doing up to 12 hours per day).

Okay, it says "up to", and I am assuming that this means regular work and long hours regularly. Even with a 9-5 kinda job I'd think it fair to be mostly excluded from the housework. (I don't want to belittle the latter at all. And I am in no way suggesting that the sex of either partner should have anything to do with who does what.)
 
He said so, didn't he?



Okay, it says "up to", and I am assuming that this means regular work and long hours regularly. Even with a 9-5 kinda job I'd think it fair to be mostly excluded from the housework. (I don't want to belittle the latter at all. And I am in no way suggesting that the sex of either partner should have anything to do with who does what.)

No, you're right, I missed that.
 
A contentless response, that can be changed when it suits your purposes, is not an honest one. When you spend most of a thread insisting that AA is not "religious," only to redefine "religious" when pressed in a way that renders it meaningless, is not very honest. Or, in case you're truly being sincere about this, let's just say that it's not conducive to meaningful dialogue.

I haven't defined or redefined anything. The literature, "the program" (steps etc) and those in AA consistently state that it is a spiritual program, not religious.
Outsiders see spiritual as being religious and religious as being spiritual, i.e. totally interchangeable, they are not. It is they who are redefining words to confuse their respective meanings imho, not I who are rendering them meaningless.


Your link leads to a massive wall of text. Before I bother to read it, will you agree that it is an authoritative explanation of AA? Or will you disclaim anything I find on that site that disagrees with your claims?

The 12 traditions are the "rules" by which we play. I said earlier in response to you that I felt they were the best guide as to what AA was about. I also said that some interpretation (as in everything else in life) was also open to some personal interpretations.

Well, that's a message I can endorse and I hope it works.

We share our experience, strength and hope.

Cheers....um.. er....:o
 
I haven't defined or redefined anything. The literature, "the program" (steps etc) and those in AA consistently state that it is a spiritual program, not religious.
Outsiders see spiritual as being religious and religious as being spiritual, i.e. totally interchangeable, they are not. It is they who are redefining words to confuse their respective meanings imho, not I who are rendering them meaningless.

Let me state it bluntly. The thread title asks "Why do people insist AA is not religious?"

You have answered it in two ways, I believe: (1) it's not religious because there is no entrance requirement, i.e. nobody requires you to believe in god; and (2) AA isn't anything, really, because it's a bottom-up organization.

Let me know if I've characterized those views unfairly.

As to (1), I think you're playing word games, because most church services aren't "religious" under your definition.

As to (2), I think you're equivocating because you're willing to praise AA when it suits you, meaning that AA is "something" about which general statements can be made ("AA is helpful/offers hope/etc.") but when pressed on anything that might undermine your position ("AA is religious"), your revert back to the "well, that's just some local group, not AA as a whole" defense.

The 12 traditions are the "rules" by which we play. I said earlier in response to you that I felt they were the best guide as to what AA was about. I also said that some interpretation (as in everything else in life) was also open to some personal interpretations.

You evaded my question.

I asked you how AA offers hope. You pointed to the traditions. I said, doesn't the 2nd tradition refer to God. You said, read this explanation. I said, I'm not going to read it unless you agree that it's an authoritative explanation. I don't want you saying, this site is great when it explains how the 2nd tradition totally isn't religious, oh, but ignore what it says down there about Jesus.

Earlier in the thread you chastised someone for selectively quoting from part of a site that generally supported your position. I'm just asking that you don't do the same thing.

So, again: is that site an accurate description of AA? If your answer is anything but "yes," then I'm not going to waste my time reading it. You can paraphrase any key points that you think need to be made. If your answer is "yes," then I'll read it and respond.
 
Let me state it bluntly. The thread title asks "Why do people insist AA is not religious?"

You have answered it in two ways, I believe: (1) it's not religious because there is no entrance requirement, i.e. nobody requires you to believe in god; and (2) AA isn't anything, really, because it's a bottom-up organization.

Let me know if I've characterized those views unfairly.

I believe you have characterised this innaccurately.

1/. AA is not religious (but it can be), it is spiritual however.
2/. ??? The bottom up stuff was relating to something else altogether; not religiosity.

As to (1), I think you're playing word games, because most church services aren't "religious" under your definition.

Not games, I am using definitions: the simple fact is that spirituality and religion are two completely different things.

As to (2), I think you're equivocating because you're willing to praise AA when it suits you, meaning that AA is "something" about which general statements can be made ("AA is helpful/offers hope/etc.") but when pressed on anything that might undermine your position ("AA is religious"), your revert back to the "well, that's just some local group, not AA as a whole" defense.

I think the word mischaracterised is appropriate here.

You evaded my question.

I asked you how AA offers hope. You pointed to the traditions. I said, doesn't the 2nd tradition refer to God. You said, read this explanation. I said, I'm not going to read it unless you agree that it's an authoritative explanation. I don't want you saying, this site is great when it explains how the 2nd tradition totally isn't religious, oh, but ignore what it says down there about Jesus.

Earlier in the thread you chastised someone for selectively quoting from part of a site that generally supported your position. I'm just asking that you don't do the same thing.

So, again: is that site an accurate description of AA? If your answer is anything but "yes," then I'm not going to waste my time reading it. You can paraphrase any key points that you think need to be made. If your answer is "yes," then I'll read it and respond.

It is an accurate desription of how "God as we understood him" (as specified in the steps) reveals himself through the collective conscience of the group. In otherwords; Billspeak for a democratic decision.

Does Bill speak woo? Sure.
Is it democracy in action? Yep, it's that too.
Is it authoritative? Yep.
Is it open to interpretation? Yes again.

I suggest you read it and find out what I am talking about then you will be informed and discussions can commence.

I would point out that I am uncertain how we got to a link between 'hope' and step 2; it seems they were different topics.
 
Last edited:
Evidence?
You mean more anomymous anecdotal tales which seem to be Proof for most here?

Hell, if it's required of us, Al, it's darn sure required of you.
For me as a drunk the only thing I required from AA is learning not-to-drink, and with luck make a better life not drinking.

For many years now, mission accomplished -- one day at a time.
 
My posts, if you read them, were the opposite. I did not see this happening in meetings. I didn't know the "Official Position" until you posted it.

So, how can I forget the "Official position" and focus on the practice? My (anecdotal) evidence is that it DOESN'T happen.

I don't know what else to say? :confused:

I understand where the burden of proof lies in logical argumentation: with the positive claim.

However if said claim is being made, and you have no experience with it, and what you consider evidence--non-anecdotal--isn't forthcoming, then why wouldn't you at least try to find evidence on your own? Why wouldn't you look into claims, if only to bolster your own experience? Myself, I would prefer and have preferred finding out I'm wrong, than remaining uninformed about it.

If the answer is something along the lines of: "Because it isn't mine to prove," you mean, not even to yourself? Never mind the argument being had here. Why wouldn't you want to know, one way or the other, for your own information? Why wouldn't you think of small sampling, and the possibility that the meetings you attended were less than one-tenth of one percent of the whole, and that's pretty flimsy "evidence?"

I have agreed with much of what you've said here, and at the risk of causing another bout of nausea for some (:p), I do admire your sobriety, and how hard you have to work at it every day to maintain it. Far, far earlier in the thread, I mentioned that alcoholic who was once in my life has slipped, and fallen very close to hitting bottom, once again. After what we thought had been twenty years sober, we have now, according to his newest ex-wife, discovered his drinking, drugging, and prostitute-paying been going on for at least 5 years, and no one is discounting the possibility it's been even longer than that. So, I do admire those who keep winning their own fight, one day at a time. And that includes Alfie, even if he frustrates me sometimes. ;)

Going back to the main discussion, it seems to me that AA could emphasize "spirituality" without having to mention god at all.

I would think it better, in many ways, to emphasize not a higher power than ourselves, but a power greater than that which we have used before. That power is inherent in me, and in my fellow humans. This keeps the rhetoric focused on how its our problem, and therefore ultimately our solution, and doesn't drag any woo into it. And it doesn't imply that people can't have their theism, their religiosity, just because the word "god" is removed!

Religious/theistic persons engage the world each day in many ways that don't promote religion in any form, and they function just fine. Because they utilize their religious beliefs, anyway, in spite of that lack of "official" sanction. God could still be an open and celebrated part of the individual's program, while not officially being part of the AA Program of Recovery, and that wouldn't be discouraged in any way.

Spirituality can be spiritual without any inclusion of god. but religion can't be religious without inclusion of god. If "spiritual" is what's being aimed for, it won't hurt to drop the religious part. It's still spiritual.

I'm functioning on 4 hours sleep, and am admittedly foggy, so I hope I'm being clear. I'm not saying to discourage "god," but rather, don't officially encourage "god," so that the program is more inclusive of all.

We atheists are growing in numbers. This hitch in the system is going to keep getting bigger...
 
Last edited:
But basically, I would ask Alfie to ponder and respond to the following questions:

1) What would you accept as evidence of "what AA does/believes/advocates"?
2) Under that definition, what do you think you can claim AA does/believer/advocates?

My gripe is that you want to claim that AA saves lives, kept person X sober, etc., but in response to critics you insist that anecdotes don't count, nothing short of official statements from an entity that apparently doesn't issue statements counts, etc.

And my gripe is that Alfie says that there is no such thing as an AA program, not officially, and yet he credits it with saving lives. How can "nothing" save a life, Alfie?

On the other hand, it has been amusing to watch Alfie's lofty claims about AA evolve over the course of this thread. In the beginning AA was everything to Alfie but now it is nothing . . . except 'hope' . . . allegedly . . . and unofficially, of course. :rolleyes:

I would also like to know how Alfie decides one step outweighs all the others? That the step talking about hope is official but all the ones talking about god aren't. It seems to me this is no different than what believers do with the bible. They disregard everything they don't like/know is wrong in the text and then claim the rest doesn't exist/isn't official. Cognitive dissonance at its best.
 
Last edited:
I have to admit, Qayak, "take what you need and leave the rest" does rather smack of cherry-picking, from at least a certain point of view.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom