Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Really? I never said you said I was superfluous, but you most certainly endeavoured to insult my intelligence. I give and take a lot in these forums, it's part of the process; but I will rarely have a crack at someone who isn't trying it on with me first. It seems a lot to me like you were.

Slingblade did no such thing, I have been rude and confrontational to you at times, Slingblade has not. Using reductio ad absurdum is not a insult to your intelligence, it is a logical extension of a point or argument until it breaks.
 
Last edited:
Thank you, David. I didn't think I had been insulting of Alfie's intellect.

But one thing I've come to realize over the years is that once your words leave your lips (or fingers) you have no control over how they are perceived.

So, that I didn't intend to be insulting doesn't mean he didn't feel insulted. All I can do is explain I didn't intend insult, and apologize. I have done so.

But thank you for the support!
 
I still baffled at the apparent inability of those arguing that AA is a religious organization to critically, or even accurately engage some of the passages that the insist mean that AA is religious.

For instance, they see the word "God" in the Steps but do not address the phrase that immediately follows: "as we understand Him". Similarly, they have repeatedly misquoted the second item in what Tinyal has called the ABCs. They write it as "No human power could have relieved us of our alcoholism", whereas it is actually written as "Probably no human power could have relieved us of our alcoholism".

God (as we know Him) I've beaten (addressed) this ridiculous assertion to death on this thread.

Did you notice that the phrase "as we understood" is followed immediately by Capital H "Him?." This is a big fat clue that undermines the the whole phrase, it refers back to the Capital G "God" at the beginning of the phrase, thus rendering the phrase "as we understood" completely meaningless.

In other words, this is a (poor & sophistic) attempt to semi-universalize the Programme. It means that one is still forced to conclude that God is a Male Supernatural Monotheistic Deity--which is perfect for Christians, Muslims, and Jews.

And it becomes clear that this Male Supernatural Deity as Personal God that one can appeal to:

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.
11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.

So the Male Supernatural Deity is clearly being invoked in #6 and #7, only He can save you from your "defects of character" and "shortcomings," which is to say only He can save you from Sin.

And just in case the stubborn still refuse to acknowledge that only God can save them from their Sins, #11 asserts that they can achieve a two way communication with the Male Supernatural Deity and subsume themselves to God's Will, thus completing the task of of #3

This blows up any notion that one's Higher Power is: a Rock or a doorknob or a volleyball or a blow-up doll. Only God has a Will that a mortal's will must be subsumed to.

I'm Still Baffled that Atheist and Agnostic AAer's REFUSE to acknowledge that AA is a Religious programme. The only way they can do that is to pretend that it isn't. This is a blatant Dishonesty that they have deluded themselves with.

The only people to inaccurately and critically engage the passages, and take them out of context, are the non-Theistic AAer's, who are getting themselves deeper and deeper into a Religious Mind-Set without even having the self-awareness that this is what is happening to them.

This is how Religious Thinking destroys rationality, unless one is Religious to begin with. Those who are used to being Religious have no problem compartmentalizing their Rational and Religious selves.

This is only a problem for the non-Theist who is forced to experience Cognitive Dissonance.

GB
 
Last edited:
But that wasn't Joey McGee's point in his response to what I had said. He insisted that because AA started as a "religious cult" it is still a religious cult today.



I don't know, and it is frankly irrelevant to my point, because, as stated above,
Joey McGee was saying that AA was religious because its origins were religious.
That is a textbook genetic fallacy.

Regardless of what McGee said, AA is not merely Religious because of it's Origins, but because it is still Religious today as the Sacred Texts of AA are still front and center of the Programme.

This has been proved time and time again on this thread. I know it is far too long for anyone to read in one sitting. But it's worth giving it a go, a few pages at a time.

GB
 
I'm baffled as to how you cannot see that your post is one huge genetic fallacy.

Is Planned Parenthood today a racist organization because Margaret Sanger advocated selectively sterilization poor, inner-city blacks?

Actually, the unsupported charge of Margaret Sanger's alleged Racism is based on the False Claims of the Anti-Abortion movement's Propaganda.

It's a crying shame that you chose to look up "genetic fallacy" on Wikipedia instead of Margaret Sanger, or you wouldn't have made this ridiculous assertion.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Sanger

Legacy

Margaret Sanger Square, NYC.

Sanger remains a controversial figure. While she is widely credited as a leader of the modern birth control movement, and remains an iconic figure for the American reproductive rights movements, pro-life groups condemn Sanger's views, attributing her efforts to promote birth control to a desire to "purify" the human race through eugenics, and even to eliminate minority races by placing birth control clinics in minority neighborhoods.[36] Despite allegations of racism,[37] Sanger's work with minorities earned the respect of some civil rights leaders such as Martin Luther King, Jr. according to Planned Parenthood Federation of America.[38] In their biographical article about Margaret Sanger, Planned Parenthood notes:

In 1930, Sanger opened a family planning clinic in Harlem that sought to enlist support for contraceptive use and to bring the benefits of family planning to women who were denied access to their city's health and social services. Staffed by a black physician and black social worker, the clinic was endorsed by The Amsterdam News (the powerful local newspaper), the Abyssinian Baptist Church, the Urban League, and the black community's elder statesman, W. E. B. Du Bois.[39]

In 1957, the American Humanist Association named her Humanist of the Year. A residential building is named after her on the Stony Brook University campus. A room in Wellesley College's library is named after her.[40] Margaret Sanger Square is the leafy intersection of Mott Street and Bleecker Street in New York City's Greenwich Village.[41]

Sanger's story has been the subject of films, including Choices of the Heart: The Margaret Sanger Story starring Dana Delany and Henry Czerny,[42] and Margaret Sanger: A Public Nuisance (1992).[43]

But while we are on the subject of racism, eugenics, and the fascist ideals associated with them, we should examine the Oxford Group from which AA emerged. The conflation of Disease with Sin was coined by the Oxford Group and was carried on by AA.

The contention that AA and the Oxford group split over AA's position that God could not Cure Alcoholism but only help the Alcoholic control it--as opposed to the Oxford Group's belief that the Cure was complete--is actually not entirely correct. Especially as Dr Silkworth prescribed Jesus ("The Great Physician") as a Cure for Alcoholism.

The actual split was more nuanced than that. The split occurred due to AA's belief that the Cure (God's Grace) had to be reinforced on a regular basis--One Day at a Time--or risk falling out of God's Grace. The Oxford Group contended that the Cure (God's Grace) was permanent, and one could not fall out of it. This mirrors the divisions in the Protestant Denominations, in which some believed that God's Grace was permanent and that others believed that God's Grace needed to be reinforced regularly to stay within God's Grace.

Why is the emergence of AA from the Oxford Group important? The following should make that clear:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford_Group#Nazi_leaders

Nazi leaders

At the beginning of the 1930s, Buchman kept in close touch with Germans active in the Oxford Group. Adolf Hitler had, at first, presented himself as a defender of Christianity, declaring in 1928, "We shall not tolerate in our ranks anyone who hurts Christian ideas". Buchman was convinced that without a change in the heart of the National Socialist regime, a world war would become inevitable. He also believed that any person, including the German leaders, could find a living Christian faith with a commitment to Christ's moral values.[25]

Moni von Crammon, a German member of the Oxford Group, was the invited guest of Heinrich Himmler for the Nuremberg Rally and she in turn invited Frank Buchman. Moni and Frank sat beside Heinrich Himmler at an informal luncheon, where they discussed religion and politics. Due to his family background, Frank Buchman spoke German fluently. Buchman and von Crammon attended two of the Nazi Party rallies, one in 1934 and the other in 1935. Von Crammon later claimed after the war, that her association with Himmler came as a result of her seeking him out in the matter of her possible arrest, due to a piece of literature that was construed as anti-Nazi, found in her possession by a maid.[26]

In August 1936, Frank Buchman was Heinrich Himmler's guest at the Berlin Olympics. Buchman offered to introduce British Member of Parliament Kenneth Lindsay to Himmler, referring to Himmler as "a great lad".[27] Buchman added that Hitler himself was being most helpful to the Group: "He lets us have house-parties whenever we like". Buchman did not seem to think much of England or of Canada: England was in a terrible state — "seething with Communism"; and so was Canada. Lindsay disagreed: he thought that such an assessment showed that Buchman really knew very little about England or Canada.[28] Oxford group member Garth Lean writes in his book that according to Buchman's young followers who went with him, Himmler came in with his henchmen, gave a propagandist account of Nazism and left, without giving Buchman a chance to speak.[29] Lean also cites a Danish reporter, Jacob Kronika, who in January 1962 gave an account in a small newspaper he edited, the Flensborg Avis, of a meeting in Berlin with Frank Buchman:
Frank Buchman when Buchman stayed at the Hotel Esplanade in Berlin. One day we ate lunch together. In the afternoon he was to have a conversation with SS Chief Himmler, who had invited Dr Buchman to come and see him. The conversation, of course, became a complete fiasco. Himmler could not, as he intended, exploit the 'absolute obedience' of the MRA people towards God for the benefit of the obedient slaves of the SS and the Nazis.

The British Foreign Office had a different report. In a confidential minute dated 16 January 1939, Makins records impressions Dr Burckhardt had gained from his recent talks in Berlin. Asked whether he thought Himmler should be included among the extremists or the moderates of the Nazis, Dr Burckhardt said Himmler had been very much disgusted by the anti-Semitic outrages. He said Himmler was ‘a very curious character' and that both he and his wife were members of the Oxford Group.[30]

Frank Buchman expressed concerns, stating, "Germany has come under the dominion of a terrible demoniac force. A counter-action is urgent. We must ask God for guidance and strength to start an anti-demoniac counter-action under the sign of the Cross of Christ in the democratic countries bordering on Germany, especially in the small neighboring countries."[31]
In 1936 Buchman had hope that Germany could be diverted from its course.
When he returned from the Berlin Olympics he gave an interview to the New York World-Telegram.

"I thank Heaven for a man like Adolf Hitler, who built a front line of defense against the anti-Christ of Communism," he said today in his book-lined office in the annex of Calvary Church, Fourth Ave and 21st St. "My barber in London told me Hitler Nazis do Anti-Semitism? Bad, naturally. I suppose Hitler sees a Karl Marx in every Jew. But think what it would mean to the world if Hitler surrendered to the control of God. Or Mussolini. Or any dictator. Through such a man God could control a nation overnight and solve every last, bewildering problem. The world won't listen to God, but God has a plan for every person, for every nation. The world needs the dictatorship of the living spirit of God. I like to put it this way: God is a perpetual broadcasting station and all you need to do is tune in. What we need is a supernatural network of live wires across the world to every last man, in every last place, in every last situation... Human ingenuity is not enough. That is why the isms are pitted against each other and blood falls. Spain has taught us what godless Communism will bring. Who would have dreamed that nuns would be running naked in the streets? Human problems aren't economic. They're moral and they can't be solved by immoral measures. They could be solved within a God-controlled democracy, or perhaps I should say a theocracy, and they could be solved through a God-controlled Fascist dictatorship."[32][33]

The Rev. Garrett Stearly, one of Buchman's colleagues from Princeton University, said statements were taken out of context. When Buchman was asked about Germany, he said that Germany needed a new Christian spirit, yet one had to face the fact that Hitler had been a bulwark against Communism there - and you could at least thank heaven for that.[34]
The Oxford Group held a rally in Stockbridge, Massachusetts where the Marchers in the parade carried the flags of 48 States and 18 nations, including Germany's swastika. A negative comment on this drew the response that "the Oxford Group bring nations together".[35]

Of the thousands of Gestapo documents made available after the war[36] Oxford Group member Garth Lean found only three that concerned the Oxford Group. One suggests the Group was "a new and dangerous opponent of National Socialism". Another states it preaches revolution against the national state and has quite evidently become its Christian opponent. The third, from 1942, says "No other Christian movement has underlined so strongly the character of Christianity as being supernational and independent of all racial barriers... It tries fanatically to make all men into brothers". Lean claims the information source is a file called Die Oxford- oder Gruppenbewegung, Herausgegeben vom Sicherheitshauptamt, November 1936", Geheim, Nummeriertes Exemplar Nr. 1".[37]

In 1938, after another Nuremberg rally and the Anschluss, Oxford Group members telephoned both Diana Mosley and her sister Unity Mitford, who were in Munich at the time attending the celebrations. The Oxford members requested an invitation and introduction to Adolf Hitler, for the purpose of "changing" him. The request was refused by both Unity and Diana. Later that same evening Oxford Group members phoned Unity's father, Lord Redesdale, who was also visiting Munich, making the same request. His reply was “no, damn it, I like the feller the way he is.”[38] Travel writer and journalist Robert Byron, who had persuaded Hitler's English admirer Unity (Bobo) Mitford, to include him in her party, entered in his diary: "Himmler apparently dotes on the Oxford Group and writes to its English members discussing their troubles with them".[39]

According to Oxford group member Garth Lean, during the war, the Oxford Group in Germany divided into three parts. Some submitted to Himmler's demand that they cut all links with Buchman and the Oxford Group abroad. The largest group continued the work of bringing Christian change to people under a different name, Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Seelsorge (Working team for the Care of Souls), without being involved in politics and always subject to surveillance. A third group joined the active opposition. Moni von Crammon's son-in-law was one of those executed along with Adam von Trott zu Solz[40][41] They were executed under Hitler's orders after the 20 July plot.
Buchman's attempts to convert the Nazi leadership was condemned by Dietrich Bonhoeffer who wrote: "The Oxford Group has been naïve enough to try to convert Hitler - a ridiculous failure to understand what is going on - it is we who are to be converted, not Hitler."[42]

A report from the Social and Industrial Council of the Church of England also condemned Buchman's approach in dealing with the Nazi regime, It stated: "It was surely this that led Dr. Buchman, so it is alleged, to believe that through 'change' induced in Hitler there could come a 'God-controlled fascist dictatorship.' His error was not so much that his appraisal of Hitler was so naive... but that he failed to see... that dictatorship is not bad just because it has a bad man as dictator."[43]

ETA: The emergence of AA from the Oxford Group is the one detail about AA's history that Dick B attempts to play down. The reason is, of course, quite obvious.



GB
 
Last edited:
Thank you, David. I didn't think I had been insulting of Alfie's intellect.

But one thing I've come to realize over the years is that once your words leave your lips (or fingers) you have no control over how they are perceived.

So, that I didn't intend to be insulting doesn't mean he didn't feel insulted. All I can do is explain I didn't intend insult, and apologize. I have done so.

But thank you for the support!

For some reason I have reacted poorly to AA Alfie many times and I have been rude and confrontational, then I end up apologising. Your words seemed to be moderate.
 
God (as we know Him) I've beaten (addressed) this ridiculous assertion to death on this thread.

Did you notice that the phrase "as we understood" is followed immediately by Capital H "Him?." This is a big fat clue that undermines the the whole phrase, it refers back to the Capital G "God" at the beginning of the phrase, thus rendering the phrase "as we understood" completely meaningless.

In other words, this is a (poor & sophistic) attempt to semi-universalize the Programme. It means that one is still forced to conclude that God is a Male Supernatural Monotheistic Deity--which is perfect for Christians, Muslims, and Jews.

And it becomes clear that this Male Supernatural Deity as Personal God that one can appeal to:

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.
11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.

So the Male Supernatural Deity is clearly being invoked in #6 and #7, only He can save you from your "defects of character" and "shortcomings," which is to say only He can save you from Sin.

And just in case the stubborn still refuse to acknowledge that only God can save them from their Sins, #11 asserts that they can achieve a two way communication with the Male Supernatural Deity and subsume themselves to God's Will, thus completing the task of of #3

This blows up any notion that one's Higher Power is: a Rock or a doorknob or a volleyball or a blow-up doll. Only God has a Will that a mortal's will must subsumed to.

I'm Still Baffled that Atheist and Agnostic AAer's REFUSE to acknowledge that AA is a Religious programme. The only way they can do that is to pretend that it isn't. This is a blatant Dishonesty that they have deluded themselves with.

The only people to inaccurately and critically engage the passages, and take them out of context, are the non-Theistic AAer's, who are getting themselves deeper and deeper into a Religious Mind-Set without even having the self-awareness that this is what is happening to them.

This is how Religious Thinking destroys rationality, unless one is Religious to begin with. Those who are used to being Religious have no problem compartmentalizing their Rational and Religious selves.

This is only a problem for the non-Theist who is forced to experience Cognitive Dissonance.

GB

Ah....the classic arm-chair psychologist's diagnosis of "cognitive dissonance". It sweeps away any reason to consider the interlocutor's position as being logically valid. What a convenience.

The issue here is that you and those who argue similarly to you see the word "God" a insist that it must mean the exact same thing to everyone who uses it. It is quite clear from the ordering and wording of the Steps that "God" is a shorthand for the "Power greater than oneself", and not necessarily anything more than that.

A "Power greater than oneself" does not have to be supernatural; it just has to be something that one just cannot control or create by oneself. What is completely perplexing to me is that those arguing that a "Power greater than oneself" is inherently religious cannot simply think of one thing that is greater than their individual selves.

Can pedestrians really guarantee that, for instance, the next time they step off the corner at a busy intersection when the right-of-way is theirs that they will not be struck by a car?

There are certainly specific thing that can be done to minimize the risk of getting hit by a car, but there is simply no guarantee that, for instance, a careless driver making a right turn will only see the green light and run them down even if they have the right-of-way. Sure, pedestrians can wait until there are no cars waiting to make a right turn, but isn't that implicitly admitting that the circumstances that lead a driver to be inattentive at an intersection when both the driver and the pedestrian have the right-of-way with respect to cross traffic make it more risky for the pedestrian to continue to cross into the intersection and are essentially out of the pedestrian's control, even though the pedestrian has the legal right-of-way?
 
Ah....the classic arm-chair psychologist's diagnosis of "cognitive dissonance". It sweeps away any reason to consider the interlocutor's position as being logically valid. What a convenience.

The issue here is that you and those who argue similarly to you see the word "God" a insist that it must mean the exact same thing to everyone who uses it. It is quite clear from the ordering and wording of the Steps that "God" is a shorthand for the "Power greater than oneself", and not necessarily anything more than that.

A "Power greater than oneself" does not have to be supernatural; it just has to be something that one just cannot control or create by oneself. What is completely perplexing to me is that those arguing that a "Power greater than oneself" is inherently religious cannot simply think of one thing that is greater than their individual selves.

Can pedestrians really guarantee that, for instance, the next time they step off the corner at a busy intersection when the right-of-way is theirs that they will not be struck by a car?

There are certainly specific thing that can be done to minimize the risk of getting hit by a car, but there is simply no guarantee that, for instance, a careless driver making a right turn will only see the green light and run them down even if they have the right-of-way. Sure, pedestrians can wait until there are no cars waiting to make a right turn, but isn't that implicitly admitting that the circumstances that lead a driver to be inattentive at an intersection when both the driver and the pedestrian have the right-of-way with respect to cross traffic make it more risky for the pedestrian to continue to cross into the intersection and are essentially out of the pedestrian's control, even though the pedestrian has the legal right-of-way?

Sophistry!

If you don't want to admit that AA is religious, fine. Just don't expect anyone else to buy your arguments.

I've got the Evidence in Black and White. You are only bringing pseudo-philosophy to the table.

GB
 
In all seriousness, the Power greater than oneself/Higher Power/God does not have to be omnipotent; all it has to be is more powerful than the person who believes in it.

But that's the crux of the problem. If you are believing that there is a Deity more Powerful than Yourself, then you are no longer an Atheist. Whether you regard that Deity as omnipotent is beside the question.

I really don't understand why those arguing that AA is religious seem to think that admitting that one doesn't control the workings of the entire universe or even their small corner of the Earth is inherently religious.

This is a befuddling argument. If you think that someone DOES control the workings of the Universe, then you are no longer an atheist, and you are now religious.

Which is fine. I'm not against religious people per se. I am against people pretending they are not religious. And I am against people imposing their religious beliefs on others.

GB
 
I didn't know pointing out sophistry was an insult.

It is when what you are calling "sophistry" is not in fact sophistry. The post of mine that called sophistry was an illustration that there are situations in everyday life the outcomes of which any given individual cannot control. In short, there are powers greater than humans that humans deal with on a regular basis.

I believe that these powers do not in turn have a single entity or a group of entities controlling them, but that does not change that such powers are not in the control of humans. Coming to believe that one in particular cannot control one's addiction on one's own through one's own power (whatever that in itself maybe), but that there are ways that one can control one's addiction by looking outside of oneself is essentailly what the Second Step says in fewer words.

The only person I insult on this thread is the dude that regularly insults anyone who disagrees with him.

I don't see you insulting yourself at all.

And I don't know what "refusing to present it" means. What have I refused to present?

You have not presented any evidence that one must conceive of God in the way that the Big Book demonstrates that Bill W does in order to work the Steps or benefit in any way from AA. All that you have presented indisputably is that the Big Book demonstrates that Bill W had a conception of God that in compatible with atheism.
 
Last edited:
It is when what you are calling "sophistry" is not in fact sophistry. The post of mine that called sophistry was an illustration that there are situations in everyday life the outcomes of which any given individual cannot control. In short, there are powers greater than humans that humans deal with on a regular basis.

I believe that these powers do not in turn have a single entity or a group of entities controlling them, but that does not change that such power are not in the control of human. Coming to believe that one in particular cannot control one's addiction on one's own through one's own power (whatever that in itself maybe), but that there are ways that one can control one's addiction by looking outside of oneself is essentailly what the Second Step says in fewer words.

It is sophistry to declare that your own anecdotal personal feelings are evidence that AA isn't Religious.

I don't see you insulting yourself at all.

That's because I only insult Alfie, who is always down for a little flame war once in a while. Which is why we've kind of been ignoring each other this go round.

The only other person I've insulted on this thread is Dymanic, and he's not around for me to kick anymore.

You have not presented any evidence that one must conceive of God in the way that the Big Book demonstrates that Bill W does in order to work the Steps or benefit in any way from AA.

But I have demonstrated that AA is Religious. Whatever floats your boat is fine by me. You can postulate whatever you want in order to make AA work for you. I don't have a problem with that.

Again, my problem is when people think that their own personal experience counts as evidence to prove that AA isn't Religious.

All that you have presented indisputably is that the Big Book demonstrates that Bill W had a conception of God that in compatible with atheism.

I'm not certain if you mean "is compatible" or "incompatible." I know it's just a typo, but the contexts are completely different.

But the fact is that the Big Book and the 12 Steps ARE incompatible with Atheism. That you choose not to acknowledge that is your own issue to deal with.


GB
 
Fair enough, though interpretation isn't the question.

In fact I think it is exactly the question: Individual interpretation of what a HP is, PGTO is, or God is. What the program is, what works for me, or whether alcohol and my behaviour are linked and problematic.

These are all things that I must interpret and decide for myself. No-one ese has to do it for me.

Are there still social scientists calling for that in this day and age? Because the problems I have detailed, the links I have posted, the testimonies I have quoted, the people I talk to on a regular basis, this stuff is all still happening today.

Sure, but oince again you apply black and white thinking, all or nothing. To tar all of AA with the same brush because of a certain number is not accurate. I think they call it cherry picking. :rolleyes:

AA is not a professional organization, they should have professionals running things and an accountability program

When they call themselves a professional organisation, perhpas that's when they will hire professionals. It then becomes something completely different to a self help group.

Tradition 8 covers that:

"Alcoholics Anonymous should remain forever nonprofessional, but our service centers may employ special workers."

Traditions here:

http://www.prismnet.com/aamen/trad.html

You haven't responded to any of my arguments properly (small sample Alfie?). AA is anti-psychiatry, always was, and still is in many places, and your defense to this is that it's not on their website.

AA is not anti psychiatry. If it is you could no doubt prove it. So far you have nothing but anecdotes, I could provide opposing anecdotes no problem. But neither constitutes proof.


AA has no opinion on This is INSANE Alfie,

No, it's "policy". You really should familiarise yourself with the traditions.

Tradition 10: "Alcoholics Anonymous has no opinion on outside issues; hence the A.A. name ought never be drawn into public controversy."

So what is AAs policy on psychiatry? Anything mentioned on same by anyone belong to the individual, not AA.

No, the lady from a few pages ago, nice counselling work there bucko.

I didn't realise I was addressing a client.
I am also curious, just what do you think counsellors and therapists do? Sit there and pay lip service, confirming every thought a client has? Many times in a session a decent counsellor will challenge the thoughts, values, the conditioning of a lifetimetime etc that a client has to give them new insights into themselves and others.

So I ask again, what do you think a counsellor does?

That aside, I was asking some genuine questions. It was not my intention to insult, but to challenge thinking.

So far all of your attacks on me have failed miserably and you can't dispute a word of what I said.

Someone bring in the laughing dog please?

I do and can dispute nearly all of you have said. So far you have provided proof of nothing - if anything, you have provided us with more arguments against your views than for them.

And yet you can't complete the program if you don't do the 12 steps.

Which/whose program?
Where does anything or anyone say this?
 
Last edited:
Sure, but oince again you apply black and white thinking, all or nothing. To tar all of AA with the same brush because of a certain number is not accurate. I think they call it cherry picking. :rolleyes:
No. That's my argument against you, reversed. You can't hide in your idealized version of what AA is, I already said there are meetings that are more like support groups and harmless cults. The point isn't that it's impossible to transcend what the program is, it's that people aren't even recognizing what it actually is, and the problems that result from it's format and structure, it's memetic menome, there are many kinds of it don't you know?

Your flaw is that you use the exceptions, and try to argue that it's changed, when I don't dispute that there are exceptions and some have changed, especially in the bigger cities, I've pointed all of this out so you should know not to use that argument against me. My point is that there's something about the history and the format that lends to all of this horrible, unacceptable crap. Midtown group is just a really horrible example of what can happen. That stuff happens in a spectrum across all of AA and it's because of it's nature!! It's a dangerous thing. Better have something scientific and secular take over, at least they test themselves, hold themselves accountable, try and learn, etc, prevent abuse and mind control from developing.

These problems I am outlining should have been corrected for, but AA wants to keep everything the same, it's cult blueprint, it's memetic virus DNA if you will, that's what it is. If AA started out as a professional organization, those kinds of things wouldn't have happened. It's a lesson in history that shouldn't be forgotten. And the fact that it's hurting anyone at all to this day is an outrage, and if you want to stand in front of people understanding these dangers and tendencies of this organism, just to apologize for your idealized version of reality, that's an outrage too.

You have to do a lot of interpretation to make it sound not ridiculous, just like Christianity apologetics. It's not funny because it's so misleading but it's very ridiculous. If people want to play with that who cares, what's unacceptable is chastizing people for handing out the correct version of history, what aa has done, who it has hurt, why, and how to prevent it. How dishonorable to apologize for all that just to save the face of the modern version.

When they call themselves a professional organisation, perhpas that's when they will hire professionals. It then becomes something completely different to a self help group.
That's not what it is. It's mental technology and you can test it scientifically, it failed. Cochrane review, if you haven't read it, you won't understand what the problems are so you can change it.

Tradition 8 covers that:

"Alcoholics Anonymous should remain forever nonprofessional, but our service centers may employ special workers."
Then stop making claims and giving advice for people to follow. AA is testable by science and if you're giving people that, that's a professional function, medicine, for the disease, so, doublethink is everywhere in AA.

So a lady goes crazy for her sponsee joining a soccer team. A guy's sponser tells him who he can talk to. Are you going to apologize for that too? This kind of thing doesn't happen in other kinds of programs because there's no where for this memetic disease to grow, it's too clean. AA is like ancient technology.
AA is not anti psychiatry. If it is you could no doubt prove it. So far you have nothing but anecdotes, I could provide opposing anecdotes no problem. But neither constitutes proof.
Whatever Alfie anyone who actually cares enough about this issue can google around and ask people in AA if they've heard people speak about that at meetings or heard people who think that. There are thousands of anecdotes on the internet from that. The fact is that it's a faith healing cult and that goes along with anti-medication, it's a breeding ground for woo because of that. The belief is passed around within the organization memeticly because people are doing everything their sponser believes. That's the facts, ask around, it used to be a hardcore debate, and has only gotten better in the last decade. It was anti-psychiatry from the start that's it's history which anyone can confirm easily for themselves. You're holding up your idealized vision, I have no problem with that, you can't deny the documentation of history and the commonality of these problems today, you can't dispute a single claim I've made.

No, it's "policy". You really should familiarise yourself with the traditions.

Tradition 10: "Alcoholics Anonymous has no opinion on outside issues; hence the A.A. name ought never be drawn into public controversy."

So what is AAs policy on psychiatry? Anything mentioned on same by anyone belong to the individual, not AA.
Pffft some excuses you're making for what actually happens and is well known about this cult. The even spent like 5 minutes on it in the AA bashing episode of penn and teller, quoting major people which is on youtube and is hilarious by the way.

I didn't realise I was addressing a client.
No, a human being, who you're basically insulting by insinuating that her husband is actually better off without her. At least that's what I thought, besides the fact you're just overapologizing for your cult picking on someone sharing a personal anecdote.
I am also curious, just what do you think counsellors and therapists do? Sit there and pay lip service, confirming every thought a client has? Many times in a sessions a decent counsellor will challenge the thoughts, values, the condioning of a lifetimetime etc that a client has to give them new insights into themselves and others. I've been to and know some counsellors

So I ask again, what do ou think a counsellor does?

That aside, I was asking some genuine questions. It was not my intention to insult.
A counsellor's job is to leave a person better than when they met them and act peacefully at all times. Challenging and questioning can be world's apart, as in your approach, language, and tone. I don't think challenging is appropriate if that's your idea of challenging.

I do and can dispute nearly all of you have said. So far you have provided proof of nothing - if anything, you have provided us with more arguments against your views than for them.
So take the time and dispute one thing I have actually said, quoting my actual words, and we'll see about that.

Asking me to "prove AA is the majority" is ridiculous. It's like asking me to prove that the sky is blue, it's beyond ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
It is when what you are calling "sophistry" is not in fact sophistry. The post of mine that called sophistry was an illustration that there are situations in everyday life the outcomes of which any given individual cannot control. In short, there are powers greater than humans that humans deal with on a regular basis.

The power you cited greater than yourself was a car running a light that then hit you. This is the kind of power you mean? Random chance?

I believe that these powers do not in turn have a single entity or a group of entities controlling them, but that does not change that such powers are not in the control of humans. Coming to believe that one in particular cannot control one's addiction on one's own through one's own power (whatever that in itself maybe), but that there are ways that one can control one's addiction by looking outside of oneself is essentailly what the Second Step says in fewer words.

Yours is the power that caused you to drink in the first place. You chose to drink. It's a behavior, not a disease. No one chooses cancer. No one chooses diabetes. They choose behaviors, like smoking and over-eating, that can cause disease. But no one says, "I think I'll go get me a big helping of brain tumor today."

And they can choose to stop those behaviors. Is it easy? No. It's pretty difficult. But it's still your choice, to start or to stop.

To say otherwise is to deny you have any power over your own life, your own choices, and your own behavior at all. And if you don't have that power, who does? A cat turd? A rock?

Really? A rock has more power over your life than you do?

You chose your own addiction. You can control your own addiction, and you are the only one who can, through your own choices. You may get support from other people, help from other people, but they aren't making your choices for you, are they?

As for this higher power, is it making your choices for you? Did this higher power make the choice for you to look up a meeting in the phone book? Did it choose for you to walk through the door? Or did you make that choice yourself? There you go. You chose a behavior. Choose a few more, and you may be quit of your addiction. But if it isn't you doing the choosing, it isn't going to happen.

If you chose it yourself, you are in control of your behavior, and therefore you are in control of your own addiction, through your own choices about your own behavior.

Tell me something: what if I decide that my Higher Power is myself? Is that okay, within AA? Can God as I understand him be myself?

Or does AA not tell you that obviously you can't be trusted to make your own choices, since you're the one who chose to drink, and look how well that turned out? "your best thinking got you here." What a snide way to say, "wow, dummy, you can't manage your own life. Let some Higher Power manage it for you." I don't know what that is, if it's not religion. It's certainly not atheism.



You have not presented any evidence that one must conceive of God in the way that the Big Book demonstrates that Bill W does in order to work the Steps or benefit in any way from AA. All that you have presented indisputably is that the Big Book demonstrates that Bill W had a conception of God that in compatible with atheism.

None of us are trying to say how you must work the program in order to benefit from it.

We're saying the program itself is religious in nature. Of course you can choose to ignore the religious parts, but that doesn't make them go away. They're still there.

If the AA program of recovery isn't religious, then why are courts now deciding that using the courts to require criminal offenders to attend AA is unconstitutional, because it violates the First Amendment?

Appeals court says requirement to attend AA unconstitutional
San Francisco Chronicle


Alcoholics Anonymous, the renowned 12-step program that directs problem drinkers to seek help from a higher power, says it's not a religion and is open to nonbelievers. But it has enough religious overtones that a parolee can't be ordered to attend its meetings as a condition of staying out of prison, a federal appeals court ruled Friday.

In fact, said the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco, the constitutional dividing line between church and state in such cases is so clear that a parole officer can be sued for damages for ordering a parolee to go through rehabilitation at Alcoholics Anonymous or an affiliated program for drug addicts.

Rulings from across the nation since 1996 have established that "requiring a parolee to attend religion-based treatment programs violates the First Amendment," the court said. "While we in no way denigrate the fine work of (Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous), attendance in their programs may not be coerced by the state."

The 12 steps required for participants in both programs include an acknowledgment that "a power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity" and a promise to "turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him." They also call for prayer and meditation.

http://articles.sfgate.com/2007-09-...arole-officer-treatment-program-appeals-court
 
It is when what you are calling "sophistry" is not in fact sophistry. The post of mine that called sophistry was an illustration that there are situations in everyday life the outcomes of which any given individual cannot control. In short, there are powers greater than humans that humans deal with on a regular basis.

I believe that these powers do not in turn have a single entity or a group of entities controlling them, but that does not change that such powers are not in the control of humans. Coming to believe that one in particular cannot control one's addiction on one's own through one's own power (whatever that in itself maybe), but that there are ways that one can control one's addiction by looking outside of oneself is essentailly what the Second Step says in fewer words.



I don't see you insulting yourself at all.



You have not presented any evidence that one must conceive of God in the way that the Big Book demonstrates that Bill W does in order to work the Steps or benefit in any way from AA. All that you have presented indisputably is that the Big Book demonstrates that Bill W had a conception of God that in compatible with atheism.

A concept of god is religious.
 
As far as we are able to tell, Human Beings rather are the supreme conscious power of the known universe - that is, unless you happen to have any evidence of any others?

So which God did you use? It must have been something given your sobriety. Surely (gasp) you didn't do a program of your own choosing.

No. That's my argument against you, reversed.

Whoosh!

Indeed it is, except I have been throwing these arguments at you, not you at me. You have nothing, nor remotely proved anything.

I'll tell you what, after this post - which will be my final to you - I will not re-engage with you until you provide to me two things. You can accept the terms or not, I really don't care:

1/. Define cult.
Explain what constitutes a cult and what does not. Where AAs similarities lie but also where there are differences.
This would be a move away from your black and white thinking and might help.

2/. Show me studies of what other treatments there are and there success rates. You keep spouting about 5% and all, but what are the success rates for others?

That's not what it is.

Sure it is.

The most popular type of self-help group is based on the Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), founded in 1935.

http://www.minddisorders.com/Py-Z/Self-help-groups.html

It's mental technology

Like CBT? Like optimal thinking?

Sound sinister doesn't it? :rolleyes:

Then stop making claims and giving advice for people to follow.

I will if you will.

So a lady goes crazy for her sponsee joining a soccer team. A guy's sponser tells him who he can talk to. Are you going to apologize for that too? This kind of thing doesn't happen in other kinds of programs because there's no where for this memetic disease to grow, it's too clean.

I agree with you; that sort of thing really shouldn't happen. I'm sure it does, I have seen it too but not quite to the level in your hand-waving example. However that is not what "the program" or AA is supposed to be about. Neither is 13 step work etc. When these things happen it is because of individuals, not the fellowship.

But once again, you would tar all with the same brush. Black and white, all or nothing. I'm starting to think this is a problem for you.

Whatever Alfie anyone who actually cares enough about this issue can google around and ask people in AA if they've heard people speak about that at meetings or heard people who think that.

Got it: You have nothing.

Pffft some excuses you're making for what actually happens and is well known about this cult. The even spent like 5 minutes on it in the AA bashing episode of penn and teller, quoting major people which is on youtube and is hilarious by the way.

Is this a meaure of the science you keep mentioning? LOL. :rolleyes:

No, a human being, who you're basically insulting by insinuating that her husband is actually better off without her. At least that's what I thought,

Then you are so very very wrong it is not funny.

A counsellor's job is to leave a person better than when they met them and act peacefully at all times.

I can agree with that.

Challenging and questioning can be world's apart, as in your approach, language, and tone. I don't think challenging is appropriate if that's your idea of challenging.

I really don't care what you think of my style, just what you think a therapist does.
Challenging and questioning are also completely different tools at the disposal of the therapist. To conflate or confude them proves your lack of understanding.
Challenging is absolutely fundamental to almost any counselling session. Sometimes one needs to be cruel to be kind as well (not always).

But I repeat, I am counselling no-one here, I am not being paid, and I don't ever just give lip service.
Clients come to me for their problems; my job (in part) is to assist them in finding solutions or to advance their progress.

If that is the extent of your thoughts around what counsellors do, then I suggest you do a bit more research yourself.

Asking me to "prove AA is the majority" is ridiculous. It's like asking me to prove that the sky is blue, it's beyond ridiculous.

In other words, you can prove nothing and your claims are ridiculous.

Got it. :)

By the way, I'd have thought it pretty easy to prove the sky is blue. :)
 
Last edited:
In fact I think it is exactly the question: Individual interpretation of what a HP is, PGTO is, or God is. What the program is, what works for me, or whether alcohol and my behaviour are linked and problematic.

These are all things that I must interpret and decide for myself. No-one ese has to do it for me.

True. But again, AA _is_ a 12-step program. So what does it say if you don't follow the steps and pick a God ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom