Dancing David
Penultimate Amazing
He does have a point I agree. But the counter to it is that it is not AA that advocates throwing away the meds; it is misguided individuals and they are fools imho. Slowly but surely AA (through efforts of people like myself and dare I say Tinyal) are trying to educate one and all.
In fact, to the best of my knowledge, AA makes no comment on meds nor psychiatric/psychological treatment in any capacity whatsoever. And unless Joey can show same, he cannot claim that AA is anything of the sort.
Um, then the AA organization would benefit from one thing AA Alfie, it should tell its members and groups to stop making statements about medical treatment, it should tell then to stay the hell out of it and make it a new tradition.
I have heard so much garbage at meetings and from members about the evils of medication and how treating mental illness is just a substitute addiction, it is disgusting. I have heard people talk about how anxiolytics are a substitute for alcohol addiction, this was huge meme in the 1990s. I have heard people say that people who are depressed should just shut the **** up and work their program. I have heard people be discouraged from seeking out psychiatric treatment and just work the program. These are all things I have heard from many individuals at meetings and in the coffee bash afterwards. I have seen sponsors discourage people who had severe symptoms from seeking out a psychiatrist. They never do this about angina or other medical issues, only psychiatry.
AA could make a big bold step by taking on a new tradition "AA does not want itself, its members of any of its affiliates to interfere in the medical treatment of any individual, the choice of an individual to seek medical treatment is between an individual and their doctor. AA does not approve of its members who are not doctors and medical professionals providing diagnosis , treatment advice or opinions regarding medical treatment, they should only encourage people to seek out competent medical authorities and advice. No comments should be made other than encouraging those who have medical issues to seek out treatment from medical professionals. No discussion of medical research into medications should be undertaken by members who are not professionally trained and competent to do so."
Last edited: