Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Indeed it is, except I have been throwing these arguments at you, not you at me. You have nothing, nor remotely proved anything.
No, this is completely backwards, if you go back, I made all of those points before this part of the thread even started. And just because you don't click on the links in my posts, doesn't mean I don't provide evidence.


I'll tell you what, after this post - which will be my final to you I will not re-engage with you until you provide to me two things. You can accept the terms or not, I really don't care:
Your second final post to me Alfie?

1/. Define cult.
Explain what constitutes a cult and what does not. Where AAs similarities lie but also where there are differences.
This would be a move away from your black and white thinking and might help.
Where have you been Alfie? I have posted this link a number of times, it reflects my thoughts on why I call AA a cult. It's not my fault you don't click on links. It is a destructice, freedom stealing environment that uses deceptive techniques and provides an environment for predators by allowing for mind control. And a whole lot of other things. I could go on and on about it for thousands of words, or you can just read who I agree with. I'm saying these things happen more often in AA than other groups because of it's structure, and the evidence supports that, unless you put your head in the sand.

2/. Show me studies of what other treatments there are and there success rates. You keep spouting about 5% and all, but what are the success rates for others?
Actually I have never said the words five percent. I've pointed to the Cochrane review, and about a dozen sources on AA horror stories and professional opinions. Have you ever realized why the Cochrane authors said that people should be told there is no evidence for effectiveness? Because people are being let down. It's immoral. If you say the program works you are saying an embarrassing lie that hurts people.

Sure it is.

The most popular type of self-help group is based on the Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), founded in 1935.

http://www.minddisorders.com/Py-Z/Self-help-groups.html
Showing me evidence that it's called a self-help group doesn't change the fact that it's a format you can test scientifically, which is medical advice. If they are giving advice and counselling people on a medical condition, it's not just a "self-help" group?

Like CBT? Like optimal thinking?

Sound sinister doesn't it? :rolleyes:
:covereyes


I will if you will.
I don't claim to be able to help people with alcoholism.

I agree with you; that sort of thing really shouldn't happen. I'm sure it does, I have seen it too but not quite to the level in your hand-waving example.
Who cares what you've seen? The experiences of thousands of people is what I'm pointing to. Testimonies of "What I saw in AA" nature that are bloody everywhere on the internet saying all of the same things as me.

Like Why I left AA

So obviously there are different meetings all over the world and some are worse than others. I never disputed this at all, I'm just pointing to problems, while you're defending your idealized version of AA, so this isn't even an argument anymore.

I have posted links to an entire free online book on AA horror stories that talk about how AA and the program itself leads to these problems. These problems start with the program and it's memetic nature and must be dealt with. Taken individually the frequency and commonality of these events paint a clear picture of a problem of pathologies in the AA system. You are the one handwaving the reality away by demanding I meet your standard of evidence which are denier standards. You don't even click on links to scientific studies and read them before criticizing them. Who's the handwaver. You tried to sell me a story that the Cochrane review used too small of a sample to be worth anything. Who is handwaving now.

However that is not what "the program" or AA is supposed to be about. Neither is 13 step work etc. When these things happen it is because of individuals, not the fellowship.
That's absolutely crap. Bill W invented 13th stepping, this is his cult, and one day you're going to see it, if you just look.

But once again, you would tar all with the same brush. Black and white, all or nothing. I'm starting to think this is a problem for you.
Quote me making a black and white statement then Alfie, this is your straw man after all.

Got it: You have nothing.
Again, just because you don't click on my links isn't a point against me. This is in reference to me saying AA has a lot of anti-psychiatry, the fact you are disputing this is and saying I have no evidence is absolutely pathetic. It's just common knowledge that you are trying to handwave away by dismissing the way I give evidence for it. Your best is that AA has changed and the history is not the past, well great, don't be a jerk and try and malign me for pointing out the facts just to apologize and protect for your beloved group today.

Is this a meaure of the science you keep mentioning? LOL. :rolleyes:
What the hell are you talking about. What do you want, a scientific study on anti-medication beliefs in AA? Sorry, I don't have or need one. You'll have to check out my links and ask around and ask the old-timers about the history of those battles, read the books on AA, books.google.com will be fine, it's just a stupid fallacy saying I have no study. Handwaving to the core. If I just say that, that's fine, if I say it's common knowledge, and point to a tv show talking about it, that's a plus. To you, that's not evidence, that's not good enough, that's not something that's worth investigating further. I have posted several stories from people saying they spoke out about it at meetings because they felt pressured to give it up. So, they fact you are apologizing for that has now crossed the line into unacceptable. It happens, deal with it.

Then you are so very very wrong it is not funny.
Oh I don't think you meant that, I think you're overapologizing for the cult, but it's like, what, can't you just leave it at that? How can you even question that it's just plain a bad thing? :rolleyes: Which leaves one with the feeling of perhaps he thinks the man's better off without her? Whatever you can explain it however you want.

Challenging and questioning are also completely different tools at the disposal of the therapist. To conflate or confude them proves your lack of understanding.
Challenging is absolutely fundamental to almost any counselling session. Sometimes one needs to be cruel to be kind as well (not always).
I understand that you and some people feel this way, I just think some people are jerks and abuse it or don't know what they are doing in the first place. Like the people who think they are counsellors after mastering AA-speak and getting a cheap piece of paper from the local community college. Seems like just going to a real college would prevent that.

Offering suggestions and providing evidence seems more interesting. Win-win seems more conducive to deprogramming and freedom. I'm very big on that whole mental freedom thing, getting people think rationally on the evidence so they can take care of themselves and not need a "program" :rolleyes: where they turn themselves over the group :rolleyes: and get scared they might die if they go have fun instead of go to a meeting :rolleyes:

But I repeat, I am counselling no-one here, I am not being paid, and I don't ever just give lip service.
Clients come to me for their problems; my job (in part) is to assist them in finding solutions or to advance their progress.

If that is the extent of your thoughts around what counsellors do, then I suggest you do a bit more research yourself.
lol no you just invented a caricature of what I think you do for a living so you can invent a way to say something that will perhaps portray me as stupid. A repeating event in this thread it's like your old standby. It's just attacking the person's "ego" which is the classic conditioning of AA.

I mean it, every time I talk to people in AA they attack my "ego". I'm just "too good" for you, or I just am obsessed with stupid things that don't matter because I need attention or I'm whining or no one helped me and I have resentments. It's utterly disgusting crap. They love to beat you down so they can build you up. Group of drunks... ;)

In other words, you can prove nothing and your claims are ridiculous.

Got it. :)

By the way, I'd have thought it pretty easy to prove the sky is blue. :)
Your nauseating pseudoargumentation is what prevents me from making the effort :)
 
Last edited:
Again, just because you don't click on my links isn't a point against me. This is in reference to me saying AA has a lot of anti-psychiatry, the fact you are disputing this is and saying I have no evidence is absolutely pathetic. It's just common knowledge that you are trying to handwave away by dismissing the way I give evidence for it. Your best is that AA has changed and the history is not the past, well great, don't be a jerk and try and malign me for pointing out the facts just to apologize and protect for your beloved group today.

Actually, I'd like to see such evidence, as well. I don't doubt that they are anti-psy, but I'd like to see something more substantial.
 
The most popular type of self-help group is based on the Suggested Twelve Steps and Suggested Twelve Traditions of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), founded in 1935.

FTFY.


I agree with you; that sort of thing really shouldn't happen. I'm sure it does, I have seen it too but not quite to the level in your hand-waving example. However that is not what "the program" or AA is supposed to be about.

Oh, so there is such a thing as "the program" when you speak of it, but not when I do?

You should let Mijo know. He's mysteriously not said another word about how there is "no 'the program,'" since I showed him that AA's own literature uses the term.




Got it: You have nothing.



Is this a meaure of the science you keep mentioning? LOL. :rolleyes:



Then you are so very very wrong it is not funny.



Sometimes one needs to be cruel to be kind as well (not always).



In other words, you can prove nothing and your claims are ridiculous.

Got it. :)

By the way, I'd have thought it pretty easy to prove the sky is blue. :)

THIS is you being not just rude, but condescending, and insulting our intelligence. I bold the above, because I feel that's exactly what you think you're doing: being cruel to us to be kind.

Knock it off. You've said you're not counseling any of us, so stop using counseling techniques on us and just have the discussion. Could ya?

It does not matter what the efficacy of the AA program is, it does not matter how many people find help and sobriety with it, and it's not really even about how many people the program does not help.

The question is and remains: is AA a religiously oriented program?
IT IS. We've shown it over and over and over. That you can't accept that is no one's fault but your own.
 

Thanks. I was wondering whether anyone would pick them up.

Oh, so there is such a thing as "the program" when you speak of it, but not when I do?

Not at all, that's why I had them in "quotation marks".

You should let Mijo know. He's mysteriously not said another word about how there is "no 'the program,'" since I showed him that AA's own literature uses the term.

Really? Then that's a slip on my part. There is a "program" and I have never disputed that. The "program" is the actions that a person takes in an effort to secure their sobriety. For many, the 12 steps form part of that program, but not everyone's. I don't believe I have strayed from this line of thought.

THIS is you being not just rude, but condescending, and insulting our intelligence. I bold the above, because I feel that's exactly what you think you're doing: being cruel to us to be kind.

And again, that is not my intention to be rude; I am simply stating my truth. Sorry you don't like it.

Knock it off. You've said you're not counseling any of us, so stop using counseling techniques on us and just have the discussion. Could ya?

I am not using counselling techniques. I am debating in the style I like. Sorry if you don't like it but I intend not to change too much. If I am given some I will give it back. If education (and isn't that what JREF is about?) is a bit rough and tumble sometimes then I humbly suggest one learns to live with it.

It does not matter what the efficacy of the AA program is, it does not matter how many people find help and sobriety with it, and it's not really even about how many people the program does not help.

Others continue to bring up this efficacy question, not I. If others bring it up saying "it doesn't work" but give nothing that supports anything that does, I tend to like to challenge that. So I ask again. What works better than AA?

I also notice that Joey D does not want to accept my challenge/request. That speaks volumes imho.

The question is and remains: is AA a religiously oriented program?
IT IS. We've shown it over and over and over. That you can't accept that is no one's fault but your own.

And I have stated over and over that "it can be if you want it to be". It is your lack of acceptance of this fact that is the problem, not mine. I have conceded time and again that Bill Ws language can be viewed as religious, but that does not make the entire "program" or fellowship religious. Take what you need and leave the rest.

Tinyal (and myself as an agnostic) are perfect examples of how non religious the program is, and that it does work without God. I have done the steps many time, I assume Tinyal has as well without a God or religion - certainly a HP and/or PGTO; but not God.

How come you can't see and accept that?
 
Last edited:
Actually, I'd like to see such evidence, as well. I don't doubt that they are anti-psy, but I'd like to see something more substantial.
What do you want to see? The only evidence there would be of this is the testimony of people in the program. There's no records of what people are told and what goes on socially in AA. All we have is the testimony of people in the program, and that's what I've provided a few cases of, and said if you want more go find them yourself. All you have to do is google alcoholics anonymous anti depressents, which is what I did here, just now.

Assuming more testimony is what you want.

I don't know how many days into the program I am, somewhere in the 100s, but I'm 22 days sober, finally found myself a good sponsor, have been talking to her every day and following her directions, and want to keep doing so...

And then she tells me that she has to "check with her grand-sponsor" to see whether I'm "allowed" to keep taking my 10mg of prozac that I take every day, mainly to deal with the devastating drop in seratonin levels that happens to me about 2 weeks out of every month.
source. This is pretty much how AA has integrated psychiatry in some places.
Quite recently I was sponsoring a girl who was on a couple of tablets for clinical depression, and she asked me to sponsor her, and I said I would, and she told me that she had already asked 3 other female members, but none of them woud sponsor her because she was on 'drugs'
I can just keep on going all day.

ETA: And the reason this is AA's fault is a) They don't actively discourage and discipline sponsors who have this message. b) it's a faith-healing cult which is why this belief flourishes there. c) They don't change so people have to learn this on their own over time, which is why pro psychiatry is so spotty in AA until this day. All problems that would not happen in a professional organization.
 
Last edited:
ASnd I have stated over and over that "it can be if you want it to be", it is your lack of acceptance of this fact that is the problem, not mine.

Tinyal (and myself as an agnostic) are perfect examples of how non religious the program is, and that it does work without God.

How come you can't see and accept that?

Because you're still talking about how it works, and efficacy, and that's

Not.

The.

Point.
 
Because you're still talking about how it works, and efficacy, and that's

Not.

The.

Point.

The I'm afraid you have lost me.

If it isn't about efficacy yet I can show efficacy without religion how does that not answer the question?

Honestly, I am confused.

I see Joey D still has nothing but anecdotes. Yet he likes to talk science. Funny huh?


Bed time now, nighty night.
 
Honestly, I am confused.

I see Joey D still has nothing but anecdotes. Yet he likes to talk science. Funny huh?
If my claim is true, what evidence are you looking for? What evidence should there be, other than massive amounts of testimony? You can't just make up imaginary standards of evidence, so what are they?

ETA

I also notice that Joey D does not want to accept my challenge/request. That speaks volumes imho.
I already explained why AA is a cult, and previously talked about what constitutes a cult, and linked to that model and that description, and that's what I agree with. I'm not dancing all over the place and giving my interpretation here, because the only point of that is for you to make pseudoarguments against which will be boring. Make them against the BITE Model and that article on the same website if you really care.

And I don't have to give you any effectiveness samples for other programs. This is your derail from the arguments I've made, that AA doesn't work, plus it's harmful, so it's net negative. Obviously any group that is not a cult with these terrible patterns is better than AA even if it also doesn't work. That's got nothing to do with what you're talking about, it's just your weak attempt to deny that there are problems no one is fixing in this recovery movement.

So, just laugh to yourself all you want alfie, it's just your "ego" ;)
 
Last edited:
The I'm afraid you have lost me.

If it isn't about efficacy yet I can show efficacy without religion how does that not answer the question?

You don't want me to believe you're that badly missing the point, do you? Really?

Question: "Why do people insist AA is not religious?"

Answer: "AA has admittedly religious origins, and a decidedly religious bent or overtone."


Do you see efficacy mentioned anywhere in that? No, you don't. Because whether the program works for a certain number of people or not has nothing to do with whether the AA program of recovery has a religious bent.


Honestly, I am confused.

That's not confusion. That's you moving the goalposts in order to score points your team hasn't earned.

I see Joey D still has nothing but anecdotes. Yet he likes to talk science. Funny huh?

Condescending, rude, and nothing to do with me or my post. I'm not Joey, in case it's slipped your notice.
 
This has been a very interesting thread - when it first started back in 2010 I followed it a little bit after it was brought to my attention but I've been reading lots of the thread over the last few days and I have to say that it has changed my mind about the AA.

Perhaps the AA does not have a large following over here in the UK or it's outside my circle, my impression of the AA was based a lot on USA entertainment shows and I'd always assumed it was just a support group with a series of steps to help addicts and I assumed the evidence was that it did work very well.

This thread has certainly been an education for me and has totally changed my mind about the AA. I now know it is of a "religious bent" and has supernatural nonsense built into it and that it ain't very effective. I also have learnt that despite its religious bent and its poor success record it can help a small number of folk and it doesn't matter if they are atheists or theists or deist (as long as you are in the type of group that allows that approach).

So thanks very much to all those that have contributed to this thread - I've really enjoyed learning something new.
 
But is it a widespread thing ? And does the litterature of AA support it, in some way ? We've been arguing that Alfie's anecdotal evidence is not enough. It would be a bit hypocritical for us to use the same level of evidence.
It remains to be postulated, what would you need to see in order to believe that the structure of AA has led to anti psychiatry? I argue that the best argument is the frequency of testimony. Let it be known that anyone can guarantee themselves to find evidence by typing anti depressant alcoholics anonymous into google. If you can form a request for a specific kind of evidence I can probably find it for you. But the frequency of the reports should be evidence enough. It would be in a court of law, if said activity were illegal. (should giving quack advice be an offence?)
 
As I've frequently heard it stated at hundreds of meetings, AA is not the place to find people who have it together, who's minds are sharp and who's ethics are commendable. As some people demonstrate from their posts (as Alfie just did in post #3801), AA is often (certainly not always) the place where you find the sickest , ethically weakest, and (hopefully temporarily) mentally challenged of people, as it's said by some that if they weren't in AA many of them would be either dead, in jail, in mental institutions, or out drinking themselves to death.
I personally don't agree with that assessment, but when examples such as some we've seen in this thread show up and post, I become curious if there isn't a grain of truth in that sometimes. :)
 
Last edited:
There is no dishonesty in any of slingblade's posts - several of your posts, however, are full of weasel words, personal accusations unsupported by any evidence, and insults directed at the person instead of the topic at hand.

An example - your post #3794. You say nothing about the topic of this thread, and accuse slingblade of dishonesty and quote-mining - with nothing to back those up. Reading posts like that from you aren't worth the effort, and I'd really prefer the 5 seconds of my life back it took to read it.

Got anything meaningful to post about the actual subject? You could of course wait on posting till I finish composing my new thread, which has a working title of 'Is AA a cult, and is it effective? Additionally, does it cause more harm than good ?'. The delay in my creating this new thread is as I collect information from various sources, internal AA documents (some unavailable to the public) & studies of various types. My free time is quite limited this time of year, so might be up to another week or slightly longer before I have it ready. I'm sure you'll enjoy participating in that one when its up.

*sigh*

What I said in the post that slingblade "quoted" (the material in her post that referred to what I had said was in quotes) was:

Yeah, first there is no "the program". Each person's program is individual to that person. Some people work the steps; some don't. Some understand "God" as a supernatural power; others don't. What seem to be going on here is that there is a fanatical focus on the word "God" and a complete inability to consider the following phrase: "as we understood (understand) Him".

What slingblade posted was:

slingblade said:
I agree with you; that sort of thing really shouldn't happen. I'm sure it does, I have seen it too but not quite to the level in your hand-waving example. However that is not what "the program" or AA is supposed to be about.

Oh, so there is such a thing as "the program" when you speak of it, but not when I do?

You should let Mijo know. He's mysteriously not said another word about how there is "no 'the program,'" since I showed him that AA's own literature uses the term.

Her use of that specific clause from my post implies that I that there was no Program at all. Anyone with third-grade reading comprehension skill could see that I was emphasizing the fact that "the program" implies that there is one single program, which there is not. Consequently I was pointing out for slingblade the hard-of-reading that each person's program is particular to that specific person: some may involve the Twelves Steps; some may not.

Do you see how the way she portrayed my post is nothing like what I actually said?

How is that not a textbook case of a quote mine?

I'm ignoring his posts now myself Slingblade - he's acting like some 17 yr old kid with 20 days of sobriety who just knows all about AA. In reality, I'm quite sure he spends most of his time living in fear (normally such a thing would make me sympathetic, but his unwillingness to learn, his apparently closed-solid mind, and his tendency to attack anyone who disagrees with him leaves him with no sympathy from me).

Uh...I have never claimed to know anything more than anyone else about AA. I did not remember that you had said that you had said that you had had 20 years or more experience with AA when I suggested you go to an open meeting, and for that, I apologize.

That said, what I have objected to about your posts since is the tendency that you seem to have to universalize your experience in AA and claim that, because you had certain experiences with religiosity in AA, AA must be religious through and through. All I have done is relate my own personal experiences in my first 32 days of sobriety, emphasize that they run contrary to yours, and question you attempts at universalization.

Why do you consider that so annoying?
 
Last edited:
Anything would be a good start.

Then it shouldn't be a problem for you.

The problem is though Belz, that anything produced will be individual opinions; it will have nothing to do with AA as a whole.

I too know of people in AA who spout "the pills are for dills" rubbish. I think I have told this story before but it bears repeating:

A new sponsee came to me last year - I will call him Bob, he is three years or so sober. He is a delightful chap, an innocent in many ways and perhaps a little naive. As we were talking one night he asked me when he thought his anxiety would disappear. To that point I didn't realise it was or had been a problem for him; save for a bit of shyness you wouldn't know.
Anyway, I asked him what his doctor had said. He told me his doctor had prescribed him some anti-depressants to which I responded: "Good, have you just started them, then?". Bob tells me he was prescribed them about two years ago and that "no, he has never taken them". When I question him as to why, he tells me because he heard from the floor and a previous sponsor the "pills are for dills" nonsense and inferred that this meant no prescription meds either.

I asked Bob what he thought AA stood for, he responded with the correct answer. I pointed out strongly that AA does not stand for Anxiety anonymous, nor broken legs anonymous. I told Bob about a friend of mine who got to AA after breaking his leg when drunk; it was one of the final straws for him to take action and he started coming to AA on crutches. I asked Bob whether he thought AA would fix his broken leg; obviously he said "No". I further explained that we often have issues that predate our alcoholism and some issues that have come sbout because of it. They do not just magic away because we get sober; many times they even get worse before we see improvement and many times it is a case of ongoing or even lifetime management. In other words, I expalined that we need to get professional help from professionals for other problems and do the work we need to assist in getting well.

Bob is now on his meds, working closely with his doctor (and sponsor) and is doing really well.

Another AA success story.

AA is not and never was designed to replace psychology medicine, etc. Some people seem to think it an panacea within AA, and some people out of AA thinks AA makes this claim. Both are wrong.
 
I may be missing something important about Joey's arguments, but as far as them being "anecdotal" goes...if no one has conducted a study, and all we have to go on are the stories of the members themselves, then I don't see why such stories should be dismissed as mere anecdotes.

After all, when someone does conduct such a study for such a group, what they're doing is compiling anecdotes.

I entered the search terms Joey suggested, and the first link that popped up does confirm that a certain--and seemingly somewhat large--number of recovering people relate that they've been discouraged from seeking that sort of help. Anti-depressant help. That's wrong.

I'm happy to show some excerpts, that I hope won't be taken as mere "quote mining." We're not allowed to reprint articles in their entirety here, so an excerpt is all I can post. You want to see the rest of it, I'll give the links where I find them, and you can read the pages for yourselves. And you should, if information is what you're really seeking.


http://www.draonline.org/medications.html

"...A.A. members and many of their physicians have described situations in which depressed patients have been told by A.A.s to throw away the pills, only to have depression return with all its difficulties, sometimes resulting in suicide. We have heard, too, from schizophrenics, manic depressives, epileptics, and others requiring medication that well-meaning A.A. friends often discourage them from taking prescribed medication, Unfortunately, by following a layman's advice, the sufferers find that their conditions can return with all their previous intensity..."

"It becomes clear that just as it is wrong to enable or support any alcoholic to become readdicted to any drug, it's equally wrong to deprive any alcoholic of medication which can alleviate or control other disabling physical and/or emotional problems."
Reprinted from The A.A. Member - Medications & Other Drugs, with permission of A.A. World Services, Inc.

This article goes on to talk about how AA and NA members could handle such misguided "advice."

This next page has some disturbing accounts. I will quote one, but you should read the whole page. There are citations and footnotes at the bottom, which usually indicates the author has done more than just "listen to random anecdotes." Within those footnotes is a cite for the book Joey's been talking about, AA Horror Stories. I think that book deserves a look, as well.

http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-coffee.html

In a cult checklist web page, [2] we read:

...an Elder with 35 years told a newcomer, a young man, his sobriety was no good because he was taking medication for high blood pressure. The newcomer, on the advice of the Elder, quit his medication, had a stroke, and is now crippled for life.

Now that's grim. And there are even more grim stories, far too many stories of people with mental problems being talked into quitting their medications, and then committing suicide.3 I recently talked with yet another ex-member old-timer, who has been in and out of A.A. for 30 years, who quit in anger, and hates A.A., because other old-timer sponsors kept telling mental cases to quit taking their medications, and then those sad cases committed suicide. His parting words to those A.A. members, after another funeral, were:
"Well, before you guys got ahold of him, at least he could say his own name.
But when you were done with him, he couldn't even do that."

Again, please go read the whole page. My excerpt isn't enough, and folks should do the follow-up, if evidence is what they seek. There are some disturbing words about halfway down the page; words that really make me angry:

And the evidence also suggests that there may eventually be a cure for some people, or some kinds of "alcoholism", or at least an effective medical treatment. We have reason to be optimistic. But that is a direct violation of a dearly-held A.A. tenet. One of the core components of A.A. dogma is the idea that alcoholism is incurable. Because modern medicine has no cure and the situation is hopeless, the only answer, they say, is to try the supernatural solution: surrender yourself to God, and practice the Twelve Steps and go to meetings forever, and hope that God will keep you sober.

But now modern medicine threatens to upset the apple cart.

Really, someone in A.A. should have seen this one coming. The A.A. Big Book has always described alcoholism as a disease,
"an actual disease that had a name and symptoms like diabetes or cancer or TB."
(The Big Book, 3rd Edition, page 227; 4th edition, page 205.)
Well, we have medical treatments for all of those other actual diseases, even cancer, and none of the treatments for those other diseases involves prayer and confessions, or going to meetings for the rest of your life... With those other "actual" diseases, you don't see articles written by A.A. and N.A. boosters, talking about the necessity of treating the patients' mind, body, and spirit by sending the patients to A.A. and N.A. meetings for the "beneficial effects".6 The New Yorker article said that some people are coming to believe that the Twelve-Step treatment for alcoholism will soon be obsoleted. (No joke, and I'll add that some other people, like the American Medical Association, thought that it was "obsolete" quackery the day that it got started.)

That's all I'm going to present, because this all deviates from the topic at hand: "Is AA a religiously oriented program?"

But Joey has a point, damn it, and it should be paid some respect.
 
Rather than throwing several pages of discussion into AAH and handing out a batch of yellow cards, I have decided to give an official moderator warning. Address the argument and not the arguer, and be civil and polite. Any further incivility and/or bickering will be considered violating a mod directive and will be actioned. Thank you for your anticipated cooperation.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jhunter1163
 
That's all I'm going to present, because this all deviates from the topic at hand: "Is AA a religiously oriented program?"

But Joey has a point, damn it, and it should be paid some respect.

He does have a point I agree. But the counter to it is that it is not AA that advocates throwing away the meds; it is misguided individuals and they are fools imho. Slowly but surely AA (through efforts of people like myself and dare I say Tinyal) are trying to educate one and all.

In fact, to the best of my knowledge, AA makes no comment on meds nor psychiatric/psychological treatment in any capacity whatsoever. And unless Joey can show same, he cannot claim that AA is anything of the sort.
 
He does have a point I agree. But the counter to it is that it is not AA that advocates throwing away the meds; it is misguided individuals and they are fools imho. Slowly but surely AA (through efforts of people like myself and dare I say Tinyal) are trying to educate one and all.

In fact, to the best of my knowledge, AA makes no comment on meds nor psychiatric/psychological treatment in any capacity whatsoever. And unless Joey can show same, he cannot claim that AA is anything of the sort.


That's fair of you to say, but I will make one point:

If people in, the members of, AA are doing these things, against AA's desires or wishes for the recovery program, then AA needs to take matters in hand and do their best to put a stop to it.

It doesn't matter if AA sanctions this kind of behavior or not; if the members are doing it, then it is part of AA; a rogue part that shouldn't be there.

Now, if the AA organization is working on it, great. More power to them. But if they're not practicing due diligence, they're being neglectful, and causing people to be hurt.

That you and Tinyal are working to change such things is good. Keep up that good work.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom