Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
He does have a point I agree. But the counter to it is that it is not AA that advocates throwing away the meds; it is misguided individuals and they are fools imho. Slowly but surely AA (through efforts of people like myself and dare I say Tinyal) are trying to educate one and all.

In fact, to the best of my knowledge, AA makes no comment on meds nor psychiatric/psychological treatment in any capacity whatsoever. And unless Joey can show same, he cannot claim that AA is anything of the sort.

Um, then the AA organization would benefit from one thing AA Alfie, it should tell its members and groups to stop making statements about medical treatment, it should tell then to stay the hell out of it and make it a new tradition.

I have heard so much garbage at meetings and from members about the evils of medication and how treating mental illness is just a substitute addiction, it is disgusting. I have heard people talk about how anxiolytics are a substitute for alcohol addiction, this was huge meme in the 1990s. I have heard people say that people who are depressed should just shut the **** up and work their program. I have heard people be discouraged from seeking out psychiatric treatment and just work the program. These are all things I have heard from many individuals at meetings and in the coffee bash afterwards. I have seen sponsors discourage people who had severe symptoms from seeking out a psychiatrist. They never do this about angina or other medical issues, only psychiatry.

AA could make a big bold step by taking on a new tradition "AA does not want itself, its members of any of its affiliates to interfere in the medical treatment of any individual, the choice of an individual to seek medical treatment is between an individual and their doctor. AA does not approve of its members who are not doctors and medical professionals providing diagnosis , treatment advice or opinions regarding medical treatment, they should only encourage people to seek out competent medical authorities and advice. No comments should be made other than encouraging those who have medical issues to seek out treatment from medical professionals. No discussion of medical research into medications should be undertaken by members who are not professionally trained and competent to do so."
 
Last edited:
Anything would be a good start.


Then it shouldn't be a problem for you.
No. Like I said, there wouldn't be any evidence except for testimony in this case. You're inventing an imaginary standard of evidence, and I resent this. I ask you for one and you throw rhetoric back in my face, try again.
 
The problem is though Belz, that anything produced will be individual opinions; it will have nothing to do with AA as a whole.
Nope, this is crap apologia, the format of AA leads to this problem, as I have shown repeatedly. Click on the links people put in threads.

I too know of people in AA who spout "the pills are for dills" rubbish. I think I have told this story before but it bears repeating:
It's an anecdote and proves nothing where's your double blind study that AA is not a cult alfie :cool:

Another AA success story.
LOL this is a story of science-based medicine triumphing over the cult! Thanks Alfie!

AA is not and never was designed to replace psychology medicine, etc.
History denier.
Some people seem to think it an panacea within AA, and some people out of AA thinks AA makes this claim. Both are wrong.
Better change the language of AA then. "Rarely have we seen a person fail that has thoroughly followed our path" lol
 
He does have a point I agree. But the counter to it is that it is not AA that advocates throwing away the meds; it is misguided individuals and they are fools imho.
bahahahah I have shown repeatedly that it is coming from the garbage program (faith healing cult) this is the weakest apologia ever.

Slowly but surely AA (through efforts of people like myself and dare I say Tinyal) are trying to educate one and all.
Not good enough. Scientology has pro-psychiatry reform movements too, cult apologia, nothing to see here.

In fact, to the best of my knowledge, AA makes no comment on meds nor psychiatric/psychological treatment in any capacity whatsoever.
Cult apologist baloney. It's a cult, you apologize for it, bad way to spend your days at JREF. Whether or not it says it on the website has nothing to do with what I'm talking about, you know it, but it's a really good reason to be critical of your multi-faceted diamond, so you try and excuse it. Gross.
And unless Joey can show same, he cannot claim that AA is anything of the sort.
Cult apologist baloney. It's not on their website so it doesn't happen. Gawd sometimes I wish I was also delusional the world is a scary place.
 
Last edited:
Um, then the AA organization would benefit from one thing AA Alfie, it should tell its members and groups to stop making statements about medical treatment, it should tell then to stay the hell out of it and make it a new tradition.

<snip>

As I mentioned above somewhere, this was done at the meetings around here. There was no directive from AA, so I guess it was more of a grass roots kind of thing.

At every meeting I was at where someone tried the anti-psychiatry or anti-meds thing, they were basically shouted down by multiple members. "AA does not play doctor" is what I learned, and of course just assumed it was like that everywhere. I didn't know there was a larger problem out there somewhere like you are describing. My sponsor approved of any and all treatments that might be effective.

All the usual disclaimers go here about this just being my personal experience. I atteneded a lot of meetings, but all were within 30 miles of my house, and most were just a 10 minute drive away - lots of drunks near here, apparently :p
 
As I mentioned above somewhere, this was done at the meetings around here. There was no directive from AA, so I guess it was more of a grass roots kind of thing.
Denier. Apologist. What people think is often wrong and often helps mask the crimes of cults.

At every meeting I was at where someone tried the anti-psychiatry or anti-meds thing, they were basically shouted down by multiple members. "AA does not play doctor" is what I learned, and of course just assumed it was like that everywhere. I didn't know there was a larger problem out there somewhere like you are describing. My sponsor approved of any and all treatments that might be effective.

All the usual disclaimers go here about this just being my personal experience. I atteneded a lot of meetings, but all were within 30 miles of my house, and most were just a 10 minute drive away - lots of drunks near here, apparently :p
It's already been repeatedly said that there has been massive reform in the last 10 years, when did you start attending? Your experience isn't a problem for anything I have said.
 
Denier. Apologist. What people think is often wrong and often helps mask the crimes of cults.

It's already been repeatedly said that there has been massive reform in the last 10 years, when did you start attending? Your experience isn't a problem for anything I have said.

I'm not sure what I denied in there, or what I apologized for :rolleyes:

2006-2010 to answer your question. I didn't know I needed more than a decade of experience to weigh in on this one. I'll bow out now and let you get back to your argument with Alfie.
 
I'm not sure what I denied in there, or what I apologized for :rolleyes:
You said "it was more of a grass roots kind of thing." this is a hurtful lie.

ETA how are you going to help solve the problem if you don't acknowledge exactly what the problem is and where it comes from. This is why it's ok to bash apologists, they are denying the harm, so they are contributing to it. Sue me.
 
Last edited:
You said "it was more of a grass roots kind of thing." this is a hurtful lie.

Geez, enough with the name calling. I'm a liar now? I could just be wrong, and if you show me I am I'll admit it. I said I "assumed" it was something like that because there wasn't a directive from AA leadership on the subject. (that I was made aware of)

In the posts above yours several members were making the point that AA should change its official policy in this area, which I agree with. Try to understand me here, we agree on this point. I was saying that in my (limited) experience the policy had changed in effect, but with no "official" proclamtion or somesuch.

Maybe "grass roots" was the wrong phrase to use, but I certainly wasn't trying to tell a "hurtful lie."
 
...

ETA how are you going to help solve the problem if you don't acknowledge exactly what the problem is and where it comes from. This is why it's ok to bash apologists, they are denying the harm, so they are contributing to it. Sue me.

I'm not trying to solve anything. I'm participating in a discussion on an internet forum. I'm not even a member of AA anymore. I'm not going to sue you. I'm going to leave you to your personal jihad against AA.

Attack me all you want, I just think you are wasting your time. I'm not exactly a high-priority target.
 
Geez, enough with the name calling. I'm a liar now? I could just be wrong, and if you show me I am I'll admit it. I said I "assumed" it was something like that because there wasn't a directive from AA leadership on the subject. (that I was made aware of)
No, being naive and gullible in the face of cult memetics is not a crime or surprising.

In the posts above yours several members were making the point that AA should change its official policy in this area, which I agree with. Try to understand me here, we agree on this point. I was saying that in my (limited) experience the policy had changed in effect, but with no "official" proclamtion or somesuch.
An outrage indeed.

Maybe "grass roots" was the wrong phrase to use, but I certainly wasn't trying to tell a "hurtful lie."
Sorry, you're contributing to the spread of one.

I'm not trying to solve anything.
That's clear.
I'm going to leave you to your personal jihad against AA.
Yep it's my ego. Disgusting.

Attack me all you want, I just think you are wasting your time.
Don't make inaccurate statements if you don't want to be corrected.
 
<snip>

Don't make inaccurate statements if you don't want to be corrected.

Can you tell me what I said that was inaccurate specifically, and when you correct me can you do it in a way that I won't be offended?

I have a hard time with my personal anecdote being labelled inaccurate, unless you were there next to me. Worthless maybe, irrelevant, off-topic, not evidence, etc., sure. But I assure you that I wasn't lying or distorting the truth when I describe things I saw or heard.
 
Can you tell me what I said that was inaccurate specifically, and when you correct me can you do it in a way that I won't be offended?
Yes, unlike some people, when I attack you, I will actually use your own words against you to show I'm not a rhetorician.

As I mentioned above somewhere, this was done at the meetings around here. There was no directive from AA, so I guess it was more of a grass roots kind of thing.

I have shown repeatedly that it is the cult of AA itself that leads to and engenders this belief. calling it "grass roots" is implying that the anti psychiatry that exists in the general population is what we're actually seeing in AA. No. Don't contribute to this lie and you won't be called an apologist if that hurts your feelings.

I have a hard time with my personal anecdote being labelled inaccurate, unless you were there next to me. Worthless maybe, irrelevant, off-topic, not evidence, etc., sure. But I assure you that I wasn't lying or distorting the truth when I describe things I saw or heard.
Your anecdote is worth something, I did not attack it. I attacked your belief that this was a grassroots phenomenon, actually even saying that without pointing out that it's not would be too much to bear.
 
Yes, unlike some people, when I attack you, I will actually use your own words against you to show I'm not a rhetorician.



I have shown repeatedly that it is the cult of AA itself that leads to and engenders this belief. calling it "grass roots" is implying that the anti psychiatry that exists in the general population is what we're actually seeing in AA. No. Don't contribute to this lie and you won't be called an apologist if that hurts your feelings.

Your anecdote is worth something, I did not attack it. I attacked your belief that this was a grassroots phenomenon, actually even saying that without pointing out that it's not would be too much to bear.

Ah. That makes more sense. I did mention in another post that "grass roots" was perhaps the wrong word or phrase. "Unofficial", maybe would be better?

The other possibility was that what I saw was entirely local, which is why I mentioned the limited meetings - by geography - that I had been to.
 
No. Like I said, there wouldn't be any evidence except for testimony in this case. You're inventing an imaginary standard of evidence, and I resent this.

I'm not inventing a standards of evidence. I simply don't want skeptics to basically use the same standards of evidence we decry from our usual opponents here.

I understand that you're fed up with the AA side, but it does no good to switch to snarky mode and become opaque to discussion. When we said AA was religious, this was the evidence for:

1) AA litterature
2) General AA outlook and statements
3) Anecdotal evidence

And against:

1) Anecdotal evidence.

So FOR seems to trump against. But now you say that AA is anti-psy. Sure, I believe you, and it would fit their MO. But let's not just stick to what the "against" side had for the previous claim. Is that AA's official policy or not ? We should stick to the same standards of evidence that led us to our conclusion about the first claim.
 
Last edited:
I'm not inventing a standards of evidence. I simply don't want skeptics to basically use the same standards of evidence we decry from our usual opponents here.
So you're engaging in concern trollery? If you can't give me an example of what you need to see that's all it is.

I've proved without a shadow of a doubt that aa itself is anti psychiatry and has to work to overcome this. Even alfie's story shows he's actually deprogramming this belief as part of his job! He apologizes for his idealistic vision and this is clear to everyone now.

ETA, re your ETA

I understand that you're fed up with the AA side, but it does no good to switch to snarky mode
There's no nice way to talk about cults abusing people.
and become opaque to discussion
quote me doing this
. When we said AA was religious, this was the evidence for:

1) AA litterature
2) General AA outlook and statements
3) Anecdotal evidence

And against:

1) Anecdotal evidence.

So FOR seems to trump against. But now you say that AA is anti-psy. Sure, I believe you, and it would fit their MO. But let's not just stick to what the "against" side had for the previous claim. Is that AA's official policy or not ? We should stick to the same standards of evidence that led us to our conclusion about the first claim.
________________
confused emotiocon

If AA is anti-psy to the exact degree I have said, what evidence would there be? You can't give me an answer, because I am correct. The only evidence there would be is testimony.

eta 2: i could give a coherent case using literature etc for saying why aa has led to this, but it's not necessary in order to prove that aa is anti-psychiatry. People can just look at the obvious reality and figure it out for themselves. it's a faith healing cult, i have shown that, and you'd expect anti psy in that environment. I now consider this matter closed.
 
Last edited:
Ah. That makes more sense. I did mention in another post that "grass roots" was perhaps the wrong word or phrase.
You mean in your response to my attack
"Unofficial", maybe would be better?
Yes.
The other possibility was that what I saw was entirely local, which is why I mentioned the limited meetings - by geography - that I had been to.
I've repeatedly mentioned that the bigger cities are more likely to have reformed sponsers, but to a limited degree. Groups are naturalistic entities that evolve naturally, genes/memes.
 
Last edited:
The problem is though Belz, that anything produced will be individual opinions; it will have nothing to do with AA as a whole.

I too know of people in AA who spout "the pills are for dills" rubbish. I think I have told this story before but it bears repeating:

A new sponsee came to me last year - I will call him Bob, he is three years or so sober. He is a delightful chap, an innocent in many ways and perhaps a little naive. As we were talking one night he asked me when he thought his anxiety would disappear. To that point I didn't realise it was or had been a problem for him; save for a bit of shyness you wouldn't know.
Anyway, I asked him what his doctor had said. He told me his doctor had prescribed him some anti-depressants to which I responded: "Good, have you just started them, then?". Bob tells me he was prescribed them about two years ago and that "no, he has never taken them". When I question him as to why, he tells me because he heard from the floor and a previous sponsor the "pills are for dills" nonsense and inferred that this meant no prescription meds either.

I asked Bob what he thought AA stood for, he responded with the correct answer. I pointed out strongly that AA does not stand for Anxiety anonymous, nor broken legs anonymous. I told Bob about a friend of mine who got to AA after breaking his leg when drunk; it was one of the final straws for him to take action and he started coming to AA on crutches. I asked Bob whether he thought AA would fix his broken leg; obviously he said "No". I further explained that we often have issues that predate our alcoholism and some issues that have come sbout because of it. They do not just magic away because we get sober; many times they even get worse before we see improvement and many times it is a case of ongoing or even lifetime management. In other words, I expalined that we need to get professional help from professionals for other problems and do the work we need to assist in getting well.

Bob is now on his meds, working closely with his doctor (and sponsor) and is doing really well.

Another AA success story.

AA is not and never was designed to replace psychology medicine, etc. Some people seem to think it an panacea within AA, and some people out of AA thinks AA makes this claim. Both are wrong.


So when some people in AA say not to take your pills that is not AA but when you tell him to take his pills that is AA.

Your argument is a No True Scotchman fallacy.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom